Loading...
SR-080527-8ACity Council Meeting: May 27, 2008x~55 Agenda Item: °°t~ To: Mayor and City Council, Chair and Members of the Parking Authority From: Andy Agle, Director of Housing and Economic Development Subject: Proposed Main Street Sidewalk and Lighting Assessment District Recommended Action Staff recommends that the City Council: 1. adopt a Resolution of Intention setting a public hearing on July 22, 2008, to consider forming an assessment district in the Main Street area to finance the ongoing operation and maintenance of the decorative festoon lighting, as well as additional sidewalk cleaning, and approving the Engineer's Report for the proposed assessment district; and 2. authorize the City Manager and Executive Director of the Parking Authority to sign ballots in support of formation of the Assessment District for their properties that will be assessed within the new district. Executive Summary The City in cooperation with the Main Street Business Improvement Association ("MSBIA") engaged Harris & Associates to assist with the formation of an assessment district in the Main Street area to finance additional sidewalk cleaning and the ongoing operation and maintenance of the festoon lighting along Main Street. Harris Associates has proposed forming the assessment district pursuant to the provisions of the Benefit.Assessment Act of 1982. The annual assessment is estimated to be $88,632 -for 157. properties. This amount will pay for additional sidewalk cleaning, electricity and maintenance of the existing festoon lighting, a reserve fund, and debt service on a loan in the amount of $132,000 which is the estimated cost to replace the existing bulbs during the term of the assessment district. It is anticipated that the City will provide a loan to the proposed assessment district for the festoon lighting bulb replacement cost to be repaid over five years at 7%. An additional action item approving the loan will be required at the time Council is asked to approve the assessment district. Council is asked to adopt the attached Resolution of Intention, setting July 22, 2008, as the date for a public hearing to count the ballots from property owners regarding formation of the district, and to authorize the City Manager and Executive Director of the 1 Parking Authority,. to sign ballots for their properties in support of district formation. The annual assessment on City-owned and Parking Authority-owned property under the proposed district is $7,873.91 or 8.88% of the total. assessment and would become an annual obligation of the City in its Operating Budget. Background The MSBIA funds various promotional materials and events on behalf of Main Street merchants through revenues generated by an annual assessment on businesses which is collected by the City with the Business License fee. In 2002, the City budgeted $250,000 as construction mitigation ("Mitigation Funds") for business disruption and loss caused by a sewer rehabilitation project ih the area. The MSBIA explored various options for use of the Mitigation Funds and determined that the most beneficial use would be for the design, installation, operation and maintenance of permanent festival lighting in the Main Street area. Such lighting would enhance the evening atmosphere and business vitality, The MSBIA explored a number of design possibilities for the decorative lighting and chose a Lumisphere xenon light product from England. This light was chosen partly for its substantial appearance, and partly for its durability, as the product is rated to last five years or longer in a marine environment. -With funds from the budget set-aside, the City retained GRT & Associates to prepare engineering specifications, plans, and structural calculations based on using these lights on the existing light poles. On October 12, 2004, the City authorized agrant- and license agreement to MSBIA to fund the installation of the lights. MSBIA .conducted an RFP process and selected Associated Group as the lighting contractor to install the Lumisphere xenon lighting. In 2005, decorative or "festoon" lights were installed along both sides of Main Street, between Pico Boulevard on the north, extending to the southern City boundary just south of Marine Street. MSBIA has been maintaining the decorative lights on a quarterly basis. Thus far, the operating and maintenance costs associated with the decorative lights have been reimbursed to the MSBIA from the 2 remainder of the original grant, but the remaining grant will be fully expended by the end of 2008. In 2007, Main Street merchants expressed a desire that the MSBIA explore options for additional sidewalk cleaning. The City of Santa Monica currently provides two (2) thorough sidewalk cleanings in the area annually. MSBIA contracted with the City's Solid Waste Management Division to provide monthly sidewalk cleanings for $1,200/month, an amount equivalent to the City's cost. Discussion In early 2007, MSBIA recognized that it needed additional funds to continue paying for the festoon lighting and additional sidewalk cleaning. For FY 2007-08, the City Council approved aone-time appropriation for MSBIA in the amount of $25;000 to be used for the continued maintenance of the festival lighting on Main Street, $50,000. for a Main Street Assessment Study and $9,600 for additional sidewalk cleaning. In cooperation with MSBIA, the City conducted a Request for Proposal process and selected Harris & Associates to assist with analyzing the formation. of a new assessment district in the Main Street area to finance the replacement and on-going maintenance of the xenon festoon lighting and the additional sidewalk cleaning. Harris' sub-consultant, MIG, Inc. was responsible. for public outreach. Harris & Associates has proposed. forming the Main Street assessment district (called the "Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District") pursuant to the provisions of the Benefit Assessment Act of 1982 ("1982 Act"). The 1982 Act requires that maintenance assessments be levied according to benefit. Section 54711 provides that the "amount of the assessment imposed on any parcel of property shall be related to the benefit to the parcel which will be derived from the provision of the service." In addition, Proposition 218, which added Article XIIID to the California Constitution, requires that a parcel's assessment may not exceed the reasonable cost for the 3 proportional special benefit conferred on that parcel. It also requires that publicly owned properties which benefit from the improvements be assessed The proposed annual assessment is .approximately $88,632. This includes the annual operating and maintenance costs associated with the xenon festoon lighting ($25,300); a replacement reserve ($4,600); and the annual costs for the sidewalk cleaning .($23,320). The assessment also includes debt service in the amount of $35,412, which is the amount needed to repay $132,000, the cost of xenon light bulb replacement at a rate of 7% over five years. It is anticipated that the City will loan the assessment district these funds. The annual assessment may increase over time due to annual CPI increases which are built into the methodology formula. Originally, MSBIA intended to raise funds through the assessment district to pay for replacement of the xenon bulbs with more energy efficient LED lights. While the on- going maintenance and energy use of the lights would be lower, the acquisition and installation cost of the LED lights was estimated to be $600,000. A survey of property owners revealed that the annual assessment was not supportable. In addition, a demonstration of the LED lights did not generate as much light as did the xenon.: If LED technology improves and creates a light that is better suited to the needs of the Main Street business community, MSBIA would hope to initiate another process to establish a district that would include LED lights. The costs for the bulb replacement program and to operate the Festoon Lights along Main Street are spread among the properties adjacent to Main Street based on the area of the property. The costs for the sidewalk cleaning are spread to the parcels directly adjacent to the sidewalks being cleaned based on the linear feet (LF) of frontage being cleaned: 4 Annual assessments range from $24.59 to $4,418.96. The median total assessment is $332.05, as shown below: Assessment Rate Calculation Table Improvements FY 2008-09 Assessment Maximum Median Estimated Units FY 2008-09 Annual Bud et / = Assessment Rate* Assessment Festoon Lights Bulb $35,412 / 17.293 Benefit = $2,047.82/Benefit $137.20 Replacement