Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
SR 01-10-2023 8C 106-002-02 / 106-024-02 / 106-040-02
City Council Report City Council Meeting: January 10, 2023 Agenda Item: 8.C 1 of 1 To: Mayor and City Council From: Denise Anderson Warren, City Clerk, Records and Election Services Department Subject: Appointment to three unscheduled vacancies on the multiple Commissions. Continued from October 25th and November 15, 2022 Board/Commission Number of Appointments Term End Date Requirements Airport Commission 1 6/30/2024 Santa Monica Resident Disabilities Commission 1 6/30/2025 Santa Monica Resident Personnel Board 1 6/30/2023 Santa Monica Resident Prepared By: Esterlina Lugo, Deputy City Clerk Approved Forwarded to Council Attachments: A. Applicant Lists_Airport, Disabilities, Personnel B. Written Comments_20221115 8.C Packet Pg. 345 Revised 11/09/22 at 4 pm City of Santa Monica Boards and Commissions Applicants Airport Commission Name Application Date Margaret Falk 5/25/2022 David J. Hopkins 9/27/2022 Eve Lopez 1/23/2022 Joseph A. Pertel 11/07/2022 Kate Scott 5/22/2022 TOTAL APPLICANTS: 5 *Incumbents listed in red 8.C.a Packet Pg. 346 Attachment: Applicant Lists_Airport, Disabilities, Personnel [Revision 1] (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Revised 1/06/23 at 5:15pm City of Santa Monica Boards and Commissions Applicants Disabilities Commission Name Application Date Cinzia Paganuzzi 12/29/2022 TOTAL APPLICANTS: 1 *Identified person with a disability *Incumbents listed in red 8.C.a Packet Pg. 347 Attachment: Applicant Lists_Airport, Disabilities, Personnel [Revision 1] (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Revised 1/06/23 at 5:15pm City of Santa Monica Boards and Commissions Applicants Personnel Board Name Application Date Melanie Luthern Allen 12/27/2022 Dirk W. van de Bunt 11/07/2022 TOTAL APPLICANTS: 2 *Incumbents listed in red 8.C.a Packet Pg. 348 Attachment: Applicant Lists_Airport, Disabilities, Personnel [Revision 1] (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:nicole faries <cali.faries@gmail.com> Sent:Friday, November 11, 2022 3:45 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support longtime Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Nicole Faries Sunset Park Item 16.A 11/15/22 1 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 349 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Patti Braun <pattibraun@aol.com> Sent:Friday, November 11, 2022 3:12 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Mayor Himmelrich, Mayor Pro Tem McCowan, and esteemed Councilmembers, I am writing today in support of my friend, long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for appointment to the airport commission. As a Sunset Park resident since 1991, I am committed to insuring that we continue to move forward on the closure of the Santa Monica Airport in 2028, and I and my husband support its conversion to a “great park” with open green space and recreational facilities, as approved by the majority of our residents in 2014. Joe Pertel shares this commitment and will make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He has worked to create opportunities for our Santa Monica students and advocated alongside myself and other parent leaders in support of our excellent schools. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Sunset Park, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during the next few critical years of the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, and will promote sustainable use with the expansion of Airport Park. He will staunchly support the Commission, and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Thank you for your consideration of Joe Pertel’s appointment to the Airport Commission. Patti Braun Resident and Homeowner, 1811 Pier Avenue, Sunset Park Item 16.A 11/15/22 2 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 350 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Lyn Greenberg <lrgpers@gmail.com> Sent:Friday, November 11, 2022 10:23 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the airport commission. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues, a sense of ethics and disciplined thinking that all of us need to see in our politics right now. I believe Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. I also trust that if compromises or negotiations are necessary to achieve a good outcome for the city, Jose will approach them with knowledge, integrity, and reasoned discourse - which we sorely need right now. -- Lyn Greenberg Ocean Park Item 16.A 11/15/22 3 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 351 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Hongfang Tan <Hongfang.X.Tan@kp.org> Sent:Friday, November 11, 2022 6:37 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Sincerely, Hongfang (Wendy) Tan NOTICE TO RECIPIENT: If you are not the intended recipient of this e-mail, you are prohibited from sharing, copying, or otherwise using or disclosing its contents. If you have received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender immediately by reply e-mail and permanently delete this e-mail and any attachments without reading, forwarding or saving them. v.173.295 Thank you. Item 16.A 11/15/22 4 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 352 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Dennis Dunbar <dennis@dunbardigital.com> Sent:Friday, November 11, 2022 5:24 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel for Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. In addition to Joe’s work on some great causes I’ve known him since our daughters played soccer together in the Santa Monica AYSO. Joe was always a great presence on the sidelines in those days helping support the team and in guiding the kids in their growth as athletes and good kids. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Dennis Dunbar 310-463-1677 Blog: http://dunbardigital.com/blog/ Website: http://www.dunbardigital.com Co-Author - Photoshop Restoration & Retouching - 4th Edition Item 16.A 11/15/22 5 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 353 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Richard Tahvildaran Jesswein <richardamir@icloud.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 9:40 AM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Richard Jesswein Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Honorable Council Members: I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Richard Tahvildaran-Jesswein, Ph.D. 23 year resident, North of Montana Item 16.A 11/15/22 6 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 354 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Asa Greenberg <agreenberg@argonautpics.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 1:16 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL Dear City Council, As a resident, business owner, and homeowner in Sunset Park, I write to support the application by long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, to join the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Asa Greenberg 2315 Pier Ave. _ Asa Greenberg Argonaut Pictures, LLC agreenberg@argonautpics.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 7 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 355 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:JESSICA TUCK <jesstuck@mac.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 1:12 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL Dear City Council I am writing an email of support for Sunset Park resident , Joe Pertel , for the Santa Monica Airport Commission . I have known him for 30 years and he is an amazing man of integrity. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please make the right decision and appoint him. Many thanks, Jessica Tuck Sunset Park resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 8 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 356 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:janet carpenter <artenviro1@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 1:00 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL RE: Joe Pertel/ Airport Commission I have known Joe Pertel as a neighbor and friend for 20+ years. He is an active member of the Santa Monica community and our neighborhood. I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Janet Carpenter 2415 28th Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 - janet carpenter artenviro1@gmail.com cell: 310 502 5163 Item 16.A 11/15/22 9 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 357 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Sarah Starks <slstarks@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 11:02 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear City Council members, I strongly support longtime Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Sarah Starks Sunset Park resident since 2009 Item 16.A 11/15/22 10 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 358 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Andrew Gumbel <agumbel@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 1:17 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL Dear City Council members, I have known Joe Pertel for many years and can strongly endorse his appointment to the Santa Monica Airport Commission. It's hard, in fact, to imagine a stronger candidate: a public interest lawyer with deep experience of the sorts of complex issues that the airport closure presents, a long-time Sunset Park resident who is known and respected in the community and has given back in countless ways, and -- not insignificantly -- a lovely, easy-going man who is likely to get along excellently with his fellow commissioners and with the rest of the city leadership. We all want the airport closure and its scheduled conversion into a park to go smoothly. Joe is the ideal person to ensure just that. I would urge you all to approve his appointment. With many thanks Andrew Gumbel Sunset Park -- Andrew Gumbel reporter - author +1 310 365-9724 www.andrewgumbel.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 11 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 359 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Rebecca Haggerty <rebhaggerty@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 2:47 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport Commission EXTERNAL To whom it may concern: I write to strongly support Joe Pertel for the airport commission. I have lived in Santa Monica for 12 years, I am a home-owner and have been active in many aspects of Santa Monica community life. I have known Joe for many years, and I believe he would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations, and a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. I feel confident Joe will prioritize our community interests during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). He will be scrupulous in mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. I strongly support Joe Pertel as a member of the airport commission and urge the City Council to do the same. Please do not hesitate to contact me at 917-664-3643 or via return email with any questions. Sincerely, Rebecca Haggerty Item 16.A 11/15/22 12 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 360 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Cathy Larson and Roger Allen <rcbreeze@rocketmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 2:21 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16 A - support Joe Pertel appointment for Airport Commission EXTERNAL Support Joe Pertel for Airport Commission appointment. Councilmembers, Joe Pertel is the only applicant who clearly supports the transformation of Santa Monica Airport land into a Great Park. Over 60% of the voters passed Measure LC affirming their desire for recreation and park space on airport land. As density in our City increases, so does the value of public parkland. Our current pandemic has emphasized the necessity of open space for residents to enjoy. Children and adults want more playing fields, Pickle Ball courts, and recreational space. We don’t need a Commissioner who is an aviation advocate. We need a Commissioner to help usher in the next chapter for the airport land—park land for the enjoyment of all. Mr. Pertel’s legal expertise is an additional asset as the City plans this transformation. Cathy Larson Sunset Park Resident Airport 2 Park Boardmember Item 16.A 11/15/22 13 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 361 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:pattyhmj <pattyhmj@aol.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 2:11 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport Commissioner EXTERNAL We will add we would like Joe Pertel to be commissioner of Santa Monica Airport. Thank you 67 year resident of Santa Monica Patty Laurie Sent from my Galaxy Item 16.A 11/15/22 14 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 362 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Roger Allen <rogerrecruiter@yahoo.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 2:02 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A EXTERNAL Santa Monica City Council Members, I support the appointment of Joe Pertel for the open Airport Commission Role. Mr. Pertel's vision of transforming the Santa Monica Airport into a Grand Park aligns with my view how the space should be repurposed. His legal expertise will compliment his role as the City navigates this process. Thank you, Roger Allen Sunset Park Resident Email rogerrecruiter@yahoo.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 15 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 363 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:pattyhmj <pattyhmj@aol.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 1:59 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Thank you we would like to say we want Joe Pertel on the Airport commission Thank you 67 year resident of Santa Monica Patty Laurie Sent from my Galaxy Item 16.A 11/15/22 16 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 364 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 Vernice Hankins From:Matty Wilder <matty@mattywilder.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 1:28 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Sue Himmelrich; Lana Negrete; Gleam Davis; Phil Brock; Kristin McCowan; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Subject:Item 16A - Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, Please appoint JOSEPH PERTEL to the Airport Commission. Joe is a longtime community member and advocate who is committed to working on behalf of the health and well-being of all Santa Monicans. As a public-interest attorney, he will bring significant legal expertise to the Commission, which will be a valuable asset as the City plans the transition from an airport to a great park. Please also oppose the other four applicants, who are all pro-airport and will fight against the City's stated plans to close the airport at the end of 2028. Additionally, City Staff already has plenty of aviation experience and expertise to ensure that the airport will continue to be operated properly and safely as long as it remains open. Thank you. Sincerely, Matty Wilder Sunset Park resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 17 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 365 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Dana Newman <danamnewman@gmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 3:46 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL Dear Santa Monica City Council Members: I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for appointment to the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make an outstanding airport commissioner. I have known him since our children attended Grant Elementary School together from 2004-2009. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Dana Newman Sunset Park Resident Member, Santa Monica Library Board Item 16.A 11/15/22 18 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 366 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:ANTONIO LYSY <alysy@mac.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 3:30 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL Dear City Council: We strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. We feel Joe Pertel would be a great asset as airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Antonio and Margaret Lysy Santa Monica Neighborhood 2470 Hill Street Antonio Lysy UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music Item 16.A 11/15/22 19 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 367 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Joan Wilder <joan@someonewilder.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 3:13 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Sue Himmelrich; Lana Negrete; Gleam Davis; Phil Brock; Kristin McCowan; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Subject:Item 16A - Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, Please appoint JOSEPH PERTEL to the Airport Commission. Joe is a longtime community member who has been volunteering in Santa Monica for decades. As a public-interest attorney, he will bring significant legal expertise to the Commission, which will be a valuable asset as the City plans the transition from an airport to a great park. Please also oppose the other four applicants, who are all pro-airport and will fight against the City's stated plans to close the airport at the end of 2028. Additionally, City Staff already has plenty of aviation experience and expertise to ensure that the airport will continue to be operated properly and safely as long as it remains open. Thank you. Sincerely, Joan Wilder Item 16.A 11/15/22 20 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 368 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Dennis Wilder <dennis@denniswilder.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 2:52 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Lana Negrete; Gleam Davis; Phil Brock; Kristin McCowan; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Subject:RE: Item 16A - Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, Please appoint JOSEPH PERTEL to the Airport Commission. Joe is a longtime community member who has been volunteering in Santa Monica for decades. As a public- interest attorney, he will bring significant legal expertise to the Commission, which will be a valuable asset as the City plans the transition from an airport to a great park. Please also oppose the other four applicants, who are all pro-airport and will fight against the City's stated plans to close the airport at the end of 2028. Additionally, City Staff already has plenty of aviation experience and expertise to ensure that the airport will continue to be operated properly and safely as long as it remains open. Thank you. Dennis G. Wilder, PhD Item 16.A 11/15/22 21 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 369 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Fue Pan <Fue.Pan@antechmail.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 5:06 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Mr. Pertel have a long history of being enthusiastic about public service, he would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Thanks, Fue Pan Sr. Oracle DBA/Architect Antech Corp. http://www.antechdiagnostics.com o:657-304-2695 c:310-893-4937 e: fue.pan@antechmail.