Loading...
SR 01-23-2024 3B City Council Report City Council Meeting: January 23, 2024 Agenda Item: 3.B 1 of 1 To: Mayor and City Council From: David White, City Manager, City Manager's Office Subject: City Manager Report - Santa Monica Fire Department 2023-2028 Strategic Plan (Attachment A) Prepared By: Sergio Ramirez, Chief of Staff Approved Forwarded to Council Attachments: A. Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) B. PowerPoint Presentation 3.B Packet Pg. 38 City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Fire Chief’s Message page i FIRE CHIEF’S MESSAGE I am honored to present the Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan. The development of this document was a collaborative effort that included input from members of a cross-section of our organization and external stakeholders. This Strategic Plan focuses on the Department's strategic initiatives aligned with the community's expectations. It is designed to provide the organization and community members with a five-year planning document capable of being evaluated, reviewed, and adjusted annually depending on our ability to meet the objectives listed in the plan. The Santa Monica Fire Department is fortunate to serve a diverse, engaged community that values public safety. I want to thank our community members and external stakeholders that provided valuable input during this process. In addition, I am humbled and grateful for the commitment displayed by the dedicated staff members of the Santa Monica Fire Department in developing this plan. This plan represents a shared vision for our entire organization and will serve as our roadmap as we continue providing high-quality emergency services to our community. DANNY ALVAREZ FIRE CHIEF 3.B.a Packet Pg. 39 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 40 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Table of Contents page iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Fire Chief’s Message ....................................................................................................... Precedes Table of Contents Section 1—Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................. 1 1.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Strategic Planning Process ............................................................................................................. 1 1.3 Strategic Planning Committee ....................................................................................................... 2 1.4 Project Stakeholders ...................................................................................................................... 3 1.4.1 Fire Department Personnel ................................................................................................ 3 1.4.2 Key Allied City Departments’ Stakeholders ..................................................................... 3 1.4.3 City Council ...................................................................................................................... 4 1.4.4 Community Stakeholders .................................................................................................. 4 1.5 Strategic Goals ............................................................................................................................... 4 1.6 Annual Work Plan ......................................................................................................................... 5 1.7 Plan Maintenance .......................................................................................................................... 5 Section 2—Santa Monica Fire Department ............................................................................................................... 7 2.1 Department Origin and History ..................................................................................................... 7 2.2 Authority and Services .................................................................................................................. 8 2.3 Organization .................................................................................................................................. 8 2.4 Service Capacity ............................................................................................................................ 9 Section 3—Values and Mission ................................................................................................................................. 11 3.1 Core Values ................................................................................................................................. 11 3.2 Mission Statement ....................................................................................................................... 12 Section 4—Planning to Plan ..................................................................................................................................... 13 4.1 Planning Schedule ....................................................................................................................... 13 Section 5—Environmental Scan ............................................................................................................................... 15 5.1 Programs and Services ................................................................................................................. 16 5.1.1 Mandated Programs/Services .......................................................................................... 16 5.1.2 Best Practice Programs/Services ..................................................................................... 17 5.1.3 Value Added Programs/Services ..................................................................................... 18 5.2 Critical Issues / Service Gaps ...................................................................................................... 18 5.2.1 Critical Issues .................................................................................................................. 18 5.2.2 Service Gaps ................................................................................................................... 20 5.3 Unmet Organizational Needs ....................................................................................................... 20 5.4 Department Project Task Plan ..................................................................................................... 21 5.4.1 High Priority Tasks (21) ................................................................................................. 21 5.4.2 Medium Priority Tasks (8) .............................................................................................. 21 5.4.3 Unprioritized Tasks (150) ............................................................................................... 21 5.5 Stakeholder Outreach and Engagement ....................................................................................... 22 5.5.1 Fire Department Personnel .............................................................................................. 22 5.5.2 Key Allied City Department Stakeholders ...................................................................... 26 5.5.3 City Council .................................................................................................................... 28 3.B.a Packet Pg. 41 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 1—Executive Summary page iv 5.5.4 Community Stakeholders ................................................................................................ 31 Section 6—Performance Audit ................................................................................................................................. 39 6.1 Emergency Services Performance ............................................................................................... 39 6.1.1 Assessment Methodology ............................................................................................... 39 6.1.2 Standard of Cover Findings and Recommendations ....................................................... 40 6.2 Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats Assessment ................................................ 44 6.2.1 Strengths ......................................................................................................................... 44 6.2.2 Weaknesses/Limitations .................................................................................................. 45 6.2.3 Opportunities ................................................................................................................... 46 6.2.4 Threats ............................................................................................................................ 47 Section 7—Envisioning Success ................................................................................................................................ 51 Section 8—Strategic Initiatives ................................................................................................................................ 53 8.1 Strategic Initiatives Overview ..................................................................................................... 53 8.2 Strategic Plan Goals, Strategies, and Objectives ......................................................................... 53 8.2.1 Goal 1: An Organization Closely Aligned with Community Values, Needs, and Service Expectations .................................................................................................................... 54 8.2.2 Goal 2: Services, Programs, and Resources Appropriate to Carry Out Our Mission ...... 54 8.2.3 Goal 3: Sustained Organizational Vitality ...................................................................... 56 8.2.4 Goal 4: Improved Organizational Systems and Processes .............................................. 57 Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress ................................................................................... 59 9.1 Strategic Objectives Implementation Sequence ........................................................................... 60 9.2 Detailed Action Plans .................................................................................................................. 65 9.3 Annual Work Plan ....................................................................................................................... 65 9.4 Plan Maintenance ........................................................................................................................ 66 9.5 Strategic Plan Rollout .................................................................................................................. 66 Appendices Appendix A—Santa Monica Fire Department Personnel Survey Appendix B—Key Allied City Department Stakeholder Survey Appendix C—City Council Survey Appendix D—Community Stakeholder Survey Appendix E—Sample Detailed Action Plans Table of Tables Table 1—Santa Monica Fire Department Strategic Planning Committee ..................................................................... 3 Table 2—Key Allied City Departments’ Stakeholders.................................................................................................. 3 Table 3—Community Stakeholders............................................................................................................................... 4 Table 4—Annual Work Plan Development Schedule ................................................................................................... 5 Table 5—Fiscal Year 2021–23 Positions ...................................................................................................................... 8 Table 6—Fire Department Facilities and Response Resources ................................................................................... 10 Table 7—Strategic Planning Workshop Schedule ....................................................................................................... 14 3.B.a Packet Pg. 42 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Table of Contents page v Table 8—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Physical Assets ................................................................. 22 Table 9—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Service Improvements ...................................................... 23 Table 10—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Workplace Satisfaction ................................................... 24 Table 11—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Employee Perception ...................................................... 25 Table 12—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Service Priorities ............................................................. 25 Table 13—Key Allied City Departments .................................................................................................................... 26 Table 14—Rating of Fire Department Service Experience ......................................................................................... 