Loading...
sr-020811-8aCity Council Meeting: February 8, 201 Agenda Item: ~~ To: Mayor and City Council From: Carol Swindell, Director of Finance Subject: Mid-Year 2010-11 Budget Recommended Action Staff recommends that City Council: 1) Appropriate Fiscal Year 2010-11 budget changes and adjust revenue budgets as detailed in Attachment A; 2) Adopt a Resolution establishing classification and salary rates for various positions detailed in Attachment B1; 3) Approve the position and classification changes detailed in Attachment 62; and 4) Approve Resolutions setting various fees in the Community and Cultural Services Department (Attachments C1, C2, and C3) and setting Animal Control fees (Attachment D1) Executive Summary This report provides two key financial reports, one on the close of FY09-10 and a status update of the FY2010-11 budget. Departments are proposing revisions to the current revenue and expenditure budgets based on mid-year budget reviews. In addition, position changes, most due to reorganizations, and salary adjustments. due to position changes and equity adjustments, are presented. Finally, the report transmits a new pricing policy for recreation programs and services, corresponding fee increases to be implemented in FY2011-12, and financial assistance guidelines to ensure that youth in the community have full access to these programs. Santa Monica's deficit reduction strategies have had a significant impact. The City closed the FY09-10 books with a positive fund balance, and projects to do so again in FY10-11. Staff recommends using one-time funds to pay down the City's pension liability to mitigate future contribution rates. Representatives from Finance are meeting with the CaIPERS actuary on February 7 to explore options to do this and will return to Council with specific recommendations and requests for action balance. Position changes include those related to the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department, adjustments to salary ranges, or position 1 reclassifications. Other changes include the addition of a limited term RDA funded community relations coordinator in the City Manager's office, positions in Finance to administer taxicab franchises (funded through franchise revenue), funds to support bicycle/sharrow education and the Buy Local campaign, and carrying forward Council contingency funds from the prior year. Adjustments have been made in the Special Revenue Fund, the Low/Moderate Housing Fund, the Earthquake. RDA Fund, and the Airport Fund. Details are provided in the various attachments. Background At the budget mid-point, staff identifies any one-time funds available for appropriation based on audited results from the prior year, reviews revenue receipts to date, recommends revenue budget changes and proposes adjustments in the budget expenditure projections, as necessary. This is also the opportunity to make position changes for reasons related ~ to things such as reorganizations, new service requirements, or .providing services in a more efficient manner. As Council was not provided with a FY2009-10 year-end update, a brief report is included below. Discussion General Fund Status Update - FY2009-10 Beginning in 2009, the City developed amulti-pronged approach of cost reductions, fee adjustments, employee negotiations, improved efficiencies, and limited use of one-time funds to address projected structural deficits over several years. These actions have borne fruit. At the close of FY2009-10, the audited undesignated General Fund balance was $7.9 million. This result can be credited to departments' careful management of expenditures and receipt of additional revenues of $4.7 million or 1.9% over projections. In January 2010, departments identified $3.3 million in projected FY2009-10 cost savings. By year-end, staff exceeded this target by an additional $4.3 million, or 1.8% of the total budget, saving a total of $7.6 million in FY2009-10. This result eliminated the need for the planned use of the economic uncertainty designation. 2 Since 2007, the City has prepaid its PERS contribution and has received a discount for doing so. This savings has been "banked" and the accumulated balance is now $6.3 million for the General Fund. Staff plans to meet with CaIPERS on February 7 to identify ways to use these one-time funds to pay down pension liabilities and reduce future contribution rates. A recommendation will be made to Council based on the outcome of that meeting. General Fund Status Update - FY2010-11 This positive trend continues in the current year. General Fund revenues are expected to exceed estimates by $6.7 million. In addition, the RDA is required make a loan repayment of $1.8 million to the General Fund. Expenditures are expected to be $0.2 million less than budget, and subsidies to other funds are projected to be $0.7 million less than budgeted. Partially offsetting these amounts is the expected setaside of $2.1 million in increased parking revenues from rate revisions for parking-related uses and $1.1 million in Measure Y funds for pass-through to the Santa Monica Malibu Unified School District. Due to the projected expenditure and revenue results, the planned release of $2.7 million of the economic uncertainty designation and $1.6 million in other designated fund balances (total of $4.3 million) is no longer required and a net operating surplus of $1.7 million is projected at the end of FY2010-11. This estimate does not include the impact of any potential additional budget savings by departments. General Fund FY 10/11 Projected Results ($ in millions) General Fund Estimated Ongoing Revenues: Estimated FY 10/11 Revenues $ 256.5 RDA Loan Repayment 1.8 258.3 General Fund Estimated Expenditures and Fund Subsidies: Operating Expenditures $ (241.3) Capital Project Expenditures (13.3) Subsidies to Other Funds (2.4) (257.0) Net FY 10/11 Revenues over Expenditures $ 1.3 Change in Operating and Capital Fund Balance Designation Increasing Available Fund Balance 0.4 Projected Surplus attune 30, 2011 $ 1.7 *Net of parking funds set aside for parking improvements in the downtown area. 3 Several revenue sources, such as parking revenue and Transient Occupancy Tax (TOT), are exceeding projections, while others are lagging. This year, a portion (one quarter's worth) of revenue from the new transaction and use tax (Measure Y) will be realized. Some revenues will be dedicated to specific uses. The .additional parking revenue realized from rate increases will fund. parking improvements in the downtown per Council's recommendation on Mav 11, 2010. Other than the transfer of funds between departments resulting from reorganizations, most of the requested Midyear expenditure changes relate to the reappropriation of prior year Council contingency funds and enhanced funding for the Buy Local Santa Monica campaign. FY2010-11 General Fund Revenue Adjustments. and Changes from Adopted Budget Revenue Increases $ Change % Change Transactions and Use Tax 2,180,000 N/A Transient Occupancy Tax 2,694,000 9.1% Real Property Transfer Tax 300,000 9.4% Parking Facility Taxes 900,000 11.1% Various Parking Related Revenues 3,738,615 10.8% Other 100,000 9, 912, 615 Revenue Decreases Property Tax (859,255) (2.5%) Sales and Use Tax (395,000) (1.4%) Utility Users Tax (874,000) (2,7%) Business License Taxes (300,000) (1.0%) Investment Income (581,000) (16.1%) Other (199, 897) (3,209,152) Net Revenue Increase / (Decrease) 6,703,463 2.7% 4 General Fund Mid-Year Recommendations Attachment A details proposed budget actions for FY2010-11 to adjust accounts to reflect the status at the midpoint in the fiscal year. Below are summaries of proposed revenue, expenditure, and balance sheet actions Revenue Adjustments -General Fund Revenues are expected to exceed annual budget projections by approximately $6.7 million, due in large part to increases in transient occupancy tax and structure attendant parking rate increases, TOT, and the new transaction and use tax. Revenue sources recommended for adjustment are identified in Attachment A. Expenditure Adjustments -General Fund Net appropriations for the General Fund decrease by $216,828 at Mid-Year. This includes the elimination of the Community Maintenance Department, the addition of a limited term RDA funded community relations coordinator in the City Manager's office, positions in Finance to administer taxicab franchises (funded through franchise revenue), funds to support bicycle/sharrow education and the Buy Local campaign, and carrying forward Council contingency funds from the prior year. Equity adjustments, which occur when a salary range for a classification is adjusted to be more competitive within the labor market or a position is reclassified to a higher level based on a comprehensive assessment, and savings from revised medical costs and employee medical contributions, are also reflected. The proposed appropriation changes and amounts are detailed in Attachment A. Revenue Adjustments -Other Funds Other fund revenue adjustments include: • Decreases in tax increment revenue of $1.8 million in the Earthquake RDA, and $0.2 million in the Ocean Park RDA reflecting lower thah anticipated assessed values in those project areas. • Tax increment in the Downtown RDA is increased by $0.9 million as a result of the increase in project area assessed value reflecting the impact of the reopening of Santa Monica Place. 5 • The Low/Moderate Income Housing fund revenues will decrease by $298,045 to reflect the net impact on the housing set-aside as a result of the changed tax increment projections. • The Beach Fund has a reduction of $0.4 million due to lower than expected beach parking revenues. • Miscellaneous grants revenue will increase by a net of $1.6 million, reflecting 'new grants, changes to existing grants, and timing changes in the receipt of grant revenues. • Airport revenues are adjusted downward by $0.4 million as a result of lower than expected landing fees and office/shop rentals. • The Cemetery Fund revenues will decrease by $2.4 million .due to less than anticipated lot; mausoleum, and miscellaneous sales and a delay in the implementation of mortuary services. • The Big Blue Bus revenues increase by $2.8 million to reflect the impact of the fare increase as well as increases in other revenue sources. Revenue sources recommended for adjustment are identified in Attachmeht A. .Expenditure Adjustments -Other Funds Proposed appropriations at Mid-Year in all non-General Fund funds total $0.9 million. Included in the request are the following • $1.4 million in additional Prop 1B grant funding in the Special Revenue Source Fund to be used for the Ocean Park Blvd. Complete Green Street Project An increase of $0:6 million in the Airport fund for professional services related to airport visioning activities • A reduction of $3.8 million in the Low/Moderate Housing fund due to an adjustment in the payment schedule for the housing line of credit as principal payments will not commence this year • A decrease of $1.8 million in pass through payments to other agencies reflecting lower tax increment revenues • An increase in transfer to General Fund for positions previously funded by the RDA CIP • A Percent for the Arts funding increase reflects an adjustment to bring funding to legally required levels for eligible projects • The Wastewater Fund is proposed to increase by $0.5 million for additional CIP program funding 6 The majority of the changes to. other funds reflect the impact of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department which folded those operations into Community .and Cultural Services and Public Works. The proposed appropriation changes and amounts are identified ih Attachment A. Community and Cultural Services Fees As part of the City's multi-pronged strategy to address the projected General Fund budget gap between spending and revenues over the next five years, the Department of Community and Cultural Services used the results of the city-wide Cost Recovery Study to develop a consistent and equitable pricing policy specifically for its recreation programs and permit services, and to develop specific fee recommendations, which are proposed to be implemented ih FY2011-12. The proposed .Pricing Policy is to be used as a guide in establishing user fees for .current and future Department recreation programs and permit services. Historically, the Department has instituted new fees and fee increases based primarily on market pricing with comparable programs, escalators to keep pace with inflation and the availability of financial assistance for eligible participants to ensure access commuhity- wide. Each year, specific fee increase proposals were introduced in the City's Proposed Budget and acted upon by the City Council. This proposed Pricing Policy is designed to build a clearer and more consistent rationale for cost recovery, resulting in continued General. Fund support while generating increased user fee revenue where justified to ensure the ongoing sustainability and resiliency of these important community-serving programs. The proposed Pricing Policy uses a community benefits continuum as a framework to determine a desired cost recovery rate for each overall program or service and then uses pricing indicators to assess when an increased fee may be warranted for activities within the program or service. The fees were also compared to similar fees in other jurisdictions. The proposed fee increases would generate approximately $350,000 annually in new revenues representing an increase of approximately 9%. Of the thirty- 7 three programs and services provided by the Department and evaluated using the new Pricing Policy, eighteen are being proposed for fee increases. Of those, seven have activities with increases that solely. capture cost-of-living increases that have not been applied in prior years. In addition, four new fees are being proposed including a lawn bowling green maintenance fee, an administrative fee for processing category one community events, a private coaching fee in the gym and a lane fee for non-resident swim team organizations using the Swim Center 2,000 hours a year or more. A summary of the proposed fee revisions by program category is provided below: Program Current Cost Recove Rate Proposed Cost Recove Rate Estimated Additiohal Revenue Adult Sports Leagues 61% 64% $12,500 Aquatics 35% 38% $104,200 Community Events - Application & Administrative Fees 4% 8% $18,000 Community Events- Neighborhood Notification 38% 61% $3,200 Community Gardens 7% 9% $2,000 Community Meeting Rooms 24% 36% $60,500 CREST - Camp Santa Monica 11 % 12% $4,700 CREST Childcare 21% 24% .