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 22 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 370 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Megan Fitzgerald <mfoodstylist@verizon.net> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 4:28 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment. EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Megan FitzGerald Sunset Park Item 16.A 11/15/22 23 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 371 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:John Fairweather <johnfairweather@earthlink.net> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 4:26 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Sue Himmelrich; Lana Negrete; Gleam Davis; Phil Brock; Kristin McCowan; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Subject:Joe Pertel for Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, I strongly recommend that you appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Not only does he have a deep understanding of aviation issues, but he is a long term Santa Monica resident with a history of volunteering. Joe is an attorney and his experience on the airport commission will be very useful when the airport closes in 2028 as the city plans and executes the transition to a great park. Other applicants for the position all oppose the City’s rights to determine the future of SMO and are pro-airport. I believe each of these other applicants would act to to thwart City decisions at the airport at every opportunity. Thank you. Sincerely, John Fairweather Item 16.A 11/15/22 24 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 372 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Brodsky, Michael <mbrodsky@lmu.edu> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 7:37 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Sue Himmelrich; Lana Negrete; Gleam Davis; Phil Brock; Kristin McCowan; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment - Support for Joseph A. Pertel Attachments:520pmOctober25th2022.png EXTERNAL Dear City Council Member, Every day, 35,000 Sunset Park, Ocean Park, and Pico neighborhood residents must endure the constant harmful impacts of noise and pollution from Santa Monica Airport. Yet only 20 or so Santa Monica residents (data directly from airplane flight operation registrations) fly out of Santa Monica Airport on any given day. Our vast number of our residents need representation on the Airport Commission by someone who will be able to give community input on SMO safety and operations that will help address the harmful issues that are impacting our 35,000 residents. I support Joseph A. Pertel to be our representative on the Airport Commission. He will make an excellent, knowledgeable, fair, and honest Airport Commissioner. Joseph A. Pertel will support all users of SMO such that operations are safe, as well as support the needs of our residents to reduce SMO’s harmful impacts while it remains. Joseph A. Pertel is also unique in that he can help advise and facilitate the planning for the closure of SMO in just *6* years! We must begin that planning right now! Our residents need representation by someone will reflect the needs of the greatest number of our residents. We cannot afford to have a commissioner who beholden to needs of the AOPA aviation lobby or will actively work to prevent the closure of SMO for the privileged few who reap all the benefits of SMO, at the expense of the health and wellbeing of THOUSANDS of our residents. Sincerely, Item 16.A 11/15/22 25 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 373 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Michael Brodsky Santa Monica Item 16.A 11/15/22 26 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 374 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 27 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 375 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Tina Tan-Pertel <tinatanpertel@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 10:26 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A)- Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear City Council, I wholeheartedly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. I have been a resident of Sunset Park since 1998. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He has consistently demonstrated a strong commitment to public service in Santa Monica. He is a long- time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations, including Team Santa Monica swim team, Santa Monica United/Surf soccer club, and Elemental Strings. He has also volunteered his time for the music and sports programs at Santa Monica High School, including its band and choir programs, literary magazines, soccer, swimming, and water polo programs. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Hongying Tan, MD, PhD Sunset Park Neighborhood Item 16.A 11/15/22 28 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 376 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:kennedy <santamonicasfx@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 9:05 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:support EXTERNAL To whom it may concern, I strongly support Joe Pertel for the Santa monica Airpot Commission. His experience and knowledge and motives are what we need to support our plan for the airport to park! Signed, PIER Ave. residemt Item 16.A 11/15/22 29 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 377 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Sanjeev Jain <sanjeev_jain2@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 8:52 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - support for Joe Pertel for the airport commission EXTERNAL I, Sanjeev Jain, have resided in Sunset Park since 2002, and have known Joe Pertel and seen his work all these years. I wholeheartedly support Joe Pertel for the airport commission. Joe would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Sanjeev Jain 2321 27th Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 30 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 378 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Dawn Joyal <dajoyal@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 8:40 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A - Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission EXTERNAL Item 16A - Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission Dear Council Members, Please appoint JOSEPH PERTEL to the Airport Commission. Joe is a longtime community member who has been volunteering in Santa Monica for decades. As a public- interest attorney, he will bring significant legal expertise to the Commission, which will be a valuable asset as the City plans the transition from an airport to a great park. Please also oppose the other four applicants, who are all pro-airport and will fight against the City's stated plans to close the airport at the end of 2028. Additionally, City Staff already has plenty of aviation experience and expertise to ensure that the airport will continue to be operated properly and safely as long as it remains open. Mrs D Joyal Sunset Park Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 31 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 379 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Nancy Owens <nancyjowens@aol.com> Sent:Saturday, November 12, 2022 8:09 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Subject: Item 16A - Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, Please appoint JOSEPH PERTEL to the Airport Commission. Joe is a longtime community member who has been volunteering in Santa Monica for decades. As a public-interest attorney, he will bring significant legal expertise to the Commission, which will be a valuable asset as the City plans the transition from an airport to a great park. Please also oppose the other four applicants, who are all pro-airport and will fight against the City's stated plans to close the airport at the end of 2028. Additionally, City Staff already has plenty of aviation experience and expertise to ensure that the airport will continue to be operated properly and safely as long as it remains open. Thank you. Sincerely, Nancy Owens Santa Monica, CA Item 16.A 11/15/22 32 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 380 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:jon kean <jonkean@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 12:17 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A--November 15, 2022 Meeting EXTERNAL Dear Esteemed City Councilmembers I am writing to you in support of the application of Joe Pertel for the vacancy on the Airport Commission. We, as a community, need smart and thoughtful people to provide guidance and serve as liaisons as we approach the anticipated closure of the airport and its potential future uses in the coming years. Joe Pertel is such a person. In addition to being a long time Sunset Park resident, Joe has spent decades in his professional career navigating complex issues as a public interest attorney. He has demonstrated a fervent commitment to Santa Monica and its residents through his local advocacy and will provide a reasoned and analytical voice to any future discussions. At a time when the health and safety of our community, as well as maintaining and growing open spaces, is a priority for the vast majority of residents, Joe can champion both. As a sitting school board member, I have seen the impact of Joe's advocacy and intellect. He has never shared an opinion on any issue without deep research and contemplation. There is no "go along to get along" with him but at the same time, I have never seen him to stay fixed on his own assumptions and beliefs if the facts show a different path. We need thoughtful people like Joe Pertel on the Airport Commission as we only have one opportunity to get this right. Thank you for your consideration of my comments Jon Kean SMMUSD Board of Education Member, As an individual. Jon Kean Jon@bcpfilm.com http://www.afterauschwitz.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 33 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 381 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Perryadle <perryadle@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 12:09 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 1(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL To Whom it May Concern, My husband and I wholeheartedly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the airport commission. We believe that Joe would make a wonderful airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our Sunset Park neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing fro the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2019, Sincerely, Perry and Dave Clennon 27th Street Sunset Park Santa Monica Item 16.A 11/15/22 34 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 382 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Susan Jain <spjain88@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 11:57 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Re: Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - support for Joe Pertel for the airport commission EXTERNAL Dear Colleagues, Today I write to wholeheartedly support Joseph Pertel for the airport commission. As a Sunset Park resident since 2002, I have observed Joseph Pertel’s constant work on behalf of our community. As a member of the airport commission, I am confident that he will serve the interests of our neighborhood and ALL of the people who live and work in Santa Monica. The son of a Navy pilot, Joe is a criminal defense attorney/ former LA County Public Defender who knows how the government and legal system work. He is experienced in analyzing complex situations & stories and has devoted his life to seeking justice for people of all backgrounds. Joe, who has studied abroad and speaks fluent Mandarin, is part of a diverse family that includes first-generation immigrants, members of our Native American community, and the LGBTQ+ community. Joe is a parent of two daughters who went through SMMUSD schools. He has been an active parent volunteer and fundraiser and has served on the advisory boards of several local sports and arts organizations including Team Santa Monica (swimming) and Elemental Strings (music). In recent years he has been an active fundraiser and promoter of the Santa Monica Youth Orchestra, a world music program based in Virginia Park that offers free world music instruction to local youth. As a neighborhood representative to the airport commission, I am confident Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, Item 16.A 11/15/22 35 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 383 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely yours, Dr. Susan Jain 2321 27th Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 36 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 384 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Alicia Mignano <aliciaforsmmusd@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 11:48 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A)- Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Alicia Mignano Pico Neighborhood -- Alicia Mignano 503.962.0703 (text) AliciaForSMMUSD.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 37 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 385 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 To help protect your priv acy, Microsoft Office prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. Item 16.A 11/15/22 38 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 386 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:marianne smith <msmithblue@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 1:24 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel for Santa Monica Airport Commision EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Marianne Smith 3014 17th street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 39 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 387 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Ben <bcwang@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 12:54 PM To:councilmtgitems; Council Mailbox; Christine Parra; Gleam Davis; Kristin McCowan; Lana Negrete; Oscar de la Torre; Phil Brock; Sue Himmelrich; David White Cc:Caroline M. Torosis; Jesse Zwick; Andrew Wilder; Diane Reynolds; Joe Schmitz; Geoffrey Neri; Stelios Makrides Subject:SMO: SM City Council Meeting November 15, 2022 - Item 16A - Santa Monica Airport Commission EXTERNAL RE: SMO -- SM City Council Meeting November 15, 2022 - Item 16A - Santa Monica Airport Commission Dear Santa Monica City Council: Kate Scott should NOT be appointed to the Airport Commission. As a reminder, in October 2017, she filed a lawsuit against the SM City Council in Los Angeles Superior Court although it was later moved to U.S. District Courts, California Central District. It halted and delayed the runway shortening project. See the note below for more details on the lawsuit. Eve Lopez should NOT be appointed to the Airport Commission. As a reminder, in April 2022, she filed a Brown Act Complaint against the SM Airport Commission based on her own misinformation. Additionally, she continues to intimidate people -- including local residents and city leaders. I personally received a threatening email directly from her mentioning my employer, birthdate, address, and communications with City Council Members and Airport Commissioners. This example and others can be provided if requested. I believe she is an loose canon with very poor judgement. Both Kate and Eve would be real problems on the Airport Commission, and I have no doubt their participation on the Airport Commission would lead to further litigation against the City. Please do not appoint any potential commissioner who will obstruct the significant progress made over the many decades. Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. SMO is scheduled to close in only 72 months in December 2028, and Joe Pertel's interests align with the City of Santa Monica and its residents. His expertise as a 27-year public interest attorney, combined with his knowledge and active involvement in community matters makes him invaluable (see his application - link). With his highly relevant experience and qualifications he will make an excellent advisor to City Council on the many important and complex matters related to SMO and its ongoing transition over the next 72 months. The path to closure is cleared for the City, per: (1) 2014 Charter Amendment and Measure LC (https://itsourland.org) (2) 2017 Consent Decree (https://smofuture.weebly.com/uploads/3/1/0/1/31010165/2017_consent_decree.pdf) Item 16.A 11/15/22 40 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 388 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 (3) 2017 SM City Council SMO Closure Resolution No. 11026 (CCS) (http://bit.ly/SMO-Closure- Resolution) PRIVATE aviation, with its impactful noise, pollution, dangers, and public costs, have occupied our public land for far too long. Please continue forward with this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to transform our public land so that we can all benefit and enjoy it. Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Santa Monica Airport Commission. Notes: Links to additional information about Kate Scott's lawsuit against Santa Monica: • https://surfsantamonica.com/ssm_site/the_lookout/news/News-2017/May- 2017/05_09_2017_New_Lawsuit_Seeks_to_Invalidate_Santa_Monica_Airport_Consent_Decr ee.html • https://archive.kpcc.org/news/2017/10/09/76487/judge-orders-santa-monica-airport-runway- shortenin/ • https://unicourt.com/case/pc-db1-scott-et-al-v-city-council-for-the-city-of-santa-monica- 577173#case-details • https://www.pacermonitor.com/public/case/22664010/Scott_et_al_v_City_Council_for_the_City _of_Santa_Monica Thank you, Ben Wang 30th Street Item 16.A 11/15/22 41 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 389 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Ted Winterer <tedwinterer@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 12:48 PM To:councilmtgitems; council@santamonica.gov Subject:Item 16-A - Airport Commission appointment support Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Mayor Himmelrich and Honorable Councilmembers, I urge you to appoint Joe Pertel to the vacant seat on the Airport Commission. Joe's lived in Sunset Park for a long time, is very familiar with the issues regarding SMO and has been an involved member of our community in many ways. He's an experienced lawyer with a keen legal mind and affable personality. He would be a fine addition to the Commission. Regards, Ted Winterer. -- Ted Winterer Realtor @Compass, 2115 Main Street Santa Monica DRE #02047989 To help protect your privacy, Microsoft Office prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. Item 16.A 11/15/22 42 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 390 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:steaven@gmail.com Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 12:28 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. My family has known Joe and his family for over 10 years. During that time, Joe has been heavily involved in the community, and in particular with youth soccer (AYSO, Clubs) as well as the various Santa Monica music programs. He has raised two amazing daughters through the public school system and has deep care for the community. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Steaven Chen Resident – 1045 23rd Street, Santa Monica, CA 90403 Cell: 310-925-8482 Item 16.A 11/15/22 43 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 391 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Hans Berggren <hansberggren@me.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 2:27 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Council Meeting Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Hello City Council, I fully support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe would be a diligent, informed, and thoughtful presence on the commission. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. I trust that the community will be well served by Joe during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). He will promote sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively support the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Please give serious consideration to the candidacy of Joe Pertel for Airport commissioner. Thank you, Hans Berggren Ocean Park, Santa Monica Item 16.A 11/15/22 44 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 392 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Julia Carnahan <jecarnahan@mac.