29 Table 15—Secondary Fire Department Service Priorities ........................................................................................... 29 Table 16—Preferred Characteristics for an Excellent Customer Service Experience ................................................. 30 Table 17—Social Media Platforms Followed.............................................................................................................. 30 Table 18—Community Stakeholders........................................................................................................................... 32 Table 19—Stakeholder Connections to City ............................................................................................................... 32 Table 20—Rating of Fire Department Service Experience Summary ......................................................................... 33 Table 21—Fire Department Service Satisfaction Summary ........................................................................................ 33 Table 22—Secondary Fire Department Service Priorities ........................................................................................... 34 Table 23—Social Media Platforms Followed.............................................................................................................. 35 Table 24—Fire Department Information Platform Preference .................................................................................... 35 Table 25—Preferred Customer Service Characteristics .............................................................................................. 36 Table 26—Standards of Response Coverage Process Elements .................................................................................. 40 Table 27—Initial Strategic Objectives Implementation Priority ................................................................................. 61 Table 28—Annual Work Plan Development Schedule ............................................................................................... 65 Table of Figures Figure 1—Santa Monica Fire Department Organization Chart ..................................................................................... 9 3.B.a Packet Pg. 43 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 44 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 1—Executive Summary page 1 SECTION 1—EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1.1 INTRODUCTION The City of Santa Monica (City) Fire Department (Department) retained Citygate Associates, LLC (Citygate) to facilitate a Strategic Planning process to guide Department planning and decision- making over the next five years. 1.2 STRATEGIC PLANNING PROCESS Strategic planning involves a deliberate effort to achieve organizational alignment around a shared vision for the future and identify the steps necessary to achieve that future. Ideally, an effective strategic plan informs the budget process, organizational priorities, and decision-making over the planning period. While this may seem daunting, the planning process is more important than the resultant plan because the assumptions and factors under which a strategic plan is developed are likely to change over time, sometimes very rapidly. The Department’s Strategic Planning Committee worked collaboratively over three months through the following six-step process to create this Plan. 1. Planning to Plan – Selection of the Planning Committee, identifying the planning period, determining when and how to initiate the planning process, assessing 3.B.a Packet Pg. 45 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 1—Executive Summary page 2 organizational support for the process, establishing the time frame for the process, and determining the extent of and process for stakeholder involvement. 2. Environmental Scan – Identification of critical elements to be considered in developing the Strategic Plan including current programs and services, critical issues / service gaps and unmet organizational needs; review of the Department’s current Task Plan; and identifying project stakeholders and how they should be included in the process. 3. Performance Audit – Conducting a detailed assessment of the organization’s current state and/or performance. 4. Envisioning Success – Identifying what success ideally looks like by the end of the planning horizon with desired end states or outcomes. 5. Strategic Initiatives – Clearly articulating the desired goals (end states) and the strategies and objectives to achieve them over the planning horizon. 6. Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress – Prioritizing the implementation sequence of the strategic objectives, developing a detailed action plan for each objective, determining the interval for periodic review/updating of the Plan, and introducing the completed Plan to the organization. In Citygate’s experience, this strategic planning model results in a plan that is “owned” by the Planning Committee and organization, with a higher probability that it will be implemented and successfully achieve one or more of its strategic goals than other planning models because guiding members of the organization created the Plan themselves. An added benefit of this model is that the Planning Committee learns how to conduct strategic planning and can monitor those factors likely to impact the Plan, making appropriate future changes without external assistance. 1.3 STRATEGIC PLANNING COMMITTEE The following Department personnel—representing the various organizational and functional perspectives of the Department and serving as the Strategic Planning Committee—invested considerable time and energy developing this Strategic Plan with Citygate’s facilitation and coaching. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 46 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 1—Executive Summary page 3 Table 1—Santa Monica Fire Department Strategic Planning Committee 1. Training Chief James Altman 2. Fire Chief Danny Alvarez 3. EMS Coordinator Catherine Borman 4. Fire Marshal Joe Cavin 5. Deputy Chief Tom Clemo 6. Battalion Chief Jeff Connor 7. Firefighter Ty Connor 8. Paramedic Coordinator Justin Crosson 9. Engineer Walter Gonzales 10. Engineer Evan McManus 11. Engineer Trevor Mustin 12. Captain Eric Nagao 13. Deputy Chief John Nevandro 14. Admin. Captain Patrick Nulty 15. Training Captain Walter Patton 16. FCEO Jason Puklus 17. Captain Matt Randleman 18. Engineer Mike Rivera 19. Engineer Mark Anthony Rizzo 20. Captain Ryan Shook 21. Captain Jonathan Sly 22. Principal Admin. Analyst Terese Toomey 1.4 PROJECT STAKEHOLDERS In a focused effort to include all Department personnel and other key City and community stakeholders in the planning process, the Department developed an online survey to capture input from various stakeholder perspectives (see: Appendices A through D—Stakeholder Surveys). The surveys were initiated on January 4, 2023, and closed on February 6, 2023. A summary of survey results can be found in Section 5.5. 1.4.1 Fire Department Personnel All Fire Department personnel were invited to participate in the online survey by internal memorandum and direct email. By the close of the survey on February 6, 2023, eighty-eight of the one hundred thirty-six members (65 percent) had completed the survey. 1.4.2 Key Allied City Departments’ Stakeholders The following key allied City Department stakeholders were invited by direct email to provide input through the online stakeholder survey. Fifteen individuals from this stakeholder group completed the survey. Table 2—Key Allied City Departments’ Stakeholders 1. Information Services Department 2. Finance Department 3. Human Resources Department 4. Department of Transportation (DOT) 5. City Manager’s Office 6. Police Department 7. Community Development Department 8. Community Services Department 9. Chief Resiliency Officer/OEM 10. City Attorney’s Office 11. Public Works Department 3.B.a Packet Pg. 47 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 1—Executive Summary page 4 1.4.3 City Council Email invitations were sent to all seven City Council members to solicit their input through an online survey with four Council members completing the survey. 1.4.4 Community Stakeholders The following community individuals and groups were also invited to contribute to this Plan through the online stakeholder survey. Invitation to participate in the survey was by direct email or personal distribution with a QR code to access the survey. One hundred fifty surveys were completed from this stakeholder group. The survey was also made available to the entire community via the Department’s social media platforms and website. Table 3—Community Stakeholders 1. Chamber of Commerce 2. Downtown Santa Monica 3. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School Dist. 4. Santa Monica Pier 5. Pacific Park 6. Santa Monica Place 7. Fairmont Hotel 8. Santa Monica Travel and Tourism 9. Santa Monica History Museum 10. Ocean Park Association 11. Rand Corporation 12. North of Montana Association 13. UCLA 14. NAACP 15. Santa Monica Police Officers Association 16. Santa Monica College 17. Mid Cities Neighbors 18. Friends of Sunset Park 19. Pico Neighborhood 20. Pico HRC 21. Northeast Neighbors 22. Human Relations Council 23. Committee for Racial Justice 24. Wilshire Montana Neighborhood Coalition 25. Rotary Club International 26. Kiwanis Club 27. The People Concern 28. UCLA Santa Monica Medical Center 29. Providence St. Johns 30. Santa Monica Interfaith Council 31. Santa Monica Bay Area Human Relations Council 1.5 STRATEGIC GOALS This Strategic Plan identifies the following four strategic goals the Department will pursue over the next five years. Goal 1: An Organization Closely Aligned with Community Values, Needs, and Service Expectations Goal 2: Services, Programs, and Resources Appropriate to Carry Out SMFD’s Mission Goal 3: Sustained Organizational Vitality Goal 4: Improved Organizational Systems and Processes 3.B.a Packet Pg. 48 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 1—Executive Summary page 5 The Strategic Plan further identifies 14 strategies and 38 measurable objectives to achieve these goals over the next several years and beyond, as well as an Implementation Plan to ensure the contents of the Plan are integrated into the Department’s annual planning, budget, and work cycle. Sample Detailed Action Plans are included in Appendix E. 1.6 ANNUAL WORK PLAN Annual work plans are critical to creating and maintaining momentum and making continued progress on any long-term plan. The Planning Committee established the desire to develop an annual work plan corresponding with the City’s biennial budget cycle and incorporating those strategies and objectives that will receive intentional focus and effort over that 12-month period considering anticipated organizational capacity and availability of needed resources. Strategies and objectives need not be accomplished in any specific priority or sequence; however, they should be initiated individually or in parallel to ensure logical and incremental progress toward achievement of a particular strategy or goal. Annual Work Plan progress will be reviewed at each monthly Command and General Staff meeting. The Planning Committee established the following Annual Work Plan schedule. Table 4—Annual Work Plan Development Schedule Objective Date Initiate Annual Work Plan development January 2 Complete Draft Annual Work Plan January 24 Complete Detailed Action Plans for included Strategic Objectives June 1 Final City Budget adopted Second Tuesday in June Finalize Annual Work Plan June 30 Implement Annual Work Plan July 1 1.7 PLAN MAINTENANCE To ensure continuing progress and the effectiveness and relevance of the Strategic Plan, an individual or group to be identified by the Fire Chief, in collaboration with the Executive Management Team, will be tasked to review this Plan at least quarterly for the first year, and thereafter as determined by the Fire Chief and/or Review Team. The Strategic Plan will be revised as needed to provide maximum utilization of available resources to achieve the identified strategic goals, and to add or modify strategies and/or objectives as needed to address changes in the political, fiscal, organizational, or City environment. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 49 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 50 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 2—Santa Monica Fire Department page 7 SECTION 2—SANTA MONICA FIRE DEPARTMENT 2.1 DEPARTMENT ORIGIN AND HISTORY Fire protection in Santa Monica began in October 1875 when six citizens organized the Crawford Hook and Ladder Company. In March 1889, another small group of citizens gathered at the town hall to adopt the Constitution of the newly formed Santa Monica Hose and Ladder Company, which was the beginning of the Santa Monica Fire Department. Over the ensuing 100 years, hand-drawn carts and buckets were replaced with horse-drawn vehicles and steam pumpers, which eventually gave way to gasoline and ultimately diesel-powered vehicles. In 1974, the Department became the first fire department in the nation to deliver paramedic services by an engine company. Since then, the organization has grown to become a Class 1 Department 1, providing specialized services including a full-time hazardous materials response unit, an urban search and rescue team, dedicated airport response cadre, an accredited fire academy, and a comprehensive all-hazards fire prevention division. 