R-9143
e
e
RESOLUTION NO. 9143
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA
APPROVING THE MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND ADOPTING A
MITIGATION MONITORING PLAN FOR
THE 1136-1144 FOURTH STREET
SENIOR HOUSING /PUBLIC PARKING STRUCTURE PROJECT
WHEREAS, a Notice of Availability of an Initial Study and
Proposed
Mltlgated
Negative
Declaration,
for
the
senior
houslng/public parking structure located at 1136-1144 Fourth
Street (Project) was publlshed on November 25, 1996 in compllance
with the California Environmental Quality Act {CEQA} and the City
of Santa Monica CEQA Guidelines, and
WHEREAS, on April 29, 1997, the City council, as Lead Clty
Agency,
revlewed the Initial Study and Proposed Mitigated
Negatlve Declaration, and Mitlgatlon Monltoring Plan,
NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA
DOES HEREBY RESOLVE AS FOLLOWS:
#
SECTION 1.
The City Council finds that the Inltlal Study
identified potentially slgnlficant effects in the following three
areas:
l}light and glare, 2}trafflc/clrculatlon/parklngi
3 )
cultural resources.
SECTION 2.
The City Council finds that the followlng
conditions of approval lmposed on the ProJect and agreed to by
the Menorah Housing Foundatlon of the Jewlsh Federatlon Councll
1
eff44
e
e
(Applicant] w~ll avoid these effects or m~tigate the effects to a
po~nt where clearly no sign~f~cant effects w~ll occur:
1. Prior to lssuance of a Certificate of Occupancy, the
Appl~cant shall des~gn and install exterior bUlldlng
light~ng that sheds light pools only on the subject property
located at 1136-1144 Fourth Street. North and west facades
shall incorporate the minimal light~ng needed to sat~sfy
safety requirements.
2.
Fln~sh materials, ~ncluding glazing, shall be of a
reflectlvlty to minimize glare and shall be reviewed
ver~f~ed by the Arch~tectural Review Board.
low
and
3. Prior to closure of the existing surface parking lot located
at 1136-1144 Fourth Street (Lot) and pr~or to issuance of a
bu~ld~ng permit, the Appl~cant, w~th approval by the C~ty,
shall implement a restriping plan for both Th~rd and Fourth
Streets between W~lsh~re Boulevard and California Avenue
that will create 42 new metered spaces.
Modifications to the east s~de of this block of Third Street
will involve restr~p~ng 13 ex~st~ng parallel park~ng spaces
for d~agonal parklng. This will y~eld 24 dlagonal spaces,
for a net ga~n of 11 new spaces. Modifications to the west
s~de of Fourth Street, immediately fronting the subject
site, will entail the provis~on of 17 new curb-side parallel
park~ng spaces. Mod~f~cat~ons to the east s~de of Fourth
2
eff44
e
e
Street will entail the provision of 14 new curb-s~de
parallel park~ng spaces. Together, the mod~f~cat~ons to the
1100 blocks of Third and Fourth Streets wlll yield 42 new
parking spaces ~n the vlClnity of the project s~te located
at 1136-1144 Fourth Street.
4. Prior to issuance of a build~ng permit, the Applicant shall
subm~t to the Plann~ng and Community Development Department
a copy of a recorded lease agreement for 20 park~ng spaces
located with~n 1000 feet of the perlmeter of the 1136-1144
Fourth Street parcel for use by drivers who purchase a
perm~t to park In elther the Third Street Structure or the
Lot(Permit Parkers) during the construction per~od
5.
Prlor to
implement
the
the
closure of the Lot, the Applicant shall
follow~ng notiflcation/education measures to
reduce the inconvenience and negative lmpact of the closure
of the Lot:
A. Notice shall be prov~ded to the buslnesses and
employers who use or benef~t from the Fourth Street
Park~ng Lot and a copy of the not~ce and a
certlflcation of mailing shall be provlded to the City
Planning Dlvlsion.