Acres Acre (assessed for 5 years onl ) Festoon Lighting O & M $29,900 / 17.293 = $1,729.07/Benefit $115.85 Benefit Acres Acre Sidewalk Cleaning $23,320 / 14,814.96 = $1.58/LF $79.00 Linear Feet me maximum ut~m ugnnng and sidewalk cleaning rates will be increased annually for cost of living. The attached Assessment Diagram shows the boundaries of the district. The lines and dimensions of each parcel within the District are those lines and dimensions shown on the maps of the Assessor of the County of Los Angeles. In order for the assessment to be on the property tax rolls for FY 2008-09, the assessment must be submitted to the County of Los Angeles by August 10, 2008. The Council is requested to adopt the attached resolution of intention to form the assessment district. Notices of the City's intent to form an assessment district; and to hold a public hearing will be mailed to property owners forty-five (45) days in advance of the public hearing., The mailing is anticipated to occur on June 6, 2008, and the public hearing is expected to be held on July 22, 2008. Ballots, to be marked in support of or in opposition to the proposed assessment district, will be included with the notices. For ballots to be counted, they must be submitted to the City Clerk prior to the close of the public hearing on the issue. Notice of the public hearing will be published in the Santa Monica Daily Press. After the public hearing has been conducted, the assessment ballots that are submitted prior to the close of the public hearing will. be tabulated based on the proposed 5 assessment amount. It is anticipated. that the ballot tabulation will occur the same night as the public hearing and that the City Council will be able to receive the results of the balloting that evening. If more than 50% of the ballots returned, weighted by the assessments, are against the proposed assessment district, then a majority protest has occurred and the assessment district cannot be formed. If less than a majority protest is received, then the City Council may choose to adopt a Resolution of Formation for the assessment district and levy assessments. The attached Engineer's Report, which has been prepared for this project, establishes the formula used to distribute the costs of providing the services to the benefiting Previous Council Actions On November 12, 2002 Council approved various contracts and expenditures for the Ocean and Main Street Sewer Rehabilitation Project, including setting aside $250,000 of Mitigation Funds into a special Public Works Fund to fihance future capital improvements in the area. From this budget allocation, $26,428.62 was expended for the preparation of the electrical specifications, plans and structural calculations. The grant amount to MSMA of $220,000 covered its contract cost of $205,000 with Associated Group and provided ah additional $15,000 for other operational project costs. On September 20, 2004, an Information Item was presented to Council to view the design. On September 28, 2004, City Council approved the grant of Mitigation Funds to MSBIA and authorized the City Manager to enter into. a License Agreement in the amount of $220,000 for the design, installation, maintenance and operation of the festival lighting system improvements. 6 In the FY 2007-08 Budget, Council allocated $50,000 to be used for a Main Street Assessment Study; $25,000 to be used toward operation and maintenance of the festival lights; and $9,600 for sidewalk cleaning. Alternatives If the assessment. district is not approved, MSBIA will continue to pay for the operating expenses and maintenance .costs associated with the xenon festoon lighting until the City grant funds are depleted. It is anticipated that the MSBIA will continue to operate the existing festoon lighting on a decreased schedule until full replacement of the xenon bulbs is needed. At that time, MSBIA may remove the festoon lights from Main Street because of the high replacement costs. If the assessment district is not approved, MSBIA will continue to pay for the sidewalk cleaning until the City grant funds are depleted. At that time, MSBIA may continue to pay for less supplemental sidewalk cleaning per annum. Environmental Analysis The recommended Council action is exempt from CEQA under Section 15301, Existing Facilities. Contractor/Consultant Selection The City issued a Request for Proposal to eight assessment engineering firms and received three responses. A selection committee composed of City staff and representatives of MSBIA selected Harris & Associates. The City's contract is with Harris & Associates who has retained MIG, Inc. as asub-consultant to assist with public outreach. Public Outreach MIG attempted to contact 23 people and was able to complete 11 preliminary telephone "stakeholder" interviews with property owners representing 12.0% of the total proposed 7 assessment to gauge their level of support for the program that called for replacement of xenon lights with LED lights and sidewalk cleaning. In addition, NIIG's interviews asked the stakeholders if there were elements of the proposed bulb replacement and sidewalk cleaning program that they specifically supported or didn't support, service levels that they would support and. an assessment threshold they would find to be acceptable. MIG worked with City and MSBIA staff to develop a community presentation and a fact sheet. The fact sheet was mailed to all property owners in the Main Street area and it announced the community meeting that was held on April 17th at The Victorian. It also provided some background information on the proposed LED replacement program and sidewalk cleaning, and a brief agenda for the community meeting as well as a tear-off comment card that could be mailed back to the City if the property owner wanted to state his/her opinion in writing. The City received four written/oral responses to the Fact Sheet. The community meeting held oh April 17th- at The Victorian attracted two (2) stakeholders. Both stated that they would be in support of the proposed bulb replacement and sidewalk cleaning program. Due to the low response to the first Fact Sheet mail-out and the low turn-out at the community meeting, the City and MSBIA are hosting a second community meeting on May 22"d. A revised fact sheet announcing the 2nd Community Meeting and the revised proposed bulb replacement and sidewalk cleaning program is being mailed. The results of that community meeting will be reported to Couhcil at the meeting of May 27tH Financial Impacts & Budget Actions If approved, the assessment district would require. a loan from the City in the amount of $132,000 to be repaid from the assessments over a 5-year period at 7% interest. The Council will be asked to approve this loan at the public hearing on July 22, 2008. 8 City- and Parking Authority-owned property represents 8.88% of the total assessment. The annual assessments associated with the City of Santa Monica properties total $5,792.88 and the annual assessments associated with the Santa Monica City Parking Authority properties total $2,081.03. Prepared by: Erika Cavicante, Senior Administrative Analyst Forwarded to Council: Andy Agle, C Housing and '" P/Larfiont Ewell Development ~, Manager Attachments: Attachment 1 Diagram Attachment 2 Attachment 3 Main Street Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District Engineer's Report Resolution of Intention 9 Attachment 1 Main Street Business Area Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District Assessment Diagram Engineer's Report for the Main Street Business Area Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District (Fiscal Year 2008-09) Prepared under the provisions of the Benefit Assessment Act of 9982 For the CITY OF SANTA MONICA Los Angeles County, California Prepared by: Hdrr15 ~t /ai550~'Idt@5 Apri123, 2008 City. of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District - FY 2008-09 Page i ENGINEER'S REPORT CITY OF SANTA MONICA MAIN STREET BUSINESS AREA FESTOON LIGHTING AND SIDEWALK CLEANING ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FISCAL YEAR 2008.09 TABLE OF CONTENTS Report ...................................................................... Part A -Plans and Specifications .................................. Part B -Estimate of Cost ............................................... Part C -.Method of Apportionment......... _ ...................... Part D -Assessment Diagram ................... _................... Part E -Assessment Roll ................................................ q:\santa monica\msbia 82 acflreportslsta monica msbia lights sdwk ad gyp[ 23apN8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 1 CITY OF SANTA MONICA FISCAL YEAR 2008.09 ENGINEER'S REPORT PREPARED PURSUANT TO THE PROVISIONS OF THE BENEFIT ASSESSMENT ACT OF 1982 ARTICLE 4, CHAPTER 6.4 OF THE CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE Pursuant to Part 1, Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government of the State of Califomia, and in accordance with the Resolution of Initiation adopted by the City Council of the City of Santa Monica, State of California, in connection with the proceedings for: MAIN STREET BUSINESS AREA FESTOON LIGHTING AND SIDEWALK CLEANING ASSESSMENT DISTRICT Hereinafter referred to as the "Assessment District" or "District", I, Joan E. Cox, P.E., the authorized representative of Hams &. Associates, the duly appointed ASSESSMENT ENGINEER, submit herewith the "Report" consisting of five (5) parts as follows: PART A PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS Plans and specifications for the existing and ultimate improvements are as set forth on the lists thereof, attached hereto, and aze on file in the Housing and Economic Development Department and are incorporated herein by reference. PART B ESTIMATE OF COST The estimated cost to be funded by the District for the operation, servicing and maintenance of the improvements for fiscal yeaz 2008-09, including incidental costs and expenses in connection therewith. PART C METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT The method of apportionment of assessments indicates the proposed assessment of the net amount of the costs and expenses of the maintenance and/or servicing of the existing and ultimate improvements to be assessed upon the several lots and parcels of land within the Assessment District in proportion to the estimated special benefits to be received by such lots and parcels. q:\santa monicaUnsbia S2 actkeports\sfa manica msbia lights sdwl: ad ipt 23api0g.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment Qistrict- FY 2008-09 Page 2 PART D ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM The Assessment Diagram, which shows the exterior boundaries of the Assessment District, the boundaries of any zones within the Assessment District and the lines and dimensions of each lot or parcel of land within the Assessment District, is provided herein. The lines and dimensions of each lot or parcel within the Assessment District are those lines and dimensions shown on the maps of the Assessor of the Cormty of Los Angeles for the fiscal yeaz to which this Report applies. The Assessor's maps and records are incorporated by reference herein and made part ofthis Report. PART E ASSESSMENT ROLL An assessment of the estimated cost of the improvements on each benefited lot or parcel of land within the Assessment District is provided herein. The undersigned respectfully submits the enclosed report as directed by the City Council. The undersigned certifies that she is a Professional Engineer, registered in the State of California. DATED:. Apri123, 2008 Harris & Associates BY: Joan E. Cox, P.E. R.C.E. No. 41965 E. NO. 47965 KP. 3/37/10 q:\santa monica\msbia S2 acflreports\sta monica msbia Gets sdw$ ad rpt 23api0S.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 3 PART A PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS FOR THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA MAINSTREET BUSINESS AREA FESTOON LIGHTING AND SIDEWALK CLEANING ASSESSMENT DISTRICT FISCAL YEAR 2008-09 The facilities, which have been constmeted within the Main Street Business Area of the City of Santa Monica, and those which may be subsequently constmcted, will be serviced and maintained as generally described as follows: Festoon Li tin, Overall bulb replacement (initial year) and on-going operation and maintenance. Improvements include but are not limited to: fixtures, bulbs, conductors, equipment including guys, anchors, metering devices, controllers and appurtenant facilities as required to provide festoon lighting in Main Street, from Pico Boulevard to south of Marine Street within the boundaries of said Assessment District. Maintenance means the furnishing of services and materials for the ordinary and usual operation, maintenance and servicing of the festoon lighting improvements or appurtenant. Operating and servicing means the furnishing of electric energy for the festoon lighting improvements or appurtenant facilities, the operation of controllers and the administration of all aspects of the maintenance and the District. Sidewalk Cleanine Steam cleaning of the sidewalks 10-times per year (in addition to the City's standard ttivice a yeaz cleaning) and once a month spot cleaning. Improvements include but aze not limited to: sidewalks, curb and gutter, curb. ramps and appurtenant facilities in public rights-of--way within the boundaries of said Assessment District. Maintenance means the famishing of services and materials for the cleaning and servicing of the sidewalk improvements or appurtenant facilities including steam cleaning. Operating and servicing means the administration of all aspects of the maintenance and the District. The plans and specifications for the improvements, showing the general nature, location and the extent of the improvements, aze on file in the Housing and Economic Development Department and are by reference herein made a part of this report. q:~santa monica~msbia 82 act~reporfs~sta manica msbia li8hts sdwk ad ipt 23apA8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lightng and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 4 PART B ESTIMATE OF COST The City's budget for the operation, maintenance and servicing of festoon lighting and sidewalk cleaning, shown below, details the estimated costs for Fiscal Year 2008-09 as available at the time of preparation of this report. The incidehtal expenses may include engineering fees, legal fees, printing, mailing, postage, publishing, and all other related costs identified with the district proceedings Funds raised by the assessment shall be used only for the purpose as stated herein. A contribution to the District by the City may be made to reduce assessments or maintenance maybe deferred to reduce the overall annual cost, which in turn would reduce the assessment, as the City Council deems appropriate annually. Any balance or deficit remaining on July 1 must be carried over to the next fiscal year. Estimated Annual Improvements Budget Festoon Lighting Bulb Replacement Est. Replacement Costs $110,000 City Administration and Contingency (20%) $22,000 $132,000 Est. Annual Cost 5 years @ 7% interest $32,193.. .Annual Administration (10%) $3 219 Year 1 of 5: $35,412 Festoon Lights O&M Electricity $17,000 Maintenance $6,000 $23,000 Annual Administration (10%) $2,300 Replacement Reserve (20°/0) $4,600 $29,900 Sidewalk Cleaning $21,200 Annual Administration {10%) $2,120 $23,320 Total Est. Annual Budget $88,632 q:\sanfa monica~nsbia 82 act\reports\sta monica msbia lights sdwk ad ipt 2iapA8.dac City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District - FY 2008-09 Page 5 PART C METHOD OF APPORTIONMENT Introduction The Benefit Assessment Act of 1982 (hereinafter referred to as the "1982. Act") permits the establishment of assessment districts by cities for the purpose of providing certain public improvements which include the maintenance and operation costs of streets and street lighting services. "Streets" as defined herein is based on the definitions provided by the Office of the Controller for the State of Califomia in the Guidelines Relating to Gas Tax Expenditures published by the Division of Local Government Fiscal Affairs. The state's gas tax program is administered in city agencies, but audited by the Office of the State Controller. The proceeds of the gas tax are statutorily limited to expenditures for streets and roads. Because the funds are restricted to street and road costs, the State Controller has developed "Street Purpose Definitions and Guidelines" based on the Manual of Uniform Highway Accounting and Financial Management Procedures developed by the American Association of State Highway Officials. "Streets", as iY relates to this District, is defined as the operation or maintenance of facilities within the right-of--way used for street or road purposes. The 1982 Act. requires that maintenance assessments be levied according to benefit. Section 54711 provides that the "amount of the assessment imposed on any pazcel of property shall be related to the benefit to the parcel which will be derived from the provision of the service". Additionally, Section 54715(c) of the 1982 Act permits