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 1:32 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Santa Monica City Council members, I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Joe’s work in the community on behalf of others has long impressed me. He’s extremely knowledgable, caring, and generous. Please appoint him. Julia Carnahan 2239 27th Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Cell: 323-244-9663 Email: jecarnahan@mac.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 45 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 393 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Debbie Mulvaney <debbiemulvaney@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 1:28 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I wholeheartedly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Thanks. Debbie Mulvaney Mulvaney Business Advisors 310-600-1864 Item 16.A 11/15/22 46 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 394 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Lutz, Joseph <JLutz@seyfarth.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 2:44 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Lutz, Joseph Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL To whom it may concern: Please nominate Joe Pertel to the empty Airport Commission seat. Best regards, Joe Lutz Joseph Lutz | Senior Counsel | Seyfarth Shaw LLP 2029 Century Park East | Suite 3500 | Los Angeles, California 90067-3021 Direct: +1-310-201-1545 | Mobile: +1-310-717-3692 | Fax: +1-310-551-8345 jlutz@seyfarth.com | www.seyfarth.com To help protect your priv acy, Microsoft Office prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING: This email may contain privileged or confidential information and is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s). Any unauthorized use or disclosure of this communication is prohibited. If you believe that you have received this email in error, please notify the sender immediately and delete it from your system. Item 16.A 11/15/22 47 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 395 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Gregg Chadwick <greggchadwick@icloud.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 2:30 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:I Endorse Joe Pertel for the Empty Airport Commission Seat EXTERNAL Dear Santa Monica City Council Members, I Endorse Joe Pertel for the Empty Airport Commission Seat. As a Santa Monica homeowner and a small business owner with my business in the city of Santa Monica, I know that we need a forward thinking leader to fill the empty Airport Commission seat. Joe is an attorney and Sunset Park resident who is willing to step in and help guide the city towards the closure of SMO, protect impacted residents, and insure safe operation in the meantime. A resolution to close SMO was made by the City Council in 2017, and most importantly residents voted citywide and passed measure LC in 2014 to turn the land into a park, cultural, and recreational center as residents intended way back in 1926 when the land was purchased by a park bond. The airport is likely the most underutilized piece of property in Santa Monica. It is time to start converting empty land no longer needed for the dwindling airport into uses residents can enjoy including sports fields and courts, walking paths, and more. This can be done in affordable steps as other cities in the USA and abroad have accomplished upon closing their airports with great success. As an official body of residents, it is important to see that the Airport Commission is made of residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of the community, and not developers and aviation interests. Thank you, Gregg Chadwick 2308 Schader Drive #206 Sata Monica, CA 90404 www.greggchadwick.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 48 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 396 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Alan Levenson <alan@alanlevenson.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 2:29 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A - Airport Commission Seat EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission Begin forwarded message: From: NoJets <info@nojets.org> Subject: Action: New Airport Commissioner Recommendation Date: November 13, 2022 at 2:23:47 PM PST To: <alan@alanlevenson.com> Reply-To: NoJets <info@nojets.org> Item 16.A 11/15/22 49 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 397 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 View this email in your browser To help protect your priv acy, Microsoft Office prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. Send a quick note to the City Council asking to appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Joe is an attorney and Sunset Park resident who is willing to step in and help guide the city towards the closure of SMO, protect impacted residents, and insure safe operation in the meantime. A resolution to close SMO was made by the City Council in 2017, and most importantly residents voted citywide and passed measure LC in 2014 to turn the land into a park, cultural, and recreational center as residents intended way back in 1926 when the land was purchased by a park bond. The airport is likely the most underutilized piece of property in Santa Monica. It is time to start converting empty land no longer needed for the dwindling airport into uses residents can enjoy including sports fields and courts, walking paths, and more. This can be done in affordable steps as other cities in the USA and abroad have accomplished upon closing their airports with great success. As an official body of residents, it is important to see that the Airport Commission is made of residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of the community, and not developers and aviation interests. Send a note endorsing Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission seat, and any additional thoughts you may have to the council: Subject: Item 16A/Airport Commission Send to: councilmtgitems@santamonica.gov Item 16.A 11/15/22 50 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 398 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Thank you! Alan Levenson To help protect your priv acy, Microsoft Office prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet. "A drop of effort can create a sea of change." It is important to keep this list alive and growing. Please ask a neighbor to email us to add them to this list. Together we are stronger. And it is free! Send requests or email addresses to add to the list: info@nojets.org. Copyright © 2022 No Jets SMO, All rights reserved. Thank you for your continued support to reduce airport impacts and improve our quality of life. Want to change how you receive these emails? You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list. To help protect your privacy, Microsoft Office prevented automatic download of this picture from the Internet.Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp Item 16.A 11/15/22 51 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 399 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 Alan Levenson www.alanlevenson.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 52 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 400 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:David K <caymanswim@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:24 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Council Meeting Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear City Council: I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. I first got to know Joe when I moved to Montana Avenue in Santa Monica in 2010. I had taken over as executive director of the largest and oldest youth swim team in Santa Monica (Team Santa Monica). Joe volunteered to serve on the board and was selected vice-president. Often when people serve on boards, they offer opinions a few hours a month. Joe offered sweat and real help. No job or task was beneath him; breaking down tents at events, loading ice into coolers, and sitting through numerous committee meetings for special projects. He also helped our board navigate legal issues that periodically arose with ease. I have no doubt that if selected Joe will serve just as tirelessly in this role. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, David Kelsheimer Team USA Olympic Coach Item 16.A 11/15/22 53 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 401 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Edward McQueeney <edpmcq@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:09 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe to the Airport Commission! He is a fair and honest choice who represents the views of residents well. Sent from the all new AOL app for iOS Item 16.A 11/15/22 54 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 402 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Jimbeamer <jimbeamer28@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:02 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:16A-Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Hi We would like to see Joe Pertel assigned to the the SMO Airport Commission. As a resident living near the airport we like Joe and his ideas regarding the future of the airport. Thank You Jim Item 16.A 11/15/22 55 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 403 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Jonathan Stein <jstein@jsteinlaw.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 2:52 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel EXTERNAL City Councilpersons, Joe Pertel should be appointed to the SMAC to close the Airport. Jonathan Stein Law Offices of Jonathan Stein, PC 2520 Murrell Road Santa Barbara, CA 93109 310-968-4455 jstein@jsteinlaw.com www.jsteinlaw.com [This message may contain confidential and privileged information. If it has been sent to you in error, please reply to advise the sender of the error, and then immediately delete this message. Thank you.] Item 16.A 11/15/22 56 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 404 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Sejon Ding <sjding@hotmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 2:44 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Please appoint Sunset Park resident and attorney to the Airport Commission. Best regards, Sejon Ding Pristine Windows, Inc Tel: 310-446-8180 www.pristinewindows.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 57 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 405 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:David Kaplan <david@kckarchitects.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:41 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment - Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Please support Joe Pertel for the Airport Commission. He is a longstanding Sunset Park resident and thoughtful participant in community issues. thanks, David Kaplan 2419 Pier Avenue Item 16.A 11/15/22 58 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 406 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:William Fordes <waveskiboy@mac.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:40 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Members of the City Council As a thirty year resident of Santa Monica, and one of the original supporters of the Proposition that prevailed so spectacularly in the Airport to Park process, I lend my support to Joe Pertel for appointment to the Airport Commission. The overwhelming majority of the voters who participated in the proposition elections supported CLOSURE of the airport and construction of a park. That OVERWHELMING majority did not consist of air plane pilots and others personally, financially interested in continued operation of the airport. Rather, the support was from people tired of the noise, the danger, the pollution and the unnecessary associated health risks. The support, that is, was from people who wanted the airport closed forever. Now, however, there are pilots and airport cronies sitting on the Commission. That is why Joe Pertel should be appointed. He is a member of the community who supports closure, is not personally motivated by financial considerations to keep the airport from closing, and as such is representative of the huge majority that voted to close the airport. Please appoint Mr Pertel to the open seat on the airport commission Sincerely, Bill Fordes 2308 27th St SM CA 90405 “Nobody knows anybody…not that well….” — Miller’s Crossing Item 16.A 11/15/22 59 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 407 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Alan Kerner <kerners@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:38 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport Commission EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the airport commission. He is committed to following the City Counsel and residents of Santa Monica wishes regarding the future of the airport. Sincerely, Alan Kerner 1761 Sunset Ave Santa Monica CA 9040 Sent from my iPad Item 16.A 11/15/22 60 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 408 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:V N Davich <vdavich@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:33 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Nomination for Airport Commission: Joe Pertel EXTERNAL As a former boardmember of SMPL, I am nominating Joe Pertel for appointment to the Airport Commission. Joe is an attorney and Sunset Park resident who is willing to step in and help guide the city towards the closure of SMO, protect impacted residents, and insure safe operation of the airport and upcoming matters. thank you for your consideration Victor Davich Item 16.A 11/15/22 61 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 409 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Allison <jamag1234@cox.net> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:08 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:I endorse Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Hello- As a resident of Sunset Park, (2211 Pier Avenue), my husband and I both support Joe Pertel for the vacant Airport Commission seat. Thank you! Allison Greene Item 16.A 11/15/22 62 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 410 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Ellen Hannan <elhasm@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:57 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel for airport commission EXTERNAL I attended the community meetings for the airport vision. These were held before the Airport to Park plans and ballot issue. I strongly support a city resident to be placed on the commission. Please consider Joe Pertel. Ellen Hannan Item 16.A 11/15/22 63 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 411 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Will Guston <willguston@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:50 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16/A Airport EXTERNAL Dear Santa Monica City Council Members, It is my recommendation that you appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Joe Lives in Sunset Park and cares deeply about this beautiful area of Santa Monica and the impact that SMO has on the neighborhood and All of Santa Monica and the surrounding area. He is prepared to help create a wonderful future for the airport as it closes and transitions to a great park that will Enhance the quality of life of many people. Place Joe Pertel on the Airport Commission. Respectfully Will Guston Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 64 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 412 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Elin Katz <butrpg55@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 3:46 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/ Airport Commission EXTERNAL I urge you to appoint Joe Pertel to the airport commission. He lives in the area affected by the airport and will help enforce the will of the residents who passed measure LC. Thank you, Elin Katz 3017 Dahlgren Ave, Los Angeles, CA 90066 Item 16.A 11/15/22 65 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 413 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Airport2Park <airport2park@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:11 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Sue Himmelrich; Lana Negrete; Gleam Davis; Phil Brock; Kristin McCowan; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Subject:Airport Commission Appointment - Please appoint Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Councilmembers, The Santa Monica Airport 2 Park Foundation supports the appointment of Joseph Pertel to fill the current Airport Commission vacancy. Mr. Pertel’s vision of the future of the Airport property aligns with that of the Santa Monica Airport 2 Park Foundation—a Great Park for the enjoyment of ALL. Santa Monica residents passed Measure LC with a 60% majority affirming their desire for the Airport land to be transformed into park space and recreational uses. Mr. Pertel is a longtime Santa Monica resident who understands the needs of the residents of Santa Monica. He has raised a family in Santa Monica during which time he was involved in youth sports, Santa Monica Music programs, and community service. As the son of a Navy pilot, Mr Pertel grew up surrounded by aviation and has a “deep appreciation and respect for military and civil aviation.” As a practicing attorney, his law expertise will be a valuable asset analyzing and understanding the complexities of aviation regulations, the consent decree, and other legal issues that may arise as the City moves toward closure of SMO. Appointing Joseph Pertel to the Airport Commission would be another step towards the realization of a much needed great urban park in the Santa Monica. Santa Monica Airport 2 Park Board Item 16.A 11/15/22 66 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 414 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Robert Brown <rcbee44@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:40 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Santa Monica City Council - Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL Dear Council, I am writing to strongly endorse JOE PERTEL to fill the vacant seat on the Santa Monica Airport Commission. In 2014, I worked hard to pass MEASURE LC and defeat Measure D. In walking street after street I listened to the residents’ concerns about the effects of noise, pollution, particulate contamination and lead poisoning on them and their families. Thankfully our efforts paid off and MEASURE LC passed overwhelmingly while the well-funded Measure D went down in flames. The city is excited for December of 2028 and the closure of SMO. It can’t come soon enough! Joe Pertel has come along at the right moment. His wisdom, intelligence, diligence and patience will be huge assets to both the Airport Commission and to the Council as we move closer to 2028. I have known Joe for many years as our girls have been friends since middle school at JAMS. And our paths probably crossed years ago at Yale as we both sang in a cappella singing groups. What I know is that Joe is a fair listener, a curious questioner and a pro-active thinker. His analytic voice and his legal expertise will only enhance the work of the Commission. I URGE YOU to vote YES on Joe Pertel’s appointment to the Airport Commission. Sincerely, Robert Brown E: rcbee44@gmail.com M: 310.795.5353 2401 Pier Avenue SAnta Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 67 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 415 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Stephen Unger <steve@ksmuconsulting.