B. Notificat~on shall ~dentify the scheduled dates for
closure, prov~de maps of alternat~ve park~ng
faCll~tles, and urge buslnessesjemployers to not~fy
employees and customers of the planned closure and
3
eff44
e
e
parklng alternatives prior to the scheduled closure
dates.
C On-slte slgning whlch meets the Slze, height, letterlng
and locatlon requlrements of the Zonlng Adminlstrator
sign postlng requirements shall be lnstalled notlfYlng
customers of the scheduled dates for closure and
llsting alternatlve parklng facilities. Durlng the
constructlon phase, the Applicant shall place a sign on
the Lot, to the satlsfaction of the Clty, identifying
available publlc parking locatlons at the Third Street
Parking structure and at parklng Structures Number 1
and 2
D. The Applicant shall provlde 100 flyers and one poster
each to places of buslness that beneflt from the
existing Fourth Street parking lot as identified by
City Plannlng staff, notifYlng customers of the
scheduled dates for closure, and providing maps of
alternative parklng facllities for future VlSltS.
6 Prlor to issuance of a bUllding permit or any demolltlon or
gradlng permits, the Appllcant shall inform construction
grading crews of the potential for buried archeological and
paleontologlcal resources. If resources are discovered
durlng the excavations, work in the immediate area of the
flnd shall be halted and a qualified archaeologist or
paleontologist contacted to determlne the slgnlflcance of
the materlals and to develop appropriate follow-up measures.
4
eff44
e
e
SECTION 3. The City Counc~l has rev~ewed and consldered the
Ini t~al Study and M~ tigated Negat~ ve Declaratlon, and the
Mitigation Monitoring Plan on the ProJect together w~th any
comments rece~ved during the public rev~ew process, prlor to
act~ng on the project.
SECTION 4. The C~ty Council f~nds that based on the Initial
Study and comments received that there is no substantial
eVldence that the Project (as modified by the conditions
outlined in Sect~on 2} will have a slgnificant effect on the
environment, and hereby approves the Mitigated Negatlve
Declaration.
SECTION 5.
The
City Councll adopts the Mit~gatlon
Monltoring plan, whlch ~s included as Attachment A, to
ensure that the required mitigatlon measures will be
implemented.
SECTION 6.
The City Clerk shall certify to the adoption of
th~s Resolution, and thenceforth and thereafter the same
shall be ln full force and effect.
APPROVED AS TO FORM.
~~.
MARSHA J r(1)UTRIE -\
Clty Attorney
5
eff44
e
e
Adopted and approved t11lS 6th of May 1997
\
~ OQ11~
Pt O'Connor, Mayor
I, Mana M Stewart, City Clerk of the City of Santa MOnIca, do hereby certrfy that the
foregolllg Resolution 9143(CCS) was duly adopted at a meetlllg ofthe City Council held on the
6th of May. 1997 by the follo\\mg vote
Ayes
Councllmembers
Femstem, Genser, Mayor O'Connor. Rosenstelll
Noes
CouncIlmembers
None
Abstalll
CouncIlmembers
Ebner, Mayor Pro Tern Holbrook
Absent
Councrlmembers
Greenberg
ATTEST
...
~~~~
Mana M Stewart, CIty Clerk
e
f.\ppd\share\eirtemps\fourthst\reso2b wpd
Last rev~sed July, 199~
6
e
eff44
e
ATTACHMENT A
7
e
eff44
~ ~-? ~ ~-g t ~& ~
",-r:=c..<-'c..=-~c..
5"""1;~ 'J'~;:;"~::::-
cr:; a. =r gC g ~~. ~ 0; ~o ~'
";:u ~r.:;;: G~~"O:::
F ~~- ~ ~ -,,< ~ 0:: g
~--j~<~- ~;-G tI'
.. - t""I- -....}.., ] J. ~o.
5~;;~~ -~ ~
~I> ~~~~~~~~
~[~[~~~~lj~
~ [ ~ ~ ~~ 1?-i ~ 0'0 r.