1 Public Protection Class 1 as determined by the Insurance Services Organization (ISO). 3.B.a Packet Pg. 51 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 2—Santa Monica Fire Department page 8 2.2 AUTHORITY AND SERVICES Operating under authority provided by the City Charter, the Department provides fire suppression, pre-hospital emergency medical services, hazardous materials response, search and rescue, fire prevention and fire code compliance, arson investigation, community outreach and education, and other fire and life safety-related services. The Department serves more than 92,000 residents over the 8.3 square-mile City area, with a total staff of 138 personnel operating from five fire stations. An annual operating budget of $46.5 million was adopted for Fiscal Years 2021–23. 2.3 ORGANIZATION As summarized in the following table and organizational chart, the Department is organized into four divisions that are organized under a Fire Chief who is appointed by the City Manager. Table 5—Fiscal Year 2021–23 Positions Operating Division Authorized FTE1 Personnel Administration 14 Suppression & Rescue 105 Fire Prevention 15 Training 4 Total 138 1 FTE = Full-Time Equivalent 3.B.a Packet Pg. 52 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 2—Santa Monica Fire Department page 9 Figure 1—Santa Monica Fire Department Organization Chart 2.4 SERVICE CAPACITY The Department’s service capacity for fire and non-fire hazards consists of a daily minimum of 35 response personnel staffing seven engines with four personnel each (including at least two paramedics), one aerial ladder truck staffed with five personnel (including at least one paramedic), and one Battalion Chief Command Team operating from five fire stations, as summarized in the following table. The Department also deploys a Rescue Utility, Type I Urban Search and Rescue (USAR) apparatus, Aircraft Rescue and Fire Fighting (ARFF) apparatus, Type I Hazardous Materials Unit, Crash Rescue Utility, and one Medical Response All-Terrain Vehicle (ATV) as needed based on the type of incident. In addition, the Department launched a pilot Community Response Unit (CRU) in September 2021 to better address the needs of vulnerable populations in the City, including those experiencing homelessness. The CRU is staffed with two personnel, including at least one paramedic, from 7:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. Monday through Wednesday and from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. every other Thursday. The CRU works in collaboration with other City departments, regional agencies, and 3.B.a Packet Pg. 53 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 2—Santa Monica Fire Department page 10 non-profits to help bridge the gap for housing and other support services. The CRU is funded through June 2023 at the time of this Plan. Table 6—Fire Department Facilities and Response Resources Station Address Year Built Assigned Resources1 Minimum Daily Staffing 1 1337 7th Street 2020 Engine 1 Engine 6 Truck 1 Battalion 1 Community Response Unit2 Rescue Utility 1 4 4 5 2 2 222 Hollister Avenue 2003 Engine 2 USAR 2 Utility 2 4 3 1302 19th Street 1971 Engine 3 Engine 4 4 4 5 2450 Ashland Avenue 1980 Engine 5 HazMat 5 Crash Rescue 5 HazMat Utility 5 Crash Rescue Utility 5 4 7 1100 Palisades Beach Road 2019 Engine 7 Med Cart 1 Utility 7 4 Total Daily Staffing 35 1 Staffed resources are shown in bold; other resources are staffed as needed by on-duty station personnel or recalled off-duty personnel 2 Staffed with two personnel including at least one paramedic Monday through Wednesday and every other Thursday The Department’s Effective Response Force (ERF) to mitigate more serious or complex emergencies—including confirmed building fires, wildland fires, multiple-patient medical emergencies, vehicle collisions with extrication required, and technical rescue incidents—consists of four engines, one ladder truck, one Emergency Incident Technician, and one Battalion Chief for a total of 23 personnel. As noted, the Department also has specialized capability for hazardous materials, urban search and rescue, and aircraft emergencies. The Department also has a mutual aid agreement with the City of Los Angeles Fire Department and is a signatory to the Los Angeles County Mutual Aid Plan and California Master Mutual Aid Agreement. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 54 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 3—Values and Mission page 11 SECTION 3—VALUES AND MISSION This section identifies the Department’s core values and mission statement, adopted in 2018. 3.1 CORE VALUES Integrity: We adhere to the highest standard of conduct at all times. Compassion: We treat those we serve as we want our own family treated. We are courteous and respectful to all, every time, every call. Teamwork: Teamwork is the cornerstone of the fire service. We are committed to constantly working together and supporting each other toward a common goal of excellence in achieving our mission. Accountability: We strive to meet the highest standard of the fire service, both personally and professionally. We are accountable to those we serve and to each other in all that we do. Trust: Since 1889 we have faithfully served our community. We earn trust through our actions and behavior. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 55 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 3—Values and Mission page 12 3.2 MISSION STATEMENT We believe in helping people by preserving and improving the safety, health, and wellbeing of our community. We provide collaborative and innovative fire protection, emergency medical care, and life safety services. We make a difference every day. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 56 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 4—Planning to Plan page 13 SECTION 4—PLANNING TO PLAN The first step in the strategic planning process is Planning to Plan. In this step, the Planning Committee is identified—ideally to represent a broad cross-section of organizational levels, functions, programs, and perspectives. The Planning Committee then reviews the planning process in detail to ensure an understanding of the entire process, including the time and effort required. The Committee then determines a workshop schedule that best accommodates its members and the overall project schedule. Finally, a schedule of deliverables to which Planning Committee and Department leadership mutually agree is identified. These steps were completed at the Department All Hands and Command/General Staff Strategic Plan orientation meetings on January 23, 2023, and reviewed at the first Planning Workshop on January 30th. 4.1 PLANNING SCHEDULE The following table shows the planning schedule established by the Department and Strategic Planning Committee. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 57 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 4—Planning to Plan page 14 Table 7—Strategic Planning Workshop Schedule Planning Element Date Time All Hands and Command/General Staff Orientation Meetings January 23, 2023 9:30 AM – 2:30 PM Planning Workshop #1 January 30, 2023 9:30 AM – 2:30 PM Planning Workshop #2 February 6, 2023 9:30 AM – 2:30 PM Planning Workshop #3 February 23, 2023 9:30 AM – 2:30 PM Draft Strategic Plan Submitted By March 3, 2023 5:00 PM Draft Strategic Plan Review March 28, 2023 9:30 AM – 12:00 PM Final Strategic Plan Submitted By April 31, 2023 5:00 PM Final Strategic Plan Presentation May 17, 2023 9:30 AM – 12:00 Noon 3.B.a Packet Pg. 58 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 15 SECTION 5—ENVIRONMENTAL SCAN This section summarizes the Planning Committee’s review of critical elements to be considered in developing the Strategic Plan including current programs and services, critical issues / service gaps, unmet organizational needs, and potential collaboration and partnership opportunities, reviewing the Department’s current Project Plan, 2019 Standards of Cover Study results, and identifying project stakeholders and how they will be included in the process. The following elements were completed at the first planning workshop on January 30, 2023. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 59 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 16 5.1 PROGRAMS AND SERVICES 5.1.1 Mandated Programs/Services The Department is required to provide the following programs and services by federal or state law, regulation, or local ordinance, formal agreement, policy, or procedure.  Fire suppression  Local/regional automatic aid  Fire hydrant testing  Enforcement of California Fire Code  Inspection of regulated occupancies  Inspection and permitting of regulated operations  New development plan review  Fire protection and life safety systems plan review, installation, and operational inspection  Hazardous materials program management (Certified Unified Program Agency [CUPA] for the City)  Fire origin and cause investigation  Training  New firefighters  Recurrent training in specified subject areas  EMS skills  Provision of a certified Safety Officer at emergency incidents  Ambulance fleet inspection and maintenance coordination  Respiratory Protection program  Department-level finance services  Budget development/management  Contracts management  Procurement 3.B.a Packet Pg. 60 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 17  Accounts receivable  Accounts payable  Payroll  Grant management  Staff reports  Department-level administrative support services  Meeting management  Public counter services  Public Records Act requests  Department-level recruitment/hiring/onboarding  Telephone calls  Employee support services  General administrative/clerical support  Large-scale event planning  Emergency Operations Center support  Emergency Medical Services quality assurance / quality improvement program  Department-level infectious disease control program 5.1.2 Best Practice Programs/Services The following programs and services provided by the Department, although not mandated, are considered best practices.  Technical rescue response (USAR)  Hazardous Material release/spill response/mitigation (HazMat)  Aircraft Rescue Fire Fighting (ARFF)  Pre-hospital EMS services  Statewide mutual aid  Non-mandated occupancy/operations inspection and permitting  Non-mandated occupancy inspections 3.B.a Packet Pg. 61 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 18  Non-mandated recurrent training to maintain/enhance operational skills and knowledge  Coordination of communications equipment testing and maintenance  Continued execution of the Information Technology Strategic Plan  Pre-incident planning  Coordination with the City Public Safety Communications Center  Insurance Services Office (ISO) Public Protection Classification Program  Center for Public Safety Excellence (CPSE) / Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI) fire agency accreditation management 5.1.3 Value Added Programs/Services Although not required or considered best practice, the Department provides the following programs and services to enhance the safety and quality of life for City residents, businesses, and visitors.  Community Response Unit (CRU)  Rapid Extrication Module (REM)  Regional/statewide wildland fire response  Homeless / behavioral / mental health issues response  Department Honor Guard  Department chaplaincy program  Traffic calming advisory support  CPR/first-aid training for other City Departments  Succession planning /mentorship  Facilities maintenance coordination  Community outreach/communication  Public Automatic External Defibrillator (AED) program 5.2 CRITICAL ISSUES / SERVICE GAPS 5.2.1 Critical Issues The Planning Committee identified the following critical issues facing the Department.  Low-acuity EMS incidents 3.B.a Packet Pg. 62 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 19  Service demand volume and increasing call trend  Crew safety on EMS calls involving individuals that are under the influence of drugs or alcohol, or experiencing a behavioral health emergency  Ambulance availability  Hospital emergency department wait times  Number of ambulances deployed daily by the City’s ambulance contract provider  Need to provide Department-staffed ambulances for surge demand  Number of Department paramedics  Administrative workload capacity, particularly relative to:  Procurement and the complexity of procurement  Contracts  Grant management  Recruitment/hiring challenges  Availability for local/regional mutual aid  Daily response staffing level  Lack of development impact fees to help fund Department capital infrastructure and equipment impacted by development  Station personnel workload capacity  Program management  Daily population fluctuations  Facilities management  Planned future development  Computer Aided Dispatch (CAD) challenges  Public Safety Communications Center staffing shortages  Employee mental health services  Succession planning  Narrowing qualified instructor gap  Inter-departmental collaboration  Injury prevention 3.B.a Packet Pg. 63 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 20  Fire incidents trending upward  Traffic signal to facilitate Station 7 access onto Highway 1 (Pacific Coast Highway) 5.2.2 Service Gaps The Planning Committee further identified the following service gaps.  