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:38 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Please appoint Joe Pertel to the SM Airport Commission! EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, Please appoint Joe Pertel to the SM Airport Commission! I know something about selecting great leadership ( see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_A._Unger ) Joe is a great choice for this key position. Thank you, good luck and kind rgds, Stephen A. Unger Long Time Homeowner and Taxpayer Sea Colony 1 Santa Monica, CA Item 16.A 11/15/22 68 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 416 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Louis Ssutu <lsapc@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:36 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, I respectfully endorse Joe Pertel to fill the vacant seat on the Commission. Thank you. Sincere regards, Lou Ssutu Resident of Ocean Park Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 69 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 417 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Ann Garneau <anngarneau@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:32 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Endorsing Joe Pertel EXTERNAL It would be so exciting to see the dreams and plans for the SM airport made real. It is a sadly empty space and deserves better use than for a few wealthy plane owners. Cheers to Joe who is ready to move the good ideas forward. Ann Garneau Item 16.A 11/15/22 70 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 418 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:chutney.hunter@gmail.com Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 5:03 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL I Chutney Li support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Chutney Li Sunset Park resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 71 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 419 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Lisa Sandbank <sister@brotherlab.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:54 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:16A Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council members, As a Sunset Park resident and an advocate for the health and safety of Santa Monica, its visitors and neighbors, I wish to endorse Joe Pertel for a seat on the Airport Commission because of his commitment to improve quality of life for airport neighbors and for Santa Monica residents by helping us return the land to a more sustainable and enjoyable space that was once Clover Field. Thank you Lisa Sandbank Item 16.A 11/15/22 72 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 420 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:deeonn la <deeonn@hotmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:53 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear City Council Members, I am writing to express my strong support of long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community would make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him to the Commission. Thanks, DeAnne Ozaki, Santa Monica Resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 73 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 421 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Jckoury <jckoury@aol.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 4:50 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joseph Pertel's application for the Airport Commission ... EXTERNAL Dear Council-members: I am a resident of the Pico-Ocean Park community as well as a local business owner. My family and I have been residents since 1996. I am writing to offer my support for Joe Pertel's appointment to the Airport Commission. Mr. Pertel worked for me at the Los Angeles Public Defender's Office in 1998 and since then he and I have worked together professionally and been neighbors while our children attended the Santa Monica schools. Mr. Pertel is hard working, conscientious and dedicated to improving our community. In our discussions about the future of the airport, he has repeatedly expressed his desire, consistent with so many people in our community, to mitigating the harmful impact the airport has on our residents and ultimately shutting down the operations of the airport and re-purposing that property as park space. Mr. Pertel has no personal interest in the appointment except to see the end of the negative health and safety impacts the airport has on Santa Monica residents. Thank you for your consideration. Joel Koury LAW OFFICES OF JOEL C. KOURY 3435 Ocean Park Blvd, Suite 107-50 Santa Monica, CA 90405 Office: 424-248-8670 Cell: 310-560-2001 Item 16.A 11/15/22 74 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 422 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Betsy Katz <betsyjkatz@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 5:05 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Members of the Santa Monica City Council, I am writing to ask that you appoint Joe Pertel to the empty seat on the Airport Commission. Joe is a Santa Monica resident who shares my vision of the future of SMO. I look forward to the closure of SMO and the great space that can then be used for all Santa Monica residents to enjoy - park land and a recreational center. In the meantime, Joe will help to insure safe operation of SMO - a great concern to this resident who lives under the flight path and worries about the toxic air pollution created by the use of avgas and the old leaky gas tanks that sit over our aquifer. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Betsy Katz 310-415-0130 . Item 16.A 11/15/22 75 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 423 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Stephen Li <stephen.d.li@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 5:03 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment. EXTERNAL I Stephen Li support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Stephen Li Sunset Park Resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 76 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 424 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Cris Armstrong <crisarm@msn.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 5:33 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport commission EXTERNAL Appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Joe is an attorney and Sunset Park resident who is willing to step in and help guide the city towards the closure of SMO, protect impacted residents, and insure safe operation in the meantime. A resolution to close SMO was made by the City Council in 2017, and most importantly residents voted citywide and passed measure LC in 2014 to turn the land into a park, cultural, and recreational center as residents intended way back in 1926 when the land was purchased by a park bond. The airport is likely the most underutilized piece of property in Santa Monica. It is time to start converting empty land no longer needed for the dwindling airport into uses residents can enjoy including sports fields and courts, walking paths, and more. This can be done in affordable steps as other cities in the USA and abroad have accomplished upon closing their airports with great success. As an official body of residents, it is important to see that the Airport Commission is made of residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of the community, and not developers and aviation interests. Cris Armstrong 2016 Ashland Ave Santa Monica, Ca 90405 Get Outlook for iOS Item 16.A 11/15/22 77 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 425 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:John Smith <john.smith7@mac.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 5:23 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Dear Councilmembers, I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, John Smith Sunset Park resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 78 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 426 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Steven Novak <stevenovak@earthlink.net> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:53 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear SM City Council -- I have been a resident of Ocean Park since February 1990 and am in favor of closing the Santa Monica Airport in favor of less noisy activities like recreational spaces and parks. I endorse Joe Pertel for the vacant airport commission seat. Thank you. Sincerely, Steve Novak Item 16.A 11/15/22 79 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 427 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Item 16.A 11/15/22 80 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 428 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Maitra-Konell Family <vivadna4@verizon.net> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:51 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport Commission EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the SMO Airport Commission. Thank you Item 16.A 11/15/22 81 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 429 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Cyn Yamashiro <cyn.yamashiro@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:29 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - Joe Pertel Application for Airport Commission Importance:High EXTERNAL Santa Monica City Council Members, My name is Cyn Yamashiro and I am a resident of Sunset Park. Both my adult sisters and Mother are also residents of Sunset Park. Collectively, we are three households that will be impacted by how Santa Monica allows the airport to be developed. Given our vested interest in a thoughtful and considered process, I wholeheartedly and strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel has served on the boards of many local youth organizations and a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. He has represented countless youth in delinquency proceedings and is well regarded in Los Angeles as a criminal defense attorney. In addition, Joe Pertel serves on the Los Angeles County Bar Association’s Independent Defender Program Executive Committee. In that capacity, Joe has repeatedly demonstrated both a commitment to a fair and just process in dealing with issues presented to the committee, but also the ability to make tough and reasoned decisions. These are, of course, critical years for the Santa Monica Airport and Joe is dedicated to mitigating Santa Monica Airport health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Cyn Yamashiro 1302 Pearl Street Item 16.A 11/15/22 82 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 430 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 83 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 431 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 Vernice Hankins From:Katharine Dreyfuss <kitdreyfuss@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:18 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Council members: Please appoint Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission Seat. The Airport Commission needs to consist of residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of the community, and not developers and aviation interests. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Katharine Dreyfuss Item 16.A 11/15/22 84 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 432 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 7 Vernice Hankins From:Yolanda Lewis <ylewis123@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:02 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Application for the Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Santa Monica City Council members, As a Sunset Park resident, I enthusiastically support Joe Pertel's appointment to the Airport Commission. In Santa Monica schools and politics, Mr. Pertel has been active in several community programs. His level-headedness, great communication skills, and dedication to the betterment of Santa Monica make him an excellent candidate for the position. Consistent with the wishes of so many in our community, he has expressed his desire to mitigate the harm caused by the airport to our residents and ultimately shut down operations so that the property can be repurposed as a park. Besides ending the negative health and safety impacts the airport has on Santa Monica residents, Mr. Pertel has no personal interest in the appointment. Thank you for your consideration. Yolanda Lewis Item 16.A 11/15/22 85 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 433 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Douglas Family Gmail <1828pearl@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 7:23 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:SM Airport Commission EXTERNAL To The Honorable City Council, Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. Joe is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a fellow Sunset Park resident, with a child in Samohi, I trust Joe to keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. I have known him for nearly three decades and emphatically support Joe Pertel for the SM Airport Commission. Hyun Im 1828 Pearl 310.804.4973 Item 16.A 11/15/22 86 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 434 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Sheila Forsander <s_forsander@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 7:03 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Strong support for Joe Pertel for SM Airport Commision EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Sheila Forsander 3000 block of 17th Street Santa Monica 90405 Sunset Park neighborhood Item 16.A 11/15/22 87 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 435 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Matt Hendrickson <hendrickson1965@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:55 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Joe is an attorney and Sunset Park resident who is willing to step in and help guide the city towards the closure of SMO, protect impacted residents, and insure safe operation in the meantime. The airport is likely the most underutilized piece of property in Santa Monica. It is time to start converting empty land no longer needed for the dwindling airport into uses residents can enjoy including sports fields and courts, walking paths, and more. This can be done in affordable steps as other cities in the USA and abroad have accomplished upon closing their airports with great success. As an official body of residents, it is important to see that the Airport Commission is made of residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of the community, and not developers and aviation interests. Thank you! Matt Hendrickson 2258 22nd St. Santa Monica, 90405 Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 88 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 436 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:drcblum@aol.com Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 6:54 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel for Airport Commissioner EXTERNAL Dearest Santa Monica City Council, I hope you and your family are safe, healthy, and happy as we enter the holiday season. I can't emphasize enough the need for the City Council to support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident living on the west side of Santa Monica Airport (SMO) and served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues, which is something that might be necessary as the closure of SMO in the future is likely to lead to complex issues of concern As a representative of our neighborhood I feel confident that Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the SMO. Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. It will be a huge gift to have someone like Joe seeking to support the local community, work with the city council, and support the future of Santa Monica and its residents. Warm Regards, Charles Dr. Charles L. Blum drcblum@aol.com 1752 Ocean Park Boulevard Santa Monica, CA 90405 310-392-9795 www.drcharlesblum.com CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This E-Mail communication (including attachments) is covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act 18, U.S.C 2510-2521, is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any retention, dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. Please reply to the sender that you have received this message in error, and then delete it. Thank You. Ferpa Notice: Additionally, these records are protected by the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act and are provided to the intended recipient under an exception to the Act found in Section 99.32. Item 16.A 11/15/22 89 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 437 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 These records must be maintained confidentially and may not be re-disclosed. They must be destroyed when your legitimate educational interest no longer exists. Item 16.A 11/15/22 90 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 438 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Grace Gabe <gracepgabe@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 9:40 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:i support Joe Pertel EXTERNAL dear council as a long time resident and homeowner in santa monica i support Joe Pertel to fill the empty airport commission seat. we have an opportunity to use that large area for parks and community programs. in that way we can improve the lives and health of many residents and avoid the land grab of the real estate investors to build luxury apartments and shopping malls. we need breathing space in santa monica, not more crowding and traffic. thank you grace gabe, m.d. Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 91 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 439 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Julie Ginsberg <ginsbergjc@yahoo.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 9:24 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I Julie Ginsberg, support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Julie Ginsberg 1128 19th St Item 16.A 11/15/22 92 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 440 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Natalie Atun Greenberg <natalie.greenberg.2010@anderson.ucla.edu> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 9:08 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL I am emailing to show my support for long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Natalie Greenberg Resident, Pier Avenue in Santa Monica (Sunset Park) Natalie A. Greenberg 917.686.9321 Item 16.A 11/15/22 93 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 441 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:JOHN VENTURA <JOHN_VENTURA@msn.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 8:06 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear City Council, As a member of the community, and a resident of Sunset Park area for the last 15yrs, I would like to endorse the appointment of Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission seat. Thank You, John Ventura Item 16.A 11/15/22 94 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 442 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Jeffrey Douglas <jjdxxx1@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 7:33 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - Joe Pertel EXTERNAL I am a long-time resident of Sunset Park, Santa Monica. My son attended Will Rogers Learning Community, John Adams Middle School, and is now a Freshman at Santa Monica High School. I have been active in the PTA, PTSA and participate actively in the parent support groups for a variety of student activities. I am a small business owner in Santa Monica and a daily user of Clover Park. I have known Joe Pertel for over twenty years. I write to endorse him enthusiastically for a position on the Santa Monica Airport Commission. Joe is a talented, dedicated lawyer, respected within the legal community as a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. He is a long-term resident of Sunset Park and a committed community member. He has served as a director on the boards of many youth organizations. He is an excellent listener and communicator. The community trusts him. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport. Joe is dedicated to mitigating Airport health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Jeffrey J. Douglas Pearl Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 95 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 443 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Ose Dalldorf <bizzi1975@yahoo.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 1:13 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16 A/ Airport Commission EXTERNAL To whom it may concern I am endorsing Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission seat. Thank you, Your longtime resident of Santa Monica Item 16.A 11/15/22 96 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 444 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:D F <wittyone6@msn.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 11:47 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:16A Airport commissioner EXTERNAL I would be pleased if some progress closing SM Airport would be made. Hopefully by supporting Joe Pertel for commissioner will help. Thank you, Dee Forrest Item 16.A 11/15/22 97 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 445 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:G- LO <lorriabenson@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 11:24 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Empty Airport Commission seat EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the empty Airport Commission seat. We in Sunset Park believe Joe Pertel can best represent our interests, and those of the majority of Santa Monica residents. He is qualified and understands all the issues and the history. I heartily endorse Mr. Pertel and hope you will not delay in appointing him to the seat. Thank you for your time. best, Item 16.A 11/15/22 98 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 446 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:David Abramis <dabramis@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 10:44 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Iris Souza Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL To Whom It May Concern: I am writing mainly to endorse Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission seat. We need an Airport Commision that is comprised of residents who share a vision of the future and that lives up to the expectations of our community, and not just developers and aviation interests. I thank you for your attention to this matter. Sincerely, David Abramis, Santa Monica resident and home owner 2642 33rd St. Santa Monica, CA 90405 (562) 985-5360 (work #) Item 16.A 11/15/22 99 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 447 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:T GROSSMAN <tina.grossman@gmail.com> Sent:Sunday, November 13, 2022 10:27 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission -Pls Support Joe Pertel for Airport Commission EXTERNAL Writing in support of Joe Pertel for airport commission Thank you, Tina Grossman Sunset Park resident 310.392.6455 Item 16.A 11/15/22 100 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 448 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission and believe he would be an invaluable and tireless public representative and conscientious leader. I have known Joe and his family for many years and am confident he would make a fantastic airport commissioner. He has actively served on numerous local youth sports and music organization boards. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. Joe has consistently demonstrated his teamwork, leadership and vision as a community advocate. Joe is an active listener and consensus builder with the experience and disposition to assess and synthesize the many competing viewpoints necessary for the airport transition. As a representative of the Santa Monica public, Joe will keep our interests in mind during these next critical years of the impending airport transition. Joe is conscientious and dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable land uses such as expansion of the Airport Park, and actively supporting City Council in preparation for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Bruce Malarky Maple Street, Santa Monica 310-383-0924 Item 16.A 11/15/22 101 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 449 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:George T. Milkovich <gtm1@cornell.edu> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:05 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Pls appoint Mr. JOE PERTEL TO AIRPORT COMMISSION EXTERNAL We are writing to urge you to appoint Mr. PERTEL to the vacancy on the Airport Commission. We believe that Mr PERTEL work to insure that the property now used as an airport will be converted to be enjoyed by ALL the people . As residents of Santa Monica for over 20 years, we believe that Mr. PERTEL will follow the Resolution passed by the City Council in 2017 and the measure LC passed by the Santa Monica voters in 2014. Thank you for your attention to this matter. George and Carolyn MILKOVICH 310 569 2139 Item 16.A 11/15/22 102 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 450 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Janie Docter <janield@verizon.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:54 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:SM Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL I strongly support my friend and long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. We served as board members on Elemental Strings for many years which provides ensemble experience to young musicians in Santa Monica and surrounding cities. We were also very involved with youth sports programs especially when I was a board member of SM AYSO. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Janie Docter Sunset Park Resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 103 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 451 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Cheyton Jain <cheyton.jain@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:43 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - Joe Pertel for the airport commission EXTERNAL Hello! For what it's worth, I want to support Joe Pertel for airport commissioner. He's been a long-time resident of Sunset Park and an already active member of our community. Considering the recent decision to close the airport, it would make sense to appoint someone in the post who wants to see that decision through, whereas the other candidates have publicly expressed their interest in keeping the airport open. I truly believe he would keep the community's interests at the top of his mind. Sincerely, Cheyton J. Item 16.A 11/15/22 104 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 452 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Jennifer Polhemus <jenniferpolhemus@verizon.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:38 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment. EXTERNAL I support the application of Joe Pertel. I met Joe through nonprofit arts volunteer work more than 10 years ago. He is a man of high character and strong intellect, and a hard worker – exactly the type of person we prize on City Commissions. Jennifer L. Polhemus 40-year Santa Monica resident; Santa Monica business owner 2521 32nd Street, Santa Monica, CA 90405-3102 JenniferPolhemus@Verizon.net Item 16.A 11/15/22 105 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 453 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Toby Berlin <tobyberlin@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:33 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:16 A - Airport Commision EXTERNAL Dear Council: I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Item 16.A 11/15/22 106 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 454 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 Toby Berlin 1701 Pier Avenue UNIT B (note new address!) Santa Monica, CA 90405 310-200-9306 Item 16.A 11/15/22 107 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 455 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Kenny Fields <kennyfieldseditor@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:35 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Hello, I am a Sunset Park home owner since 1992. I am writing today to express my support for Joe Pertel to occupy the vacant seat on the Airport Commission. Joe will represent the citizens of Sunset Park well as we move toward the eventual closure of the airport. Joe will help make sure that the commission represents the will of the residents expressed so strongly with the passage of measure LC to close the airport and turn it into a multi use park which will benefit the entire City that is need of more open space and recreational facilities. Thanks for your time. Kenny Fields 1740 Cedar Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 108 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 456 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission and believe he would be an invaluable and tireless public representative and conscientious leader. I have known Joe and his family for many years and am confident he would make a fantastic airport commissioner. He has actively served on numerous local youth sports and music organization boards. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. Joe has consistently demonstrated his teamwork, leadership and vision as a community advocate. Joe is an active listener and consensus builder with the experience and disposition to assess and synthesize the many competing viewpoints necessary for the airport transition. As a representative of the Santa Monica public, Joe will keep our interests in mind during these next critical years of the impending airport transition. Joe is conscientious and dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable land uses such as expansion of the Airport Park, and actively supporting City Council in preparation for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Bruce Malarky Maple Street, Santa Monica 310-383-0924 Item 16.A 11/15/22 109 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 457 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:George T. Milkovich <gtm1@cornell.edu> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:05 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Pls appoint Mr. JOE PERTEL TO AIRPORT COMMISSION EXTERNAL We are writing to urge you to appoint Mr. PERTEL to the vacancy on the Airport Commission. We believe that Mr PERTEL work to insure that the property now used as an airport will be converted to be enjoyed by ALL the people . As residents of Santa Monica for over 20 years, we believe that Mr. PERTEL will follow the Resolution passed by the City Council in 2017 and the measure LC passed by the Santa Monica voters in 2014. Thank you for your attention to this matter. George and Carolyn MILKOVICH 310 569 2139 Item 16.A 11/15/22 110 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 458 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Janie Docter <janield@verizon.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:54 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:SM Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL I strongly support my friend and long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. We served as board members on Elemental Strings for many years which provides ensemble experience to young musicians in Santa Monica and surrounding cities. We were also very involved with youth sports programs especially when I was a board member of SM AYSO. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Janie Docter Sunset Park Resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 111 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 459 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Cheyton Jain <cheyton.jain@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:43 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission - Joe Pertel for the airport commission EXTERNAL Hello! For what it's worth, I want to support Joe Pertel for airport commissioner. He's been a long-time resident of Sunset Park and an already active member of our community. Considering the recent decision to close the airport, it would make sense to appoint someone in the post who wants to see that decision through, whereas the other candidates have publicly expressed their interest in keeping the airport open. I truly believe he would keep the community's interests at the top of his mind. Sincerely, Cheyton J. Item 16.A 11/15/22 112 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 460 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Jennifer Polhemus <jenniferpolhemus@verizon.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:38 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment. EXTERNAL I support the application of Joe Pertel. I met Joe through nonprofit arts volunteer work more than 10 years ago. He is a man of high character and strong intellect, and a hard worker – exactly the type of person we prize on City Commissions. Jennifer L. Polhemus 40-year Santa Monica resident; Santa Monica business owner 2521 32nd Street, Santa Monica, CA 90405-3102 JenniferPolhemus@Verizon.net Item 16.A 11/15/22 113 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 461 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Toby Berlin <tobyberlin@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 8:33 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:16 A - Airport Commision EXTERNAL Dear Council: I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Item 16.A 11/15/22 114 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 462 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 Toby Berlin 1701 Pier Avenue UNIT B (note new address!) Santa Monica, CA 90405 310-200-9306 Item 16.A 11/15/22 115 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 463 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Kenny Fields <kennyfieldseditor@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:35 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Hello, I am a Sunset Park home owner since 1992. I am writing today to express my support for Joe Pertel to occupy the vacant seat on the Airport Commission. Joe will represent the citizens of Sunset Park well as we move toward the eventual closure of the airport. Joe will help make sure that the commission represents the will of the residents expressed so strongly with the passage of measure LC to close the airport and turn it into a multi use park which will benefit the entire City that is need of more open space and recreational facilities. Thanks for your time. Kenny Fields 1740 Cedar Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 116 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 464 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Marion Klein <marionhk@icloud.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:13 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Support Joe Pertel for Airport Commissioner EXTERNAL Please support him! I truly appreciate this. Gratefully Marion Klein Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 117 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 465 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Jasmine Smith <jasmine.smit21@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:06 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Letter of support EXTERNAL I wholeheartedly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Jasmine Smith Sunset Park -- Jasmine Smith (310) 804-4794 jasmine.smit21@gmail.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 118 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 466 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:omglaw@gmail.com Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:02 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Airport Commission - Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Dear Council Members, I am writing to urge you to appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. He is a resident of Sunset Park. Is involved with the community and is familiar with community issues and the sentiment of local residents, and is qualified to serve. He does not have special interests, as some of the other candidates do, except for representing the needs of the neighborhood and residents. Thank you, Ofer Grossman 1115 Hill Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 119 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 467 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:A. Harewood <aharewood@verizon.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:55 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:SM Airport Commission Appointment: 11/15/22 SM City Council Item 16(A) Attachments:Airport Commission Application - Joe Pertel.pdf Importance:High EXTERNAL Santa Monica City Council: Per his attached resume, and as myself a long-time (8 as a renter, 31 as a homeowner) and current resident of Sunset Park, I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Sincerely, Adrian Harewood 2437 Pier Avenue, Sunset Park Item 16.A 11/15/22 120 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 468 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Stephen Cooper <scooooper@yahoo.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:52 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel endorsement EXTERNAL To whom it may concern: I have known Joe Pertel for about 15 years and unquestionably support him for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Stephen W. Cooper 2410 Ocean Park Boulevard Item 16.A 11/15/22 121 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 469 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:JORDAN ELLIS <jordanrellis@me.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 11:00 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Hello, I am a resident of Santa Monica and strongly endorse Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission seat. Thanks, Jordan Ellis Bryn Mawr Ave 310-779-2771 Item 16.A 11/15/22 122 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 470 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Traci Wallace <traciwallace@earthlink.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:57 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Dear Members of the Council, I am asking you to please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. I realize that there is an empty seat on the Commission and it is important to me as a Santa Monica resident to see that the Airport Commission is made of other residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of our community, and not developers and aviation interests. We voted citywide and passed measure LC in 2014 and communicated that we would like the airport land turned into a park, cultural, and recreational center, as residents intended way back in 1926 when the land was purchased by a park bond. Please allow Santa Monica residents to be represented on the Airport Commission and appoint Joe Pertel to the vacant seat. Thank you, Traci Wallace, Ph.D. 1731 Dewey Street 310-351-7555 Item 16.A 11/15/22 123 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 471 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Jamie Dunham <jdunham13@yahoo.