$42,600 CREST Enrichment 48% 53% $23,300 CREST -School Break Sports Camps 23% 25% $5,500 CREST Youth Sports Lea ues -Elementary 21% 26% $31,700 CREST Youth Sports Lea ues -Middle Sch 13% 16% $15,000 Lawn Bowling Permits 0% 26% $1,600 Memorial Park Gym 10% 13% $12,700 Miles Playhouse 5% 6% $4,000 Outdoor Permits 24% 25% $200 Rosie's Girls 21% 23% $2,500 Sports Field Permits 35% 37% $6,000 8 In proposing new and increased fees, the Department was sensitive to the fact that the economic climate may be negatively affecting some Santa Monica youth. To ensure continued full access to the Department's youth programs, the City will continue to provide a very generous financial assistance program for Santa Monica resident youth and for non-resident youth attending public school in Santa Monica and participating in school-based programs. The City's financial assistance income eligibility scale exceeds typical federal and state guidelines thereby allowing more people to qualify. For instance, a family of four can qualify with an income of up to $65,000 annually. The financial assistance program currently-serves approximately 1,100 youth with nearly $940,000 annually in foregone revenue. Qualified youth are not turned away, however financial assistance awards are subject to a $300 cap per child, per calendar quarter for recreational programs. Childcare programs are not subject to the cap. Further details,on the Pricing Philosophy, methodology used, program descriptions and corresponding fee calculations for each program or permitting service, and the City's financial assistance guidelines are provided in the following attachments: Attachment C4: Proposed Pricing Policy for Recreation Programs and Permit Services Attachment C5: Summary Chart of Benefit Levels, Cost Recovery Rates and Proposed Fee Rates Attachment C6: Detail of Proposed Fee Increases Attachment C7: Financial Assistance Guidelines and Procedures Recreation and Parks Commission Recommendations The proposed pricing policy was brought before the Commission on December 16, 2010 and January 20, 2011, and after broad noticing of impacted users, the specific fee increases were also brought before the Commission on January 20, 2011. The Commission received public input at the January meeting. Relevant fee proposals were also discussed at meetings of the Commission's Sports Advisory Council and Community Gardens Advisory Committee. 9 In response to comments made by the Recreation and Parks Commission in December regarding the Pricing Policy, several clarifications were made. In January, the Commission indicated that they appreciated the clarifying changes staff made to the Pricing Policy and found it to be a clear document. They had no other comments on the policy. Public comment focused on the new fee category in the Aquatics Program for regional swim teams and the- elimination of the non-profit resident rate for meeting rooms. No public comment was received on any of the other fee increases. Regarding the proposed fees, the Commission recommended that the fee changes be limited to the four new proposed fees: 1) use of the Lawn Bowling Green at Douglas Park 2) a coaching fee for use of Memorial Park Gymnasium 3) a lane fee for non-resident swim teams using the Swim Center 2,000 hours a year or more, and 4) an administrative fee for processing category 1 community event applications. The Commission also recommended that the City Council look at event fees and new revenue streams; including personal training and film permit-fees in our parks, and that non-resident fees be increased to market rates for Los Angeles County. Based on this input, staff modified the fee proposal for park building meeting rooms to reduce the impact on Santa Monica non-profit organizations. The original staff proposal for park building meeting rooms eliminated non-profit rates and offered one rate for all residents. However, staff is now proposing the inclusion of a park building meeting room discount of 50% for Santa Monica based non-profit organizations that have at least 50% Santa Monica residents. The revised community meeting room fee increases will still significantly address an annual structural deficit of approximately $90,000 for facility staffing, which in past years could be met with salary savings. However, due to budget reductions, these savings no longer exist. Fortunately, one-time savings were able to be utilized this fiscal year to handle the shortage, however this cannot be sustained. The proposed additional revenue must be raised in order to avoid significant reductions in 10 the hours meeting rooms are available to the public. Staff will continue to consider the additional Commission recommendations for future years including additional increases to non-resident rates and identifying new revenue streams to support programs and services. Animal Control Fees In keeping with the policy of conducting fee studies at periodic intervals, the Police Department conducted a study of animal control fees for animal licenses and pound fees to ensure that the fees recover an appropriate level of cost recovery. Staff recommends that the fees be updated to keep the cost recovery level at approximately the same percentage (25%) as when they-were last updated approximately five years ago. Fee recommendations are attached shown on Attachment D1 and D2. Other Police Department fees were studies last fiscal year, so no changes are proposed. Financial Impacts & Budget Actions The budget impact of adoption of the mid-year changes are detailed in Attachment A of this report. Prepared by: David Carr, Budget Administrator Approved: Forwarded to Council: e Carol Swindell d Gould Director of Finance City Manager Attachments: A: Proposed FY2010-11 Mid-Year Revenue, Expenditure and Balance Sheei Changes B1: Resolution Establishing New Classification and Adopting Salary Rates for Certain Positions B2: Position and Classification Changes 11 C1: Resolution Setting the Amount of Fees to be Charged for the Use of Community and Recreational Facilities Operated by the Community and Cultural Services Department and for the Use of Beach Parking Lots, and a Definition of Facility User Categories C1a: Facility Fees Resolution - Exhibits A to F C1b: Facility Fees Resolution -Exhibit G C2: Resolution Establishing User Fees for Social Service, Recreation and Community Programs, Classes and Services of the Department of Community and Cultural Services C3 Resolution Establishing Application Fees, Administrative Fees, and Neighborhood Notification Fees for Community Events C4: Proposed Pricing Policy for Recreation and Programs and Permit Services C5: Benefit Levels and Cost Recovery Rates Summary C6: Council Fee Increase Proposal C7: Financial Assistance Guidelines D1: Resolution Establishing Fees for Animal Control Services D2: Animal Control Services Fee Resolution -Fee Listing 12 PROPOSED FY2010-11 REVENUE, APPROPRIATION, AND BALANCE SHEET CHANGES I. REVENUE ADJUSTMENTS Fund - Deparfinent/Division General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business andRevenue Operations General (Ot) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (01) Finance/Business and Revenue Operations General (Ot) Planning and Community Development /City Planning / Development Review General (Ot) Public Works/Administration General (Ot) Fire/Administration TOTAL GENERAL (01) FUND: Amount Reason ATTACHMENT A ($874,000) To reflect a decrease in Utility Users Taxes primarily due to lower taxes from telephone services. ($395,000) To reflect less than anticipated Sales Taxes. $2,180,000 To reflect expected first quarter receipts from new voter-approved transactions and use tax (Measure Y). ($859,255p To reflect decreases. in most property tax categories reflecting an unexpected decrease in assessed valuation in the City. ($300,000) Decreased Business License Taxes reflecting the lagging effects of the economic downturn. $2,694,000 Increased Transient Occupancy Tax revenues reflecting a stronger than anticipated recovery in tourism. $300,000 Increased Real Property Transfer Taxes, primarily due to the sale of several large properties. $900,000 - To reflect greater than anticipated parking facility tax revenues. ($581,000) To reflect decreased in investment income reflecting the record low interest rate environment. $3,738,615 To reflect increases in structure attendant parking and structure permits, primarily due to rate increases. ($40,960) To reflect a revenue decrease in Planning Presubmittal Review Revenue due to significant drop in volume following the implementation of the fee in September 2010. $100,000 To reflect revenue from newly offered Lit services. ($158,937) To reflect delayed implementation of Traffic Accident Haz-mat Recovery program and less than anticipated revenues from the new fee charged to skilled nursing homes for emergency responses. $6,703,463 A-1 PROPOSED FY2010-11 REVENUE, APPROPRIATION, AND BALANCE SHEET CHANGES Fund DeoartmentfDivision Beach Recreation (11) Community and Cultural Services/Open Space Management-Beach Administration LowlModerate Income Housing and Economic Housing (15) DevelopmenUHousing Downtown RDA (16) Housing and Economic DevelopmenUAdministration and Redevelopment Earthquake RDA (17) Housing and Economic DevelopmenUAdministration and Redevelopment Ocean Park RDA (18) Housing and Economic DevelopmenUAdministration and Redevelopment Miscellaneous Grants Various (20) Resource Recovery and Recycling (27) Fund Public Works/ Resource Recovery and Recycling Airport (33) Fund Cemetery (37) Fund City Manager/Airport Amount Reason ATTACHMENT A $3( 89,873) To reflect less than anticipated beach parking revenues. $2( 98,045) Less than anticipated housing setaside revenues from the Earthquake rewvery and Ocean Park project areas, partially offset by greater setaside revenues from the Downtown project area due to the reopening of Santa Monica Place. $867,000 Greater tax increment revenues due to the reopening of Santa Monica Place. $1,8( os,ooo) Less than anticipated tax increment revenues reflecting declining assessed values $1( 79,000) Less than anticipated tax increment revenues reflecting declining assessed values $1,588,151 To reflect a net increase in grant revenues reflecting new grants, changes to existing grants, and timing changes in the receipt of grant revenues. $69,550) Td reflect less from public use of the transfer station and less recycling lease rentals, partially offset by greater City use of the transfer station $3( 47,916) to reflect less than anticipated landing fees and office/shop rentals. Public Works/Cemetery $2,396,340) To reflect less than anticipated lot, mausoleum, and miscellaneous sales and a delay in the implementation of mortuary services. Big Blue Bus (41) Fund Big Blue Bus/Transit Programs Totat All Funds: $2,761,191 To reflect fate increases ($1,634,423) and a net increase of $1,126,768 in revenue from various other sources. $6,431,081 A-2 PROPOSED FY2010-11 REVENUE, APPROPRIATION, AND BALANCE SHEET CHANGES II. APPROPRIATION ADJUSTMENTS ATTACHMENT A Fund DeoartmenUDivision Amount Reason General (D1) City Council $147,738 To reflect an appropriation of unspent contingency funds from FY2009-10. General (01) City Manager's Office $56,792 To reflect the addition df a limited term RDA funded 1.0 FTE Community Relations Coordinator. General (01) Finance $181,436 To reflect the addition of 1.0 FTE Treasury Supervisor, 1.0 FTE Taxi Franchise Program Coordinator, 1.0 FTE Admin.Staff Assistant and other additional position changes. These costs will be offset by taxicab franchise fees. General (01) Human Resources $1,564 To reflect a minor salary and wages equity adjustment. General (01) Planning and Community $17,295 Adjustment reflects the appropriation df funds Development to support bicycle and sharroweducation and outreach approved by City Council and minor salary and wages equity readjustment. General (01) Police ($2,037) To reflect salary and wages adjustment from position changes. General (Ot) Community Maintenance ($27,108,261) Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. General (01) Community and Cultural Services $11,771,412 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department and other program adjustments. General (01) Public Works $15,359,757 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department and other program adjustments. General (01) Housing and Economic $62,400 Changes reflect decreased grant funding. Development offset by a replenishment of funds for the Buy Local Santa Monica campaign approved by City Council. General (01) Non-Departmental/ Interfund ($704,924) Reflects savings resulting from revised Transactions medical costs and employee contributions to medical for the second half of FY2010-11. Total General (01) Special Revenue Fund Capital Improvement Program (04) Beach Fund (11) Beach Fund (11) Community Maintenance CommuniTy and Cultural Services Total Beach (11) ($216,828) 51.354.680 Reflects additional Prop 1B grant funding. ($2,675,799) Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. $2,738,664 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department and other program adjustments. A-3 ATTACHMENT A PROPOSED FY2010-17 REVENUE, APPROPRIATION, AND BALANCE SHEET CHANGES Fund DeoartmenUDivision Amount Reason Low/Moderate Income Non-Departmental/All Others (53.783.3331 Reflects a decrease due to a delay in Housing (15) Principal repayment for Line of Credit. Downtown RDA (16) Earthquake RDA (17) Earthquake RDA (17) Total Earthquake RDA (17) Miscellaneous Grants (20) . Miscellaneous Grants (20) Miscellaneous Grants (20) Miscellaneous Grants (20) Non-Departmental/All Others Reflects increased Tax Increments due to the opening of Santa Monica Place. Non-Departmental/All Others $1,441,254 Reflects a decrease in Tax Increment payments to other agencies and an increase _ in transfer to General Fund for positions previously funded by CIP. Community and Economic $335,200 Reflects an increase in the share of eligible Development Capital CIP projects. ImprovemenUPercentfnr the Arts 51.776.454 - Library Community Maintenance Community and Cultural Services Public Works Miscellaneous Grants Capital Improvement Program (20) Total Miscellaneous Grants (20) $5,000 Reflects additional grant funds for the Library. ($260,550) Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department $62,300 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. $198,250 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. $179,575 Reflects additional grant funds for Capital 5184.575 Improvement Projects. Beach House Fund (24) Community Maintenance ($1,598,045) Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Beach House Fund (24) Public Works $1,598,045 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Total Beach House - $0 Fund (24) Pier Fund (30) Community Maintenance ($1,926,280) Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Pier Fund (30) Public Works $1,926,280 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Total Pier Fund (30) $Q Wastewater Fund (31) Capital Improvement $500.000OOQ Reflects additional program funding. A~ PROPOSED FY2010-11 REVENUE, APPROPRIATION, AND BALANCE SHEET CHANGES ATTACHMENT A Fund Deoartment/Division Amount Reason Airport Fund (33) Community Maintenance ($713,638) Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Airport Fund (33) Public Works - $713,638 Changes are a result of the reorganization that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Airport Fund (33) City Manager's Office/Airport $600,000 Reflects an increase in professional services agreements related to airport visioning process. Total Airport Fund (33) $y$ Big Blue Bus (41) Big Blue Bus ($55.206) Reflects a decrease in the grant amount of Local Return approved by Metro. Vehicle Management Community Maintenance ($5,778,327) Changes are a result of the reorganization Fund (54) that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Vehicle Management Public Works $5,778,327 Changes are a result of the reorganization Fund (54) that eliminated the Community Maintenance Department. Tofial Vehicle Management (54) ~ Workers Compensation Finance/Risk Management (59) 586.989 Reflects the addition of 0.5 FTE Administrative Staff Assistant and 1.3 FTE Staff Assistant II that will be focused on reducing workers compensation costs. Total All Funds: III. BALANCE SHEET CHANGES General (01) Balance Sheet Transfer- in Special Revenue Fund Balance Sheet Transfer - in (04) $657,546 $25,000 Reflects release of designation for bicycle outreach program funding. $65,000 Reflects release of designation for GLOW festival funding. A-5 ATTACHMENT C4 PROPOSED PRICING POLICY FOR RECREATION PROGRAMS AND PERMIT SERVICES CITY OF SANTA MONICA COMMUNITY & CULTURAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT C4-1 COMMUNITY AND CULTURAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT PROPOSED PRICING POLICY FOR RECREATION PROGRAMS AND PERMIT SERVICES Santa Non4m° This Pricing Policy is to be used as a guide. in establishing user fees for current and future Department recreation programs and permit services. Historically, the Department has instituted new fees and fee increases based primarily on market pricing uvith comparable programs, escalators to keep pace with inflation and the availability of financial assistance for eligible participants to ensure access community-wide. Each year, specific fee increase proposals were introduced in the City's Proposed Budget and acted upon by the City Council.. This proposed Pricing Policy is designed to build a clearer and more consistent rationale for cost recovery, resulting in continued General Fund support while generating increased user fee revenue where justified to ensure the ongoing sustainability and resiliency of these important community-serving programs. THE FRAMEWORK: THE COMMUNITY BENEFITS CONTINUUM The Community Benefit Continuum -Recreation Programs. The Department of Community and Cultural Services provides an array of recreation programs. In order to determine the extent to which these programs should be sustained by the City's General Fund versus user fees, a "community benefit continuum" has been developed to assist in categorizing these programs and establishing the appropriate levels of financial support. For this purpose, "community" relates to the residents of Santa Monica. This continuum. contains four benefit categories: broad community benefit, targeted community benefit, core community benefit, and individual benefit. • Broad community benefit is at one end of the continuum and applies to programs where users have unstructured, open access to specified recreational areas. As such, significant support from General Fund tax dollars to cover the costs of delivering this access is justified. Examples of programs include the Playground Partnership and Playground Access. • Targeted community benefit applies to programs that serve targeted populations with special needs including low income families, seniors, at-risk youth and people with disabilities. These programs receive significant General Fund support with little or no fees in order to ensure active participation by these groups who otherwise might not have access. Examples of programs include the Senior Recreation Center, PAL, Virginia Avenue Park, and adaptive recreation programs such as "Santa Monica Adaptive Recreation and Sports" (SMARS). • Core community. benefit programs address a community priority historically identified by the City Council during the annual budget process as a core program area that should receive funding priority. In the case of recreation programs, these core areas include Youth, and Recreation and Active Living. C4-1 • Because these areas have been identified by the City Council as funding priorities, the programs receive significant General Fund support along with moderate .user fees to help cover the operating costs. Examples of programs include "Childcare, Recreation, Enrichment, Sports, Together" (CREST), Adult Sports, Aquatics and The Cove, Santa Monica Skatepark. • Individual benefit is on the far end of the continuum, and applies to programs that do not primarily serve members of a targeted population or meet a core community priority as identified by the City Council but provide a high level of individual benefit. These programs result in positive individual benefits from participation, and therefore user fees should cover most, if not all, of the operating costs. Examples include instructional programs that focus on individual skill development or social activities such as Community Classes. Direct service programs offered by the Community Recreation and Human Services Divisions are categorized into each of the four benefit categories based on the extent to which the programs meet the benefit category definitions. Categorizing Recreation Programs. To aid in the categorizing of recreation programs by benefit level, criteria with a ranking system have been established. These benefits criteria take into consideration factors as noted below. By developing rankings of 10 = mostly true; 5 =somewhat true and 0 =mostly false, use of the criteria results in an average ranking for each program. This ranking is conducted by an interdivisional group of program staff from the Department that are knowledgeable about the programs being categorized Rankings have been based on the benefits criteria as follows: • The program allows open access (drop-in) • The program meets the Recreation and Active Living Community Priority historically approved by the City Council • The program meets the Youth Community Priority historically approved by the City Council • The program primarily serves low income residents • The program primarily serves at-risk youth, people with disabilities or seniors • There is a high demand for the program/service. It consistently fills or is at or above 80% capacity • Similar opportunities are not available in the local private sector or neighboring cities. • The program primarily does not provide individual instruction/curriculum Using the average ranking for each recreation program, the program is then matched to the appropriate community benefit level, with the highest ranked indicating broad community benefit and the lowest indicating individual benefit as follows: C4-2 Averaoe Rankino Community Benefit Level 7 to 10 Broad Community Benefit 7 to 10 Targeted Community Benefit 4.1 to 6.9 Core Community Benefit 1 to 4 Individual Benefit The Community Benefit Continuum -Permit Service. The Community and Cultural Services Department not only provides recreational programs but also issues permits for the use of the parks, beaches, open spaces and facilities to individuals, schools and organized user groups. Permit services are also categorized and placed on a "community benefit continuum" of three benefit levels. The benefit level criteria are as follows: • Open community access: Permits issued are for recreational, cultural, or social services activities that allow open access to the public. • Limited community access: Permits issued are for recreational, cultural or social services activities requiring membership, admission or registration fees to participate. (i.e. field permits, meeting rooms, Miles Playhouse, community events, lawn bowling) Private access: Permits issued are for a private use (i.e. film permits, community gardens, surf permits) Various categories of permits .are available, i.e., field permits, meeting room permits, surf permits. Individual permits issued within these various categories may align with different benefit levels however an overall benefit level is assigned to each permit category. If 67% or more of permits issued annually within a category align with a specific benefrt level, than that benefit level is assigned to the permit category. If the permits issued result in less than 67% alignment with each of the benefit levels, then the benefit level assigned to that permit category is limited community access. ALIGNING COST RECOVERY RATES WITH COMMUNITY BENEFIT LEVELS Establishing Cost Recovery Rates. Cost recovery rates for each program or permit service are calculated based on the total annual delivery cost compared to the amount of revenue realized for that program or service for the year. Total annual delivery costs generally include direct staffing costs, supplies and expenses, custodial services, department and divisional administrative costs as well as a factor for overhead costs for support services received from internal departments. Cost Recovery Ranges. The community benefits continuum also assigns "cost recovery ranges" to each category in order to assist in establishing equitable user fees for the program and services within the benefit categories. These ranges are based on the premise that those programs and services with greater community benefit should receive more General Fund support and thus have lower "cost recovery rates" C4-3 generated from user fees. Conversely, those programs and services that result in the highest individual benefit should rely less on the General Fund for support and thus have a higher "cost recovery rate" supported by user fees. Stated in ranges for each benefit level, these cost recovery rates (or the percentage that user fees and other revenue contribute to the overall delivery cost of the program) are as follows: Recreation Programs: Community Benefit Level Broad Community Benefit Targeted Community Benefit Core Community Benefit Individual Benefit Cost Recovery Ranoe 0% 0% -25% 26% -75% 76% -100% Permit Services: Community Benefit Level Open Community Access Limited Community Access Private Access Cost Recovery Range 0% - 25% 26% - 75% 76% - 100% PRICING INDICATORS AND ESTABLISHING FEES The current fee of each activity within a program or fee within a permit service is then reviewed to determine the extent to which it is aligned with a number of pricing indicators. Instituting a new fee or increasing a fee may be warranted when: • The program or permit service does not fall within the appropriate cost recovery range • Fees are "under market" and are below those charged by comparable cities and/or service providers • Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price Index and/or other escalators have not kept up with the cost increases • The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been increased in many years. • Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use which would result in decreased overall revenue • Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users • Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Specific non-resident fees may be instituted or increased when: • Demand for the activity or permit exceeds capacity • Verifying residency is practical and cost effective • A high percentage of participants are non-residents • Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service C4-4 Annual cost escalators are to be used where appropriate to aid in addressing cost increases. Fees should be reviewed during budget cycles and adjusted as appropriate based on the pricing indicators, factoring in the desired cost recovery ranges. In cases where a program or services is significantly out of line with its cost recovery range, multi-year strategies should be considered. C4-5 Benefit Levels and Cost Recovery Rates Summary Cost Recovery Levels: RECREATION PROGRAMS Attachment C5 1i24i2D11 0% Broad Community Benefit Programs where participants have open access to specified recreational areas. As such, significant support from General Fund tax dollars to cover the costs of delivering this access is justified. 0% - 2S% Targeted Community Benefit Programs that serve targeted populations with special needs including low income families,- seniors, ~at-risk youth and people with disabilities. These programs receive significant General Fund support with little or no fees in order to ensure active participation by these rou s who otherwise mi ht not have access. 26% - 75% Core CommunityBenefit Programs that meet a community priority area as historically identified by the City Council as a core community priority, i.e., Youth, Recreation and Active Living. Because these areas have been identified by the City Council as funding priorities, the programs receive significant General Fund support along with moderate user fees to help cover the operating costs. 76% -100% Individual Benefit Programs that do not primarily serve members of a targeted population or meet a core community priority, as identified by the City Council but provide a high level of individual benefit. These programs result in positive individual benefits from participation, and therefore user fees should cover most, if not all, of the o eratin costs. PROPOSED CURRENT NET NEW TOTAL PROGRAMS BENEFIT CURRENT COST -COST PRICING INDICATORS PROPOSED BUDGETED REVFROM ~ REVENUE LEVEL RECOVERY RATE RECOVERY USED REVENUE aera w ~ ~ H v REVENUE BUDGET INCREASE Dund Partnership Broad 0% $ _ Playground Access Broad 0% $ _ Activities League' Targeted 1% $ 14,000 a Avenue Park' Targeted 0% $ 5,500 Programst Targeted 1% $ 5,500 aptive Recreation & Sports (SMARS)~ Targeted 8% S 21 5nn The Cove, Santa Monica Skate Park Core 7% $ 18,577 Airport Drop-in Soccer Community Classesa'° Core 27% Individual 94% ~ ~ $ $ 5,000 976 231 SUB-TOTAL NEW REVENUE $ 254,499 F:\BUdget\Share\MID-TERM BUDGET\MY2010-11\Staff Report and Exhibits\Attachment CS-Benefit and Cost Recovery.xlsx CS-], Cost Recovery Levels: PERMIT SERVICES 0 - 25% Open Community Access Permits issued are for recreational, cultural, or social services opportunities with open access to the public 26% - 75% Limited Community Access Permits issued are for recreational, cultural, or social services opportunities requiring membership, admission, or registration fees to artici ate (i.e. field ermits, meetin rooms, Miles Pla house, communit events) 76% - 100% Private Access Permits issued are for a private use (i.e. film permits, community gardens, surf permits) Various categories of permits are available, i.e., field permits, meeting room permits, surf permits. Individual permits issued within these various categories may align with different benefit levels however an overall benefit level is assigned to each permit category. If 67~ or more of permits issued annually within a category align with a specific benefit level, than that benefit level is assigned to the permit category. If the permits issued result in less than 67% aligriment with each of the benefit levels, then the benefit level assigned to that permit category is limited community access. PROPOSED CURRENT VARIANCE TOTAL PERMITS BENEFIT CURRENT COST COST PRICING INDICATORS PROPOSED BUDGETED FROM REVENUE LEVEL RECOVERY RATE RECOVERY USED REVENUE on>•c cv n r~o REVENUE BUDGET INCREASE Concession Stands" Limited 56% $ 5,058 SportsStoragea Limited 30% S 6.879 Limited 54% Surt Permits Private SS% $ 32,022 Beach Filming Permit' Private 147% Fees to be evaluated with City-wide filming $ 63,550 Park Filming Permita Private 14% fee assessment-Public Works $ 4,300 SUB-TOTAL NEW REVENUE $ 95,567 NOTES: TOTAL NEW REVENUE -Programs and Permits $ 350,066 S.9% 1. Revenue totals include Proposition A Transportation funds in addition to user fees, if any. 2. Cost recovery rates do not include Public Works costs for any programs or service permits. These costs may be especially significant for aquatics. The cost recovery rate indicated may be significantly lower if these costs were applied. 3. Cost recovery rates do not include Public Landscape/Beach Maintenance costs with the exception of Lawn Bowling Green and Playground Partnership. These costs may be significant for community classes, adults sports leagues, outdoor courts and field permits. The recovery. rates indicated may be significantly lower if these costs were applied. 4. Community Classes rates are established by negotiation with contracted instructors, rather than fees established by City Council. 