","o-~..,~-g~- ~--
'1..&.0 ~ ""'t U' :::J W
~~!g~F."~~cr:6~
;::; - c..::i -'-~ ~:::::;J ~ 0'"
~ ... Q ~-re C ~..,_ ::I = :i g
t-.Jrv"B -..., c: ~G V'(JO ~
~-...,~~c: ~~"O,....
~ ::"~Jgg~-oo~~
3;';~~~ Q;5:~~
~ ~[]~ ~~~2.
< ~ c. {O ..... (5
r.rs 1Jl; c:
~
0>
IJ';
r:
- ...
~[3';-1~S:
E~~-g.~ :;:
~g=g~~
" ",,0'0 F ~ ;;:i
;- ;:]- ~ r: ~
..;.;;=-""CI~
N _.....:;,.....
~29.g5~
~ ~ g"g '" ~
3 =.=r< ~~
~~-1~Z~
'" 0> 0'" =: S;
2.. a.. 0... ~ i' ~
.{g g; a r; ;? ~
~Ci..c..'-_3>:
~ Q s~ ~ ~
0-::; ~ ;:' ~
~ ;.~[
;r..-~3V'
<: ~""O
~ :r [~
" <>
~
~
OJ
> t;:I:-o-::: -
<: c t:j c;r 3
~~a~~
CD ~ g ~, ~
c..~;:a
[g a g
~::;:~~
- ,,-
~~!!.~
~ ~ ~ ~
5) 0.. c;-
""..0
o _
" ::l
;1<1;
::r
~g-~Q;~~:?
S-l::-""!:':"loE
~~g-g~g~
O'Cf'bQ'OS~
~ 0' ~uc; ~
5 !:i
~ "
0> :3 !t-
g-~[
a~~
~ ~ ;;-
d a ~
:s :II ('}
~ ~ ~
~"'O
::j ;:;l
1ii
..
::l
0..
g?~~
t'l e!. i Q,.
~"O :: ~
~~~
0..
o
::l
n
I>
.....
01
::!l
"
rr.
::l
<r-;
:;
,.,
~
",,'1;:<::>
<~~g.
~ "'C (p -
g.,~~
; i:tl e
_ 0 ..,
rF. a.!!!.
~5
r.- ;;
~::r
~ ~
.:<
o~
~
3F
~
- ~
~ e.
lr. "
tJ'CfQ
6~
0>
...
::;
qe
.l~~
~ :.i' =-:g __
~ ~~ [ ~
~ ="'8 a::;:,
~5ow~
-g8~::r~
~-g..,~o:>:
3c:'<~~
go:;~
V):;':r~
n (b ><
~ ~ !i
;:J~i5
3 ~ ..,
.,-0-
=-~s:::
f}'::; ". g:
~ z<iii
lr. 0 -
~ ~~
fl) C) =
0.. " "
<> 0.. 'JQ
8~~
~
".
:r
!e..
0'"
to
.,
~
otjfj;~
gs.~Q
.g ;.!!l
!!l ~ g 0'
~~~
9..
~
?;
"
{/'JC:
'" c
tr=-
-0..
'< -
O~
~ Re
i5
"
R~
" '"
:!o;
o "
: !!l
'JQ0..
g~
~~
i[
;:;
::l
OIJ
:;q
~ "0
o -
::l !!l
~'"
;;
<r-;
:;
o
"
g
iii:
a:
CD
III
d-
o
:l
3C
m
IIJ
C
~
o
:l
Q,
E:
o
:l
o
....
)>
'l:J
1:l
a
<
!!.
>
n
=-
o
:l
;II
'"
.Q
C
l
31:
o
Oa
~S'
c ::I
..::I
u:I
S'
"'iii:
jg
cg.
CD::I
~ci
-ulf
.,!! '&
q~ il
~g:
4Il
:r
a
!!.
o
~
~
Ii>
j
n.