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:54 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Thank you, Jamie Dunham Pier Avenue resident Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android Item 16.A 11/15/22 124 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 472 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 Vernice Hankins From:Docter, Daniel <Daniel.Docter@dell.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:54 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment EXTERNAL To Santa Monica City Council: I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Daniel Docter 1625 Dewey Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 Internal Use - Confidential Item 16.A 11/15/22 125 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 473 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 Vernice Hankins From:Jamie Ginsburg <jbcginsburg@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 10:39 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel for SM Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Jamie Ginsburg Sunset Park neighborhood Item 16.A 11/15/22 126 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 474 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Joseph Hardin <joehardin@earthlink.net> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 11:12 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission Appointment. EXTERNAL To the Santa Monica City Council Members: Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Santa Monica Airport Commission. It will be great to have a long time Santa Monica resident and concerned parent on the commission. Joe is highly qualified and will put the health and welfare of the citizens of Santa Monica over the "big money" outside interests that have plagued our city for the 21 years I have lived here. Thanks for your hard work, Joe Joseph Hardin 2349 Pier Ave Santa Monica CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 127 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 475 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Barbara Inatsugu <inatsugub@aol.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 11:01 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:ITEM 16.A – Appointment to one unscheduled vacancy on the Airport Commission Attachments:PERTEL - CC ITEM 16A AIRPORT COMMISSION - LTR OF SUPPORT.pdf EXTERNAL NOVEMBER 14, 2022 TO: Mayor, Mayor ProTem, and Members of the Santa Monica City Council councilmtgitems@santamonica.gov From: Barbara Inatsugu, Sunset Park Resident LETTER OF SUPPORT: Appointment of Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission ITEM 16.A – Appointment to one unscheduled vacancy on the Airport Commission for a term ending on 6/30/2024 I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for appointment to the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge and dedication to our community, deliberative approach to decision-making, and ability to work well with others, together with his experience as an active participant in a variety of local organizations make him an ideal candidate for appointment. Furthermore, he is a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues, as described in his Airport Commission Application. Joe is committed to insuring that the City continue to move forward on the closure of the Airport in 2028 and its conversion to park with open space and recreational facilities, as approved by a large majority of our residents in 2014. His voice as a Commissioner would be an informed and important one. As Chair of the SMMUSD Personnel Commission, I worked regularly with Joe, who at one point was my Vice Chair, so I can attest from first hand experience to his effectiveness as a member of that Commission. Boards and Commissions are an important part of our City’s governing structure. Santa Monica has long been committed to providing community members with a variety of opportunities to have a meaningful role in City governance. Advisory Committees are one such substantive opportunity. Item 16.A 11/15/22 128 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 476 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 For that reason, it is important that the City Council appoint commissioners who will take their appointment seriously, regularly attend commission meetings, and read each commission agenda and all staff reports – in other words, understand and be committed to the role and responsibilities of a City Commissioner, come to all meetings of the Commission prepared and ready to deliberate and forward advice and recommendations to the City Council that are based on what is in the best interest of the City and the community (the people) of Santa Monica. The Airport Commission, the residents of Santa Monica, as well as the City would benefit from his appointment. Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Barbara Inatsugu (she/her/hers) inatsugub@aol.com Item 16.A 11/15/22 129 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 477 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Hilda Borgese <hborgese@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 11:26 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel Attachments:Joe Pertel.docx EXTERNAL Item 16.A 11/15/22 130 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 478 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Christine Hardin <chardin2349@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 12:00 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission Send to: councilmtgitems@santamonica.gov EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. My husband and I are Sunset Park residents. Thank you. Christine Hardin Joseph Hardin 2349 Pier Avenue Santa Monica, CA 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 131 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 479 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Julius Reder Carlson <juliusredercarlson@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 11:46 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Supporting Joe Pertel for SMO EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident Joe Pertel for the Santa Monica Airport Commission. His legal experience, knowledge, and dedication to our community make him a wonderful candidate. Please appoint him. Julius Carlson Down town Santa Monica Neighborhood Item 16.A 11/15/22 132 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 480 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 Vernice Hankins From:Shabnam Fasa <shab@santamonicayouthorchestra.org> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 11:43 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Support of Joe Pertel for SMO EXTERNAL I (wholeheartedly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Shabnam Fasa 1017 4th street Santa Monica Sent from my iPhone Item 16.A 11/15/22 133 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 481 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Jan Simonovic <janrsimonovic@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 12:39 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel EXTERNAL Dear Santa Monica City Council, PLEASE, PLEASE appoint Joe Pertel to the Santa Monica Airport Commission!! We need him to help make the airport an asset for all of us. Sincerely, Jan Simonovic Item 16.A 11/15/22 134 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 482 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Jennifer Field <filoudotcom@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 12:23 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL I’d like to endorse Joe Pertel for the empty Airport Commission seat. Additionally, I would suggest the City keep front and center to the public all information pertaining to the airport closure/further use, and the general facts surrounding the process. Based on several recent conversations with residents, it seems the AOPA continues to assert there will be a backdoor deal with developers, we will be stranded in case of emergency, and, removing the “bubble" over SMO will result in LAX jets strafing over neighborhoods at 2,000 ft. Thank you for your attention. Jennifer Field Item 16.A 11/15/22 135 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 483 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Steven Naftali <stevenaftali@yahoo.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 2:00 PM To:councilmtgitems Cc:Nojets Info Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Honorable Santa Monica City Council Members: My family and I reside on Marine St. and Steiner Ave. We respectfully ask the City Council to appoint Joe Pertel to the empty Airport Commission seat. Joe is an attorney and Sunset Park resident who like us lives under the irritating noise of the SMO aircraft and the pollution that they cause. As an official body of residents, it is important to see that the Airport Commission is made of residents who share a vision of the future that lives up to the expectations of the community. Not those of the developers and aviation interests. The City Council made a resolution to close the SMO in 2017. Our residents voted citywide and passed measure LC in 2014 to turn the land into a park, cultural, and recreational center. As the residents intended way back in 1926 when the city purchased the airport land by a park bond. In its current form the airport is likely the most underutilized piece of property in Santa Monica. It is time to start to convert the empty land that the dwindling airport no longer needs into uses that the residents can enjoy. Like sports fields and courts, walking paths, and such. We can do this in affordable steps with great success. Like the other cities in the USA and abroad have accomplished after they closed their airports. Respectfully submitted, Steve Naftali SteveNaftali@yahoo.com The information transmitted is intended only for the person which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon, this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this message in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer. Item 16.A 11/15/22 136 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 484 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:jay puvvula <jpuvvula@hotmail.com> Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 3:21 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL I strongly support long-time Sunset Park resident, Joe Pertel, for the airport commission. Joe Pertel would make a great airport commissioner. He is a long-time Sunset Park resident who has served on the boards of many local youth organizations. I've known Joe Pertel over the years as a fellow parent from elementary school to high school. He has whole heartedly contributed to our community with his active participation and generosity. He is also a public interest attorney with decades of experience analyzing complex legal issues. I know over the years that he has done a lot of pro-bono work. He is highly intelligent and pragmatic. I have a great deal of respect for him and highly recommend him As a representative of our neighborhood, Joe will keep our community interests in mind during these next critical years for the Santa Monica Airport (SMO). Joe is dedicated to mitigating SMO health impacts, promoting sustainable uses such as the expansion of Airport Park, and actively supporting the Commission and City Council in preparing for the successful closure of the airport and its conversion to a park in 2029. Sincerely, Jay Puvvula MD 11th and Marine St by Marine Park. Item 16.A 11/15/22 137 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 485 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:zinajosephs@aol.com Sent:Monday, November 14, 2022 9:26 PM To:councilmtgitems; Christine Parra; Gleam Davis; Kristin McCowan; Lana Negrete; Oscar de la Torre; Phil Brock; Sue Himmelrich; David White Cc:zinajosephs@aol.com Subject:FOSP: City Council 11/15/22 item 16-A -- Airport Commission -- Joe Pertel EXTERNAL November 14, 2022 To: Mayor Himmelrich and City Council members From: Board of Directors, Friends of Sunset Park RE: 11/15/22 agenda item 16-A – Airport Commission appointment A majority of the FOSP Board members have voted to support the appointment of Joseph Pertel to the Airport Commission. Joe’s dad was a Navy pilot, so he grew up around various Naval Air Stations in Florida, Virginia, Rhode Island, and Maine, where he developed an appreciation for military and civil aviation. Since graduating from college and law school, Joe has been a long-time Sunset Park resident and has raised his family here, serving on the SMMUSD Personnel Board, and volunteering with various youth sports organizations. This has made him aware of the need for more open space, parks, and recreational facilities in our city. With his legal training and 27 years of experience as an attorney, he understands FAA regulations, the 2017 Consent Decree, and the history of litigation involving the city and Santa Monica Airport. He is also aware of the safety and pollution impacts of past and current Airport operations on local residents. Joe views the conversion of Santa Monica Airport to a great park, after the airport closes at the end of 2028, as a "once-in-a-lifetime opportunity." We believe that he will do an excellent job of analyzing options and representing community concerns as the planning process goes forward. Item 16.A 11/15/22 138 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 486 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 He has a demonstrated commitment to the improvement of the quality of life for Santa Monica residents, particularly the children of Santa Monica, and we expect that commitment to continue to play itself out in his service on the Santa Monica Airport Commission. Item 16.A 11/15/22 139 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 487 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:jmw_smbsc01@verizon.net Sent:Tuesday, November 15, 2022 8:38 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Joe Pertel's pending Commission appointment EXTERNAL To the Santa Monica Council members. I support the appointment of Joe Pertel to the Santa Monica Airport Commission. As a native to Santa Monica that was born and raised under the airport’s flight path, and still to this day, live within ‘earshot’, and an active member of the community, I feel I should add my voice in support of Joe Pertel. Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Santa Monica Airport Commission. Stay safe, Stay well, James M. Wilson, AIA Item 16.A 11/15/22 140 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 488 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Vernice Hankins From:Council Mailbox Sent:Tuesday, November 15, 2022 8:00 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Fw: NO!!! Joe Pertel. airport commission From: lori brown <loreb2@aol.com> Sent: Monday, November 14, 2022 8:35 PM To: Council Mailbox <Council.Mailbox@santamonica.gov>; Phil Brock <Phil.Brock@santamonica.gov>; Lana Negrete <Lana.Negrete@santamonica.gov>; Oscar de la Torre <Oscar.delaTorre@santamonica.gov>; Christine Parra <Christine.Parra@santamonica.gov> Subject: NO!!! Joe Pertel. airport commission EXTERNAL Dear council members Many residents especially in Sunset Park have been the recipient of vitriol and online bullying from Joe Pertel. !!!!! I question his motives which is further exacerbated by his associations. Please note: The Sunset Park Board was not unanimous for Mr. Pertel. Thank you for your time and careful consideration on the appointment. Lori Brown Sunset park resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 141 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 489 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Nikki Kolhoff <nhkolhoff@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 15, 2022 8:57 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Fw: Oppose Joe Pertel for Airport Commission EXTERNAL ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Nikki Kolhoff <nhkolhoff@yahoo.com> To: council@smgov.net <council@smgov.net>; phil.brock@santamonica.gov <phil.brock@santamonica.gov>; lana.negrete@santamonica.gov <lana.negrete@santamonica.gov>; oscar.delatorre@santamonica.gov <oscar.delatorre@santamonica.gov>; christine.parra@santamonica.gov <christine.parra@santamonica.gov> Sent: Monday, November 14, 2022 at 11:31:02 PM PST Subject: Oppose Joe Pertel for Airport Commission Dear City Council - I am writing to oppose the appointment of Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. First, as the recipient of much ire from Joe Pertel on social media, I can confirm he is a social media bully. This past election season he was involved in the perpetuation of the falsehood that anyone who opposes unlimited growth or the Dem Club endorsements is a right-wing Republican Trumper. This is mean, dangerous, divisive, and anti-democratic, and conduct not befitting a commissioner. Second, in 2021 Chris Harding formed a group called SMIG (Santa Monicans for Integrity in Government) and Joe did some of their legal work. The group members are Judy Abdo, Jason Islas, Chris Harding, Tom Larmore, Debbie Mulvaney, and Joe Pertel. SMIG initially formed to block Oscar de la Torre from voting on district elections and to retain the at-large elections for more development. See here: https://smdp.com/2021/02/03/your-column-here-7/ Then SMIG threatened to shut down the Santa Monica High School Alumni Association for advocating to preserve the History Building. Joe filed a complaint on behalf of SMIG regarding paperwork technicalities and making the false accusation that the alumni association was engaged in "propaganda" and should have its nonprofit status revoked simply for advocating to save the flagship building of the Samohi campus. The History Building was a cultural resource of Santa Monica and would have been landmarked if those rules applied to school land. Joe Pertel and Chris Harding went against the pleas of 5 neighborhood organizations, the Samohi Alumni Association, the Santa Monica Conservancy, and a petition of 6000 people to save it, and instead behaved like bullies to push through the demolition while Chris Harding's wife, Laurie Lieberman, was pushing the demolition on the school board. They supported demolition and construction as "progress." This will be looked back on as one of the lowest points in our city's history. Prior to that, Joe Pertel teamed up with Joel Koury and asked a court not to pay claimants on their lawful awards in the SMMUSD pupil fee lawsuit settlement. Item 16.A 11/15/22 142 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 490 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Finally, I am suspicious of the motives of anyone working with the biggest land use lawyer in town to do what is in the best interests of residents with respect to the airport land, when there is no track record to support that, but rather the opposite. It would be a mistake to believe he is an advocate for residents or the conversion of the airport to a park. Thank you for your consideration. Nikki Kolhoff Santa Monica Resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 143 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 491 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Nikki Kolhoff <nhkolhoff@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 15, 2022 11:13 AM To:councilmtgitems; Phil Brock; Lana Negrete; Oscar de la Torre; Christine Parra Cc:Doug.sloan@smgov.net Subject:Fw: Oppose Joe Pertel for Airport Commission - Documentation of Joe's Divisive Attacks Attachments:koury pertel objection body.pdf; 2021-06-01 Letter from Joe Pertel re Samohi Alumni Association.pdf EXTERNAL City Council - As further support for my objection, I am attaching the following documents: 1. Objection filed by Joe Pertel and Joel Koury to the SMMUSD pupil fee lawsuit settlement filed February 10, 2020. This appears motivated by their ongoing feud with Kevin Shenkman. However, Joe was willing to hurt families in order to defeat Shenkman. Not only did he object to the payment of legal fees, but he objected to the payment of lawful claims to parents and students. The claims were for reimbursement of amounts paid out of pocket that the school district was required by law to pay for. It is not clear that the people who signed Joe's request to join an objection were aware that they were objecting to payment of claims in addition to legal fees. Joe and Joel's objection further divided the school community by making parents and students who filed claims the enemies of the school district instead of focusing on the unlawful behavior of the district. This behavior emboldens the district to do less and challenge more, which puts our kids at risk, and the most recent example is a $45 million jury verdict against SMMUSD for the abuse of two special needs students. 