Adequate information technology support  Inefficient Fire Prevention fee billing, collection, and reconciliation processes  Fire station first-due districts  Too large  Inequitable first-due service demand  Understanding other City departments’ roles and functions  EMS support capacity  Prosecution of intentionally set fires  Community paramedicine program 5.3 UNMET ORGANIZATIONAL NEEDS The following unmet organizational needs were identified by the Planning Committee.  Funding to complete the new Training Center facility  Ongoing funding for Fire Facility Capital Improvement Plan  Additional staffing capacity, particularly relative to the following Department functions:  Logistics  Finance  Affordable local housing for employees  Health/wellness program for non-uniformed personnel  Expedited workers’ compensation treatment and return-to-work process  Adequately matching resource needs to community risks  Staffing levels (operational and administrative functions)  Response apparatus types 3.B.a Packet Pg. 64 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 21  Permanent, long-term solution(s) to address unhoused and vulnerable population impacts on service demand and operational capacity  CRU authority to refer patients to alternative treatment other than hospital emergency room  Facilities  Station 3 upgrades  Permanent Station 7  Public Safety Facility tenant improvements 5.4 DEPARTMENT PROJECT TASK PLAN In recent years, the Department has maintained a Project Task Plan to monitor and manage ongoing projects. At the start of this process, the plan included 179 individual tasks prioritized as follows. The Project Task Plan was intended to be an overall management tool that will sunset upon adoption of this Strategic Plan. 5.4.1 High Priority Tasks (21)  1 completed  19 in progress  1 no progress 5.4.2 Medium Priority Tasks (8)  1 in progress  2 behind schedule  4 not started 5.4.3 Unprioritized Tasks (150)  21 completed  122 in progress  1 behind schedule  4 on hold  2 not started 3.B.a Packet Pg. 65 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 22 5.5 STAKEHOLDER OUTREACH AND ENGAGEMENT In a focused, intentional effort to engage all Department personnel and other key City and community stakeholders in this process, Department staff developed an online survey to capture input from the various stakeholder perspectives as follows. 5.5.1 Fire Department Personnel All Fire Department personnel were invited to participate in an online survey (Appendix A) by internal memorandum distributed via email on January 4, 2023. By the close of the survey on February 6, 2023, eighty-eight of the one hundred thirty-six personnel (65 percent) completed the survey with results summarized as follows. Question 1: Physical Asset Quality The following table summarizes the responses to the request to rate the quality of the following physical assets. Table 8—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Physical Assets Physical Asset Percent Responding Somewhat Good or Very Good Building/Facilities 61% Apparatus Fleet 84% Light-Duty Vehicle Fleet 72% Tools/Equipment 95% Technology 61% Access to Training 63% PPE 93% Uniform 77% Comments to this question included:  Stations 3 and 7 need improvements  Station 5 has long-standing plumbing issues  Concern over recent apparatus out-of-service time  Continue to stay ahead of apparatus replacements 3.B.a Packet Pg. 66 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 23  All stations requesting to all have utility trucks  Tools and equipment are high quality and recent timely purchases are appreciated  Information technology has greatly improved over the past years; however, concerns expressed over time it takes to get technology repairs and responses from Information Services Department (ISD)  Concerns about the timeliness of the training approval process, inconsistent access to training, and lack of training opportunities  Many employees concerned with the newer structural turnout clothing design  Dissatisfaction with the uniform ordering process Question 2: Significant Changes Needing Department Adaptation The responses to the question asking, “What significant changes are occurring or have occurred in Santa Monica that the Department needs to adapt to?” included:  Risk profile changes with increased development and multi-story buildings  Increasing call volume  Increased EMS low-acuity calls / response model  Facilitation of unhoused and mental health issues  Increased demand for services with limited resources Question 3: Three Ways the Department Could Improve Services The following table summarizes responses to the request for respondents to check the top three ways the Department could improve its services to the community. Table 9—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Service Improvements Suggested Improvement Percent Increase communications and visibility to the community 29% Strategically enhance services 62% Provide more staff training 29% Offer more public education 31% Collaborate more with regional partners 42% Seek to diversify staff with future hires 11% Provide improved career ladders or succession planning 65% Increase communications and visibility to the community 0% 3.B.a Packet Pg. 67 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 24 Questions 4–6: Employee Workplace Satisfaction The following table summarizes the responses to three questions rating satisfaction with specific workplace factors. Table 10—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Workplace Satisfaction Workplace Factor Percent Responding Somewhat Good or Very Good Support for your physical wellbeing 81% Support for your emotional/mental wellbeing 65% Compensation, including benefits 91% Diversity, equity, and inclusion 63% Workload 57% Quantity/quality of practical hands-on skills training 66% Computer-based training 54% Professional development opportunities 61% A clear career development path 63% Succession planning and promotional development 64% Communications within your crew/team members 95% Communications within your shift/team 91% Bottom-up communication across the organization 70% Top-down communication by senior leadership 73% Question 7: Employee Perception The following table summarizes the responses to the following questions. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 68 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 25 Table 11—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Employee Perception Perception Factor Percent Responding Yes or Definitely Yes Do you feel a sense of belonging within the Department? 88% Is the Department’s culture inclusive and respectful of individual differences? 79% Do you feel valued? 77% Do you feel trusted by your peers? 95% Do you trust your peers? 86% Are you treated respectfully by Department leadership? 91% Do you trust the Department’s leadership? 79% Do you feel the Department leadership has your best interest in mind? 79% Are you treated respectfully by your peers? 84% Do you respect your peers? 95% Is morale high on your shift/team? 79% Can you raise concerns or express criticisms of the Department without fear of retribution? 74% If you raise ideas for innovation or improvement, will they be carefully considered and implemented if appropriate? 54% Service Priorities The following table summarizes the responses asking for service priorities over the next 5–10 years. Table 12—Fire Department Survey Response Summary – Service Priorities Service Priority Percent None of the following 8% Medical emergency response times 30% Fire emergency response times 6% Terrorism or natural disaster planning 8% Facilitation of homeless or mental health services 48% 3.B.a Packet Pg. 69 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 26 Comments to this question included:  Increased staffing  EMS and fire responses and possible changes to the service delivery model Other Comments Following are common themes to the responses requesting any other comments.  Succession planning for civilian personnel  Improved accountability  Increased training opportunities 5.5.2 Key Allied City Department Stakeholders Stakeholders from the following key allied City departments were invited by direct email sent on January 4, 2023, to provide input through an online stakeholder survey (Appendix B). Table 13—Key Allied City Departments 1. Information Services Department 2. Finance Department 3. Human Resources Department 4. Department of Transportation (DOT) 5. City Manager’s Office 6. Police Department 7. Community Development Department 8. Community Services Department 9. Chief Resiliency Officer / OEM 10. City Attorney’s Office 11. Public Works Department Question 1: Satisfaction with Fire Department Interaction Of the responses received, eighty-two percent rated their interaction with the Department over the past year as satisfied or very satisfied. Question 2: Improving Fire Department Interaction Of the survey responses received, 60 percent provided responses suggesting ways the Fire Department could improve its interaction with the respondent’s department, summarized by theme as follows:  Ensure City policies and procedures are followed  Be better partners and actively participate in collaboration Question 3: Satisfaction with Fire Department Communications Eighty-two percent of respondents said they were satisfied or very satisfied with Fire Department communications with their department. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 70 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 27 Improving Fire Department Communications Sixty percent of the responses received suggested ways the Fire Department could improve communications with the respondent’s department, summarized by theme as follows.  In-person or phone call explanations/clarifications  Identify the Department’s technology liaison  Be present and attend meetings when part of a City team  Including fire updates and messages in other departments’ communications (newsletters, email blasts to City business partners, etc.) Improving Fire Department Collaboration Responses also included suggestions regarding how the Department should better collaborate with City partners, summarized as follows.  More regular scheduled communications for coordination on shared issues (SUS/overdoses, suicide prevention, high users)  Determine the appropriate level to right size the Fire Department budget and eliminate or control unnecessary spending to avoid going over budget. Using DART or the homelessness teams as current examples, Fire should continue to collaborate with other departments  Collaborate on programs that will help better educate our community on fire safety and/or addressing health or fire-related situations in the home  Provide public information and communications updates to relevant City partners Understanding of Fire Department Core Services All survey responses indicated moderate or extensive knowledge of the Department’s core services. Fire Department Strengths Responses to the question, “From your perspective, what does the Fire Department do well?” are summarized as follows:  They work very independently and have very well-defined procedures to deal with outages and other incidents  The planning I have seen with known, upcoming maintenance and downtime situations has been spectacular. Other departments could learn from the Fire Department’s methodologies  Community service and engagement 3.B.a Packet Pg. 71 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 28  Outstanding at responding to emergency calls for service and delivering lifesaving care  Very friendly, approachable, and collaborative Suggested Improvements Responses to the question, “What can the Fire Department do to improve itself?” included:  Be more proactive and less reactive; more scheduled conversations around shared issues  Improved administrative staffing levels  Capitalize on the goodwill and trust the Department has with the community and other City departments to address the issues surrounding the unhoused population  Ensure City policies are followed  The Department could benefit greatly by improving its diversity  Continued community outreach and public awareness of core services and safety tips 5.5.3 City Council The seven City Council members were invited to participate in the survey (Appendix C) by direct email invitation on January 4, 2023, with four responses (57 percent) having been received when the survey closed on February 6, 2023. Fire Department Service Experience The following table summarizes responses to the question, “What services have you received from the Fire Department and how would you rate the Department’s performance relative to services received?” 