the designation of zones of benefit within any individual assessment district "on a parcel, class of improvement to property, or use of property basis, or a combination thereof'. -Thus, the 1982 Act requires the levy of a true "assessment" rather than a "special tax." In addition, Proposition 218, which added Artich XIIID to the California Constitution, requires that a parcel's assessment may not exceed the reasonable cost for the proportional special benefit conferred on that pazcel. Article XIIID provides that only special benefits are assessable and the City must separate the general benefits from the special benefits. It also requires that publicly owned properties which benefit from the improvements be assessed. This report establishes the formula to be used to distribute .the costs of providing the services described in this report to the benefiting parcels within the City. q:\santa monicalmsbia 82 acAreportsCsta monica msbia fi8hts sdwk ad rp[ 23apA8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area Apri123, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District - FY 2008-09 Page 6 Benefit Analysis A. Festoon Lights along Main Street Special Benefits. The Festoon Lights along Main Street are in addition to the streetlights already in place. Therefore, these lights provide enhancement of the existing lighting. The Festoon Lights provide additional community character and vitality to the properties along Main Street, in that they: • Promote social interaction, • Promote business and industry, • Contribute to a positive nighttime visual image, and • Enhance pedestrian safety Therefore, all properties along Main Street receive direct and special benefit from the additional community character and vitality provided by the Festoon Lighting. There aze a variety of land uses within the benefiting area, includmg residential and commercial uses, mixed residential and commercial uses, institutional uses (such as church, library and museum), pazking lots and access ways, and parks. Dffferent land uses benefit differently from the additional lighting. • Commercial properties are considered to benefit from all four aspects of the additional community character and vitality; therefore, they receive a benefit factor of 1. • Mixed use parcels, with commercial on the bottom floors and residential on the top floors; aze considered to benefit the same as commercial properties; therefore, they also receive a benefit Factor of 1. • Institutional properties, such as libraries, museums and community gardens, aze considered to benefit from the promotion of social interaction and the enhancement of pedestrian safety, which are two of the four aspects; therefore, they receive a benefit factor of one-half (0.5). • Park properties are essentially vacant properties but are used for social interaction. Therefore, park properties aze considered to benefit from the promotion of social intemction and from enhanced pedestrian safety; therefore, they also receive a benefit factor of one-half (0.5). • Residential properties are not considered to receive significant benefits from the additional lighting except for enhanced pedestrian safety; therefore, these properties receive a benefit factor of one-fourth (0.25). • Pazking lots and access ways, which serve the properties azound them,. aze essentially vacant land uses. As such, they do not benefit from most of the additional community chazacter and vitality aspects; however, they do benefit from enhanced pedestrian safety, as their primary function is getting people to and from the surrounding properties; therefore, these properties receive a benefit factor ofone-fourth (0.25). Public properties are assessed the same as private properties. General Benefit. No general benefits from the improvements are considered to exist. General benefits, if any, to the surrounding community and public in general from festoon lighting are nominal, intangible and are not quantifiable. q:\san[a monica\msbia 82 act\reports\sta monica msbia lights sdwk ad rpt 23aprt18.doc City of Santa Monica -Main. Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 7 B. Sidewalk Cleaning Special Benefit. Steam cleaning of the sidewalks removes dirt and debris from the sidewalks being cleaned.. This creates a cleaner environment adjacent to properties and provides a service that property owners aze usually responsible for. Therefore; Sidewalk Cleaning is considered a direct and special benefit to those properties directly adjacent to the sidewalks being cleaned. For condominium properties of multiple stories, such as the condominium parcels at the southeast corner of Main and Marine, the benefit is considered to the bottom floor parcels that aze on the same level as the cleaned sidewalk. General Benefit. No general benefits from the improvements are considered to exist. General benefits, if any, to the surrounding community and public in general from sidewalk cleaning are nominal, intangible and are not quantifiable. Apportionment Methodology A. Festoon Lights along Main Street The costs to install and operate the Festoon Lights along Main Street aze spread to the properties adjacent to Main Street based on the area of the property, in acres, multiplied by the appropriate Benefit Factor. (Acreage is calculated by dividing the property square feet (sf) by 43,560 sf per acre.) Pazcel size is used as the base unit of lighting benefit because the benefits of community character and vitality goes to how much a property is used versus how much a property fronts the lights. The more a properly is used, the more it benefits from the additional lighting: Street frontage along Main Street was not used. because of the inconsistency of depths and parcel shapes within this azea. An example of this is thiee parcels in this azea, each with 50 feet of frontage along Main Street, but with varying parcel azeas of 5,000 sf, 3,970 sf, and 1,940 sf. Therefore, street frontage was not considered to be a fair indicator of benefit for lighting. The formula for calculating the Benefit Acres for each property is (Pazcel Acres) x (Benefit Factor) =Benefit Acres B. Sidewalk Cleaning The costs for the Sidewalk Cleaning aze spread to the parcels directly adjacent to the sidewalks being cleaned based on the linear feet (LF) of frontage being cleaned, Frontage is considered an appropriate because sidewalk cleaning is considered to be a service that that property owners aze usually responsible for. Therefore, each property is assessed based on the amount of frontage directly adjacent to the property. q:~santa monica~msbia 82 act~reportslsta monica msbia liglrts sdwk ad Ipt 23aprtl8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008. Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 8 Assessment Rate Calculation The table below provides the assessment apportionment for the areas of benefit and shows the maximum annual assessment rate for FY 2008-09. FY 2008-09 Maximum Estimated FY 2008-09 Improvements Budgef / Asmt Units = Asmt Rate* Festoon Lights Bulb Replacement $35,412 / 17.293 Benefit Acres = $2,047.82 /Benefit Acre (assessed for 5 years only) Festoon Lighting O & M $29,900 / 17.293 Benefit Acres = $1,729.D7 /Benefit Acre Sidewalk Cleaning $23,320 f 14,814.96 Linear Feet _ $1.58 / LF * The maximum annual maintenance assessment rates (for festoon lighting O & M and sidewalk cleaning) will be increased each subsequent Fiscal Year by the annual change in the Consumer Price Index (CPI), during the preceding year, for All Urban Consumers, for the Los Angeles, Riverside and Orange County areas, published by the United States Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics (or a reasonably .equivalent index should the stated index be discontinued). The actrial assessments levied in any fiscal year will be as approved by the City Council and may not exceed the .maximum assessment rate without receiving property owner approval for the increase. q:\sanfa monica\msbia S2 act~reports~sta monica msbia lights sdwl; ad rpt 23aprO8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 9 PART D ASSESSMENT DIAGRAM The Assessment Diagrams, showing the exterior boundaries of the each Zone within the District, are provided on the following pages. The lines and dimensions of each lot or pazcel within the District aze those lines and dimensions shown on the maps of the Assessor of the County of Los Angeles for the fiscal year to which this report applies. The Assessor s maps and records are incorporated by reference herein and made part of this report. q:\santa monica\msbia 82 act\reports~sta monica msbia lights sdwk ad rpt 23apA8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighfing and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District - FY 2008-09 Page 10 City of Santa Monica Main Street Business Area Festoon Lighting and. Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District Assessment Diagram Sheet 1 of 4 •----. District Boundary --- -Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning ••---•---i-• Sidewalk Gleaning tanly q:\santa monica\msbia 82 act\reports\sta monica msbia lights sdwl: ad Ipt 23apN8.dac City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 11 City of Santa Monica Main Street BusinessArea Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Gleaning Rssessment District Rssessment Diagram Sheet 2 of 4 1 Assessment Number 0 Parcel ® Not a Part Distric# Boundary ----- Festoon t.ighting and Sidewalk Cleaning •-••-•••-•••- Sidewalk Cleaning dnly q:\san[a monica\msbia 82 acf~reports\Sta monica msbia lights sdwk ad ipt 23apA8.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District - FY 2008-09 Page 12 City of Santa Monica Main Street Business Area Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District Assessment Diagram Sheet 3 of 4 1 Assessment Number Parcel Not a Part pistrfct Boundary ----- Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning ••••-•••-•••• Sidewalk Cleaning only q:\santa monica\msbia 82 acdreportslsta monica msbia fights sdwk ad apt 23apr08.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area Apri123, 2008 Festoon Lighfing and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 13 City of Santa Monica Main Street Business Area Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Gleaning Assessment District Assessment Diagram Sheet 4 of 4 ~a a n~a~. t3s F' 13T. ~ 138 123 `122. 24 t2 .139 ?zT aa_ 125 728.t2 ..tot 1311 742 14 `15~~~ 313 ~O4 445.. ~~ 14 ye 134 ;~' Q~0 ~ 732 13S 752 P/~ O,JJ__ e o'y 14T ~5t ~~\~ 15Q Ts~ .151 154 157 749 x WE °6%%lli!!ll~~~ 153 1 l~ssessment Number 0 Parcel ® Not a Part District Boundary -- -- Festoon Lfghting:and Sidewalk Cleaning -••••••••••-- Sidewalk Cleaning Only q:\santa monica\msbia 82 act\repord\sta monica msbia fie~ts sdwk ad apt 23apr08.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area Apri123, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 14 PART E ASSESSMENT ROLL The total proposed assessment for Fiscal Yeaz 2008-09 -and the amount of the total proposed assessment apportioned to each lot or parcel within the District, as sho~~~n on the latest assessment roll at the Los Angeles County Assessor's Office, are provided on the following pages. The description of each lot or pazcel is part of the records of the Assessor of the County of Los Angeles and these records aze, by reference, made part of this Report. q:\santa monica\msbia 82 act\reports~sta monica msbia fights sdwk ad rpt 23aprtl8.dw City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 15 c=axb h=f+g i k=d+e+i Festoon Festoon Festoon Festoon Total Festoon Lighting Lighting Light Bulb ~ Lighting Sidewalk Sidewalk Total Maximu m Map Assessor's Land Lighting Benefit Benefit Replacem't ORM Main St Side-St Sidewalk Sidewalk FY OB-09 Property Address No. Parcel No. Use Acres Factor Acres Asmt Asmt LF LF LF Asmt Asmt 144 PICO BLVD 1918 1 4289020004 Commercial 0.366 1.00 0.386 $790.46 $667.42 120 .00 .140.00 260 .00 $410.80 $1,868. 68 MAIN ST 2 4289020005 Commercial 0.207 1.00 0.207 $423.90 $357.92 60 .00 0.00 60 .00 $94.80 $876 62 145 BAY ST ~ 1 3 4289020006 Mixed Use 0.414 1.00 0.414 $847.80 $715.83 120 .00 150.00 270 .00 $426.60 . $1,990. 23 901 MAIN ST 4 4289019024 Commercial 0.240 1.00 0.240 $491.48 $414.98 45 .00 120.00 165. 00 $260.70 $1 167 16 1907 MAIN 1 ST 5 4289019025 Parkin !Access 0.232 0.25 0.058 $118.77 $100.29 84 .00 0.00 84. 00 $132.72 , . $351. 78 913 MAIN ST 6 4289019005 Parkin /Access 0.116 0.25 0.029 $59.39 $50.14 42 .00 0.00 42. 00 $66.36 $175 89 211 BAY ST 7 4289019006 Commercial 0.240 1.00 0.240 $491.48 $414.98 87 .00 120.00 207. 00 $327.06 . $1 233 52 2000 MAIN ST 8 4289020021 Mixed Use. 1.170 1.00 1.170 $2,395.95 $2,023.01 .301 .60 338.70 640. 30 $1,011.67 , . $5 430 63 2003 MAIN ST 9 4289018001 Commercial 0.276 1.00 0.276 $565.20 $477.22 120 .00 100.00 220. 00 $347.60 , . $1 390. 02 2015 MAIN ST 10 4289018003 Commercial 0.207 1.00 0.207 $423.90 $357.92 60 .00 0.00 60. 00 $94.80 , $876 62 2021 MAIN 2104 M ST 11 4289018054 Mized Use 0.413 1.00. 0.413 $845.75 $714.11 120 .48 150.16 270. 64 $427.61 . $1,987. 47 AIN ST 12 4289021011 Commercial 0.069 1.00 0.069 $141.30 $119.31 60. 00 50.00 110. 00 $173.80 $434 41 2110 MAIN 21 ST 13 4289021012 Commercial 0.207 1.00 0.207 $423.90 $357.92 60. 00 0.00 60. 00 $94.80 . $876. 62 16 MAIN ST 14 ~ 4289021013 Mixed Use 0.206 1.00 0.206 $421.85 $356.19 60. 00 0.00 60. 00 $94.80 $872 84 2150 MAIN ST 15 4289021902 Park 0.413 0.50 0.207 $422.87 $357.05 120. 00. 150.00 270. 00 $426.60 . $1,206. 52 2101 MAIN ST 16 4289017001 Commercial 0.110 1.00 0.110 $225.26 $190.20 120. 00 .40.00 160. 00 $252.80 $668. 26 2113 MAIN 2115 MAI ST 17 4289017005 Commercial 0.206 .1.00 0.206 $421.85 $356.19 60. 00 0.00 60. 00 $94.80 $872. 84 N ST 18 4289017006 Parkin /Access 0.138 0.25 0.035 $70.65 $59.65 60. 00 0.00 60. 00 $94.80 $225 10 201 PACIFIC ST 2 19 4289017007 Commercial 0.138 1.00 0.138 $282.60 $238.61 60. 00 100.00 160. 00 $252.80 . $774. 01 200 MAIN ST 20 4289022054 Mized Use 0.088 1.00 0.088 $180.21. $152.16 60. 00 63.93 123. 93 $195.81 $528. 18 2210 MAIN ST 21 4289022078 Commercial 0.119 1.00 ~ 0.119 $243.69 $205.76 40. 00 0.00 40. 00 $63.20 $512 65 2216 MAIN 2218 M ST 22 4289022017 Commercial 0.120 1.00. 0.120 $245.74 $207.49 40. 00 0.00 40. 00 $63.20 . $516. 43 AIN ST 23 4289022016 Commercial 0.120 1.00 0.120 . $245.74 $207.49 40. 00 0.00 40 00 $63 20 $516 43 2222 MAIN ST 24 4289022015 Mixed Use 0.060 1.00 0.060 $122.87 $103.74 40. 00 0.00 . 40. 00 . $63.20 . $289 81 2224 MAIN ST 25 4289022013 Mixed Use 0.119 1.00 0.119 $243.69 $205.76 40. 00 0.00 40. 00 $63.20 . $512 65 2230 MAIN 214 ST 26 4289022012 Commercial. 0.058 1.00 0.058 $118.77 $100.29 40. 00 62.50 102. 50 $161.95 . $381. 01 PACIFIC ST 27 4289016029 Mixed Use 0.413 1.00 0.413 $845.75 $714.11 60. 00 150.00 210. 00 $331.80 $1 891. 66 2215 MAIN ST 28 4289016003 Commercial 0.206 1.00 0.206 $421.85 $356.19 25. 00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 , $817. 54 2219 MAIN ST 29 4289016025 Commercial 0.413 1.00 0.413 $845.75 $714.11 120. 00 150.00 270. 00 ~ $426.60 $1 986. 46 2303 NEILSON WAY 30 4289023905 Institutional 0.751 0.50 0.376 $768.96 $649.27 223. 53 290.13 513. 66 $811.58 , $2,229. 81 2301 MAIN ST 31 4289015023 - Commercial 0.129 1.00 0.129 $264.17 $223.05 48. 00 116.30 164. 30 $259,59 $746 81 2307 MAIN ST 32 4289015022 Commercial 0.133 1.00 0.133 $272.36 $229 97 50 00 0 00 50 00 $79 00 . $581 33 2311 MAIN ST 33 4289015038 Parkin Access 0.385 0.25 0.096 $197.10 . $166.42 . 44. 00 . 0.00 . 44. 00 . $69.52 . $433 04 2311 MAIN ST 34 4289015020 Parkin /Access 0.016 0.25 0.004 $8.19 $6.92 6. 00 0 00 6 00 $9 48 . $24 59 2311 MAIN ST 35 4289015037 .Parkin /Access 0.142 0.25 0.036 $72.70 $61.36 53. 29 . 0.00 . 53. 29 . $84.20 . $218 28 2321 MAIN ST 36 4289015024 Commercial 0.083 1.00 0.083 $169.97 $143.51 - 50. 50 0.00 50. 50 $79.79 . $393 27 2327 MAIN ST 37 4289015031 Commercial 0.120 1.00 0.120 $245.74 $207.49 79. 00 61.50 140. 50 $221.99 . $675 22 2400 MAIN ST 38 4288015034 Commercial 0.326 1.00 0.326 $667.59 $563.68 231. 23 47.39 278. 62 $440.22 . $1 671 49 2435 NEILSON WAY 39 4288015901 Parkin /Access 0.00 - $0.00 $0.00 0. 00 136.21 136. 21 $215.21 , . $215 21 2420 MAIN 2428 M ST 40 4288015004 Commercial 0.039 1.00 0.039 $79.86 ~ $67.43 25. 00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 . $186. 79 . AIN ST 41 4288015005 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38.04 25. 00 0.00 25 00 $39 50 $122 59 2434 MAIN ST 42 4288015006 Commercial 0 022 1 00 0 022 $45 05 . , . 243 . . . . $38.04 25. 00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 $122. 59 0 MAIN ST 43 4288015007 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38 04 25 00 0 00 25 00 $39 50 . . . . . $122. 59 q:\santa monica\msbia 82 act4eports\sta monica msbia lights sdwk ad ryt 23apr08.