5. Tennis Reservations applies to public use of Reed Park courts, and Ocean View courts on weekends and summer weekdays, plus permits for private instructors, schools and tennis organizations. Free first-come-first-served use of tennis courts is available at Memorial, Douglas, Clover, Marine and Los Amigos Parks. F:\BUdget\Share\MID-TERM BUDGET\MY2010-11\Staff Report and Exhibits\Attachment CS -Benefit and Cost Recovery.xlsx CS-2 PRICING INDICATORS -PROGRAM ACTIVITIES AND PERMITS Fees should be imposed or increased when: CODE DESCRIPTION A Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery level B Fees are "under. market" and are below those charged by comparable cities and/or service providers C Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price Index ahd/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases D The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years E Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue F Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users G Financial Assistance is available H The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Non-resident fees should be imposed or increased when: CODE DESCRIPTION I Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity J Verifying residency is practical and cost effective K A high percentage of participants are non-residents L Instituting or increasing the fee is not expced to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service F:\BUdget\Share\MID-TERM BUDGET\MY2010-11\Staff Report and Exhibits\Attachment CS -Benefit and Cost Recovery.xlsx C5-3 ATTACHMENT C6 RECREATION PROGRAMS AND PERMIT SERVICES PROPOSED FEE INCREASES FY 11/12 1/24/11 CITY OF SANTA MONICA COMMUNITY & CULTURAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT COMMUNITY & CULTURAL SERVICES PROPOSED RECREATION PROGRAMS AND PERMIT SERVICES FEE INCREASES FY 11/12 Table of Contents Recreation Programs Aquatics ..................................................................................... Memorial Park Gym ................................................................... CREST Childcare ..................:...................................................... CREST Enrichment Classes ......................................................... CREST Youth Sports Leagues .......................................................... CREST Camp Santa Monica ............................................................. CREST Santa Monica Sport Experience .........................................:. Rosie's Girls Camp .......................................................................... Adult Sports Leagues ...................................................................... Permit Services C6-1 ............:............................... C6-5 ............................................ C6-8 ...................:...................... C6-10 .......................................... C6-12 ............................................. C6-14 .......................:..................... C6-16 ............................................. C6-18 ............................................. C6-20 Miles Memorial Playhouse .................................................:.................. ............................................ C6-22 Community Meeting Rooms .................................................................. ............................................ C6-24 Sports Fields ..........................:............................................................... ............................................ C6-27 Outdoor Permits .............:...................................................................... .......:...................................: C6-30 Community Events ................................................................................ ............................................ C6-32 Community Events Neighbor Notification ............................................ ............................................ C6-35 Lawn Bowling Green .............................................................................. ............................................ C6-37 Community Gardens .............................................................................. ............................................ C6-39 PROGRAM: AQUATICS Description: The Santa Monica Swim Center provides recreational swimming, classes, other programming and permitting of pool lanes to swim organizations. The facility has been growing in popularity since it opened in 2002. Santa Monica residents have priority class registration and are charged Idwerfeesthan non-residents. Total Participants: City Program -youth 37,306, others 111,553 (# of class registrations & drop-in enhances) Permit Groups-approximately 15 different groups Community Benefit level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 35% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 38% Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imposed or Indicator used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imposed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market" and are below those charged by ~ Verifying residency is practical and cost effective comparable cfties and/or service providers Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permR service warrants a fee and a fee has not ~ Instituting or increasing thefee is not expectedto result in an existed before or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service ^ Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease I I participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higherfees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users ~X Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: A recent survey of fees in surrounding communities found that, on average, Santa Monica has some of the lowest fees for recreational swim, swim lessons and adult fitness classes. Staff is proposing fee increases that take into account the cost to provide services, current market rates and affordability of specific user categories. Proposed fees for City activities were developed by calculating a cumulative CPI increase since fees were established in FY 2003 rounded to the nearest quarter or dollar. New fees are proposed for non-resident, non-profit permit groups with over 2,000 permitted hours and are priced half way between the resident and non-resident permit rate. These groups are regional in nature with less than 30% Santa Monica residents but serve a significant number of residents. C6-1 Current vs. Proposed Fees RECREATIONAL/LAP SWIM: Da ily Entrance Percentaee Current Proposed Increase Increase Residents-Youth $1.00 $1.25 $0.25 25% Residents -Adult $2.50 $3.25 $0.75 30% Residents-Senior/Student $1.25 $1.50 $0.25 20% Residents-Family $5.00 $6.25 $1.25 25% Non Res -Youth $2.00 $2.50 $0.50 25% Non Res-Adult $5.00 $6.50 $1.50 30% Non Res- Senior/Student $2.50 $3.00 $0.50 20% NonRes-Family $10.00 $12.50 $2.50 25% RECREATIONAL/LAP SWIM: Swim Pass (20 visits) Residents-Youth $10.00 $12.50 $2.50 25% Residents-Adult $40.00 $50.00 $10.00 25% Residents-Senior/Student $20.00 $25.00 $5.00 25% Non Res -Youth $20.00 $25.00 $5.00 25% Non-Res-Adult $80.00 $100.00 $20.00 25% Non-Res- Senior/Student $40.00 $50.00 $10.00 25% SWIM LESSONS (per hour) Residents group $8.00 $10.00 $2.00 25% Non-Res group $16.00 $20.00 $4.00 25% Residents semi-private $32.00 $40.00 $8.00 25% Non-Res semi-private $70.00 $80.00 $10.00 14% .SHARKS SWIM TEAM (includes 54 hours of programming) Residents $90.00 $112.00 $22.00 24% Non Res $125.00 $156.00 $31.00 25% YOUTH SPECIALTY CLASSES (Water Polo, Diving, Synchronized Swimming -includes 8 hours of programming) Residents $64.00 $80.00 $16.00 25% Nan-Res $128.00 $160.00. $32.00 25% C6-2 ADULT WATER FITNESS CLASSES Percentaee Sinele Class Current Proposed Increase Increase Res-Adult $4.00 $5.00 $1.00 25% Res-Senior/Student $2.00 $2.50 $0.50 25% Non Res-Adult $8.00 $10.00 $2.00 25% Non Res-Senior/Student $4.00 $5.00 $1.00 25% 10 Class Pass Res-Adult $35.00 $44.00 $9.00 26% Res-Senior/Student $17.50 $22.00 $4.50 26% Non Res-Adult $70.00 $88.00 $18.00 26% Non Res- Senior/Student $35.00 $44.00 $9.00 26% PERMIT GROUPS Non-Profit Youth Sports Groups Short Course Fees leer lane per hour Santa Monica Based $4.00 $5.00 $1.00 25% Non SM Based /2,000 hrs $4.00 $7.50 $3.50 9% Non Santa Monica Based $8.00 $10.00 $2.00 26% Long Course Fees Santa Monica Based $8.00 $10.00 $2.00 25% Non SM Based /2,000 hrs $8.00 $15.00 $7.00 88% Non Santa Monica Based $16.00 $20.00 $4.00 26% Non-Profit Adult Sports Groups Short Course Fees Iper lane per hour Santa Monica Based $7.00 $8.75 $1.75 25% Non SM Based /2,000 hrs $7.00 $13.00 $6.00 86% Non Santa Monica Based $14.00 $17.50 $3.50 25% Lone Course Fees Santa Monica Based $14.00 $17.50 $3.50. 25% Non SM Based /2,000 hrs $14.00 $26.00 $12.00 86% Non Santa Monica Based $28.00 $35.00 $7.00 25% C6-3 Other Or¢anizations & Businesses Percentaee Short Course Fees (per lane oerhour) Current Proposed Increase Increase Santa Monica Based $16.00 $20.00 $4.00 25% Non Santa Monica Based $32.00 $40.00 $8.00 25% Lone Course Fees Santa Monica Based $32.00 $40.00 $8.00 25% Non Santa Monica Based $64.00 $80.00 $16.00 25% Percentaee Tournaments -Fitness Pool Onlv Current Proposed Increase Increase SM-based NP Youth Groups $150.00 $187.00 $37.00 25% Non SM-Based NP Youth 2,000 hrs $150.00 $280.00 $130.00 87% SM-based NP Adult Groups $250.00 $312.00 $62.00 25% Non SM-Based SP Adult 2,000 hrs $250.00 $468.00 $218.00 87% Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $165,612 20% decrease due to higher permit fees ($ 61,428) Net Projected Revenue Increase $104,185 Comparisons Cities included in comparison: Culver City, Torrance, Beverly Hills, West Hollywood, EI Segundo, Los Angeles, Santa Monica YMCA. Staff conducted a review of programming and permit fees for use of other cities' pools. Financial Assistance Program (FAP) for Youth Participants: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $14,700 for Aquatics programs annually. Date of Previouslncrease:July 2002 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: The public was notified through the Swim Center web site, postings at the Swim Center and sending notifications to ongoing permit groups. The fee change was also brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-4 PROGRAM: MEMORIAL PARK GYM Description: Memorial Park Gym is open to the public for drop-in basketball, volleyball and pickleball. Participants pay a fee to access the gym, ranging from $1- $3 per entry depending on age and residency. In addition, group permits for use of the gym are issued for either the full gymnasium, or half. Individuals can take out a permit to use the gym for parties, or play. Although private and semi-private coaching occurs during drop-in recreation, there is currently no fee structure in place for this activity. This allows private coaches to pay the same entrance fee as participants while they are using the gym as a place of business and charging clients market rates. The amount of private coaching in the gym has not been tracked, but it is estimated that it may be occurring 3 -4 hours per week. Total Participants: Private Coaching: Estimated 2 coaches per week Drop In: youth 1,491, others 8,674 (# of entrances) Gym Rentals: schools 426 hours, others 250 hours Current Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 10% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 13% Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be. imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imposed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market" and are below those charged by ~ Verifying residenry is practical and cost effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee anda fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Imposing higherfees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Private Coaching: The proposed new Private Coaching Fee will create a system similar to private tennis instruction at the City's public courts where instructors are required to pay an Instructors Fee for public court usage while teaching, as well as the current Fitness Trainers Fee for private training at the Annenberg Community Beach House fitness room. Staff proposes setting the fee at $10 per hour for up to 2 clients. This rate is the same as the Beach House Fitness Trainer Fee. (Both fees are lower than the $14.40 Tennis Instructor fee, as tennis instructors are granted exclusive court use, but coaches and trainers have shared use of facilities.) In addition to the Private Coaching Fee, coaches will be required to have a Santa Monica business license and obtain insurance. C6-5 Drop-In Gym: Fees for the drop in gym program have not increased since FY 2003-04. Based on a cumulative CPI from that year to the present, the proposed daily entrance fee increase for residents would average $0.33 and for non-residents would average $0.50. Drop-In Daily Entrance Percentaee Residents Current Proposed Increase Increase Youth $1.00 $1.25 $0.25 25% Adult $2.00 $2.50 $0.50 25% Senior $1.00 $1.25 $0.25 25% Drop-In Daily Entrance Percentaee Non-Residents Current Proposed Increase Increase Youth $1.00 $1.25 $0.25 25% Adult $3.00 $3.75 $0.75 25% Senior $2.00 $2.50 $0.50 25% Drop-In C!uarterly Pass Percentaee Residents Current Proposed Increase Increase Youth $12.00 $14.50 $2.50 21% Adult $25.00 $31.25 $6.25 25% Senior $12.00 $15.00 $3.00 ZS% Non-Residents .Youth $15.00 $19.00 $4.00 27% Adult $30.00 $37.50 $7.50 25% Senior $15.00 $18.75 $3.75 2S% Gym Rentals; Memorial Park Gymnasium is permitted to private schools, community groups and individuals for sports activities. It is believed that the current permit fees were established in the 1990's. Staff is proposing the gym rental fees be raised by compounded CPI increase from 2003. Residents Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase 1/2 Gym $28/hr $35/hr $7/hr Full Gym $56/hr $70/hr $14/hr Non-Res Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase '/: Gym $40/hr $50/hr $10/hr FuIIGym $75/hr $100/hr $25/hr Percentaeelncrease 25% 25% Percentaeelncrease 25 33% C6-6 Gross Projected Revenue Increase -Private Coaching 50% decrease in participation due to higher fees Gross Projected Revenue Increase -Drop-In Gym 10•~ Decrease in participation due to higher fees Gross Projected Revenue Increase- Gym Rental 10% Decrease in participation due to hiaher fees Net Projected Revenue Increase $1,560 $- 780 $4,766 $- 476 $8,442 S- 844 $12,688 Current Fees with Comparisons Private Coaching: No comparisons available, as private coaching is not allowed in other area gyms. Gym Droo-in: The following cities have gymnasiums with drop-in play, however do not charge entrance fees: Torrance, EI Segundo, Inglewood, Los Angeles (Penmar, Westchester, Westwood, Palisades, Venice, Mar Vista, Cheviot Hills) $20.00 processing fee Financial Assistance Program for Youth Participants: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City offers financial assistance for eligible youth to participation in Gymnasium Drop-In. Currently, no financial assistance has been requested. Date of Previous Increase: Unknown, but believed to be in the 1990's Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increases: The proposed gymnasium fees were posted at Memorial Park Gym and on the Community Sports webpage. The fee notice was also sent to regular gym permittees. The fee was also brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-7 PROGRAM: CREST CHILDCARE Description: This CREST program provides on-site before-and after-school child care at the Cit~fs seven elementary schools in partnership with the Santa Monica Malibu Unified School District. The District operates grades K-3, and the City operates grades 4-5. Total Participants: youth 2,300 registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 21% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 24% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should 6e imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ^ level Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity a Pees are "under market" and are helow those charged by ^ comparable cities and/or service providers Veri in residen fy g ty is practical and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ^ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cast increases residentr ^ The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not ^ Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an existed hefore or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue. Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users ^X Financial Assistance is availahle . The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: City staff is proposing an increase to the monthly fee. This increase is consistent with the fee -that the District charges for their portion of the CREST Childcare program and also brings the program's fees in-line with other local school-based after-school programs. Current Monthly Fee Proposed Monthly Fee Increase - Percentagelncrease $300.00 $350.00 $50.00 17% Gross Projected Revenue Increase $42,550 Decrease in participation due to higher fees (S Oj Net Projected Revenue Increase $42,550 C6-8 wrrenr reel wan compansons Program Adult to Maximum Program Fee oer Month es Total class time Name youth Ratio Ca aci Location Culver City $188/month Ages 6-12 1:10 30 per site M-F for 3 hours 2 schools ($47/week) (Grades K-6) & 3 parks -CitXof Santa ~3D0/month--& Ages? it 1c16 SDlpersite 7AM-school ~bell& ~ 7scRonCs i Manica onetime $Sfl=~~ ;(Grades 4-6)-~ .aftersch'ool until 6PM rngistration fee ~ ~ - Glendale $380/month & annual Ages 7-12 1:15 ~ 40 per site 7 AM-school bell & All school Un'rfied $80 registration fee (Grades 3-5) afterschool until 6PM sites '. Manhattan $400/month & annual Ages 7-12 1:15 40 per site 7 AM-school bell & All school Beach $SO registration fee (Grades 3-5) afterschool until 6PM sites Unified SM-Malibu $350/month & annual Grades 1-3 1:15 40 per site Afterschool-6 PM All school USD $50 registration fee sites SM YMCA $300/month & .Grades K-6 1:8-10 30 in each 1:30-5:30 PM SM Family $60 registration fee age group YMCA STAR $420 month (approx. Grades K-5 1: 10-14 Unlimited Afterschool-6 PM Elementar $4,200 per school y schools year) + one time $66 registration fee Financial Assistance Program: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualifyand is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live or attend public school in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $528,704 for CREST Childcare programs. Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2009 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 (Program starts in September 2011) Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: Notices were posted on the Human Services Division website, at all public elementary and middle schools in Santa Monica and will be included in re- enrollment packets; which will be sent to incoming 4th and 5th grade parents in April and May. The changes were also included on the agenda for the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting on January 20, 2011. C6-9 PROGRAM: CREST ENRICHMENT CLASSES Description: The CREST Enrichment program provides before- and after-school classes at seven elementary schools and two middle schools in Santa Monica. CREST Enrichment operates Monday - Fridayand provides classes for grades K-8.The mission of the CREST Enrichment Program is to present a wide variety of high quality, affordably priced before- and after-school enrichment classes, which enhance the education of Santa Monica school students. Total Participants: youth 3,000 registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 48% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 53% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should he imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imposed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery level ^ Demand for activiTy or permit service exceeds capacity Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by ^ Verifying residency is practical and cost effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annual fee adjustmenu that are currently based on Consumer Price ^ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indezand/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Current Fee Anticipated Increase Percentage Increase $90.00 - $180.00 $10.00 Up to 11% Enrichment fees are negotiated with contracted instructors and not adopted by the City Council. Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $23,250 Decrease in participation due to higher fees (S 0 ) Net Projected Revenue Increase $23,250 C6-10 current tees warn comparisons Program Resident Fee Non-Res. Fee Aees Total class time Program Location Name Beverly Hills $112 25% more for Grades 45-60 minutes Elementary school non-residents Preschool-S (8-9 class sessions) sites city of Santa ! $90 Same _ ;Ages 5 14 ?, __ _ 1 hour classes ` _ 7 elementary & 2 Mooiw .' (8 ciasssessions} ~ middleschoo~sttes Planet Bravo $145 Same Ages 2 years & 1 hour classes John Adams Middle up (8-class sessions) School STAR $128 Same Ages 2 years & 1 hour classes Elementary schdol up (8-class sessions) sites Torrance $70 Varies Ages 2 years & 1 hour classes Teen Center, up (8-10 (class sessions) Recreation Center & Cultural Arts Center Financial Assistance Program: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live or attend public school in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $60,750 for CREST Enrichment programs. Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2002 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee. Increase: Notices were posted on the Human Services Division website, at all public elementary and middle schools in Santa Monica and will be included in re-enrollment packets, which will be sent to incoming 4th and Sth grade parents in April and May. The changes were also included on the agenda for the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting on January 20, 2011. C6-11 PROGRAM: CREST YOUTH SPORTS LEAGUES (Elementary and Middle School Sports) Description: This CREST program provides practice and league play in team sports for youth in grades 3 through 8 and offers an introductory program for beginners in .grades K-2. The fee covers an 8 session series, with each session lasting 3 hours. Total Participants: youth 2,540 registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: Middle School 13%, Elementary School 21% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: Middle School 16%, Elementary School 26% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by comparable cities and/or service providers Verifying residency is practical and cost effective f~ Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- I ^ I Index and/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higherfees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like aRivities or services Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentagelncrease $90.00 $125.00 $35.00 39% Gross Projected Revenue Increase (combined programs middle & elementary) $68,898 10% decrease in participation of full fee paying participants due to higher fees 22 225 Net Projected Revenue Increase (combined programs middle & elementary) $46,673 C6-12 Current Fees and Comaarisons Proeram Name Fee oer Session Practices Games Fee Includes City of Beverly Hills - $160 Res/$200 Non-Res 1 hr 30 min/wk 8 Basketball(agesl0-14) City of Beverly Hills- $200 Res/$250 Non-Res 1 hr 45 min/wk 8 Basketball (ages 4-10) City of Beverly Hills- $105 Res/$131 Non-Res 1 hr/wk 8 Saturday Morning Soccer (ages 5-8) City of Beverly Hills - $12S Res/$156 Non-Res 1 hr/wk 8 Soccer (ages 5-8) City of Beverly Hills- $150 Res/$188 Non-Res 1 hr 30 min/wk 8 Track & Running (ages 5-12) City of Los Angeles - $110 1 hr/wk S+playoffs Uniform/Trophy Mar Vista Recreation Center City of Los Angeles - $100 1 hr/wk 8 Uniform/Trophy Penmar Recreation Center City of Los Angeles - Cheviot Hills Recreation Center $115 1 hr/wk 8 Uniform/Trophy City of Santa Monica- CREST! ~ ~ $90 ~ ~ 3 firsJwk ~ .8 -, Uniform/Trophy I City of West Hollywood- $6S 1-2 hr practices 10 Baseball League (ages 6-16) 2x/wk Culver City $125 Res/$136 Non-Res 46 min/day- 8 wks No Games Proeram Name Fee oer Session Practices Games Fee Includes Palisades Recreation Center $125 1 hr/wk 10 Uniform/Trophy Santa Monica YMCA-Volleyball $100/member- $160/non-member 2hrs/wk 10 Westwood Recreation Complex- $100 1 hr/wk 10 Uniform(7rophy Basketball League Financial Assistance Program: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live or attend public school in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $51,435 for Youth Sports Leagues programs. Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2009 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of.Proposed Fee Increase: Notices were posted on the Human Services Division website, at all public elementary and middle schools in Santa Monica and will be included in re- enrollment packets, which will be sent to incoming 4th and 5th grade parents in April and May. The changes were also included on the agenda for the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting on January 2Q 2011. C6-13 PROGRAM: CREST -CAMP SANTA MONICA (School Break Day Camps) Description: School break camps are offered for fourteen weeks per year, two weeks in winter, two weeks in spring, and ten weeks in summer. Camps serve elementary school children ages 8-14. Total Participants: youth 930 registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 11% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 12% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should he imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should he increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by comparable cRiesand/or service providers Verifying residency is practical and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently hosed on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kepi up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not ~ Instftuting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an existed before or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Increased fees are not expected to signifcantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Type Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentagelncrease Residents $170.00 $200.00 $30.00 18% Non-Residents $190.00 $220.00 $30.00 16% Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $10,323 10% decrease in participation of full fee paying participants due to higher fees 5 600 Net Projected Revenuelncrease $4,723 C6-14 Current Fees with Comparisons-Weekly Rates Non-Resident/ Pro¢ram Name Resident Fee Member Fee Aees Total class time Pro¢ram Location Beverly Hills $180-$200/week $200-$250/wk Ages 5-14 M-F, gam-Spm 2 schools & 3 parks Culver City $110-$130/week $145-$160/week Ages 5-17 M-F, gam-6pm Veteran's Memorial Complex City of Santa t $170/week ? $190/iueek Ag~3 % 14 : J,A F,%30arn-Spm . Schoats; Parks & City Monica ~ ~' _Maiotenance-Yards Delphi Academy $401-500/week Same Ages 4-11 M-F, 8:16am-4:15pm Delphi Academy in SM Summer ~ SM Camp Long Beach $90-$145/week Same Ages 5-12 Mf-F, gam-4pm City parks & aquatic center My Global Groove $250-$350/week Same Ages 3-13 M-F, gam-3pm Venice Center for Cultural ($60-$70 day) Peace with Justice Adventure and the Arts Rustic Canyon $225/week+$60 Same Ages 6-12 M-F, loam-3pm Rustic Canyon registration fee Recreation Center sM YMCA Day $150-$200/week $250/week Ages 3-18 M-F, 8:30am-6pm - SM YMCA Camps Torrance $115/week $135/week Ages 6- 14 M-F, 8:30am-4:30pm Park sites Financial Assistance Program: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live or attend public school in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $99,603 for Camp Santa Monica programs. Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2003 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: Notices were posted on the Human Services Division website, at all public elementary and middle schools in Santa Monica and will be included in re- enrollment packets, which will be sent to incoming 4th and 5th grade parents in April and May. The changes were also included on the agenda for the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting on January 20, 2011. C6-15 PROGRAM: CREST- SANTA MONICA SPORTS EXPERIENCE (School Break Sports Camp) Description: The Santa Monica Sports Experience (SMSE) program provides daily sports camps structured around active play. Activities include traditional sports such as basketball, flag football and volleyball and organized high impact games to keep youth moving. The program is only offered during school breaks: winter, spring and summer and includes a. full day or part-time option. Camps serve elementary school children ages 8-14. Total Participants: youth 1,070 registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 23% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 25% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: nx Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery J level ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity tees are "under market" and are below those charged by Verifying residenry is practical and cost effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activiTy or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Q Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease . participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Type Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentage Increase Residents $170.00 $200.00 $30.00 18% Non-Residents $190.00 $220.00 $30.00 16% Gross Projected Revenue Increase $11,850 10% decrease in participation of full fee paying participants due to higher fees 6 400 Net Projected Revenue Increase $5,450 C6-16 wnrni rers wun wrnpurrsurrs-vveercry rsores Non- Program Name Resident Fee Resident Fee Ages Total class time Program Location Advantage Basketball Camps $205-$225/4-day Same Ages 7-18 M-TR, Varies upon activity week 9am-Spm AYSO Soccer summer $135-190/week Same Ages 4-16 M-F, Memorial Park 9am-3pm City ofSaMa;'Nlonica- ~$170[week ? Ages814 M-F, .' Schools, Parks'. SM Sports Experience ,. ; 8:30am-$pm ~ Fitness bythe sea $330-$345/week Same Ages 5-14 M-F, Will Rogers State ($66-$69/day)+ 9:16am-3:46pm Beach, Tower 14 in $25 Reg. Fee the Pacific Palisades Santa Monica $300/week Same Ages 4-14 M-F, Crossroads School K- Primetimesports 9:30am-4pm 125ports Ce nter Sierra Adventure Camps $645-$555/week Same Ages 7-17 M-F, Varies Varies upon activity (Watersports Day Camp) +$25 reg. fee 8:15-9:16am to Financial Assistance Program: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live or attend public school in Santa Monica. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $114,750 for Santa Monica Sports Experience programs. Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2003 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: Notices were posted on the Human Services Division website, at all public elementary and middle schools in Santa Monica and will be included in re- enrollment packets, which will be sent to incoming 4th and 5th grade parents in April and May. The changes were also included on the agenda for the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting on January 20, 2011. C6-ll PROGRAM: ROSIE's GIRLS Description: Rosie's Girls is an award winning day camp designed to build self-esteem, leadership and physical confidence in middle school girls through an exploration of trades and other non-traditional activities. During the intensive, three-week summer program, girls go "behind the scenes" and experience what it takes to operate a city. The participants learn skills in carpentry, welding, plumbing, automotive, fire fighting, tree trimming and other technical trades. Participants engage in fun physical challenges, including sailing, kayaking, self-defense, ropes course and more. They also participate in making creative expression projects, such as a mask and journal, and develop critical thinking and leadership skills while exploring issues such as gender roles, body image and social pressure. The program also allows the girls to participate in unique community service projects. Total Participants: youth 188 registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 21% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 23% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by Verifying residency is practical and cost effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annual fee adjustmentr that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Index and/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrantr a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users ~X Financial Assistance is availahle The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Instituting or increasing the fee is not ezpected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Type Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentagelncrease Residents $325.00 $380.00 $55.00 17% Non-Residents $430.00 $485.00 $55.00 13% Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $6,380 10% decrease in participation of full fee paying porticipants due to higher fees 3 876 Net Projected Revenuelncrease $2,504 C6-18 Current Fees with Comparisons-Weekly Rates Non-Resident Program Name Resident Fee Fee Ages Total class time Ctt~ of Santa Ntonica - Rasie; s Girls $325/week $430/yveek Ages 8 14 j ~ M F, 8:38am Spm Tocaloma Summer Day Camp $589/week Same Ages 4-14 M-F, 8:30am-4pm (4 week min.j Tumbleweed Day Camps $695/week Same Ages 8-14 M-F, Sam-Spm (Summer 2010) UCLA Family Commons Girls Get $325/week Same Ages 9-12 M-F, gam-lpm or Real (Comparable to RG) 1-Spm Financial Assistance Program: Assistance in the form of a discount is offered to families who qualify and is based on income. Assistance is available to youth who live or attend public school in Santa Monica. In the summer, only those non-resident students who are required to do mandated summer school at SMMUSD in Santa Monica are eligible for FA. Verification of residency, school enrollment and income are required. Currently, the City provides financial assistance in the amount $23,400 for Rosie's Girls programs. Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2003 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: Notices were posted on the Human Services Division website, at all public elementary and middle schools in Santa Monica and will be included in re- enrollment packets, which will be sent to incoming 4th and 5th grade parents in April and May. The changes were also included on the agenda for the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting on January 20, 2011. C6-19 PROGRAM: ADULT SPORTS LEAGUES Description: The Citys adult sports league program is one of the largest, most diverse recreational sports programs in Southern California. Men and women of all skill levels are welcome to join one of the organized leagues. Basketball leagues for men and women; softball leagues for men, women and coed teams; and women and coed volleyball leagues are offered. These leagues are offered year round and reach capacity each season. The current fee structure, implemented FY 2008-09, established categories for teams which added the Santa Monica Business Teams and Non-Resident Teams categories. The original fee charged for Santa Monica Residents to enroll a team into one of the leagues has not changed since FY 2003-04. Total Participants: • 58 Basketball Team Registrations • 37 Volleyball Team Registrations • 280 Softball Team Registrations Community Benefit Level: Core Community Current Cost Recovery Rate: 61% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 62% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permR service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ D d f ti it i i d level eman or ac v y or perm t serv ce excee s capacity Fees are "under market" and are below those charged by ~~ comparable cities and/or service providers Vert in residen fy g ty is practical and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents - The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not ® Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an existed before or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users ~X Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequhable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Fee Changes Leagues Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentage Increase Basketball- Resident $250.00 $275.00 $25.00 10% Basketball-Bus/NR $280.00 $310.00 $30.00 11% Basketball- NR $315.00 $345.00 $30.00 - 10% Volleyball -Resident $200.00 $220.00 $20.00 10% Volleyball -Bus/NR $225.00 $25D.00 $25.00 11% C6-20 Leagues Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentage Increase Volleyball -NR $250.00 $275.00 $25.00 10% Softball-Men's-Resident $350.00 ~ $385.00 $35.00 10% Softball-Men's-Bus/NR $395.00 $435.00 $40.00 10% Softball-Men's-NR $440.00 $480.00 $40.00 9% Softball-Women's-Resident $330.00 $365.00 $35.00 il% Softball -Women's-Bus/NR $370.00 $410.00 $40.00 11% Softball-Women's-NR $415.00 $455.00 $40.00 10% Softball-Coed-Resident $330.00 $365.00 $35.00 11% Softball-Coed Bus/NR $370.00 $410.00 $40.00 11% Softball-Coed - NR $415.00 $455.00 $40.00 10% Gross Projected Revenue Increase $12,475 0% Decrease in participation due to higher fees lS 0) Net Projected Revenuelncrease $12,475 Current Fees with Comparisons Cwt Softball Basketball Vollevball $480 Resident $320 Resident Beverly Hills $500 Business $360 Business NA $540 Non-Resident $400 Non-Resident Culver City $410 $375 NA Torrance $340 Resident $415 NA $390 Non-Resident $330 $350 Resident $250 Resident: $200'ResidenY Santa Monica ~-~ $370 $395 Busfiess $280 eusiness`.,~ ~ $225 Business $4iS $440 Non-Resident $31$'Non-Resident $250 Non-Resident Financial Assistance: Not available Date of Previous Increase: Last increase for resident rates is FY 2003-04. Resident/Business and Non- Resident rates created July 1, 2008. Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: Notices about fee increases were posted at Memorial Park, on the Community Recreation Division website, and sent to adult sports league managers. The fee change was also brought before the Sports Advisory Council on January 12, 2011 and the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-21 PERMIT SERVICE: MILES MEMORIAL PLAYHOUSE -Weekend Performance Rentals Description: The Miles Memorial Playhouse is a registered historical landmark for the City completed in 1929 and bequeathed to the City by former Councilman J. Euclid Miles. The Northridge earthquake did considerable damage to the building in 1994 and after 4 years of renovation and retrofitting, the Playhouse re-opened in 1998 with a professional lighting grid, sound system and presentational capabilities akin to most professional theaters. It is available to non-profit arts organizations and City produced presentations of music, theater and dance open to the general public. Thus, with its professional amenities, availability to non-profits, 132 person audience capacity and low rental rates, there is no other theater quite like the Miles in the Los Angeles area. A "Weekend Performance Rental" is a week-long permit. It grants user groups specific access from Monday-Sunday, allowing for up to 4 public performances on Thursday-Sunday and INCLUDES 25 hours of rehearsal and tech time from Monday AM until the show opens, usually Thursday or Friday night. Total Participants: • 10,000+Audience members annually • 20-25 different non-profit user groups a year ranging, 6 persons to 25 persons per group Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery Rate: . 5% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 6% Pricing Indicators: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imposed or increased: Program or permt service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capaciTy level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by V if i id i i l comparable cities and/or service providers er y ng res ency s pract ca and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A highpercentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not ~ Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an existed before or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on mast users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: The current weekend performance rate was established in 2009/10. Rentals of 1-3 weeks in length are $600 per weekend. Rentals of 4 or more are $700 per weekend. This split was in recognition of the fact that most dance and music based non-profits have smaller staffs, less financial capacity and usually only want 1-3 weekends whereas larger non-profit theater companies -who usually want 4-6 weeks have more financial capacity and staff and could pay a slightly higher fee than those who want to secure the playhouse for a shorter period of time.) C6-22 The Proposed Fee increase of $100 per weekend to each category would bring the Weekend Performance rental rate up to $700 for 1-3 weeks and $800 for 4 or more weeks. Duration Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentagelncrease Weekend (1-3 weeks) $600.00 $700.00 $100 17% Weekend (4 weeks plus) $700.00 $800.00 $100 14% Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $4,000 0% Decrease in participation due to higher fees ($ 0) Net Projected Revenue Increase $4,000 ~urrenu ree wnn ~urnpmrsuns Venue Cost Comments Electric lodge -Venice $1,500 (4 day rental) Studio/Stage -Hollywood $650 (weekend) No rehearsal or load in time. Maximum seating: 75 Financial Assistance Program for Youth Participants: N/A Date of Previous Increase: July 1, 2009 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: The proposed Weekend Performance rental rate increase were posted at Reed Park, on the Cultural Affairs Division and Miles Playhouse websites and disseminated to our list of past user groups. The fee change was brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-23 PERMIT SERVICE: COMMUNITY MEETING ROOMS Description: City meeting facilities are in high demand by City programs, City-sponsored organizations, nonprofit groups and the general public for meetings and social gatherings. The permit fees for City community meeting facilities were established in the late 1990s. Since then, fees have increased yearly by the Consumer Price Index (CPI). During this time, the cost of issuing permits, maintaining and staffing the facilities, as well as overhead expenses, have increased at a much higher rate than CPI. Total Participantst: 63 Santa Monica different nonprofits groups 18 different non-Santa Monica nonprofit groups • 497 Residents (# of permits issued) ® 106 Non-residents (# of permits issued) Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery Rate: 24% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 36% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should he increased: imposed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by comparable cities and/or service providers Verifying residency is practical and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently haled on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activfties or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Park Buildings-The current park meeting room fee structure is based on type of user (nonprofit, community and business); residency status and room size. The proposed park meeting room fee structure eliminates the business rate (barely used) and bases the fee structure on size of room and residency. Rooms will be divided into small and large and resident and non-resident fees will be charged. A 60% discount is offered to Santa Monica based non-profit organizations with a minimum of SO% Santa Monica residency. The current priorities used for booking rooms will remain unchanged. Ken Edwards Center (KEC), - At KEC residency has not been a pricing factor, however, type of user and room size has been. Staff recommends that the type of fee user categories be eliminated with only the t FY 2009/2010 Figures C6-24 discounted rate for senior services non-profit agencies use of 100A and 1008 and the limited fee waiver for City funded non-profits remaining. The current priorities used for booking rooms will remain unchanged. This revised pricing structure will greatly simplify the fee schedule and be more comparable to meeting room fees at Santa Monica public libraries. ($25.00 per hour small room, $50 per hour large room) Staff further recommends that meeting rooms be designated as either small (capacity 18-55) or large (capacity 56 - 130) and that spaces at facilities with room dividers (Reed Park and KEC) are treated as separate small rooms. Small rooms will be $25 each per hour and large rooms will be $SO each per hour. Current & Proposed Fees Facility Current Maximum Capacity Current Community Hourly Rate Proposed Maximum Capacity Proposed Hourly Rate Percentage Increase Park Buildings Small -Residents 18 - 55 $18.98 18 - 55 $25.00 32% Med-Residents 90-100 $25.04 - - 100% Large- Residents 120 - 130 $29.60 90 -130 $50.00 69% Small -Non Resident 18 - 55 $37.96 18 - 55 $35.00 -8% Med -Non Resident 90 - 100 $49.79 - - 41% Large-Non Resident 120-130 $62.17 90-130 $70.00 13% Facility Current Maximum Capacity Current Non-Profit Hourly Rate Proposed Maximum Capacity Proposed Discounted Hourly Rate Percentage Increase Park Buildings Small-SM Non-Profit 18-66 $10.84 18-55 $12.50 15% Med-SMNon-Profit 90-100 $14.32 - - 75% Large-SMNon-Profit 120-130 $17.75 90-130 $25.00 41% To qualify for the non-profit discount, the organization must have at least 50% Santa Monica residents. The average expected attendance at non-profit self-help group meetings is 13 - 26 people. Depending upon the number of attendees, following is the per person hourly cost: At current Santa Monica non-profit rate At proposed discounted Santa Monica non-profit rate Small room $0.42 - $0.83 Small room $0.48 - $0.96 Medium room $0.55 - $1.10 Large room $0.96 - $1.92 Large room $0.60 - $1.37 The average expected attendance at anon-profit Red Ribbon Squares dance is 40 people. Depending upon the number of attendees, following is the per person hourly cost: At current Santa Monica non-profit rate Large room $0.44 At proposed discounted Santa Monica non-profit rate Large room $0.63 C6-25 Proposed Current Current Current ~ Discounted Maximum NP Hourly Community Proposed Hourly Percentage Facility Capacity Rate Hourly Rate Capacity Rate Increase Ken Edwards Center Small-Res&NonRes 40-SO $16.47 $46.07 40-50 .