3.B.a Packet Pg. 72 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 29 Table 14—Rating of Fire Department Service Experience Fire Department Service No Experience Above Average Excellent Fire emergency 1 1 1 Medical emergency 1 1 1 Other emergency 1 1 1 Fire or life safety inspection – business or residential 1 1 1 Plan review 2 1 0 School tour 1 1 1 Station tour 1 1 1 Other public outreach 1 1 1 Secondary Fire Department Service Priorities The following table summarizes responses to the question, “Other than extinguishing fires and responding to medical emergencies, what are the most important service priorities the Department should focus on?” Table 15—Secondary Fire Department Service Priorities Fire Department Service Responses Preventing fires through building and property inspections 3 Teaching hands only Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR) 1 Providing public fire and life safety education 1 Preferred Customer Service Characteristics The following table summarizes responses to the question, “Please select the top three characteristics you feel make for an excellent customer service experience as they relate to services you need from the Santa Monica Fire Department.” 3.B.a Packet Pg. 73 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 30 Table 16—Preferred Characteristics for an Excellent Customer Service Experience Characteristic Responses Level of Training/Proficiency 2 Timely Response 2 Responsiveness 3 Professionalism 0 Problem Solving Skills 1 Communication with Customers 0 Compassion 1 Empathy 0 Courtesy/Politeness 0 Adaptability 0 Helpfulness 0 Satisfaction with Current Department Communications To the question asking Council members’ satisfaction with the current weekly update provided to the City Manager’s Office, one response was neutral, one satisfied, and one very satisfied. Social Media Use The following table summarizes responses to the question, “Do you follow the Santa Monica Fire Department on any of the following social media platforms?” Table 17—Social Media Platforms Followed Social Media Platform Responses Facebook 1 Twitter 1 Nextdoor 0 Instagram 3 SMFD Website 0 Department Strengths The following responses were received to the question, “From your perspective, what does the Santa Monica Fire Department currently do well?” 3.B.a Packet Pg. 74 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 31  Amazing staff that is very well trained and compassionate; they also have amazing response times  Very responsive and easy to work with Challenges Ahead The following responses were received to the question, “List two challenges for the Santa Monica Fire Department over the next five years.”  Addressing homelessness  Recruitment  Funding  Adapting to more social, mental, and medical problems/emergencies than fires Suggested Improvements The following responses were received to the question, “What can the Santa Monica Fire Department do to improve itself?”  Staff CRU team and advocate for more funds and resources to staff CRU with tenured staff  Ensure Fire is out in the community at events, similar to the Police Department 5.5.4 Community Stakeholders The following thirty-one key community individuals or groups were also invited to contribute to this Plan through an online survey. Invitation to participate in the survey was sent by direct email on January 4, 2023, or personal distribution of a QR code to access the survey. The survey was also made available to the public via the Department’s social media platforms and website. At the close of the survey on February 6, 2023, one hundred fifty responses had been received from this stakeholder group. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 75 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 32 Table 18—Community Stakeholders 1. Downtown Santa Monica 2. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School Dist. 3. Santa Monica Pier 4. Pacific Park 5. Santa Monica Place 6. Fairmont Hotel 7. Santa Monica Travel and Tourism 8. Santa Monica History Museum 9. Ocean Park Association 10. Rand Corporation 11. North of Montana Association 12. UCLA 13. NAACP 14. Santa Monica Police Officers Association 15. Santa Monica College 16. Mid Cities Neighbors 17. Friends of Sunset Park 18. Pico Neighborhood 19. Pico HRC 20. Northeast Neighbors 21. Human Relations Council 22. Committee for Racial Justice 23. Wilshire Montana Neighborhood Coalition 24. Rotary Club International 25. Kiwanis Club 26. The People Concern 27. UCLA Santa Monica Medical Center 28. Providence St. Johns 29. Santa Monica Interfaith Council 30. Santa Monica Bay Area Human Relations Council 31. Chamber of Commerce City Connection The following table summarizes the community survey responses regarding the respondent’s connection with the City. Table 19—Stakeholder Connections to City City Connection Percent Live in City 51% Work in City 15% Live and work in City 30% Other 4% Fire Department Service Experience The following table shows the percentage of the above average or excellent responses to the question, “What services have you received from the Department and how would you rate the Department’s performance relative to services received?” 3.B.a Packet Pg. 76 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 33 Table 20—Rating of Fire Department Service Experience Summary Fire Department Service Above Average or Excellent Percentage Fire emergency 93% Medical emergency 89% Other emergency 74% Fire or life safety inspection – business or residential 86% Plan review 77% School tour 88% Station tour 96% Other public outreach 83% Service Satisfaction The following table shows the percentage of the responses receiving a 4 or 5 satisfaction rating on a 1–5 scale to the question, “How satisfied are you with the Department relative to each of the following?” Table 21—Fire Department Service Satisfaction Summary Fire Department Service Factor Above Average or Excellent Percentage Quality of Service 91% Personnel 86% Timeliness of Response 85% Ability to Work with Diverse Populations and Groups 74% Communications 80% Professionalism 88% Fire Prevention Inspections/Plan Check Services 68% Public Education Programs 63% 3.B.a Packet Pg. 77 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 34 Secondary Fire Department Service Priorities The following table summarizes the percentage of responses requesting the most important service priorities the Department should focus on other than extinguishing fires and responding to medical emergencies. Table 22—Secondary Fire Department Service Priorities Fire Department Service Percent Preventing fires through building and property inspections 63% Teaching hands only Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (CPR) 52% Providing public fire and life safety education 61% Other: Community outreach and education; fire hazards; when to call 9-1-1 16% Fire Department Website Use Of responses received, 29 percent of respondents had visited the Department website versus 71 percent who had not. Website Recommendations Following are key themes of the responses received to the request for any comments/recommendations related to the Fire Department website:  Additional information about Department staff and their duties  More information on the 3-1-1 system and how people can get follow-up from the Fire Department  The City website in general is not easy to navigate; it can be difficult to find information when you need it Social Media Use The following table summarizes responses to the question, “Do you follow the Santa Monica Fire Department on any of the following social media platforms?” 3.B.a Packet Pg. 78 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 35 Table 23—Social Media Platforms Followed Social Media Platform Responses Facebook 9 Twitter 23 Instagram 18 Nextdoor 5 Information Platform Preference The following table summarizes the responses received to the question, “How would you prefer to receive information from the Fire Department?” Table 24—Fire Department Information Platform Preference Communication Platform Percent Email 54% USPS Mail 4% Text Message 12% Facebook 4% Instagram 8% Nextdoor 1% Twitter 5% Public Meetings/Events 4% Not interested in receiving information 6% Other 2% Familiarity with SMAlerts Of the responses received to the question, “Are you familiar with SMAlerts?” 71 percent responded, “yes” and 29 percent, “no.” SMAlerts Registration To the survey question, “Have you registered your mobile telephone number with SMAlerts?” Of the responses received, eighty percent responded, “yes” and 20 percent responded, “no.” 3.B.a Packet Pg. 79 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 36 Preferred Customer Service Characteristics The following table summarizes responses to the survey question, “Please select the top three characteristics you feel make for an excellent customer service experience as they relate to services you need from the Santa Monica Fire Department.” Table 25—Preferred Customer Service Characteristics Characteristic Percent Timely Response 68% Level of Training/Proficiency 58% Responsiveness 29% Professionalism 27% Communication with Customers 24% Helpfulness 20% Problem Solving Skills 21% Empathy 17% Compassion 11% Courtesy/Politeness 11% Adaptability 6% Suggested Improvements The following is a summary of responses received to the question, “What can the Santa Monica Fire Department do to improve itself?”  Assist the public in knowing how to respond to/report issues related to people experiencing homelessness  Additional fire resources to address homelessness and people experiencing homelessness  Increased community outreach, engagement, and visibility in non-response capacities  Increased fire education programming 3.B.a Packet Pg. 80 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 5—Environmental Scan page 37 Other Comments The following is a summary of responses to the question, “Are there any other comments regarding the Santa Monica Fire Department and the level of service it provides to the City that you would like us to consider in the development of our five-year strategic plan?”  Improved response times  Continue to provide high-quality services  Improved community classes like CERT, DART, Civilian Fire Academy, Cadet program, and ongoing public training  Accessibility issues regarding traffic and response vehicles  Impact that the unhoused population has on the fire service 3.B.a Packet Pg. 81 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 82 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 39 SECTION 6—PERFORMANCE AUDIT The Planning Committee assessed the Department’s current state and performance as follows. 6.1 EMERGENCY SERVICES PERFORMANCE In 2019, the Department retained Citygate Associates, LLC (Citygate) to conduct a Standards of Coverage (SOC) study to review the adequacy of its current fire station deployment system, the risks to be protected, and the emergency incident outcomes desired by the community. The Planning Committee reviewed this study as one component of the Department’s current state and performance. 6.1.1 Assessment Methodology The core methodology used by Citygate for this deployment analysis was the “Standards of Response Coverage,” which is a systems-based approach to fire department deployment as published by the Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI). This approach uses local risk factors and demographics to determine the level of protection best fitting the Department’s needs and evaluates deployment using risk and community expectations on outcomes to help elected officials make informed decisions on fire and EMS deployment levels. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 83 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 40 Fire service deployment, simply summarized, is about the speed and weight of response. Speed refers to initial response (first-due) of all-risk intervention resources (e.g., engines, ladder trucks, rescues, ambulances) strategically deployed across a jurisdiction for response to emergencies within a travel time sufficient to control routine to moderate emergencies without the incident escalating to greater size or severity. Weight refers to multiple-unit responses for more serious emergencies, such as building fires, multiple-patient medical emergencies, vehicle collisions with extrication required, or technical rescue incidents where more firefighters must be assembled within a time interval to safely control the emergency and prevent it from escalating into an even more serious event. The Standards of Response Coverage process consists of the following eight elements: Table 26—Standards of Response Coverage Process Elements SOC Element Description 1 Existing Deployment Policies A review of current agency deployment policies. 2 Community Outcome Expectations A review of the community’s expectations relative to the agency’s response to emergencies. 