sr-062210-1c~;tYof City ®uncil Report
Santa Monica
City Council Meeting: June 22, 2010
Agenda Item: ~ _G
To: Mayor and City Council
From:. Marsha Jones Moutrie, City Attorney
Subject: Awarding Bid to Publish City's Legal Notices
Recommended Action
Staff recommends that the City Couhcil award a bid in the amount of $60,000 to the
Santa Monica Daily Press to publish the City's legal notices for FY2010-11, pursuant to
the requirements of Section 609 of the City Charter.
Executive Summary
State and local law require that legal notices, primarily relating to public bidding and
land-use matters, be published in a newspaper of general circulation. Santa Monica
City Charter Section 609 sets forth the procedures for annual selection of an official
newspaper for publication of legal notices. In accordance with Charter Section 609, the
City published a notice inviting bids to publish the City's legal notices during FY2010-11.
After reviewing the three bid proposals received, Staff recommends that the Santa
Monica Daily Press be selected at an approximate annual cost of $60,000, based on
expected total expenditures in FY2009-10.
Background
The Santa Monica Municipal Code and State law require that legal notices, primarily
items relating to public bidding and land use matters, be published in a newspaper of
general circulation published- in the City (SMMC Sec. 9.04.20.22.050) or, if there is
none, in a paper of general circulation published nearest to the City (Government Code
Sec. 6042). Under State law, a paper qualifies for adjudication by either 1) being
printed in the City for one year or 2) being published in the City for three years and
having a principal office of publication in the City.
1
Staff published a notice inviting bids and selected an official newspaper based on the
following criteria:
® Proof of adjudication in the City of Santa Monica
• Amount of bid (ad rate, which cannot exceed customary rates)
• Circulation (including copies per issue, documented readership)
Delivery methods (news racks, home delivery, on-line, other)
• Publication schedule (weekly, daily)
• Percentage of local news carried
Fiscallhtegrity
• Reputation of publication
The notice seeking bids was sent to a list of local publications on May 4, 2010; and
published in the Santa Monica Daily Press, the City's current newspaper of record,
three times between May 4 and May 14, 2010, with bids due May 19, 2010. The City
received four bids for legal advertising services from the Santa Monica Daily Press, the
Santa Monica Mirror, the Argonaut and the Santa Monica Observer.
Discussion
The Santa Monica Daily Press is being recommended for selection based on the criteria
outlined in the notice inviting bids. A summary of the selected vendor's proposal
appears below:
Publication Rate Circulation Delivery Methods Publication
Schedule % of Local
News
19,000 daily 6 issues
$12.75/col. print audited 750 box, rack and weekly,. Mon - °
Daily Press
inch (no min.)
& 3,000 drop locations; online Fri and 75 /o
online & paid subscriptions weekend
edition
The other bidders are the Santa Monica Mirror, the Observer Newspaper and the
Argonaut. The prices offered by the Mirror and the Argonaut were significantly higher -
$14.90 and $14.15 per column inch respectively. Both are published weekly, with the
the Mirror's circulation being 20,000 copies and the Argonaut's circulation being 30,000.
2
The Observer Newspaper offered a lower price of $10.00 per column inch; however,
circulation is also much lower than the other bidders at 5,000 copies and does not
represent a good value for the City
Staff is recommending the Santa Monica Daily Press for selection because it meets or
exceeds all of the criteria outlined in the request for bids and those offered by the other
bidders. The Daily Press' costs per column inch are less, while its circulation is greater.
The Daily Press, an adjudicated newspaper of general circulation since 2005, has a
daily audited circulation of 19,000 (114,000 weekly). The Daily Press publishes six
papers each week, offering citywide exposure and flexibility in its legal advertising. On
average, the Daily Press publishes over 50 original local news stories per week and
devotes a minimum of 75% of the newspaper to local news, opinion and other
commentary. In addition, the Daily Press has a good reputation as a paper of record in
the City of Santa Monica and has enjoyed an excellent working relationship with City
staff, offering a dedicated employee to service the City's account. The $12.75 per
column inch rate offered by the Daily Press is approximately 39% lower than its regular
open rate and represents the best value of the bids received. The City typically
publishes 4,500-5,000 column inches' worth of legal advertising in a fiscal year and can
expect costs up to $60,000 in FY2010-2011.
While the City Charter requires the selection of a single adjudicated newspaper for the
purpose of publishing legal notices, it should be noted that display advertising to inform
residents of City programs and services can and will continue to be placed in other local
newspapers, both print and on-line, within approved budget allocations. Also, certain
legal noticing, particularly Purchasing Officer bid notices that require dissemination
beyond Santa Monica's borders, will continue to be published in the Los Angeles Times
or other regional papers in addition to the Santa Monica Daily Press.
Financial Impacts and Budget Obligations
As of April 2010 (FY2009-10), the City has spent $47,465.09 to publish legal notices in
the Santa. Monica Daily Press (3,722.75 column inches). Based on the probable
3
purchase of a similar number of column inches in FY2010-11, the purchase order to be
awarded to the Santa Monica Daily Press. is $60,000. Funds are included in the
FY2010-11 budget at account number 01211.522520, Records & Election Services.
Prepared by: Joseph Lawrence, Assistant City Attorney
Approved:
d Y~Y~C-~i
Ma s a Jon Moutrie
City Attorn y
Forwarded to Council:
Rod Gould
City Manager
4