II>
~
:1
::!l
"
~
o
:l
~
o
o
3
3
CD
::I
It
-
-
(M
er
-
-
~
~
~~
...<=
dQ' 5i
=- :T
g" ~
::;ri
<= ~ ~
=. '7J. ~
...~'-<:
s; e. <=
E:r~~
1<1 ::c: ~
~ <= ~
Q. = ~
~ S' ::;
!l> 10 <=
"I:l =
<= .,,;:;'
:1 = ll>
5r g:
(lCI ;;.
("")."
=-~
!l> "'I
~c:
==
~(fQ
'"
...
"'I
=
l"l
...
=
"'I
~
e
'"
~
(JC
<'>
tv
-
.
:1~1i;~il!~iij~fi~
~~r;; g-~~~~5~Q-gS:-;2~a~
~~~~iri}~~~r:~il~~
g-?~~;~~~~~~~~~~~~
.; n :: ~ ~ (=) E. ~ 2.~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~; ~ s
~: ~R~~~_~8~5o~~~~
~~a~]~~:~~~:~~:~~
"N a JJ ;.&',r: E;"< c..g~:' O"~rJc a
~~"< f-g~~g ~ ~~s.-E 'V
a 0 ~ 'l" ~ ~ ~ 2 ~-g ~ ;; ~ :;. ~ S' :;
~ ~~!i~~'~~a5n~~~
"C ~""C ii:;J'"
~ c = .
~!~~
E:=-~~
i ~; ~
a3:=
r;tI - tIIlI
= - ~
~Q;
.. .c -
~ :; 3
0' :""C
-~~
" "
"" .,
'<
o';:jO"
= ~
a:~~
=' (j C
()Q n ~
12 3.. C
g
-0 0-
'" -
2-~()
" - -
1JCi2<"'::
c;_
~ a g
" '"
o 5
" ""
~ ~ a- i "g ~.; ~ ~ -
~a~~ ~~l~ 2.~
;c!:;~a~~~8.."g-
g~: ~:~ rrJi ~~
= ~ :.:,,; ;-~~;::
~~;a5i~~~::~
5-~~~;]!~~s-
c..f~;d8":e"<=En3
~=--=;~ ~i;:.
= ; =.
~ ;l ~
g-~~
=-'"
=-g.,
::I (") a
<10 <>
] =.. ~
3
0-
9
;<
n
0"
~ Q
0'<
" ."
~
<iO
N
..
-'
-'
~
~
I
-
-
,j;l,.
,j;l,.
~""i
_ c
rJQ' =
~ :1
-=-
S'
::I ~
;s:;il
o a t"'l
a.~5
o e.o
'"I 0 ....
50 ., fIl
(J'Q :c ...
lP 0 a
g, = ...
;p:l S' 3:
.g(J'Q~
~ :c;:;"
e. = ~
::I ="
aa=:
,.,
t"'l"'C
="lP
~ .,
~c:
::=
~(JQ
'"
~
,.,
-
=
.,
..
g
n
"':l
"
ere
'"
<.0.>
-5 ~ -= ::i ~~. ,- ~
"3~~"'gg-_~
.g~~~~(;~
~~~~a~~
;Yrtg.c..~(')~
_ ~ ~ S ri ;~ ::w:,
O~OC~O~~
l~o..,~~g-~
~ ~~ 2 g J; ao ~
3~~--;;(iq~
~go~6E.o~
~(';)~:.rc..~~~
;:; 0 ::,} ~ c...::3 ~ oC;j
r1~8;J5~;T
"(,;::Jc..::;!!.~
::Iou:a{Jt;;(b':j
~o;g.g(l'
(b (JQ - ('tl .... t&)
~~g-~5-[
Vi" 8 -' ~ ~ 2-
~::I~~~o
~H2.gri~
~2..~_~g~
~o~~tiS;
~ ~!Rg
"'::J E.
a~ ~g~
8 &"'8:4'g.
:3 g _ 2 f)
~oaga
oa~elg~
E. ~ ~~ ~
n~a-o...5
tIlQ.c:5cr
g ~ ~ 3
6 c.. ""'I:
... '"
v. ~
"0 C"'Q'Q Q.. Ei.i ."