3 Community Risk Assessment A review of the assets at risk within the community. 4 Critical Task Study Identification of the essential tasks that must be performed and the personnel required to deliver a stated outcome for an ERF. 5 Distribution Analysis Analysis of the spacing of initial response (first-due) resources (typically engines) to control routine emergencies. 6 Concentration Analysis Analysis of the spacing of fire stations so that larger or more complex emergencies receive sufficient resources in a timely manner to prevent escalation (ERF). 7 Reliability and Historical Response Effectiveness Studies Using recent prior response statistics, determining the percentage of conformance to established response performance goals the existing deployment system delivers. 8 Overall Evaluation Proposing Standard of Cover statements by risk type as appropriate. Source: CFAI Standards of Cover, 6th Edition 6.1.2 Standard of Cover Findings and Recommendations Pursuant to the 2019 assessment, Citygate made seventeen findings and seven recommendations. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 84 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 41 SOC Findings Finding #1: The Department’s response unit types are appropriate to protect against the hazards likely to impact the City. The daily staffing of 35 personnel provides a minimum ERF for one emerging to serious incident with remaining staffing capacity for two concurrent moderate incidents requiring only a single engine response. Finding #2: The Department has established response performance objectives partially consistent with best practice recommendations as published by the CFAI. However, the City Council has not recently adopted a complete, best practice-based response time goal that begins with the 9-1-1 call receipt, nor goals for all types of emergency risk outcomes. Finding #3: The Department has a standard response plan that considers risk and establishes an appropriate initial response for each incident type; each type of call for service receives the combination of engines, trucks, specialty units, and command officers customarily needed to effectively control that type of incident based on Department experience. Finding #4: The geographic mapping coverage analysis shows the current City fire station locations are too closely spaced to provide best practice first responder travel times to all neighborhoods. Prompt travel from the stations to the outer neighborhoods is hampered by dense zoning and cars parked on streets and exacerbated by traffic congestion at peak commute or recreational activity periods. Finding #5: At least two simultaneous incidents are occurring more than fifty-seven percent of the time. This primarily impacts station areas 1 and 3. Finding #6: The annual number of simultaneous incidents has been relatively constant over the past four years. As simultaneous incidents increase, the coverage provided by the busiest companies to their own station areas and adjacent station areas diminishes, which further shifts workload to other companies. Finding #7: While the GIS map model of 4:00-minute travel time coverage reaches the pier and beach areas, due to visitor congestion, the area is very difficult to get to quickly. For incidents in the temporary Station 7 area, the travel time is 5:47 minutes from Station 1 and 5:55 minutes from Station 2. Both times are significantly slower than a 4:00-minute goal. Finding #8: Santa Monica’s dispatch processing time of 2:36 to 2:50 minutes is far slower than a fire service best practice of 1:30 minutes. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 85 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 42 Finding #9: Santa Monica has not been measuring PSC processing performance from the earliest possible time stamp of PSAP receipt. The City must rectify this as soon as possible. Finding #10: At 2:50 minutes, 90th percentile crew turnout performance is 50 seconds slower than a Citygate-recommended goal of 2:00 minutes or less. Finding #11: At 5:19 minutes, 90th percentile first-unit travel time performance is thirty-three percent slower than the 4:00-minute best practice goal for urban areas. Finding #12: There are serious medical emergencies in all of the City’s zip codes. Even if counts vary by area, all have the same EMS risks to be protected equally. Finding #13: Zip codes 90402 and 90403 are too far from a fire station to receive travel time coverage in less than 5:00 minutes, especially during periods of traffic congestion. Finding #14: Outdoor EMS emergencies are slowing dispatch and travel times due to their volume and difficult-to-determine locations and emergency types. The quantity is large enough Citywide to justify a separate response-time measure to ensure these emergencies do not inadvertently lengthen Department performance measures to buildings and other surface street (not freeway) locations. Finding #15: EMS incidents involving unhoused persons cluster into fifteen principal types found predominately downtown and the oceanfront. These incidents would benefit from a non-traditional EMS health care approach. Finding #16: At a realistic (inclusive of full dispatch time) measure of 9:10 minutes, 90th percentile first-unit call-to-arrival performance is significantly slower than a best practice and Citygate-recommended goal of 7:30 minutes. Finding #17: At a realistic (inclusive of full dispatch time) measure of 11:16 minutes, the 90th percentile ERF (First Alarm) call-to-arrival performance is faster than the Citygate- recommended goal of 11:30 minutes for urban areas. This is due to there being multiple fire stations in the core of the City where most of the more serious events occur. SOC Recommendations Recommendation #1: Use existing resources to improve incident data capture and decrease 9-1-1 dispatch and fire crew turnout times to best practices levels. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 86 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 43 Recommendation #2: Deploy at least one four-firefighter engine company in a station located in the northern 25 percent of the City. If this is not possible, deploy a two-firefighter/paramedic FRU from a smaller, commercial location in the northern 25 percent of the City. Recommendation #3: Given the longer response/travel times to the pier and beach areas, the Department should continue to provide at least a small FRU located in the immediate area. Recommendation #4: Develop a program that includes non-Departmental stakeholders to deploy an outdoor medical specialty response team of firefighter/paramedics and allied health care personnel to meet the needs of the patients presenting in Santa Monica. Recommendation #5: It is critically important for the City team to conduct a detailed follow- up regarding incidents taking longer than 3:00 minutes to process in the PSC, and determine which factors, if any, causing delays can be mitigated. Recommendation #6: Given the high volume of outdoor emergencies overall, in addition to the pier and beach areas, the City should adopt a two-tier dispatch measure: one for in-building EMS events and another for outdoor, oceanfront, and freeway emergencies. Recommendation #7: Adopt Updated Deployment Policies: The City Council should adopt updated, complete performance measures to aid deployment planning and to monitor performance. The measures of time should be designed to deliver outcomes that will save patients, when possible, upon arrival and keep small and expanding fires from becoming more serious. With this is mind, Citygate recommends the following measures: 7.1 Distribution of Fire Stations: To treat pre-hospital medical emergencies and control small fires, the first-due unit should arrive within 7:30 minutes, 90 percent of the time from the receipt of the 9-1-1 call at the City’s PSC; this equates to a 90-second dispatch time, a 2:00-minute company turnout time, and a 4:00-minute travel time. 7.2 Multiple-Unit Effective Response Force (ERF) for Serious Emergencies: To confine building fires near the room of origin, keep vegetation fires under one acre in size, and treat multiple medical patients at a single incident, a multiple-unit ERF of at least 23 3.B.a Packet Pg. 87 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 44 personnel, including at least one Battalion Chief, should arrive within 11:30 minutes from the time of 9-1-1 call receipt at the City’s PSC 90 percent of the time. This equates to a 90-second dispatch time, 2:00-minute company turnout time, and 8:00-minute travel time. 7.3 Hazardous Materials Response: To protect the City from the hazards associated with uncontrolled release of hazardous and toxic materials, a multiple-unit ERF of at least 20 personnel, including on-duty hazardous materials specialists, the Department’s hazardous materials response unit, and at least one Chief Officer, should arrive within 11:30 minutes from the time of 9-1-1 call receipt at the City’s PSC 90 percent of the time. This equates to a 90-second dispatch time, 2:00-minute company turnout time, and 8:00-minute travel time. 7.4 Technical Rescue: To provide technical rescue services as needed with enough trained personnel to facilitate a successful rescue, a multiple-unit ERF of at least 25 personnel, including on-duty technical rescue specialists and at least one Chief Officer, should arrive within 11:30 minutes from the time of 9-1-1 call receipt at the City’s PSC 90 percent of the time. This equates to a 90-second dispatch time, 2:00-minute company turnout time, and 8:00-minute travel time to facilitate safe rescue/extrication and delivery of the victim to the appropriate emergency medical care facility. 6.2 STRENGTHS, WEAKNESSES, OPPORTUNITIES, AND THREATS ASSESSMENT As a second component of the Department’s current state and performance, Citygate facilitated an assessment of Department Strengths, Weaknesses/Limitations, Opportunities, and Threats (S.W.O.T.) through small group exercises during the second planning workshop on February 6, 2023. The assessment provided the following results. 6.2.1 Strengths  Personnel knowledge and engagement  Apparatus fleet  Training  Specialized response services (USAR, HazMat, ARFF, CRU, REM)  Customer service  Headquarters location (downtown services coverage)  Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 88 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 45  Organizational culture/wellness  Community support  Organizational flexibility / pilot programs  Police Department relationship  Pre-planning  Self-sufficiency  Opportunities for varied assignments  Firefighter rank evaluation process  Low turnover  Robust Capital Improvement Project process  Logistics section  Motivated workforce  City support resources  EMS response model  Participation in the Los Angeles Area Fire Chiefs Association  Regional fire agency relationships  Labor-management relationship  Recruit training academy accreditation  Use of technology  Emergency incident mitigation  Staff/personnel 6.2.2 Weaknesses/Limitations  Staffing shortages / workload capacity  Operations  Administration  Fire Prevention  Long-term solution to houseless crisis  Facilities 3.B.a Packet Pg. 89 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 46  Public Safety Facility improvements  Station 3  Station 7  Training Facility CIP  The size of response districts  EMS ambulance transport contract with McCormick Ambulance  Contract compliance  No dedicated EMS division  Budget limitations  Service fees collection  Number of Department firefighter paramedics  No community paramedicine program  Availability of employee mental health counseling and therapy services from providers familiar with public safety challenges  A need for a more comprehensive preventive cancer screening  Organizational culture relative to PPE hygiene  Lack of disposable booties for contaminated scenes  Infectious disease exposure awareness and hygiene when responding to skilled nursing / rehabilitation facilities  Uneven incident workload  Response resource distribution/locations (e.g., north of Montana Avenue)  Recruitment outreach capacity  Recruitment diversity  Number of qualified Engine Strike Team leaders  Fire Department collaboration/presence in the Public Safety Communications Center 6.2.3 Opportunities The Planning Committee identified the following opportunities with a focus on potential collaborative partnerships. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 90 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 47  Local hospitals  Los Angeles County Emergency Medical Services Agency (LEMSA) policy awareness/education  Field response resource funding  Improved collaboration  Elementary/middle/high schools  Cadet program  ROP program  Career days  Mentorships  Parent-Teacher organizations  Neighborhood groups  Los Angeles County Emergency Medical Services Agency  Advocate for policy changes impacting pre-hospital healthcare system  Creative solutions to provide medication for unhoused individuals  On-call professional physical/mental health therapists  On duty Physician’s Assistant / Nurse Practitioner with authority to issue on-site prescriptions to patients not needing transport to the emergency department  Sponsorships opportunities (company logos on apparatus)  Sponsorships to fund socks, blankets, shoes, etc. for homeless  Embedded Fire Department member on City Outreach Team  Revenue to offset the cost of facilitating large events in City/region (e.g., World Cup, Olympics)  Airport re-use plan / Station 5 location  Additional truck company 6.2.4 Threats  EMS  Citywide staffing shortages  External staffing shortages (hospitals, McCormick, etc.) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 91 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 48  Supply chain shortages  Ambulance availability  Hospital emergency department wait times  Unknown virus exposures  Loss of authority to provide ambulance services  Finance  Loss of revenue due to changing EMS payor mix  Department program funding  Inability to increase Department budget  Loss of grant funding  Taxpayer ballot measures  Staffing/workload capacity  Operations  Alternative response models  Decommissioning of some existing response resources  Facility security  Technology hacking  Council support of strategic goals  Safety  Personnel safety (active shooter, mental illness, behavioral issues)  Synthetic drug exposure  Unknown disease exposures  Employee workload fatigue/burnout  Fire Prevention  Staffing/workload capacity  Ordinance changes  International Code Council (ICC) scalar structural changes  Impacts of traffic calming measures on response performance 3.B.a Packet Pg. 92 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 6—Performance Audit page 49  Political landscape  Public image and perception  Shifting priorities 3.B.a Packet Pg. 93 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 94 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 7—Envisioning Success page 51 SECTION 7—ENVISIONING SUCCESS The Planning Committee was tasked to identify what success should look like at the end of the five-year planning horizon. Through multiple small group exercises, the Committee envisioned the following outcomes / end states considering all preceding planning elements including Department program and service priorities, critical issues / service gaps, unmet organizational needs, potential collaboration/partnership opportunities, the Department’s current Project Task Plan, the performance audit, and stakeholder outreach results.  Increased staffing  Operational response staffing  Administrative functions staffing  Effective Response Force (ERF) staffing  Right-sized Department budget  Continued updating/work of Department-level plans 3.B.a Packet Pg. 95 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 7—Envisioning Success page 52  Solid succession plan  Career pathways plan  Resilient, sustainable response model meeting best practices  Funding/support to accomplish strategic goals  Satisfied workforce  360-degree evaluations  Comprehensive employee mental health/wellness program  Agency accreditation  Appropriate resources to address the impacts that homelessness has on service demand and capacity  Improved understanding of SMFD programs and services (internal and external awareness)  Facility needs addressed  Dedicated EMS division with appropriate staffing capacity to address current needs and potential future services  Organizational culture shift relative to health, wellness, and safety practices  Upward mobility / career pathways for civilian staff  A comprehensive Community Risk Reduction Plan  Improved recruitment outreach  Measured Strategic Plan success  Maintain current response unit staffing levels  Improved relationships with allied City departments  Maintain high employee retention  Improved Public Safety Communications Center fire dispatch services 3.B.a Packet Pg. 96 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 8—Strategic Initiatives page 53 SECTION 8—STRATEGIC INITIATIVES 8.1 STRATEGIC INITIATIVES OVERVIEW In the context of this Strategic Plan:  Goal – a desired end state or outcome.  Strategy – the broad approach or framework used to achieve a goal.  Objectives – the measurable steps needed to fully execute a strategy. 8.2 STRATEGIC PLAN GOALS, STRATEGIES, AND OBJECTIVES Following the performance audit and envisioned success exercises, the Planning Committee developed and refined the following four overarching goals, 14 strategies to achieve those goals, and 38 measurable objectives needed to fully execute those strategies. These goals, strategies, and objectives were developed and refined over two workshops to address critical issues; performance/service gaps; unmet organizational needs; organizational strengths, weaknesses/limitations, opportunities, and threats; and stakeholder survey results over the next five years. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 97 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 8—Strategic Initiatives page 54 8.2.1 Goal 1: An Organization Closely Aligned with Community Values, Needs, and Service Expectations Strategy 1A—Improve Community Outreach and Communications Objective 1A-1: Develop and implement a community outreach, communications, and engagement plan to facilitate enhanced engagement with community stakeholders including neighborhood associations. Objective 1A-2: Explore opportunities to make alterations to enhance the Department website to include additional content. Strategy 1B—A Holistic Focus on Community Risk Reduction Objective 1B-1: Develop and implement a comprehensive Community Risk Reduction Plan. Strategy 1C—A Long-Term Solution to the Impacts that Unhoused and Vulnerable Populations have on Operational Capacity and Service Levels Objective 1C-1: Continue to evaluate and evolve the Community Response Unit (CRU) to include development of a comprehensive program that addresses the operational impacts of calls for service and resultant case management. Strategy 1D—Improved Communication, Coordination, and Collaboration with Allied City Departments Objective 1D-1: Continued involvement in Citywide committees and work groups. Objective 1D-2: Evaluate other opportunities to build and improve relationships and collaborate with other City departments. 8.2.2 Goal 2: Services, Programs, and Resources Appropriate to Carry Out Our Mission Strategy 2A—Programs and Services that Protect the Values at Risk and Meet Community Needs and Expectations Objective 2A-1: A dedicated Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Division with appropriate staffing to manage existing EMS services and evaluate SMFD’s current deployment/response models, including in-house ambulance transport services, a community paramedicine program, etc. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 98 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 8—Strategic Initiatives page 55 Objective 2A-2: A sustainable operational deployment model that meets best practices. Objective 2A-3: Operational response performance goals that facilitate desired emergency incident outcomes. Objective 2A-4: Update the 2019 Standards of Cover Study. Strategy 2B—Appropriate Operational Response, Support, and Administrative Services Staffing Capacity Objective 2B-1: Operational response services and staffing capacity appropriate to protect the values at risk from expected hazards and meet community service expectations to include EMS and special operations. Objective 2B-2: Adequate administrative, training, and fire prevention staffing capacity to meet current and anticipated future City and Department needs and workload demand. Objective 2B-3: Collaborate with Office of Emergency Management (OEM) management to identify service enhancement opportunities relative to Fire Department dispatch including a thorough review of the 2023 Federal Engineering Regional Fire Dispatch Consolidation Study. Strategy 2C—Safe, Reliable Facilities Adequate for Current and Projected Future Needs Objective 2C-1: Response resource locations or station spacing that facilitate desired outcomes and adopted response performance goals. Objective 2C-2: Continue to pursue Fire Facilities Master Plan goals to include tenant improvements in the Fire Department section of the Public Safety Facility to better accommodate Department administrative staff, a Station 3 upgrade, and construction of a permanent Station 7. Objective 2C-3: Seek reliable funding for the Fire Facilities Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). Strategy 2D—Safe, Reliable Apparatus and Equipment Appropriate to Meet Current and Future Needs Objective 2D-1: Continue to maintain and periodically update the Apparatus Replacement Plan and required CIP funding. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 99 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 8—Strategic Initiatives page 56 8.2.3 Goal 3: Sustained Organizational Vitality Strategy 3A—An Organizational and Individual Focus on Employee Health, Safety, and Wellness Objective 3A-1: Develop and support a comprehensive employee mental health/wellness program that recognizes the unique needs of public safety personnel. Objective 3A-2: Update the Safety Program to conform with recognized industry best practices where possible. Objective 3A-3: Identify opportunities to reduce work-related injuries and improve injury case management and return to work processes. Strategy 3B—An Adaptable Organization Open to Change, Innovation, Accountability, and Continuous Improvement Objective 3B-1: Foster an inclusive culture that welcomes and supports diversity, equity, and inclusion. Objective 3B-2: Improved organizational awareness relative to employee health, wellness, and safety practices. Objective 3B-3: An organizational structure that provides appropriate workload distribution, supervision, skills/competencies, and job title and descriptions. Objective 3B-4: Continued development and execution of Department-level plans. Objective 3B-5: Attain Center for Public Safety Excellence (CPSE) / Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI) accreditation. Objective 3B-6: Measurable Strategic Plan implementation progress. Objective 3B-7: Provide team building opportunities throughout the organization that foster and promote leadership, motivation, professionalism, accountability, and strengthened connections among all staff. Objective 3B-8: Improved use of data to address emerging issues and plan for service delivery challenges. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 100 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 8—Strategic Initiatives page 57 Strategy 3C—An Organizational Environment that Fosters and Supports Personal and Professional Growth and Development Objective 3C-1: Establish clear career pathways for each division/function including required and desired knowledge, skills, and competencies for each position. Objective 3C-2: Provide effective succession planning and training throughout all levels of the organization, including better utilization of Department instructors and providing all employees the tools they need for continuous improvement. Objective 3C-3: Ensure equity of opportunity for assignments, training, education, and promotion. Objective 3C-4: Explore opportunities to implement a more comprehensive performance evaluation process to include 360-degree reviews. Objective 3C-5: Firefighter recruitment efforts focused on middle school through college outreach to educate and encourage students into fire service career pathways, potentially including an Explorer or Cadet program. 8.2.4 Goal 4: Improved Organizational Systems and Processes Strategy 4A—Improve Fee Collection Workflow Objective 4A-1: Employ fiscal best practices in all SMFD billing processes. Objective 4A-2: Implement software upgrades and/or third-party billing solutions. Strategy 4B—Ensure Sustainable Funding for Mission-Critical Programs, Services, and Capital Facilities and Equipment Objective 4B-1: Collaborate with other City departments to establish a Citywide Developer Impact Fee. Objective 4B-2: Explore potential alternative funding and other cost-recovery options. Strategy 4C—Leverage Technology to Improve Organizational Systems and Processes Objective 4C-1: Update Technology Strategic Plan to include findings from the February 2023 Moss Adams Risk Assessment Survey. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 101 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) 3.B.a Packet Pg. 102 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 59 SECTION 9—PLAN IMPLEMENTATION AND MEASURING PROGRESS The final step of the planning process involves initially prioritizing the implementation sequence of the strategic objectives, developing a Detailed Action Plan for each strategic objective, determining the interval for periodic review, updating of Strategic Plan elements as needed, and determining how and when the Plan will be introduced to the organization and stakeholders. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 103 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 60 9.1 STRATEGIC OBJECTIVES IMPLEMENTATION SEQUENCE To provide opportunity for early success—and to build and maintain momentum—the Planning Committee identified the following three categories to guide implementation of the thirty-eight strategic objectives.  