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 16 c=axb h=f+g i k=d+e+i Festoon Festoon Festoon Festoon Total Festoon Lighting Lighting Light Bulb Lighting Sidewalk Sidewalk Total Maximum Map Assessor's Land Lighting Benefit Benefit Replacem't O&M Main St Side-St- Sidewalk Sidewalk FY 08-09 Property Address No. Parcel No. Use Acres Factor Acres Asmt Asmt LF LF LF Asmt Asmt 2430 MAIN ST 44 4288015008 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38.04 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $122 .59 2434 MAIN ST 45 4288015009 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38.04 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $122 .59 2440 MAIN ST 46 4288015010 Commercial 0.044 1.00 0.044 $90.10 - $76.08 50 .00 0.00 50 .00 $79.00 $245.18 2444 MAIN ST 47 4288015035 Commercial 0.078 1.00 0.078. $159.73 $134.87 50 .00 0.00 50 .00 $79.00 $373 .60 2450 MAIN ST 48 4288015014 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38.04 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $122 59 2502 MAIN ST 49 4288014001 Commercial 0.039 1.00 0.039 $79.86 $67.43 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $186. . 79 2510 MAIN ST 50 4288014002 Commercial 0.039 1.00 0.039 $79.86 $67.43 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $186 79 2510 25 MAIN ST 51 4288014003 Commercial 0.041 1.00 0.041 $83.96 $70.89 26 .09 0.00 26 .09 $41.22 . $196. 07 10 MAIN ST 52 4288014004 Commercial 0.021 1.00 0.021 $43.00 $36.31 23 .91 0.00 23 .91 $37.78 $117. 09 2510 25 MAIN ST 53 4288014005 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38.04 25 .00 ~ 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $122. 59 10 MAIN ST 54 4288014006 Commercial 0.022 1.00 0.022 $45.05 $38.04 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $122 59 2518 25 MAIN ST 55 4288014007 Mixed Use 0.022 1.00 0.022. $45.05 $38.04 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 . $122. 59 22 MAIN ST 56 4288014035 Commercial 0.197 1.00 0.197 $403.42 $340.63 125 .00 0.00 125 .00 $197.50 $941 55 181 OCEAN PARK BLVD 57 4288014034 Commercial 0.161 1.00 0.161 $329.70 $278.38 100 .00 0.00 100 .00 $158.00 . $766 08 2401 2403 MAIN ST 58 4288001039 Commercial 0.075 1.00 0.075 $153.59 $129.68 32 .50 100.00 132 .50 $209.35 . $492. 62 MAIN ST 59 4288001040 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 $254 79 2407 MAIN ST 60 4288001019 Commercial .0.058 1.00 0.058 $118.77 $100.29 25 .00 0.00 25 .00 $39.50 . $258 56 2409 MAIN ST 61 4288001020 Commercial 0.058 1.00 0.058 $118.77 $100.29 25 .00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 . $258. 56 2411 MAIN ST 62 4288001021 Commercial 0.115 1.00 ~ 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 50 .00 0.00 50. 00 $79.00 $513. 34 2420 2503 2ND ST MAIN ST 63 4288001042 Commercial 1.149 1.00 1.149 $2,352.95 $1,986.70 250 .00 0.00 250. 00 $395.00 $4,734. 65 64 4288001026 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 - $98.56 25 .00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 $254. 79 2507 2 MAIN ST 65 4288001028 Commercial -0.115 1.00 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 50 .00 0.00 50. 00 $79.00 $513. 34 515 MAIN ST 66 4288001035 Commercial 0.229 1.00 0.229 $468.95 $395.96 100 .00 0.00 100. 00 $158.00 $1 022. 91 205 NORMAN PL 67 4288001036 Commercial 0.229 1.00 0.229 $468.95 $395.96 100 .00 100.00 200. 00 $316.00 , $1,180. 91 2520 2ND ST 68 4288001900 Commercial 0.00 - $0.00 $0.00 100.00 100. 00 $158.00 $158 00 2601 MAIN ST 69 4288002902 Institutional 0.226 0.50 0.113 $231.40 $195.38 50. 00 400.00 450. 00 $711.00 . $1,137. 78 2612 MAIN ST 70 4288013904 Institutional 0.106 0.50 0.053 $108.53 $91.64 68. 30 68.80 137.10 $216.62 $416. 79 2625 NEILSON WAY 71 4288013905 Commercial - 0.00 $0.00 $0.00 100.00 100. 00 $158.00 $158 00 2640 MAIN ST 72 4288013900 Insttutional 0.180 0.50 0.090 $184.30 $155.62 200. 00 0.00 200. 00 $316.00 . $655 92 2612 MAIN ST 73 4288012900 Insttutional 0.090 0.50 0.045 $92.15 $77.81 100. 00 0.00 100. 00 $158.00 . $327. 96 2654 MAIN ST 74 4288012001 Commercial 0.181 1.00 0.181 $370.66 $312.96 200. 00 39.50 239. 50 $378.41 $1 062. 03 2654 MAIN ST 75 4288012002 Commercial 0.00 $0.00 $O.W 30.01 30. 01 $47.42 , $47. 42 2675 NEILSON WAY 76 4288012902. Parkin /Access 0.00 $0.00 $0.00 - 80.00 80. 00 $126.40 $126. 40 2615 MAIN ST 77 4288002021 Commercial 0.114 1.00 0.114 $233.45 $197.11 50. 00 100.00 150. 00 $237.00 $667. 56 2619 MAIN ST 78 4288002022 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25. 00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 $254. 79 2625 MAIN ST 79 4288002045 Mixed Use 0.115 1.00 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 50. 00 0.00 50. 00 $79.00 $513. 34 2627 MAIN ST 80 4288002025 Commercial 0.114 1.00 0.114 $233.45 $197.11 50. 00 0.00 50. 00 $79.00 $509 56 2631 MAIN ST 81 4288002026 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25. 00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 . $254. 79 2633 MAIN ST 82 4288002027 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25 00 0 00 25 00 $39 50 $254 79 2637 26 MAIN ST 83 4288002036 Commercial 0.229 1.00 0.229 $468.95 $395.96 . 100. 00 . 0.00 . 100. 00 . $158.00 . $1,022. 91 51 MAIN ST 84 4288002032 Commercial 0.115 1.00 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 50. 00 0.00 50. 00 $79.00 $513. 34 2653 2665 MAIN ST 85 4288002033 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25. 00 0.00 25. 00 $39.50 $254. 79 MAIN ST 86 4288002044 Commercial 0.287 1.00 0.287 $587.72 $496.24 125. 00 0.00 125. 00 $197.50 $1,281. 46 q:\santa monica\msbia 82 act\repor[s\sta monica msliie lights sdwk ad rp[ 23apr08.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area April 23, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 17 c=axb h=t+g i k=d+e+i Festoon Festoon Festoon Festoon Total Property Address 2663 MAIN ST 2702 MAIN ST Map No. 87 Assessor's Parcel No. 4288002035 Land Use Commercial Festoon Lighting Acres 0.115 Lighting Benefit Factor 7.00 Lighting Benefit Acres 0.115 Light Bulb Replacem't Asmt $235.50 Lighting O&M Asmt $198.84 Sidewalk Main St LF 50.00 Sidewalk Side-St LF 100.00 Total Sidewalk LF 150.00 Sidewalk Asmt - $237.00 Maximum FY 08.09 Asmt $671.34 150 HILL ST 2725 NEILSON WAY 2708 MAIN ST 2710 MAIN S 88 89 90 91 4288011016 4288011901 4288011900 4288011009 Commercial Parkin /Access Parkin /Access Commercial 0.091 0.046 1.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.091 0.046 $186.35 $0.00 $0.00 $94.20 $157.35 $0.00 $0.00 $79.54 50 25 .00 .00 79.40 25.00 72.70 0.00 129 25 72 25 .40 .00 .70 .00 $204 $39 $114 $39 .45 .50 .87 .50 $548 $39 $114 $213 .15 .50 .87 .24 T 2712 MAIN ST 2716 MAIN ST 2720 MAIN ST 2724 MAIN ST 2732 MAIN ST 2736 MAIN ST 2802 MAIN ST 2804 MAIN ST 2810 MAIN ST 2826 MAIN ST 2826 MAIN ST 151 ASH LAND AVE 2825 NEILSON WAY 2701 MAIN ST 2709 MAIN ST 2711 MAIN ST 2713 MAIN ST 2719 MAIN ST 2727 MAIN 5T 2727 MAIN ST 2727 MAIN ST 2801 MAIN S 92 93 94 95 96 . 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 ~ 111 112 113 4288011002 4288011003 4288011004 4288011005 4288011006 4288011007 4288010001 4288010015 4288010005 4288010006 4288010007 4288010014 4288010901 4288010900 4288003043 4288003042 4288003041 4288003040 4288003045 4288003035 4288003034 4288003033 Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Parkin /Access Parkin /Access Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial "Commercial Commercial 0.022 0.023 0.045 0.045 0.045 0.022 0.022 0.067 0.045 0.089 0.067 .172 0.057 0.057 0.057 0.230 0.057 0.057 0.057 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.022 0.023 0.045 0.045 0.045 0.022 0.022 0.067 0.045 0.089 0.067 - 0.172 0.057 0.057 0.057 0.230 0.057 0.057 0.057 $45.05 $47.10 $92.15 $92.15 $92.15 $45.05 $45.05 $137.20 $92.15 $182:26 $137.20 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $352.23 $116.73 $116.73 $116.73 $471.00 $116.73 $116.73 $116.73 $38.04 $39.77 $77.81 $77.81 $77.81 $38.04 $38.04 $115.85 $77.81 $153.89 $115.85 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $297.40 $98.56 $98.56 $98.56 $397.69 $98.56 $98.56 $98.56 25 25 50 50 50 25 25 75 50 100 75 5 25 25 25 100 25 25 25 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 - - .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 38.51 40.34 25.21 65.55 100.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 .0.00. 0.00 0.00 25 25 50 50 50 25 25 75. 50. 100. 113. 40. 25. 65. 175. 25. 25, 25. 100. 25. 25. 25. .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 00 00 00 51 34 21 55 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 $39 $39 $79 $79 $79 $39 $39 $118 $79 $158 $179 $63 $39 $103 $276 $39 $39 $39 $158 $39 $39 $39 .50 .50 .00 .00 .00 .50 .50 .50 .00 .00 .35 .74 .83 .57 .50 .50 .50 .50 .00 .50 .50 .50 $122.59 $126.37 $248.96 $248.96 $248.96 $122.59 $122.59 $371.55 $248.96 $494.15 $432.40 $63.74 $39.83 $103.57 $926.13 $254.79 $254.79 $254.79 $1,026.69 $254.79 $254.79 $254.79 2803 2807 2817 T MAIN ST MAIN ST 114 115 116 4288003032 4288003048 4288003029 M&ed Use Commercial Commercial 0.057 0.114 0.057 ~ 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.057 0.114 0.057 $116.73 $233.45 $116.73 $98.56 $197.11 $98.56 25 50 25 .00 .00 .00 0.00 0.00 0.00 25. 