~~~~~Q
~5~g.~S
OQ"cg~:r
""l .? "'+l (D
!!l
'<
]g.~g
"C Cor.! ~~
~ iH~ :;
=~(I)cr=
g S; ~ 1:1
-g.~ ~ ii
f;! VI P) ~
" .. - !!l
'" g.
... Q.
"" 0.<70
~3~5
-oQ.n
~ :::- S =
lJQ :!lJ:I -
'" 0 -
!~
00'"'0-':;
~a.~~
~ e-!a ;:
O~ g ~
S !!l ~
!: 0.
o
'"
~ ~
~ S
~
~~c~~~~:::
5 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .~
r€ ~ ~ a ~ ;.: :
::::!~ ~~_..~~
;::; ~ {tI ....... ~ ':J-o~
~~~]~~~~
2..~~*~~~~
55"_~.a~~~~
-- -.,-../..--~
'~:i-~1>~~ ~"'
s~~(')~-_::::
~::;~E-~~~;r
...J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~.~ :;:
~ ::. ~ .r,,;. :.. ~ ~ _
:s c 't: ~ 5; ::.:..~~
~~s.""'!~~~~
g. ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ::
~:t-S":;~r'_~
~~~~~~irg.
::~~~~~~ v
~ri;~!:~~.~~
......~~ ~;"'::lS-
~ ~;:~ ~ ~ ~
:i ~ Q .....
<lq -=:.,1<S.,if
f"") "'Q t::fi' ""C ::!:oI c.
;;;.;!1 0 6i'<
~5~~3~
",{JQifo!!J'E-
~Otll""'c.o
r~g-o!!l
~ to'l VJ ::s .....
tr e 5 0 Vl
g.~~"'g 5"
;:s~v..~=
::g~~"'Sl
[!i- ~!l S1
:Tn a
~S!?;f~rD
a.., :lI 0 -
" c
~ 0
~
<:
~
"
'"
o
....,
""
.. '~
~ ;: ~ ~ ~ ~~t ~ 0
~~~-~~s.~~t
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~~~~~g~~~~
~~~"'I~....::s--'"t _
~ "'" ~ ~ ~ ~ =::: ~ ~
~~~ S~] ~~El~
~:; &';= iS~a~~n
~S%..c~~f!-~~~
......O'C; ~S.--~~;:5 r:
~~~~ir~~~~~
~~g:g~g-~E.~~
~~~~~~~~l;;
~~!:.~~~l~~
S~~~~~~,~~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c _ ~
~ '::-.;:, E"~ it~:: '"
~~S.::::::--5""'~
~ ~ Ci:~~~tK:~:iO
~ 5 Si ~ ,5 ~ ~ ~
$Si:!~~ ~~~
a - ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~
"' "
,;;;
2 ;J>
"'-0
rJQ:!,
(;
!a
1>
-0
~
a.
...
o
:;>
~
"
jf
<<i
III
l:!:
o
~
~
m
III
II>
c:
~
g
Q.
a:
o
~
a
)>
-0
-0
i
)>
~
o
~
::0
..
..Q
c:
i
a.
!l:
o
gil
.,[
~r5
S"
"11f
j 2,
is"
~ S'
'iCe
"lIil
Ill::l i
l"C~i
~~
s-
a:
!!.
o
~
"2-
ii'
::I
Ii:
~
:I.
::!l
n
i
::I
o
fi
o
o
3
3
..
:
lit
-
-
W
Q\
I
-
-
....
....
~~
..0
liQ- =
~ :1
....=-
o'
= ~
:=iil
= a ,...,
~~~
= e. =
"'I = ....
:3" "'I rr.
~ :c ~
III = S.
g, = III
;l:l S' ~
.g~;
= .., ;:;.
a.. = III
= 0-
~ ::
(':l'l
=-"tl
~ !;
ll:"i:.
::=
=,11C
'J)
...
"'I
C
,.,
...
c
.,
"