$25.00 `51.8%,-45.7% Med -Res & Non Res 80 -100 $31.59 $92.14 n/a n/a 58.3%, -45.7% Large -Res & Non Res 100 -120 $39.48 $118.44 n/a - n/a 90%, 36.7% Small -Senior Services 50 $12.34 n/a 50 $18.75 51.9% Agencies 100A or 1006 Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $93,168 15% Decrease in participation due to higher fees /$32,638) Net Projected Revenuelncrease $60,533 Comporisons City Small Room Large Room Other Costs Santa Monica Public $26/hr $50/hr Libraries City of LA, Westwood $135/3 hrs Fees do not vary based $25 ea additional $160/3 hrs Table use: $75 on residency and type of $q0 ea extra hr hour user group. Res: $40.40/hr - Res: $80.70/hr Beverly Hills Non-Res: $50.50/hr Non-Res: Kitchen use: $53.50 $100.90/hr NP Free NP Free Res Private: Res Private: $25 sm, $60 med/hr $100/hr Kitchen fees: EI Segundo Non-Res NP: Non-Res NP: Res Private: $100/hr $35sm,$60 med/hr $110/hr Non-Res NP:$110/hr Non-Res Non-Res Private: $12S/hr Non-Res Private: Private: $50 sm, $76 med/hr $125/hr Res Private: $140/4 hrs, $2S ea extra Custodian fee of $50 may apply, $20 staffing fee hr. Non-Res Private: $160/4hr, $25 ea Culver City extra hr. may apply. Kitchen fee: Res NP: $100/4 hrs, Non-Res NP: Res $180/4 hrs, $25 ea extra hr. $160/4hr. - Non-Res $200/4hr, $26 ea extra hr Res NP:$35/hr Res Private & Non-Res NP: $36.50/hr Torrance Non-Res Private: $43/hr -Kitchen fee: $61.25/hr The above fees are for a basic meeting. Costs may increase up to $186/hr depending upon the event. Financial Assistance: Santa Monica based non-profit organizations receive a 50% discount off of the resident rate when using park building rooms. Senior service non-profit organizations permitting KEC Rooms 100A & 100B receive a 25% discount. City-funded non-profit organizations and approved C6-26 neighborhood organizations may permit KEC for up to 300 hours per year at no charge (WISE and Healthy Aging 600 hours). Date of Previous Increase: Other than CPI, the fee has not been increased since the late 1990s. Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification Permit Process: Notices about fee increases have been posted on the Community Recreation website and at all affected meeting room facilities. Regular meeting room users were notified and the fee change was brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. The discounted rate for Santa Monica based non-profit organizations was added following the Recreation and Parks Commission meeting. C6-27 PERMIT SERVICE: SPORTS FIELDS -COMMUNITY MEMBERS, PRIVATE SCHOOLS, CAMPS Description: Sports fields are in high demand by City programs, public and private schools, nonprofit organizations, community groups and individuals. The City issues permits for use of City,. John Adams and Lincoln Middle Schools and Playground Partnership site fields based on a priority user system that is designed to serve a broad range of users. The permit fee for use of a field is dependent upon the user type, sport and need for lights. An artificial turf staffing fee also applies for use of the fields at Airport Park and John Adams Middle School (JAMS). This staffing fee was first developed in 2006 for select permittees at Airport Park but expanded to all permittees at both Airport Park and JAMS beginning January 2010. The Artificial Turf Staffing fee is adjusted each year based on CPI. The permitting and lighting fees were established in the 1990s and have not been adjusted since then although the cost of issuing permits, maintaining fields and permit enforcement, as well as overhead expenses, have increased. Total Participants: • 4 different Private Schools • 6 different Santa Monica based Non-Profit Organizations • 1 Non-Santa Monica based Non-Profit Organizations 55 different Resident Community Groups/Individuals e 18 different Non-Resident Community GroupsJlndividuals • 10 different Youth Sports Groups Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery Rate: 35% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 370 Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imposed arincreased: Prog2m or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level tees are "under market' and are below those charged by ~ Verifying residenty is practical and cast effective comparable cities and/or service providers O Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residentr The activity or permit servicewarrants a fee and a fee has not ~ Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an existed before or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Increased fees are not expected to signifcantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequhable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Proposed permitting fees were developed by calculating cumulative CPI increases since July 2003 rounded to the nearest quarter and are being proposed for community members, private schools, non- profit groups and camps. Permit fees will remain unchanged for youth sports groups. C6-28 Resident Sport Type User Current Hourly Rate Proposed Hourly Rate Increase Percentage Increase Low Intensity Community, Private Schools, Non-Profits $10.00 $12.50 $2.50 25% Camps $20.00 $25.00 $5.00 25% High Intensity Community, Private Schools, Non-Profits $15.00 $18.75 $3.75 25% Camps $25.00 $31.00 $6.00 24% Lights Community, Private Schools, Non-Profits $10.00 $12.50 $2.50 25% Non-Resident Sport Type User Current Hourly Rate Proposed Hourly Rate Increase Percentage Increase Low Intensity Community, Private -. Schools, Non-Profits $15.00 $18.75 $3J5 25% Camps $25.00 $31.00 $6.00 24% High Intensity Community, Private Schools, Non-Profits $20.00 $25.00 $5.00 25% Camps $30.00 $37.50 $7.50 25% Lights Community, Private Schools, Non-Profits $15.00 $18.75 $3.75 25% Low Intensity Sport -baseball, softball High IntensitySport-soccer, football, lacrosse, rugby Artificial Turf Staffing Fee: $22.80 (Fy 10/11 rate) increases annually by COLA Youth Sports Groups lights and permit fees remain unchanged Gross Projected Revenue Increase $5,977 0% Decrease in participation due to higher fees ISO1 Net Projected Revenuelncrease $5,977 c.urrenr rees wrrn Baseball/softball -Res NP free, Res Private $25/hr, Non-Res NP $25/hr+ $10/hr after regular business hrs, Non-Res Private $ZS/hr+$25/hr above regular business hrs El Segundo Soccer Field -Res NP free, Res Private $100/hr, Non-Res NP $150/hr, Non-Res Private $175/hr. If use is outside of regular business hours, a $20 staffing fee is charged. Non-Res are also charged a lights fee of $12/hr Beverl Hills Resident NP $27.00/hr, Resident Private $54.50/hr, Non-Res NP $59.50, Non-Res Private CulverCity Lights $10/hr. Resident Adult $36/hr, Non-Res Adults $52/hr, staffing fee of $ $25/hr outside of normal business hours Torrance ~ $15/hr fields, $15/hr lights, $20 field prep fee, $22:50 chalk and bases (Res/NR fees same) C6-29 Financial Assistance: Not Available Date of Previous Increase: It is not known when the permit fees were implemented, likely in the 1990s. Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification of Proposed Fee Increase: Notices about fees were posted on the Community Recreation website, sent to regular permit users, and posted at Memorial and Airport Park outdoor bulletin boards. The fee change was also brought before the Sports Advisory Council on January 12, 2011 and the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-30 PERMIT SERVICE: OUTDOOR PERMITS (Basketball and Beach Volleyball} Description: The City issues permits for use of City outdoor basketball courts and for beach volleyball courts. The outdoor permit fee is dependent upon the user type, and whether the user is a Santa Monica Resident, or Non-Resident. The fees were established in FY 2007-08 and have not been adjusted since then. Therefore, it is recommended that the permitting fees be increased to better cover the cost of providing this amenity; however permitted use of these courts is minimal. Total Participants: Approximately 8 permits issued per year Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery Rate: 24% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 25% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imposed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by comparable cities and/or service providers Verifying residency is practical and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price O A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not ~ Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an existed before or has not been raised in many years overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: City staff is proposing an increase of $.75 - $4.00 for basketball court usage and $.25 - $4.00 for beach volleyball courts. These fee increases are derived from compounding CPI increases since July 2007. Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $ 218 0% Decrease in participation due to higher fees (S 0) Net Projected Revenue Increase $ 218 Current Fees & Comparisons Basketball: Residents Per Hour Current Proposed Increase Percentagelncrease Youth Groups, Non Profits, Private Schools, Community $10.00 $10.75 .75 8% Camps $30.00 $32.00 $2.00 7% C6-31 Non Resident Per Hour Current Proposed Increase Percentagelncrease Youth Groups, Non Profits, Private Schools, Community $12.50 $13.50 $1.00 8% Camps $60.00 $64.00 $4.00 7% Volleyball: Residents Per Hour Current Proposed Increase Percentagelncrease Youth Groups, Private Schools, Community $5.00 $5.50 $0.50 10% Non-Profit Organizations $2.75 $3.00 $0.25 9% Camps $30.00 $32.00 $2.00 7% Non Resident Per Hour Current Proposed Increase Percentagelncrease Youth Groups, Private Schools, Community $6.25 $6.75 $0.50 8% Non-Profit Organizations $2.75 $3.00 $0.25 9% Camps $60.00 $64.00 $4.00 7% Current Fees with Comparisons None of these entities rent our outdoor basketball courts. Outdoor basketball courts are first come/first served as are the beach volleyball courts. Courts used for hosting beach volleyball tournaments must obtain a beach special event permit which will include use of the beach volleyball courts. Cities surveyed for comparisons included: Manhattan Beach, Huntington Beach, Newport Beach, Corona Del Mar, Hermosa Beach, Redondo Beach, Santa Barbara, and the County of Los Angeles. The only city permitting beach volleyball courts is Santa Barbara (see rates below). Beach Volleyball Courts Santa Barbara Resident Non-Commercial $ Resident Commercial $ Non-Res Non-Commercial $ Non-Res Commercial 5 Financial Assistance Program: Not available. Date of Previouslncrease: 7/1/07 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: 7/1/11 Public Notification Process: Notices about fees have been posted on the Community Recreation website and mailed to regular permittees.-The fee change was brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-32 PERMIT SERVICE: COMMUNITY EVENTS Description: An Event Application Fee is a processing fee charged for community events in public spaces that are subject to the City's Events Ordinance (i.e., events with 150 or more people or events that interfere with traffic). This fee ranges from $50 - $200 and is based on the event category and lead time. Bayside District and Pier Restoration Corporation produced events are exempt from the Event Application Fee. All Category 2 and 3 (expressive or first amendment) events and accredited schools pay the lowest Application Fee. From a simple wedding in a park to the LA Marathon, events come in all shapes and sizes. Staff is proposing the application fee rates be increased based on compounding CPI from FY 2003/2004 rounded to the nearest $5.00. In addition, since the current fee structure does not take into account the amount of staff time required to coordinate events successfully staff is proposing an Administrative Fee to supplement the Application fee based on the complexity of the event. Before issuing an event permit, staff spends a lot of time consulting with and coordinating the many requirements from various City offices and local agencies - these can include, but are not limited to various Police Department offices, Transportation Management, Building. and Safety, the Alcohol, Beverage and Control OfFce and the LA County Lifeguards. The Administrative Fee which is to supplement the average revenue received from Application Fees is designed to cover the direct costs of issuing a permit. Projected Event Applications Processed: 97 Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery: 4% Proposed Cost Recovery: 12% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are"under markeY'and are below those charged by Verifying residency is practical and cost effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annualfee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ Ahigh percentage of participants or permittees are non-- Indezand/br other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years f ~ Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease ~~ participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial ASSistanceis available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services C6-33 Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Application Fee: # Weeks prior to event Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percent Increased 16 or more $50.00 $65.00 $15.00 30% 12-16 $100.00 $125.00 $25.00 26% 30 days -11 weeks $200.00 $250.00 $50.00 25% The application fee will increase by COLA each year, rounded to the nearest dollar. Administration Fee: Based on clearly-defined levels of event complexity, the proposed Administrative Fee for Category 1 events, which would be in addition to the Event Application Fee, covers additional staff time required to process and coordinate permits for intermediate and complex events: An Administrative Fee would not be charged for Category 2 and 3 events- (expressive or first amendment) or for Category 1 events produced by the Pier .Restoration Corporation, Bayside Distrito Corporation or Santa Monica public schools. The proposed Administrative Fee is based on staff hours required to process events. The fee structure defines three levels of events: • Simple: Events requiring consultation, coordination or services from 1 - 4 City offices or agencies. • Intermediate: Events requiring consultation, coordination or services from 5 - 8 City offices or agencies. ® Complex: Events requiring consultation, coordination or services from 9 or more City offices or agencies. Staff Position Simple Intermediate Complex StaffASSistant III 1 hr 1 hrs 2 hr Administrative Staff Assistant 2 hrs 5 hrs 8 hrs Senior Administrative Analyst 1 hr 2 hrs 2 hrs Community Use Administrator 0 hrs 1 hr 2 hrs TotalStaffCost $188 $450 $689 Proposed Administrative Fee $80 $340 $58D The average projected Application Fee revenue is $109. The Administrative Fee will increase by COLA each year, rounded to the nearest dollar. Gross Projected Revenue Increase $21,000 10% Decrease in participation due to higher fees ($3,000) Net Projected Revenue Increase $18,000 Current Fees with Comparisons Application Fee Application Fee Non-Profit C~ Residents Non-Residents Pasadena $55.00 $160.00 Not Available Redondo Beach $40.00 $40.00 Not Available. C6-34 C~ Application Fee Application Fee Non-Profit Residents Non-Residents West Complex Event Complex Hollywood $2,400 processing fee $1,200 processing fee Late fee: $3,600 less than 14 days prior to event Late fee: $1,800 less than 14 days prior Late fee: $7,200 less than 7 days prior to event Late fee: $3,600 less than 7 days prior Intermediate Event Intermediate Event $800 processing fee $262.50 processing fee Late fee: $1,200 less than 14 days prior to event Late fee: $400 less than 14 days prior Late fee: $2,400 less than 3 days prior to event Late fee: $525 less than 3 days prior Simple Event Simple Event $188 processing fee $94 processing fee Late fee: $188 less than 7 days prior to event Late fee: $94 less than 7 days prior Late fee: $262 less than 3 days prior to event Late fee: $188 less than 3 days prior San Diego $150 per event Not Available $10 per day late fee for applications received less than 60 days prior to event Beverly Hills Small Scale Event $596, Large Scale Event $2,658 Not Available Culver City- Event Fee $30/day, $15 Event Fee $40/day, Not Available ea additional day $20 ea additional day Application Fee Application Fee Non-Profit City Residents Non-Residents Santa Moniea , $50.00:16 or more weeks tri advance ? Not Available '$100.00:12-1S weeks inaduan~e $200.DQ:30days--ilweeksinaduarice Date of Previous Increase: Application Fee - 2001, Administrative Fee -New Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification Process: Notices about this new fee have been mailed to all repeat clients. The fee change has also been posted on the Community Events webpage and brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission onlanuary 20, 2011. Financial Assistance Program for Youth Participants: Not Applicable C6-35 PERMIT SERVICE: COMMUNITY EVENTS NEIGHBOR NOTIFICATION Description: The Neighbor Notification Fee for Community Events was set by Council resolution in 2001. It is assessed to organizers of permitted events to recover City costs of notifying neighbors in a particular area about an upcoming event that will have noise or traffic impacts. The fee was set at $150 for all Category 1 events. Category 2 & 3 events (expressive or first amendment), if there is adequate time to prepare the notice, are mailed at no cost to the event organizer. Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery Rate: 38% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 61% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should he imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market" and are helow those charged by ~ Verifying residency is practical and cos[ effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Index and/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available - The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Given that there are events in the City that extend beyond a fixed venue site and have noise or traffic impacts along the entire event route (e.g., races), neighbor notices need to be sent to a much larger number of residents. Therefore, staff is proposing that event organizers of events extending beyond a fixed venue site be charged for the actual cost of printing and postage if that amount exceeds $150. The fee will be based on the number of notices, mailed at a cost of %0.54 per piece which includes $0.10 printing charge and $0.44 postage charge. Fees will remain the same for Category 1 events at fixed venue sites. Notices for Category 2 and 3 events (expressive or first amendment) will continue to be mailed at no cost to the event organizer. NEIGHBOR NOTIFICATION EXTENDED VENUE SITE PROPOSED FEE EXTENDED NOTIFICATION # OF RESIDENTS/ BUSINESSES COST PER PIECE TOTAL LA Marathon Segment 1519 $0.54 $820.26 North Race Route SK 3633 $0.54 $1,961.82 St. John's SM 5000 300 $0.54 $162.00 5 & 1- K Classic 1507 $0.54 813.78 Cost per piece to be increased annually by CPI $3,757.86 C6-36 Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $3,758 Less $1s0 fee per event ($600) Net Projected Revenue Increase $3,158 Financial Assistance Program (FAP) for Youth Participants: Not Applicable Date of Previous Increase: 2001 Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification Process: Notices about fee increases were mailed to all repeat clients with events extending beyond a fixed venue site. The fee change was also posted on the Community Events website and brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-37 PERMIT SERVICES: LAWN BOWLING GREEN Description: The City's lawn bowling green, located in Douglas Park, is a unique recreational amenity made possible by a donation from Mr. Marcellus L. Joslyn in 1947. The green has been home to the Santa Monica Lawn Bowling Club who organizes olav each week for its membershio and hosts several regional lawn bowling tournaments each year. The Lawn Bowling Club volunteers host open houses and offer lessons in an effort to encourage the public to learn the sport and join the Club. Total Participants: Santa Monica Lawn Bowling Club (70 members) Community Benefit Level: Limited Community Access Current Cost Recovery Rate: 0% Proposed Cost Recovery Rate: 26% Primary Pricing Indicators Used: Indicators used to determine whether fees should be imoosed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: imoosed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand for activ"dY or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market' and are below those charged by Verifying residency is practical and cost effective comparable cities and/or service providers Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Indexand/orother increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a tee has not existed before or has not been raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Instituting or increasing the fee is not expected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Imposing higherfees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial Assistance is available - The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Current use of the lawn bowling green is limited to the Santa Monica Lawn Bowling Club. There are currently no fees established for the use of the bowling green. The Club also currently permits the Douglas Park Clubhouse at a rate of $2.51 per hour, increasing by CPI each year. Historically the Club has purchased maintenance equipment and performed light greens maintenance to supplement work performed by the City's landscape contractor. The City's maintenance contract for the lawn bowling green and minimal clerical support amounts to $6,085 per year. Staff proposes the Santa Monica Lawn Bowling Club pay an annual maintenance fee to the City of $1600. The amount equates to approximately 26% of the maintenance costs and approximately $2.00 per hour, based on their estimated average use of the green for the last three years. Based on a membership of 70, the additional annual cost per person is $22.86 per year or $1.90 per month. Gross Projected Revenue Increase $1,600 0% Decrease in oarticipation due to higher {ees (SOJ Net Projected Revenuelncrease $1,600 C638 Current fees with Comparisons Beverly Hills Annual maintenance fee of $1474.10 Hermosa Beach No fee. All maintenance is performed by the lawn bowlers San Clemente 50% of gross receipts, minimum ot$700 per year Alhambra $1200 - $1300 per year Santa Barbara 100% of annual maintenance contract and $4000 - $6000/year in utility costs Financial Assistance: Not Applicable Date of Previous Increase: New Fee Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification Process: Notices about fee were posted on the Community Recreation website, posted at Douglas Park and sent to the Santa Monica Lawn Bowling Club. The fee change was also brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-39 PERMIT SERVICE: COMMUNITY GARDENS Description: The community gardens are comprised of 120 plots in the City of Santa Monica, located at Main Street, Park Drive and Euclid Park. The gardens provide an opportunity for residents to exercise, practice sustainability, grow organic fruits, flowers and vegetables and meet neighbors with like interests. Total Participants: 120 plots (69 Main Street, 38 Park Drive, 13 Euclid Park) Community Benefit Level: Private Access Current Cost Recovery: 7%a Proposed Cost Recovery: 9% Primary Pricing Indicators Used Indicators used to determine whetherfees should be imposed or Indicators used to determine whether non-resident fees should be increased: - imposed or increased: Program or permit service does not meet targeted cost recovery ~ Demand far activity or permit service exceeds capacity level Fees are "under market" and are below those charged by ~ Veri m residen comparable cities and/or service providers ~'~ g n' is practical and cost effective Annual fee adjustments that are currently based on Consumer Price ~ A high percentage of participants or permittees are non- Index and/or other increases have not kept up with cost increases residents The activity or permit service warrants a fee and a fee has not existed before or has not keen raised in many years Increased fees are not expected to significantly decrease participation or use, thereby decreasing overall revenue Imposing higher fees are not expected to pose an economic hardship on most users Financial ASSirtance is available The fee is inequitable to other like activities or services Instituting or increasing the fee is not ezpected to result in an overall loss of revenue for the activity or service Projected Revenue & Calculation Basis: Proposed annual fees were developed by calculating cumulative CPI increase since the last fee restructure in FY 2003 and rounded to the nearest dollar. Current Fee Proposed Fee Increase Percentagelncrease $60.00 $75.00 $15.00 25% Gross Projected Revenuelncrease $2,000 0% Decrease in participation due to higher fees ($0) Net Projected Revenuelncrease $2,000 Current Fees and Comparisons: City Annual Fee LA-Ocean View Farms $30.00 LA-Sepulveda Garden Center $25.00 West Hollywood $100.00 Santa Monica $613.00 Los Angeles is raising plot fees to $120 beginning January, 2011 C6-40 Financial Assistance: Not applicable Date of Previous Increase: The current annual licensing fee was set in FY 2003. Effective Date of Proposed Increase: July 1, 2011 Public Notification Process: A notice about the fee increase was posted on the Community Recreation website and sent to all licensed gardeners. The fee increase was also brought before the Community Gardens Advisory Committee on January 12, 2011 and brought before the Recreation and Parks Commission on January 20, 2011. C6-41 ATTACHMENT C7 FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE GUIDELINES AND PROCEDURES CITY OF SANTA MONICA COMMUNITY & CULTURAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT COMMUNITY AND CULTURAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE San.n.,•,.;••a GUIDELINES AND PROCEDURES Financial Assistance for youth programs is offered by the City of Santa Monica's Community and Cultural Services Department. The Department administers the Financial Assistance program and verifies application and income information. Financial Assistance is available for childcare and recreational programs. The purpose of the Financial Assistance Program is to provide access to after school childcare, homework help, sports leagues, sports facilities, swim lessons, camps, and enrichment and community classes to Santa Monica youth who would not otherwise be able to afford these programs. Childcare programs include childcare, full-day day camps, middle school camps and combination full day camps. Levels of Financial Assistance range from 25% - 90%. Recreational programs include enrichment classes, sports leagues, sports facilities, aquatic classes, community classes, and mini-camps. Semi-private swim classes are not eligible. Levels of Financial Assistance range from 25% - 75%. A homeless family may qualify for 100% financial assistance. APPLICATION REQUIREMENTS In order to qualify for financial assistance a family must meet the following requirements: • Participants must be under age 18 at the beginning of the program. • Youth residing in Santa Monica may qualify for childcare programs and recreational programs. • Non-resident youth, while attending SMMUSD public schools on permit, may qualify for school-based programs only. Non-resident youth may qualify for summer childcare if the youth has been required to attend summer school. • Custodial parents or legal guardians must be employed for a minimum of 32 hours per week, be attending school full time (12 or more semester units or 9 or more quarter units), or be in the process of seeking employment (unemployment award and Work Seek form is required). CT-1 Exemptions from the employment and school requirement (income and family size guidelines still apply) are as follows: • Parents or guardians with children age five and under • Parents or guardians sixty years of age or older • Parents or guardians with a disability which temporarily or permanently prevents them from working VERIFICATION OF RESIDENCY Applicants must submit a copy of a government issued photo ID. In addition, one of the following is required as verification of residency: • Current Utility Bill (gas or electric) no PO Boxes • Rent Agreement • Mortgage Receipt • Section 8 Housing Verification • SMMUSD School Permit (for non-residents) VERIFICATION OF INCOME QUALIFICATION The following documentation must be attached for all adults in the home. • 1040 Income Tax Form For unemployed parents or guardians that do not have 1040 forms, SSI / EDD Quarterly Forms (In addition to this documentation, a work seek form must also be submitted quarterly.) Full-time Student Parents that do not have 1040 forms must submit proof of School Enrollment (required quarterly) Assistant levels are based on the following income scale: C7-2 Level 1 - 90% and 75% Level 2 - 75% and 50% Level 3 - 50% and 25% Level 4 - 25% and 25% APPLICATION PROCEDURE Applications are available by calling (310) 458-8540 or by picking one up at the Ken Edwards Center, Reed Park, the Santa Monica Swim Center or Virginia Avenue Park. The Financial Assistance application is also available via the web pages of these locations. The completed application is to be mailed, faxed or dropped off at the Ken Edwards Center, Reed Park, the Santa Monica Swim Center or Virginia Avenue Park. Verification of residency for each adult in the household must be attached to the application. Community Classes Office (KEC) 1527 4th Street Santa Monica, CA 90401 tel 310.458.2239 fax 310.899.0840 Youth Office at Reed Park 1133 7th Street Santa Monica, CA 90403 tel 310.458.8540 fax 310.451.3569 Swim Center Office 2225 16th Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 tel 310.458.8700 fax 310.450.5076 Virginia Avenue Park Office 2200 Virginia Avenue Santa Monica, CA 90404 tel 310.458.8688 fax 310.399.4326 Applicants will receive a letter regarding the financial assistance application within 7-10 business days. If applicants have not received a letter in the allotted time, they should call (310) 458-8540 for the status. To appeal a denied financial assistance application, a written request must be submitted to the Financial Assistance Coordinator. The Financial Assistance Appeals Committee will review written appeals and parents/guardians will be notified of the Committee's decision within ten business days. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The Financial Assistance period runs on a fiscal year basis July -June. Applications for the new fiscal year are available spring of the preceding fiscal year. Families who have previously received financial assistance will be required to reapply annually. • Incomplete applications will not be accepted and will be returned. C7-3 • All recipients of financial assistance must meet the stipulated eligibility criteria. We are unable to make exceptions for hardships or emergency situations. Staff will provide referrals to supportive services for families in crisis. • Financial Assistance awards are subject to a $300 cap per child, per calendar quarter. The cap applies to the discounted portion of the fees for participation in recreational programs of limited duration. Childcare programs are not subject to the cap. • If a family would like to use financial assistance in conjunction with program fees, they must apply for financial assistance at least four weeks before programming begins. Financial Assistance must be approved before registration and we cannot retroactively adjust payments. • Space in programs is limited and determined based on overall enrollment and financial assistance levels granted. • Poor program attendance may disqualify recipients from the program or from receiving financial assistance for participation in future programs. The City of Santa Monica is dedicated to providing families with the best possible youth programs.. Questions about financial assistance or other City programs can be answered at program offices. Revised 1/27/11 C7-4 Reference Resolution Nos. 10559 (CCS) through 10563 (CCS).