Category A Can be achieved with existing Department resources.  Category B Can be initiated with existing department resources but will require additional resources to fully achieve.  Category C Cannot be initiated without additional resources. It should be noted that implementation may change as available organizational capacity, needed resources, and/or strategic objectives evolve over the five-year planning term. 3.B.a Packet Pg. 104 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 61 Table 27—Initial Strategic Objectives Implementation Priority Goal Strategy Objectives Implementation Category 1 An Organization Closely Aligned with Community Values, Needs, and Service Expectations A: Improve Community Outreach and Communication 1A-1 Develop and implement a Community Outreach, Communications, and Engagement Plan to facilitate enhanced engagement with community stakeholders including neighborhood group associations. A 1A-2 Explore opportunities to make alterations to enhance the Department website including additional content. B B: A Holistic Focus on Community Risk Reduction 1B-1 Develop and implement a comprehensive Community Risk Reduction Plan. B C: A Long-Term Solution to the Impacts the Unhoused and Vulnerable Populations have on Operational Capacity and Service Levels 1C-1 Continue to evaluate and evolve the Community Response Unit (CRU) to include development of a comprehensive program that addresses the operational impacts of calls for service and resultant case management. B D: Improved Communication, Coordination, and Collaboration with Allied City Departments 1D-1 Continued involvement in Citywide committees and work groups. A 1D-2 Evaluate other opportunities to build/improve relationships and collaborate with other City departments. A 3.B.a Packet Pg. 105 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 62 Goal Strategy Objectives Implementation Category 2 Services, Programs, and Resources Appropriate to Carry Out Our Mission A: Programs and Services that Protect the Values at Risk and Meet Community Needs and Expectations 2A-1 A dedicated Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Division with appropriate staffing to manage existing EMS services and evaluate SMFD’s current deployment/response models, including in-house ambulance transport services, a community paramedicine program, etc. C 2A-2 A sustainable operational deployment model that meets best practices. B 2A-3 Operational response performance goals that facilitate desired emergency incident outcomes. A 2A-4 Update 2019 Standards of Cover Study. A B: Appropriate Operational Response, Support, and Administrative Services Staffing Capacity 2B-1 Operational response services and staffing capacity appropriate to protect the values at risk from expected hazards and meet community service expectations to include EMS and special operations. B 2B-2 Adequate administrative, training, and fire prevention staffing capacity to meet current and anticipated City and Department needs and workload demand. B 2B-3 Evaluate fire dispatch services. A C: Safe, Reliable Facilities Adequate for Current and Projected Future Needs 2C-1 Response resource locations or station spacing that facilitate desired outcomes and adopted response performance goals. C 2C-2 Continue to pursue Fire Facilities Master Plan goals to include a tenant improvement to the Public Safety Facility to better accommodate Department administrative staff, a Station 3 replacement, and construction of a permanent Station 7. C 2C-3 Seek reliable funding for Fire Facilities Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). B D: Safe, Reliable Apparatus and Equipment Appropriate to Meet Current and Future Needs 2D-1 Continue to maintain and periodically update the Apparatus Replacement Plan and required CIP funding. A 3.B.a Packet Pg. 106 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 63 Goal Strategy Objectives Implementation Category 3 Sustained Organizational Vitality A: An Organizational and Individual Focus on Employee Health, Safety and Wellness 3A-1 Develop and support a comprehensive employee mental health/wellness program that recognizes the unique needs of public safety personnel. C 3A-2 Update the Safety Program to conform with recognized industry best practices where possible. A 3A-3 Identify opportunities to reduce work-related injuries and improve injury case management and return to work processes. C B: An Adaptable Organization Open to Change, Innovation, Accountability, Continuous Improvement 3B-1 Foster an organizational culture that welcomes and supports diversity and inclusivity. A 3B-2 Improved organizational awareness relative to employee health, wellness, and safety practices. A 3B-3 An organizational structure that provides appropriate workload distribution, supervision, skill/competencies, and job titles/descriptions. B 3B-4 Continued development and execution of department-level plans. A 3B-5 Attain Center for Public Safety Excellence (CPSE)/Commission on Fire Accreditation International (CFAI) accreditation. A 3B-6 Measurable Strategic Plan implementation progress. A 3B-7 Provide team building opportunities throughout the organization that foster and promote leadership, motivation, professionalism, accountability, and strengthened connections among all staff. A 3B-8 Improved use of data to address emerging issues and plan for service delivery challenges. A C: An Organizational Environment that Fosters and Supports Personal and Professional Growth and Development 3C-1 Establish clear career pathways for each division/function including required and desired knowledge, skills, and competencies for each position. A 3C-2 Provide effective succession planning and training throughout all levels of the organization, including better utilization of SMFD instructors and providing all employees the tools they need for continuous improvement. A 3.B.a Packet Pg. 107 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 64 Goal Strategy Objectives Implementation Category 3C-3 Ensure equity of opportunity for assignments, training, education, and promotion. A 3C-4 Explore opportunities to implement a more comprehensive performance evaluation process to include 360-degree reviews. B 3C-5 Firefighter recruitment efforts focused on middle school through college outreach to educate and encourage students into fire service career pathways, potentially including an Explorer or Cadet Program. C 4 Improved Organizational Systems and Processes A: Improve Fee Collection Workflow 4A-1 Employ fiscal best practices in all SMFD billing processes. A 4A-2 Implement software upgrades and/or third-party billing solutions. A B: Ensure Sustainable Funding for Mission Critical Programs, Services, and Capital Facilities and Equipment 4B-1 Collaborate with other City departments to establish a Citywide Developer Impact Fee. A 4B-2 Explore potential alternative funding and/or other cost recovery options. B C: Leverage technology to improve organizational systems and processes 4C-1 Update Technology Strategic Plan to include findings from the February 2023 Moss Adams Risk Assessment Survey. A 3.B.a Packet Pg. 108 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 65 9.2 DETAILED ACTION PLANS Detailed Action Plans clearly articulate the sequential steps needed to fully achieve an objective, including a description of each step, the metric for success, whether governing body policy action is required, estimated cost and funding source(s), other resources needed, who or what specific position is responsible for each step, and the expected timeline for completion. In a facilitated exercise, the Planning Committee identified some of the sequential steps needed to achieve selected higher priority objectives of this Plan; however, additional work will be needed to fully complete these. The Fire Chief, in collaboration with the Executive Management Team, will designate which individuals or group will be responsible for developing the annual work plan (as discussed in the following sub-section) as well as developing detailed action plans for those objectives identified for inclusion in the initial and succeeding annual work plans. Examples of detailed action plans are included in Appendix E for reference. 9.3 ANNUAL WORK PLAN Annual work plans are critical to creating and maintaining momentum and making continued progress on any long-term plan. The Planning Committee established the desire to develop an annual work plan corresponding with the City’s biennial budget cycle and incorporating those strategies and objectives that will receive intentional focus and effort over that 12-month period considering anticipated organizational capacity and availability of needed resources. Strategies and objectives need not be accomplished in any specific priority or sequence; however, they should be initiated individually or in parallel to ensure logical and incremental progress toward achievement of a particular strategy or goal. The Planning Committee established the following Annual Work Plan schedule with Annual Work Plan progress to be reviewed at each monthly Command and General Staff meeting. Table 28—Annual Work Plan Development Schedule Objective Date Initiate Annual Work Plan development January 2 Complete Draft Annual Work Plan January 24 Complete Detailed Action Plans for included Strategic Objectives June 1 Final City Budget adopted Second Tuesday in June Finalize Annual Work Plan June 30 Implement Annual Work Plan July 1 3.B.a Packet Pg. 109 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) City of Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan Section 9—Plan Implementation and Measuring Progress page 66 9.4 PLAN MAINTENANCE To ensure continuing progress and the effectiveness and relevance of the Strategic Plan, an individual or group—to be identified by the Fire Chief in collaboration with the Executive Management Team—will be tasked to review this Plan at least quarterly for the first year, and thereafter as determined by the Fire Chief and/or Review Team. The Strategic Plan will be revised as needed (1) to provide maximum utilization of available resources to achieve the identified strategic goals, and (2) to add or modify strategies and objectives as needed to address changes in the political, fiscal, organizational, or overall City environment. 9.5 STRATEGIC PLAN ROLLOUT The final Strategic Plan will be presented to the Department’s Command and General Staff at their May 17, 2023 meeting. The Fire Chief will determine how the Plan will subsequently be introduced to the following project stakeholders.  All Fire Department staff  City Manager  City Council  Other City Departments  Santa Monica community stakeholder groups 3.B.a Packet Pg. 110 Attachment: Santa Monica Fire Department 2023–2028 Strategic Plan (07-26-23) (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Plan) Santa Monica Fire Department Strategi Plan 2023-2028 January 23, 2024 3.B.b Packet Pg. 111 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Why a Strategic Plan? •Reinforces our Mission, Vision and Values •Communicates leader’s intent and vision to all members and stakeholders •Sets a common path •Establishes a framework and forecasts resources •Serves as an ongoing communications tool to future leadership, stakeholders and personnel 3.B.b Packet Pg. 112 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Our Stakeholders… •Key community leaders •City Council •Key City Staff throughout the City family •Local 1109 •Wide spectrum of Fire Department staff across the organization 3.B.b Packet Pg. 113 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic The Process… •Provides status of fire department •Provides stakeholder view and needs of the fire department •Review of current projects, policies and programs •Identification of immediate versus longer terms needs •Alignment with Council strategies •Alignment with fire service best practices •Preparation for accreditation 3.B.b Packet Pg. 114 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic The Outcome… •Five-year plan – 2023 - 2028 •Four primary Goals, 14 Strategies and 38 Objectives •15 Objectives currently under implementation for FY 2023-2024 •Managed monthly by objective and their related tasks •Direct integration with: •Council Goals •City Workplan •2024-2026 CIP requests 3.B.b Packet Pg. 115 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic The Outcome… •Ensure we have the resources to provide quick emergency response to our community •Ensuring we have resources for addressing homelessness •Establishment of the Emergency Medical Division •Alternative ambulance plan being researched •Fire Station 3 and 7 need replacing •Apparatus replacement program is working well •Community outreach for DEI including explorer program and recruitment efforts 3.B.b Packet Pg. 116 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic Questions? Thank you! Wolfgang Knabe Fire Chief 3.B.b Packet Pg. 117 Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation (6182 : City Manager Report- SM Fire Dept Strategic