50. 25. 00 00 00 $39. $79. $39. 50 00 50 $254 $509 $254 .79 .56 .79 2817 2817 2817 2821 MAIN ST MAIN ST MAIN ST MAIN ST MAIN ST 117 118 119 120 4288003028 4288003027 4288003026 4288003044 Parkin !Access Parkin /Access Parkin /Access Commercial 0.057 0.057 0.057 0.115 0.25 0.25 0.25 1.00 0.014 0.014 0.014 0.115 $29.18 $29.18 $29.18 $235.50 $24.64 $24.64 $24.64 $198.84 25 25 25 50 .00 .00 .00 .00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 25. 25. 25. 50. 00 00 00 00 $39. $39. $39. $79. 50 50 50 00 $93 $93 $93. $513, .32 .32 32 34 2900 MAIN ST 2900 MAIN ST 150 ASHLAND AVE 2911 NEILSON WAY 2910 MAIN ST 2912 MAIN ST 2914 MAIN ST 2916 MAIN ST 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 4288003023 4288009008 4288009001 4288009901 4288009900 4288009009 4288009013 4288009014 4288009012 Commercial Commercial Parkin (Access Parkin !Access Parkin /Access Commercial Commercial :Commercial Commercial 0.172 0.066 - 0.106 0.286 0.022 0.045 0.045 0.022 1.00 1.00 0.00 0.25 0.25 1.00 1.OD 1.00 1.00 0.172 0.066 0.027 0.072 0.022 0.045 0.045 0.022 $352.23 $135.16 $0.00 $54.27 $146.42 $45.05 $92.15 $92.15 $45.05 $297.40 $114.12 $0.00 $45.82 $123.63 $38.04 $77.81 $77.81 $38.04 75 75 50. 131. 25. 25. 25. 25. .00 .00 42 10 00 00 00 00 - 100.00 38.43 40.67 50.42 131.10 0.00 0.00 0.00 38.18 175. 113. 40. 100. 262: 25. 25. 25. 63. 00 43 67 84 20 00 00 00 18 $276. $179. $64. $159. $414. $39. $39. $39. $99. 50 22 26 33 28 50 50 50 82 $926. $428. $64. $259. $684. $122. $209. $209. $182. 13 50 26 42 33 59 46 46 91 q:\sm[a monicn\msbia 82 aot\reporls\sta movioa mebia ligirts adwk ad rpt 23apr08.doc City of Santa Monica -Main Street Business Area Apri123, 2008 Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District- FY 2008-09 Page 18 c=axb h=f+g i k=d+e+i Festoon Festoon Festoon Festoon Total Festoon Lighting Lighting Light Bulb Lighting Sidewalk Sidewalk Total Maximu m Map Assessor's Land Lighting Benefit Benefit Replacem't O&M Main St Side-St Sidewalk Sidewalk FY 08-09 Property Address No, Parcel No. Use Acres Factor Acres Asmt Asmt LF LF LF Asmt Asmt 2916 MAIN ST 130 4288009007 Commercial 0.023 1.00 0.023 $47.10 $39.77 40. 00 40.00 80.00 $126.40 $213 27 2924 MAIN ST 177 PIE 131 4288008009 Commercial 0.045 1.00 0.045 $92.15 $77.81 25. 00. 78.11 103.11 $162.91 ~ $332 . .87 R AVE 132 4288008008 Commercial - 0.00 $0.00 $0.00 180.08 180.08 $284.53 $284 53 2926 MAIN ST 133 4288008004 Commercial 0.045 1.00 0.045 $92.15 $77.81 25. 00 0.00 25.00 $39.50 $209 . .46 2934 MAIN ST 134 4288008005 Commercial 0.135 1.00 0.135 $276.48 $233.42 75. 00 0.00 75.00 $118.50 $628 38 2942 MAIN ST 2901 M 135 4288008007 Commercial 0.126 1.00 0.126 $258.03 $217.86 70. 09 78.01 148.10 $234.00 $709 . .89 AIN ST 136 4288004028 Commercial 0.113 1.00 0.113 $231.40 $195.38 50. 00 100.00 150.00 $237.00 $663 .78 2905 MAIN ST 29 137 4288004024 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25. 00 0.00 25.00 $39.50 $254 .79 09 MAIN ST 138 4288004023 Commercial 0.229. 1.00 0.229 $468.95 $395.96 100. 00 0.00 100.00 $158.00 $1 022 .91 2919 MAIN ST 139 4288004022 Commercial 0.115 1.00 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 50. 00 0.00 50.00 $79.00 , $513 34 2923 MAIN ST 292 140 4288004021 Commercial 0.057 1.00 0.057 $116.73 $98.56 25. 00 0.00 25.00 $39.50 $254 . .79 5 MAIN ST 141 4288004020 Commercial 0.058 1.00 0.058 $118.77 $100.29 25. 00 0.00 25.00 $39.50 $258 56 2929 MAIN ST 142 4288004019 Commercial 0.114 1.00 0.114 $233.45 $197.11 50. 00 0.00 50.00 $79.00 $509 . .56 2939 MAIN ST 143 4288004018 Commercial 0.056 1.00 0.056 $114.68 $96.83 24. 50 0.00 24.50 .$38.71 $250 .22 2937 MAIN ST 2941 MAI 144 4288004017 Commercial O.D59 1.00 0.059 $120.82 $102.02 25. 50 ~ 0.00 25.50 $40.29 $263 .13 N ST 145 4288004027 Commercial 0.115 1.00 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 25. 00 0.00 25.00 $39.50 $473 84 2943 MAIN ST 3002MAIN 146 4288004026 Commercial 0.115 1.00 0.115 $235.50 $198.84 25. 00 200.00 225.00 $355.50 $789 . .84 ST 147 ~ 4288007009 Commercial 0.145 1.00 0.145 $298.93 $250.72 79. 79 77.76 157.55 $248.93 $796 58 170 PIER AVE 170 PIER AVE 148 4288007011 Parkin /Access 0.00 - $0.00 $0.00 47.00 47.00 $74.26 $74 . .26 149 4288007001 Commercial 0.00 - $0.00 $0.00 - 85.00 85 00 $134 30 $134 30 3008 MAIN ST 150 4288007006 Commercial 0.062 1.00 0.062 $126.96 $107 20 35 00 0 00 . 35 00 . $55 30 . 3016 MAIN ST 151 4288007007 Parkin /Access 0.138 0.25 0 035 $70 65 . $59 85 . 75 00 . 77 46 . 15 4 . $289 .46 3005 MAIN ST 152 4288005015 A artment 0.737 0.25 . 0 184 . $377 31 . $318 58 . 161 00 . 400 00 2. 6 561 $240.89 $371 .19 3100 MAIN ST 153 4288006015 Commercial 0 442 1 00 . 0 442 . $905 14 . . . .00 $886.38 $1,582 .27 212 MARINE ST . . . . $764.25 125. 37 167.40 292.77 $462.58 $2,131 .97 154 4288005017 Com-Condo 0.101 1.00 0.101 $206.38 $174 26 154 68 38 29 192 97 $304 89 68 212 MARINE ST 155 4288005018 Com-Condo 0 00 0 00 . . . . . $ 5. 53 212 MA . $ . $0.00 46.50 46.50 $73.47 $73. 47 RINE ST 156 4288005019 Com-Condo - 0.00 - $0.00 $0.00 49 23 49 23 $77 78 $77 7 212 MARINE ST 157 4288005020 Com-Condo - 0 00 $0 00 - 0 00 . . . . 8 . . $ . 50.60 50.60 $79.95 $79. 95 20.026 17.293 $35,412.00 $29,900.09 8,498. 88 6,316.08 14,814.96 $23,407.65 $88,719. 74 q:\santa monicaMsbia 82 acf\reports\sta monica msbia lights sdwk ad rp[ 23apA8.doc ~ 5+ c e~~ April 17, 2008, 6:30PM The Victorian 2640 Main Street Santa Monica Please join MSBIA and the City for lighting demos and a discus- sion about a proposed Lighting and Sidewalk District. ® Do we want to continue the decorative, pedestrian- oriented lighting? ® Do vve want to upgrade to LED lights? ® Do we want increased sidewalk cleaning? How should we balance service levels and fees? Your input is vital to making sound decisions about our thriving business area. d City of Santa Monica' ~ # S a,~ 7~'++. ~vnra nv~m ru ' ~~-~ Property Owners to Vote on Continuing Lights and Sidewalk Cleaning THE DYiy?AMIC MAIN STREET business area where you own property is filled with a wide array of shops, restaurants, entertainment, businesses, cul- tural opportunities and gathering places. The lively ambience at- tracts locals and visitors firom all over Southern California- and beyond. Underlying tl?c area s unique image and attractiveness are the clean sidewalks for strolling and, at night, the festoon lighting along Main St~'eet. Last year, the City of Santa Monica gave the Main Street Business Improvement Associa- tion (MSPIA) a one-time grant to pay for continuing that lighting and for the additional sideta~alk cleaning (cleaning beyond what the City pro~rides for other areas). That grant is notro° ea~piring and, to continue or improve the lighting and sidewall: cleaning, another revenue source is needed. Main Street without festoon lights. Please fill out our surve other side! City of Santa Monica Main Street Business Area Additional Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District Proposed Assessment Would Pay for Continued Service MSBIA AND THE CITY are exploring forming a Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning Assessment District Property owners in the area would be assessed a set amount every year to pay for continued festoon lighting and sidewalk cleaning. If property owners approve forming the District, the assessment would pay for both more energy-efficient LEB festoon lights on YIain SireeC and increased sidewalk clecuring. All property owners ~a7ll receive a ballot in the mail to cote on whether to form the District. The proposed District wouild inchide about r5o proper3ies on IG2ain Street and side streets, starting at Pico >;lvd. and running to the southern bor<er of the Cih~ south of bZ arine St (see t a ). Main Street with festoon lights. ~~nt~~~ @~s For more detailed information about the project and the upcoming community meeting, and to let us know what you think, please contact us: Erika Cavicante, City Liaison City of Santa Monica Housing and Economic Development Department (39 O) 458-8756 Erika.cavicante@smgov.net Joe Pipersky, Joe's Grill MSBIA Chair 2917 Main Street Santa Monica, CA 90405 (39 0) 866-5637 Parcel ~ Notapart - Distdct boundary •••••• Festoon lighting and sidewalk cleaning 11°" Sidewalk cleaning only N ~yE s PLACE ST.v~P HEP`c" Erika Cavicante City of Santa Monica Housing and Economic Development Department 3223 Donald Douglas Loop South Santa Monica, CA 90405 - - - - - - - ~- - - - - - - ~ PLEASE CLIP ANO MMi - - - - - Festoon Lighting Sidewalk Cleaning ADDITIONAL LIGHTING can contribute to a positive nighttime visual image, enhance pedestrians' sense of safety, and promote busi- ness and socializing.'1'he proposal includes: Installing more energy-efficient LED festoon lights along both sides of Main Street, replac- ingthe existing xenon bulbs. Providing on-going operation (including elec- tricity costs) and maintenance of the festoon lights, which is likely to be less expensive than the current xenon lighting. An assessment would be based on the total size of property and the benefits received ~' , {properties not on Main Street wotdd r"~ not pay for the lighting). CLEAN SIDEWALKS can enhance comm- unity character and the pedestrian experience, and promote business. T he. proposal includes: s Steam cleaning sidewalks along both sides of Main Str-cet and high-traffic side streets using en~~2ronment-fiiendlj-biode~~adablesoaps and machines Chat Lrap dirtti,° wafer to prevent it from Ilowing into the ocean. b Tncrcasing sen~ice from spot ciezming twice a month to thoroughly cleaning entire side- wallcs once a month and spot cleaning once a month (the Cih's basic service is cleaning t~~~ce a pear). An assessment woLrld be based on the linear feet of propert}- on streets being cleaned. 