2. Link to statement by SMIG relating to district elections February 3, 2021 (named signatories: Judy Abdo, Jason Islas, Chris Harding, Tom Larmore, Debbie Mulvaney, and Joe Pertel). This is further work by Joe Pertel with Chris Harding and other pro-development people to stop district elections and keep massive development moving forward. It is another example of ad hominem attacks and the attempt to portray opponents as unsavory people instead of addressing substantive issues. In this instance, there is an effort to liken those wanting district elections (a format cited as more democratic by many Democratic Party organizations) as Trump supporters. SMIG also filed an amicus brief in the case. https://smdp.com/2021/02/03/your-column-here-7/ 3. Complaint filed June 1, 2021 by Joe Pertel on behalf of SMIG threatened to shut down the Santa Monica High School Alumni Association for advocating to preserve the History Building. This was a bullying tactic intended to silence Phil Brock and the Samohi Alumni Association from objecting to the demolition of the History Building. This was harmful to the continued and proper work of the Alumni Association to preserve and protect the iconic buildings of Samohi and the history of Santa Monica. These kinds of efforts result in emotional distress and negatively financially impact those who must defend against these bullying legal attacks. There is no doubt this kind of behavior resulted in a chilling of advocacy and civic discourse in Santa Monica, and the loss of an iconic cultural resource, for the benefit of development interests supported by Chris Harding. Please do not give Joe Pertel a platform to bully fellow residents and further Chris Harding's development agenda for the airport land. Thank you for your consideration. Nikki Kolhoff Item 16.A 11/15/22 144 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 492 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 Sunset Park Resident ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Nikki Kolhoff <nhkolhoff@yahoo.com> To: Councilmtgitems <councilmtgitems@santamonica.gov> Sent: Tuesday, November 15, 2022 at 08:56:57 AM PST Subject: Fw: Oppose Joe Pertel for Airport Commission ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Nikki Kolhoff <nhkolhoff@yahoo.com> To: council@smgov.net <council@smgov.net>; phil.brock@santamonica.gov <phil.brock@santamonica.gov>; lana.negrete@santamonica.gov <lana.negrete@santamonica.gov>; oscar.delatorre@santamonica.gov <oscar.delatorre@santamonica.gov>; christine.parra@santamonica.gov <christine.parra@santamonica.gov> Sent: Monday, November 14, 2022 at 11:31:02 PM PST Subject: Oppose Joe Pertel for Airport Commission Dear City Council - I am writing to oppose the appointment of Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. First, as the recipient of much ire from Joe Pertel on social media, I can confirm he is a social media bully. This past election season he was involved in the perpetuation of the falsehood that anyone who opposes unlimited growth or the Dem Club endorsements is a right-wing Republican Trumper. This is mean, dangerous, divisive, and anti-democratic, and conduct not befitting a commissioner. Second, in 2021 Chris Harding formed a group called SMIG (Santa Monicans for Integrity in Government) and Joe did some of their legal work. The group members are Judy Abdo, Jason Islas, Chris Harding, Tom Larmore, Debbie Mulvaney, and Joe Pertel. SMIG initially formed to block Oscar de la Torre from voting on district elections and to retain the at-large elections for more development. See here: https://smdp.com/2021/02/03/your-column-here-7/ Then SMIG threatened to shut down the Santa Monica High School Alumni Association for advocating to preserve the History Building. Joe filed a complaint on behalf of SMIG regarding paperwork technicalities and making the false accusation that the alumni association was engaged in "propaganda" and should have its nonprofit status revoked simply for advocating to save the flagship building of the Samohi campus. The History Building was a cultural resource of Santa Monica and would have been landmarked if those rules applied to school land. Joe Pertel and Chris Harding went against the pleas of 5 neighborhood organizations, the Samohi Alumni Association, the Santa Monica Conservancy, and a petition of 6000 people to save it, and instead behaved like bullies to push through the demolition while Chris Harding's wife, Laurie Lieberman, was pushing the demolition on the school board. They supported demolition and construction as "progress." This will be looked back on as one of the lowest points in our city's history. Prior to that, Joe Pertel teamed up with Joel Koury and asked a court not to pay claimants on their lawful awards in the SMMUSD pupil fee lawsuit settlement. Finally, I am suspicious of the motives of anyone working with the biggest land use lawyer in town to do what is in the best interests of residents with respect to the airport land, when there is no track record to support that, but rather the opposite. Item 16.A 11/15/22 145 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 493 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 It would be a mistake to believe he is an advocate for residents or the conversion of the airport to a park. Thank you for your consideration. Nikki Kolhoff Santa Monica Resident Item 16.A 11/15/22 146 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 494 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Nicola Goode <nicola@nicolagoode.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 15, 2022 11:35 AM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16(A) - Airport Commission EXTERNAL Attn. Santa Monica City Council: I'm writing in support of longtime Sunset Park, Santa Monica resident Joe Pertel as a terrific choice for the Airport Commission. He has been a consistently active member of our community including working on the boards of various youth organizations. As a dedicated, experienced public interest attorney he brings skills of complex legal analysis to the table as well. The coming years will be critical ones regarding changes to the use and direction of Santa Monica’s 'jewel in the crown’ parcel, SMO. I believe Joe would keep our best interests in mind and remain dedicated to mitigating health impacts, promoting sustainable uses while working as a balanced team player within the Commission and with the City Council. As a 20 year Sunset Park resident and tenant of an art studio space at the SMO 18th Street Art Studio campus, I look forward to the successful closure of SMO, its transition to multiple creative community based uses and the expansion of Airport Park in 2029. Sincerely, Nicola Goode Sunset Avenue, SM 90405 Item 16.A 11/15/22 147 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 495 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Law Office Of Joseph A. Pertel 2801 Ocean Park Boulevard, # 276 Santa Monica, California 90405 Telephone: (310) 503-5791 E-Mail: jpertel@yahoo.com June 1, 2021 Dr. Ben Drati, Superintendent Santa Monica Malibu Unified School District 1651 16th Street Santa Monica, California 90404 Dr. Antonio Shelton, Principal Santa Monica High School 601 Pico Boulevard Santa Monica, California 90405 RE: Santa Monica High School (“Samohi”) Alumni Association Suspension of Nonprofit Status and Partisan Advocacy VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL Dear Dr. Drati and Dr. Shelton, I am writing on behalf of Santa Monicans for Integrity in Government (“SMIG”), which includes Samohi graduates, parents of Samohi students and graduates, and Samohi Alumni Association (“SAA”) members, to express our concerns regarding the reported suspension of SAA’s nonprofit status by the California Attorney General’s Office and the California Secretary of State, its lack of good standing with the California Franchise Board, as well as SAA’s partisan political activities that we believe undermine the core mission of this important community organization. Since it is our understanding that the school district provides office space, furniture, telephone, internet and other services to SAA at no cost, we are asking the school district to conduct a formal inquiry into SAA’s nonprofit status, finances and activities to insure that it complies with California’s nonprofit legal requirements, as Item 16.A 11/15/22 148 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 496 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 2 well as fulfilling its mission to provide support to Samohi alumni and current students without partisan politics. A. Background - Samohi Alumni Association The Santa Monica High School (“Samohi”) Alumni Association was registered as a nonprofit entity with the California Secretary of State on October 26, 1953, entity number C0279539. (Exhibit A.) The current iteration of SAA was registered as a nonprofit public benefit corporation with the Secretary of State on January 7, 1991, entity number C1679526. (Id.) The SAA maintains rent-free office space with furniture, telephone and internet service on the campus of Santa Monica High School.1 (Exhibit B, p. 3.) The SAA lists its physical address as Santa Monica High School (Samohi) located at 601 Pico Boulevard, Santa Monica, California 90405 with a Samohi telephone number of 310 395-3204, extension 71564. (Id.). The SAA maintains social media accounts on Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram and Twitter. In its most recent newsletter, SAA provided the following list of current board members: Phil Brock, ’71, President; Jeff Condon, ’79, Vice President; Michael Flinkman, ’77, Treasurer; Crystal Reed, ’89, Secretary; Stephanie Hoff Brice ’70; Sharon Coatam Armstrong, ’71; Joe Deering, Jr., ’64; Naila Dada Elfarra, ’83; Becky Darden Mejia, ’58; Karl Schober, ’62; Lawson Desrochers, ’86; and Victoria Coulson, ’86.2 (Exhibit B, p. 3.) Phil Brock has served as President of SAA since 2016. He served as Vice President from 2013-2015. B. Current Nonprofit Status 1. California Secretary of State The Secretary of State requires tax-exempt organizations, including nonprofit public benefit corporations, to file a “Statement of Information” every other year after incorporation. If an entity fails to file a Statement of Information, the Secretary 1 See http://www.samohialumni.org/ 2 See https://www.facebook.com/samohialumni Item 16.A 11/15/22 149 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 497 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 3 of State informs the California Franchise Tax Board, which is authorized to assess financial penalties. (Attorney General’s Guide for Charities, “AG Guide” (2021) at pp. 43-44.) If the Secretary of State suspends a corporation for failure to file a Statement of Information, its status can only be resolved and returned to active status by the Franchise Tax Board. A corporation is not allowed to conduct business in California while suspended. According to the Secretary of State’s website, SAA filed its most recent Statement of Information on February 16, 2015, more than six years ago.3 (Exhibit C.) According to its website, the California Secretary of State has “suspended” the Samohi Alumni Association. (Id.) 2. California Attorney General’s Office The Attorney General’s Office (“AG’s Office”) regulates charities and other nonprofit organizations. As part of this process, the AG’s Office maintains a “Registry of Charitable Trusts” (“the Registry”) on its website. Charitable organizations must register with the AG’s Office within 30 days of receiving a cash donation, property donation, or other asset with financial value received for a charitable purpose. (AG’s Guide, supra, at p. 44.) Charitable organizations are required to file an “Annual Registration Renewal Form (“Form RRF-1”), as well as copies of their annual IRS Form 990. Failure to file the annual Form RRF-1 may result in the loss of the organization’s tax-exempt status. The SAA registered with the AG’s Office on December 31, 2006, Registry number 080829. (Exhibit D.) According to the AG’s Office’s official website, SAA filed its last Form RRF-1 on December 4, 2012, more than eight years ago. (Id.) The AG’s website states that Samohi Alumni Association’s Registry status is “Suspended.” (Id.) On October 5, 2020, the AG’s Office mailed SAA a “Delinquent Notice.” (Exhibit E.) In this Notice, the AG’s Office advised SAA that its “registration status 3https://businesssearch.sos.ca.gov/CBS/SearchResults?filing=&SearchType=NUMBE R&SearchCriteria=C1679526&SearchSubType=Exact Item 16.A 11/15/22 150 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 498 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 4 has been delinquent for more than 10 years.”4 (Id., emphasis added.) The Notice further advised the Alumni Association that “[y]ou are required to file the Form RRF-1 renewal fees and the IRS Form 990 . . . for the missing years within 30 days or your organization’s account will be suspended and then revoked.” (Id.) The Delinquency Notice further warned SAA that “[h]aving a delinquent or suspended status prevents your organization from any fundraising.” (Id.) On February 1, 2021, the AG’s Office formally suspended the Samohi Alumni Association. (Exhibit D.) According to its website, a charitable organization that is not in good standing with the Registry may not operate or solicit donations in California.5 3. Franchise Tax Board Most tax-exempt organizations are required to file an annual information return with the State of California Franchise Tax Board (FTB”). Most charitable organizations file FTB Form 199 or Form 199N. According to its website, SAA is “Suspended” and “Not Exempt.” (Exhibit G, p. 1, emphasis added; See also, Franchise Tax Board, Entity Status Letter, dated May 29, 2021 [“The [Samohi Alumni Association] is not in good standing with the Franchise Tax Board.”] (Id., p. 2, emphasis in original.) 4 As reflected in minutes of its board meetings, SAA has been aware of its failure to comply with California’s nonprofit laws since at least 2018, See, e.g., “State non-profit status paperwork needs to be submitted ASAP! Bret [Hammond] will work with Phil [Brock]. (Minutes 7/11/18, p.1 [underline added]); “Charitable status: Crystal [Reed] will work with Phil [Brock] to update this before the end of the year.” (Minutes 12/12/18, p. 1 [underline added]) (Exhibit F.) As of today’s date, SAA has not posted minutes of its board meetings on its website since December 11, 2019. http://www.samohialumni.org/board-meetings-agendas-- minutes.html 5 See California Code of Regulations, title 11, section 999.9.4, which states, “A person or entity subject to the registration requirements of Government Code section 12580 et seq., must be registered and in good standing with the Registry of Charitable Trusts to operate or solicit for charitable purposes. A registration that is delinquent, suspended or revoked is not in good standing and is prohibited from engaging in conduct for which registration is required including, but not limited to solicitation for charitable purposes.” (emphasis added.) Item 16.A 11/15/22 151 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 499 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 5 C. Compliance with State Nonprofit Laws and Policy Issues By this letter, we are asking SMMUSD to conduct a formal inquiry into SAA’s nonprofit status, financial condition, and related policy issues: 1. Samohi Alumni Association a. The California Secretary of State’s website states that SAA is suspended. (Exhibit C.) Is this correct and, if so, how long has SAA been suspended? If suspended, is SAA prohibited from conducting business in the State of California? If suspended and prohibited from conducting business, how long has SAA been conducting business unlawfully? Was the SAA board of directors aware of this? If so, for how long? If suspended, did SAA inform SMMUSD of this situation? If not, why not? Why did it continue to operate under these circumstances? What steps, if any, have been taken by SAA leadership, including its longtime President, Phil Brock, to bring SAA into compliance with the Secretary of State’s rules and regulations? b. The California Attorney General’s Office’s website states that SAA is suspended. (Exhibit D.) Is this correct and, if so, how long has SAA been suspended? If suspended, has SAA been prohibited from operating and/or soliciting donations? If so, when did this happen and why does SAA continue to solicit donations on its official website in violation of state law?6 Was the SAA board of directors aware of this? If so, for how long? If suspended and prohibited from operating and/or soliciting donations, did SAA inform SMMUSD of this situation? If not, why not? What are the legal consequences, if any, for soliciting and receiving donations while suspended? Do donors need to be notified? Do donations need to be returned? c. The State of California Franchise Tax Board’s website states that SAA is “suspended,” “not exempt,” and “not in good standing.” (Exhibit G, pp. 1-2, 6 On its website, SAA continues to solicit donations from Samohi alumni and the local community, stating that “[a]ll of your donations are fully tax deductible.” (Exhibit H.) See also http://www.samohialumni.org/donate.html This statement is false and misleading to the extent that SAA has been suspended by the AG’s Office and the Secretary of State and prohibited from conducting business operations and/or soliciting donations. Item 16.A 11/15/22 152 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 500 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 6 emphasis in original.) Is this correct and, if so, how long has SAA been suspended, not exempt, and not been in good standing? If suspended, not exempt, and not in good standing, is SAA prohibited from conducting business in the State of California? If suspended and prohibited from conducting business, how long has SAA been conducting business unlawfully? Was the SAA board of directors aware of this? If so, for how long? If not in good standing with the FTB, did SAA inform SMMUSD of this situation? If not, why not? Why did it continue to operate under these circumstances? What steps, if any, have been taken by SAA leadership, including its President, Phil Brock, to bring SAA into compliance with the Franchise Tax Board’s rules and regulations? d. If suspended and/or not in good standing with the Attorney General’s Office, the Secretary of State, and the Franchise Tax Board, has SAA lost its tax- exempt status? If SAA has lost is tax-exempt status, when did this happen? Was the SAA board of directors aware of this? If so, for how long? If suspended and/or not in good standing, did SAA inform SMMUSD of this situation? If not, why not? Why did it continue to operate under these circumstances? What steps, if any, have been taken to bring SAA into compliance with the rules and regulations of these California agencies? 2. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District a. Does SMMUSD provide office space, including furniture, telephone and internet services, to SAA? Does SMMUSD provide the use other district facilities to SAA, e.g., space to conduct meetings, reunions or alumni gatherings? If so, does SMMUSD have a lease agreement and/or memorandum of understanding with SAA? If not, why not? b. Does SMMUSD charge SAA rent for the use of SMMUSD office space, furniture, telephone and internet services? If so, how much? If not, is this based on SAA’s representations and agreement that SAA is a nonprofit tax-exempt public benefit corporation in good standing with all necessary State of California entities, including the AG’s Office, the Secretary of State, and the Franchise Tax Board? Item 16.A 11/15/22 153 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 501 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 7 c. If SAA is not allowed to conduct business in California, not allowed to solicit donations, and/or has lost its nonprofit status, is SMMUSD legally permitted to provide office space and other free resources to SAA? d. What is the fair market value of the office space, furniture, telephone and internet services provided to SAA by SMMUSD? If SAA was not allowed to conduct business in California, not allowed to solicit (or receive) donations, and/or lost its nonprofit status, is SAA required to reimburse SMMUSD for the fair market value of the office space, furniture, telephone and internet services provided by SMMUSD to SAA during the period of suspension? e. Should SMMUSD include a provision in any lease agreement or memorandum of understanding with SAA for office space and/or the use of other Samohi resources and facilities requiring proof of on-going compliance with state and federal nonprofit rules and regulations? Should SMMUSD require SAA to provide proof of an outside financial audit on a periodic basis as a condition for using Samohi facilities? If so, how often? D. SAA’s Political Activities and Partisan Advocacy Over the past year, we have become concerned by SAA’s participation in overt political activities related to our local elections, including the Santa Monica City Council and SMMUSD Board of Education elections in November, 2020 and, most recently, its support for a recall campaign against members of the SMMUSD school board. As set forth below, SAA has run political advertisements for local candidates, written favorably about alumni political candidates in its newsletter and social media platforms, and used its alumni mailing list for political purposes. In addition, SAA has taken a partisan political position concerning Samohi’s approved Phase III Campus Plan, arguing for the preservation of the History Building, including the use of incorrect and/or misleading information. For these reasons, we Item 16.A 11/15/22 154 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 502 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 8 urge SMMUSD to conduct an independent inquiry concerning these political activities in light of SAA’s use of Samohi facilities and resources.7 1. SAA’s Improper Political Activities The SAA’s Articles of Incorporation contain the following restrictions on political activities: Four (c): “No substantial part of the activities of this corporation shall consist of carrying on propaganda, or otherwise attempting to influence legislation, and the corporation shall not participate or intervene in a political campaign (including the publishing or distribution of statements) on behalf of, or in opposition to, any candidate for public office.” (Exhibit I, p. 2.) In SAA’s Fall 2020 edition of the Santa Monica High School Alumni Association Viking News, SAA President Phil Brock wrote an article which, in relevant part, supported his candidacy for the Santa Monica City Council, the candidacies of his “Slate of Eight” running mate for City Council, Oscar de la Torre, and running mate Esther Hickman for SMMUSD school board, as well as Kristin McCowan, who was running unopposed for a two-year term on City Council: “Finally, Santa Monica’s Municipal Elections coincide with our national elections on November 3rd. As you can tell from the paid advertisements in this issue, three outstanding Vikings seek city council nods, and another Viking is running for a seat on the school board. There are five City Council seats and three board of education seats available. I wish the best of luck to all of us trying to bring positive changes to our city’s elected officers.” (Exhibit J, Viking News, Fall 2020, p. 2.) These comments violate the express terms of SAA’s Articles of Incorporation prohibiting participation or intervention in any political campaign “on behalf of, or in opposition to, any candidate for political office.” (Exhibit I, p. 2.) In addition, we are concerned that these political activities appear to violate the terms of their nonprofit tax-exempt status 7 We are not, of course, opposed to members of SAA expressing political views in their individual capacities. We are concerned, however, when SAA members express and/or promote partisan political views in their official capacities as SAA board members and/or use SAA resources, including SAA newsletters and email lists, to promote their personal political views and/or coordinate with other partisan political organizations and/or individuals to promote their personal political views. Item 16.A 11/15/22 155 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 503 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 9 In addition, the Viking News ran four full-page color political advertisements for Phil Brock, Oscar de la Torre, and Kristin McCowan for City Council and Esther Hickman for School Board. (Exhibit J, at pp. 3, 4, 14, and 15.) The placement of these political advertisements violate the terms of SAA’s Article of Incorporation prohibiting the “. . . publishing or distribution of statements[ ] on behalf of . . . any candidate for political office.” (Exhibit I, page 2.) 2. SAA’s Partisan “Propaganda” Over the past year, SAA, particularly its President Phil Brock, acting in his official capacity as President of SAA, has become directly involved in a campaign opposing Phase III of the approved Samohi Campus Plan and supporting the preservation of the History Building, which is slated for demolition as part of the District’s on-going efforts to modernize its public school facilities. SAA President Brock’s efforts, closely coordinated with the unsuccessful campaign of school board candidate Esther Hickman, violate SAA’s Articles of Incorporation prohibiting the “carrying on of propaganda”8 and raise issues concerning its on-going relationship with SMMUSD and its use of Samohi resources. In a recent SAA newsletter, President Phil Brock published the following comments concerning the History Building: “SAVE the HISTORY Building! “The voters of Santa Monica passed the most massive school bond measure in our district’s history. The superintendent and the majority of the School Board have now slated our historic History Building for demolition . . . . “Here are the reasons the school district gives to rationalize the demolition and replacement of this revered building. The rooms aren’t square (evidently, our education suffers in rectangular rooms!), the walls are so thick that internet services is spotty (I think Broadband is the answer). 8 SAA’s Articles of Incorporation do not define “carrying on propaganda,” which is contained in a section covering restrictions on political activities by the organization. Propaganda is defined as “the spreading of ideas, information or rumor for the purpose of helping or injuring an institution, a cause or a person” or “ideas, facts or allegations spread deliberately to further one’s cause or to damage an opposing cause.” Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2021. Item 16.A 11/15/22 156 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 504 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 10 Additionally, the district notes that students do not like to walk up the hill (are more PE classes the answer?), and the ramps that satisfy ADA requirements are unsightly (elevators anyone)? . . . . “Your Board of Directors believe that the District Administration and School Board are making a mistake. Samohi’s population continues to decrease. Aside from permit students, the student population is just over 2,400 for our four-year school. My graduating class in 1971 numbered 901, with a total count of approximately 3,100 Vikings in a three-year school. As enrollment continues to decline and the number of families in Santa Monica decreases, there can be no justification for this historic building’s demolition. The SAA will be happy to forward your email and snail-mail letters to the school board. Email your message to samohialumni@gmail.com or mail your letter of protest to Samohi Alumni Association, 601 Pico Boulevard, Santa Monica CA 90405. . . . . (Exhibit J, Viking News, p. 2, emphasis added.) Mr. Brock’s comments, purportedly endorsed by SAA’s “Board of Directors,” do not accurately reflect the reasons set forth by the parents, students, teachers, staff, architects, and the School Board who helped develop the plans for Phase III of the Samohi Campus Plan and/or made the decision to remove the History Building as part of this project. Mr. Brock does not make any effort to provide a balanced discussion of the merits of competing viewpoints and there is no evidence that Mr. Brock or the SAA Board of Directors offered to provide space in the Viking News for the school district (or others) to provide the other side of the discussion. In addition to these comments, SAA posted and promoted similar statements on its Facebook account. For example, on or about October 27, 2020, the “Samohi Alumni Association” restated the following (inaccurate) reasons it claimed formed the basis for the decision to demolish the History Building: “Samohi Alumni Association “The SMMUSD wants to demolish these historic buildings and rebuild the campus. They have listed three reasons for the campus make over. 1. High school kids cannot learn in a rectangular classroom. 2. The walls are too thick for the Internet to penetrate them. 3. Kids don’t like to walk up the stairs or hill. . . . . Item 16.A 11/15/22 157 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 505 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 11 “There is no reason to destroy these buildings. They are all structurally sound and have survived two major earthquakes over the past ½ century with no damage. There is pride in those solid buildings on campus. Preserve them. Oh, one more thing. The school district got a large measure approved but has not put the bonds on sale. A remodel, if needed, would save Santa Monica taxpayers thousands of dollars each for the next thirty years.” (Exhibit K.) In addition to this and several similar posts by SAA on its Facebook page, SAA permitted former school board candidate Esther Hickman to post dozens of comments containing similar misinformation, as well as a petition that she posted nearly a dozen times on this single SAA Facebook group, without any apparent oversight or intervention by SAA’s Facebook group administrator(s). 9 In addition, SAA sent “Action Alert” emails to thousands of Samohi alumni containing, in relevant part, the following proposed letter for them to send to the District opposing the Campus Plan: “…. “I am asking the board to halt to Samohi Phase 3 and all further construction plans until historic inventories have been completed at all campuses by a historic resources expert. The historic resources policy must include local criteria 1-6, and the requirement that a historic resources expert perform assessment adaptive reuse. “The remaining bond funds must be spent on the adaptive reuse of the historic Samohi buildings. All SMMUSD resources should be focused on getting students, teachers, and staff back to school safely instead of fast- tracking new development and using public funds to demolish history resources. “Save the History Building. Go Vikings!” (Exhibit L, emphasis added.) This SAA email was distributed within hours of similar messages which were posted extensively on local social media by former school board candidate Esther Hickman 9 https://www.facebook.com/samohialumni Item 16.A 11/15/22 158 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 506 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 12 and a close associate, Nikki Kolhoff. (Exhibit M.) Once again, no effort was made on behalf of SAA to provide a balanced discussion of the issues considered by the proponents of the Samohi Campus Plan and/or the adoption of a historical resources policy by the School Board. Finally, on May 19, 2021, the SAA Facebook page posted an article entitled “Goodbye Samohi” by Charles Andrews,10 a vocal proponent of the political recall campaign targeting members of the school board, urging Samohi alumni to read the article and “take action.” (Exhibit N.) In this article, Mr. Andrews repeated (false) accusations promulgated by the recall movement and specifically instructed his readers to take political action against the school board: . . . . “ Who’s doing this? Your School District (SMMUSD), its staff and your elected seven-member School Board. Half of whom now face the threat of recall, over this and a long list of other parent and community grievances, including mismanagement of huge amounts of funds, lack of transparency, communication and access, and disrespecting, marginalizing, bullying and retaliating against parents who speak out and disagree. “CAN WE STOP IT? “Many have been trying, since the District’s master construction plan and its History Building demolition became much more widely known last year. Can we avoid a messy and expensive recall, and keep those hard-working public servants on their board? Possibly, both. “Go to the School Board site to see how to call in and raise your voices at the Board meeting Thursday night. You have to put in early to get a turn, prior to the 5:30 public start. But to have any effect with a mostly intransigent Board, the numbers would have to be impressive. Hundreds. When news spread of the destructive master plan last fall, a group put up an online petition to save the History Building and got 6,000 signatures in a matter of days. Pooh. Your School Board and SMMUSD have ignored it. “How many of you are willing to make the effort to save yet another iconic piece of Santa Monica history? Because of the seemingly irrational fervor to 10 “Goodbye Samohi,” Charles Andrews, Santa Monica Daily Press, May 18, 2021 https://www.smdp.com/goodbye- samohi/205027?fbclid=IwAR3y8XkabAvzEUEp7kIrswuIWdHFMTZYdWqE6b4uFRc 60fzQ7XSMnQ8a0ko Item 16.A 11/15/22 159 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 507 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 13 build and overdevelop, both by the City and SMMUSD, there are not many of those touchstones left. Sadly, Santa Monicans are usually not willing to make that effort. But that is what it takes. Will you, this time? (A flood of emails would also be good — ALSO — to: brd@smmusd.org, which reaches every Board member.) . . . . ‘But here, indeed, is a rare chance for a local politico to claim that banner. We’re not asking much. It can be a win-win resolution. You will forever be known as the School Board Member Who Saved the History Building. And the big bonus could be… that your papers for recall might wind up in the trash instead of the county clerk’s desk.” (Exhibit O.) F. Issues Concerning SAA’s Political Activities and Partisan Propaganda a. Did SAA violate its Articles of Incorporation by engaging in political activities by publishing SAA President Phil Brock’s partisan comments in its official Viking News concerning three City Council candidates and one School Board candidate during the last election cycle? Did SAA violate any state or federal regulation or rule concerning partisan political activities by this nonprofit organization? b. Did SAA violate its Articles of Incorporation by promoting biased, misleading, and/or factually incorrect information, i.e., “carrying on propaganda,” concerning Phase III of the Samohi Campus Plan and the demolition of the History Building? Did SAA violate any state or federal regulation or rule concerning partisan political activities of this nonprofit organization? c. Did SAA violate its Articles of Incorporation by sending, in coordination with well-known partisan political activists, “urgent action” messages to thousands of Samohi alumni on its official SAA email list concerning Phase III of the Samohi Campus Plan and removal of the History Building ? Did SAA violate any state or federal regulation or rule concerning the political activities of this nonprofit organization? d. Did SAA violate its Articles of Incorporation by posting an article by vocal recall activist Charles Andrews on its official Facebook page, advising its alumni members to “read it” and “take action”? Did SAA violate any state or federal Item 16.A 11/15/22 160 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 508 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 14 regulation or rule concerning the political activities of this nonprofit tax-exempt organization by posting this article by a leading proponent of the recall campaign and advising its members take the political action set forth in the article? e. Notwithstanding its Articles of Incorporation, as a matter of public policy, should SAA, which receives office space, furniture, telephone and internet services at no costs on the grounds of our public high school, Samohi, engage in partisan political activities and/or partisan advocacy with respect to school-related issues, irrespective of viewpoint? f. Should SMMUSD include a provision in any lease agreement or memorandum of understanding with SAA for office space and/or the use of other Samohi resources and facilities prohibiting the organization from engaging in the promotion of partisan political activities and/or partisan activities, irrespective of viewpoint? We urge SMMUSD to commence an independent inquiry of the Samohi Alumni Association at your earliest convenience. Given SAA’s suspension by the Attorney General’s Office and the Secretary of State, its lack of good standing with the Franchise Tax Board, and its ongoing partisan political activities, this is an urgent matter that requires your immediate attention. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions and/or need additional information or documentation concerning these issues. Very truly yours, // Joseph A. Pertel // Joseph A. Pertel Attorney for SMIG Santa Monicans for Integrity in Government Item 16.A 11/15/22 161 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 509 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 15 CC: Samohi Alumni Association Office of Attorney General, Department of Justice, State of California, Registry of Charitable Trusts Office of the City Attorney, City of Santa Monica, Consumer Protection Division Santa Monica Malibu Unified School District, Board of Education Attachments: 15 Exhibits Item 16.A 11/15/22 162 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 510 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 163 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 511 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 164 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 512 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 165 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 513 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 166 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 514 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 167 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 515 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) Item 16.A 11/15/22 168 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 516 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins)) 1 Vernice Hankins From:Randall Klarin <rwklarin@yahoo.com> Sent:Tuesday, November 15, 2022 2:01 PM To:councilmtgitems Subject:Item 16A/Airport Commission EXTERNAL Please appoint Joe Pertel to the Airport Commission. Randall Klarin RW Klarin Item 16.A 11/15/22 169 of 169 Item 16.A 11/15/22 8.C.b Packet Pg. 517 Attachment: Written Comments_20221115 (5458 : Appointment: Disabilities, Airport, Personnel (10 mins))