1~aEn street urea Pr®perty ~wn~r~: Stare ~'~nr'I'haaz~l~ts Ab~s~at ~.~~~ttzn~ and Sade~~alk Cieanin~ Let us know what you think! Come to the community meeting AprIl i9, 6:3opm at The Victorian (see front page for more m details)-or if you can't make it, please send this questionnaire back to the City by April i8. a ~_ Here are my thoughts about lighting along Main Street: o n rt 2. Here are my thoughts about sidewalk cleaning in the area: 3. Here are my thoughts about forming an assessment district to pay for continued lighting and sidewalk cleaning: 4. I'd like more information. Name and property address: '?z .>,; <` , ~ .~ . ~ti as Bestwavtoreachme: ~ ~. ~ ? - ~i ; <~ air ~ < o~,,it. <, . ~~ s.€aacca~~ ~c~c~®~ ~xa.~~~aa.e3~ zeE~ ,~,~ ;~ ~. ~ ; ,. ~, za. ~~~~sa~gr~acn~.e~~ae~~ ~, SOb06 tl~ `a~!uow a;ueg y~nog door se!6nop p!euop £ZZE tuaw~edaa ~uawdo!anap a!wouoa3 pue 6u!snoH eo!uoW e~ueg ~o ~!~ ea~uoH a>oeg ~ ~r~ ~~t ~ ~,. ~l~/, ~ ~~ ~~~ e~® ® fli9i ~~fi3 May 22, 2008, 6:30PM The Victorian 2640 Main Street Santa Monica Please join the City and MS- BIA for lighting demos and a discussion about the proposed Festoon Lighting and Sidewalk Cleaning District. ® Do we want to continue the decorative, pedestrian-ori- ented lighting? ® Do we want increased side- walk cleaning? ® What would your proposed annual assessment be? Property owners will decide in June-be informed before you vote! City of Santa Monica° a e Rio::. 7~l aa~rra moruca Property Owner Vote Proposed on Festoon Lights and Sidewalk Cleaning THE LIVELY AMBIENCE of the Main Street business area where you own property attracts locals and visitors from all over Southern California-and beyond. Underly- ing the area's unique image and attractiveness are the pedestrian- oriented sidewalks for strolling and, at night, the festoon lighting along Main Street Last year, the City of Santa Monica gave the Main Street Business Improve- menttLssociation (MSBIA) a one- time grant to pay for festoon light- ing and for additional sidewalk cleaning (cleaning beyond what the City provides for other areas). That grant is now expiring: In June, if the City Council moves forward with the process, property owners will vote on an assessment to maintain the current festoon lighting as it is and increase the level of sidewalk cleaning. Lf ap- proved by property owners, the medfan total assessment would be about $2b' a lnontlt. What's aMail-Back Ballot Vote? .CITIES SOMETIMES SEND BALLOTS to property owners, whether or not they ~T are registered voters, to ask them ~.- - ...~ to vote on financial issues specifi- cally concerning their property. Californians approved this method of voting, now part of the California Con- stitution, in a ryy6 statevride election. In June 2008, the Cih- is proposing to mail an official ballot to each property owner of record in the proposed Dis- trict. You will he asked to vote on whether to form an assessment district and pay an annual assessment for continued festoon lighting and in- creased sidewalk cleaning. There is one vote per prop- ertyand, in accordance with California law, votes will be weighted according to the total assessment amount assigned to that property (properties v`rith higher as- sessmentshave more weight). You will have 45 days to complete and return the ballot. Approval requires at least So% of returned ballots, weighted. by assessment. =t without Ihts. Main Street with festoon lights. or~rriunity- seed roosa TO DEVELOP THE PROPOSED DISTRICT and the elements it would fund, the City and MSBLy spoke with many property own- ers in the area, sent ont a survey and con- ducted a corrnnunity meeting. The proposed District would h~clude almost 16o proper- ties on Main Sheet and side streets, starting at Pico Blvd. and running to the southern border of the Cih~ south of Marine St It will fund continued festoon lighting and increased sidewalk cleaning. The estimated annual budget would be about $88,Sno and the total inedian assessment would be about $28 a mouth total (the size of proper- ties and their assessments vary v,~idely; your exact assessment will be on your ballot and you can also contact the City now). Festoon Lighting The Main Sheet festoon lights are in addi- tion to the Cit}~-provided sheetlights. Ad- ditional lighting can contribute to a positive nighttime visual image, enhance pedeshi- ans' sense of safety, and promote business and socializing. The proposal includes: • Providing on-going operation (including electricity costs} of the festoon lights. • Replacing bulbs as necessarT~ (bulbs are reaching the end of their useful life and almost all will need to be replaced in the near future}. • Maintaining the globes that surround the bulbs as necessary. Based on property owner feedback, an original proposal to upgrade from the current single strand of xenon lights to a double strand of even more energy-efficient LED lights ~~°as dropped as too expensive for Fest®on Lighting and Sidewalk leao~i~ and because the quality of LED lighting is inferior to xenon bulbs- Sidewalk Cleaning Clean sidewalks can enhance community character and the pedestrian experience, and promote bust- . ness. The proposal includes: • Thorough steam cleaning of sidewalks 1o times a year-in addition to the City's standard twice a year ser'<>ice-along both sides of Main Street and on all side. streets in the proposed District. • Additional spot cleaning-once a month: • ' Using environment-friendly biodegradable soaps and machines that trap dirty water to prevent it from flowing to the ocean. Assessment Methodology Each property's assessment will be based on the special benefit that property receives from the fes- toonlighting and/or sidewalk cleaning. • Festoon Lighting: Only properties on Main Street benefit from and would pay for festoon lighting-an assessment would be based on the total size of your properly and ehe level of benefits received. Commercial properties and mixed-use properties receive full benefits, parks and institutional properties (gardens, library) receive half benefits and residential uses and parking lots receive one-quarter benefits: The assessment is determined by multiplying your. benefif factor by your parcel's acreage to deter- mine a "benefit acre." The total lighting assess- mentwould be $gl~ a month per benefit acre (which includes $i~r for the bulb replacement prograan; which will only be for a 5-year pe- riod). Sidewalk Cleaning. All properties at street level benefit from clean sidewalks. Each prop- erty would be assessed based on the amount of sidewalk fi-ontage directly adjacent to their property; at a rate of $i:58 per linear footper year (about $0.13 per linear fool per month). Without additional funding, sidewalks would be cleaned only twice a yeai, and Lestoon lighting will be reduced more and more. You can read a fitll analysis of the Benefits and assessment inethodolo- gy in the Engineer's Keport, available fiom the City For more detailed information aboutttie proposal, your exact proposed assessment, and to read the detailed Engineer's Report, please contact: Erika Cavicante, City Liaison .Joe Pipersky, Joe's Gritl City of Santa Monica MSBIA Chair Housing and Economic 2917 Main Street Development Department Santa Monica, CA 90405 (310) 458-8756 (310} 866-5637 Erika.Cavicante@smgov.net ~_ 0 w r Y ~~r~s~a~hi ~~cza~o~~sdl~ K~,: 50706 tl0 `eaiuoW e~ueg y;nog door se~6no0 PleuoO EZZ£ ~uaw~eda0 ~uawdo~ana0 oiwouoo3 pue fiuisnoH esiuoW e~ueg ~o ~ll0 eoFoou eloeg Reference Resolution No. 10294 (CCS).