Loading...
SR-308-001-02 (5) . . 30 15 - 00 / -(O~ /0 -/1 SEP 2 2 1981 CA:RMM:r City Council Meeting Santa Monica, California STAFF REPORT TO: Mayor and City Council FROM: Robert M. Myers, City Attorney SUBJECT: Fish1ng Reef ~n Santa Mon~ca Bay At its meet1ng on August 18, 1981, the C1ty Council considered the recommendation of the Recreation and Parks Comm1ssion concerning establishing an artific~al reef in Santa Mon1ca Bay for the purpose of 1mproving fish habitat. The C1ty Counc11 postponed act10n on the recommendat1on pending addLtional information. The princLpal concern of the City Council was the applLcatLon of the Santa Mon1ca Bay Ordinance of 1973 to the proposed reef project. The measure was adopted by 1n~tla- tlve on April 10, 1973. (A copy of the measure is attached. ) The Santa Monlca Bay Ord1nance of 1973 only applles to the construction, build1ng, or assembly of any building, p1er or ~sland seaward of the mean hlgh tide line. So long as the proposed reef 1S below sealevel, the ord1nance would not apply. /0 -It SEP 2 2 1981 TO: . Mayor and City Council . .r(~ -r,.' , \5~ .r, t ~ FRO~l: City Staff SUBJECT: Reef PrDject Introduction This report is to brieflY inform th~ City Council as to the nature of the reef project. Background The Southern Council of Conservation Clubs, Inc., appeared before the Recreation and Parks Commission on July 16, 1981, to present a proposal to construct artificial reefs in the Santa Monica Bay. Briefly, the proposal envisions that the concrete from demolition projects be trucked to a process pad and dock located at the shoreline near where the reefs are to be created. The concrete would be cleaned and separated. and the larger segments would be located onto a special transport vessel and taken to the reef site where they would be deposited on the floor of the bay in a prescnbed pattern. Small pieces of concrete would be crushed and returned to the contractors for USe as "bedding" material. Fees collected from contractors and truckers depositing concrete at the process pad would cover the operating expenses of the project. The Southern Council of Conservation Clubs has examined this proposal, and endorses it for its economical, ecological and social benefits. These are, according to the club, as follows: (1) placing the large pieces of concrete in the bay to form reefs creates a constructive alternative to dumping them in rapidly being used landfill sites; (2) artificial reefs create and enhance the ocean floor habitat and establish new fish populations and sport fishlng opportunitles in the Santa Monica Bay, (3) will conserve fuel and save on other transportation expenses since the distance from the demolition sites to the sea reef collection pads will be less than the distances to the nearest useable landfill site. ., T{J : , Mayor and Cit~ncil Santa r1. > Ca 1 iforni a > August 4> 1981 -2- The suggested locatlon for the processlng pad in this presentatlon is at the foot of Imperial Boulevard near the Los Angeles Airport. Recom'J1endation The proposed reef location appears to be within the territorial limits of the Clty of Santa Monica. Section 10201 of the munlcipal code defines the Santa '1onica Harbor as that portion of the Santa Monica Bay included wlthin the corporate territorial limlts of the City. It is staff's opinion that it would be necessary to receive the Clty Council's approval for this project. If Council desires to pursue this project further. they should refer the project to the staff for further conslderation and recomwendation to the City Council. Prepared by: Donald T. Arnett, Director Recreation and Parks DTJ\ :dc .- . -. ~ t .. ~.. . . J \\ Pi "i ~ f t.i '. ': -' : !':: i- ,1-, . ' . . D MUNICIPAL BALLOT - CITY OF SANTA MONICA GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION TUESDAY, APRIL 10, 1973 MEASURE SUB~IlTTED TO VOTE OF VOTERS Shall the ordmance submItted by an InlUatlYl! petItIOn prohlbltmg the construction, bUlld- YES 160. mg, or assembhng of a bUlldmg, pIer, or Island seaward of the mean high tIde hne in the "Santa tylomca 'Bay", except by a maJonty NC{ 162. vDle of the people, be adoptedq BALLOT ENDS THIS PAGE . , '.... ~,- ~9 ; ~. ~,' t:~. .~ ~ i 60 1 " 63 61 ~~ fi6 67 ~ ~ -J 19 1\ n ,;,rt 7~ 7., 75 17~ I 1> " "..... ""'-' " " ~ ~ { I '-' J. t ~ i 1 t :;cr2S~~~ (';I a _-< ::) ':r 0-0 "":3 '0"'_1"') :=.'""' :; o;:;:::::;;;r o~vo;;.gQ...... ~ 'E ~~ 2 :;. ~ !2,3..j>.:;- s:O _ n - "" I"') ell ~ ........~::iCQ.l :; (t ;;- S s; ~~_ ~ ~ .... s:::::: ..... 0 ::l 0,) :::: ::$ ~ '""t (t- ..., ::rVl~o2~~ ct:-.- ~-::3 ;; :g 0 ~~ :3 c> . 0 -.....::3.... = ..., - -..... r-+-S:-:2.)>2tI"J o (C 0-0 r:?-. --t """t "'0 0 om.j>.=..,... "C 0'''' _........e.". 'OGl'jo"'::; o~::r'" no. ~ 0 ~ -("';: Co:; -::S"":)\D-~ ov.l(;'"-.JO:':: ::Ir'J""1"W;:::S oow_.....~ -.0...... ~ 0.... 9~9~g[ (t:~;:: a"~t'" "C -:;{J r"".l!'b.... ... =- 0"" f') -.:! -8'" ::;Q. ~;J~_3 ~;-...~~:~ e,.- Q..=--:fJ n- n;C O::o~~I'j~ ~-.("-~-- "'n=--<'o C) ~ 0 ,.... ""'1-::1::;'00"" ("Di"V'ltl-.~ L,... ~ t.:: - ~ ';,- ~ -r.:; ~ '- \ -- I. ... C> :t- ., .. m :xl Z 0 C> m C Z :xl -I ~ :t- -< m -I ):> r 0 Z :t- ." s: 0 ::j -I ::! ." Ul :xl C -< < r Z CIl s: ." )> m c:i ):> 0 z ... 2 m :xl 0 ,0 ." -I :t- o :xl ... ):> l> (II l> 0 C Z to r 3: :;D 0 2 -.,J (rJ m 0 rn )> r z ):> Z m 0 C> n 0 )> m ::! ):> 2 0 CIl (II ):> Z -I 2 -I ol> ::j~ -<0 z Ci l> -. ~. ~, b 5-'" r-. 1 [ " f t . r- j- . ,- I ~ .i . I o ...., v>c. ::r:::- nee 603 ~;' ::r:::,. ontc~"> :::c. Coo - - f''''' 0::: = __ . ~v>~:;;rth \CJ,,",ncc tl:i -~~ n;;. o ~ ;; "" e.3:l '< ~ ,g::r ~g ~Qg. r.n~ (t (tr 5 j:I:I z:::- -tc -0 ~:; ~ ~ '" (C 3:'< ;;;; B: 0 : OCt 3 :: 3- ----0 c.. (1) nnS ~5 V] c U" "'<' v.; -~- 5 ~.. t: ~;::'" go>'"' ",'" "O~=- fn --:oJ ~~_ g.!::..n. to> "0 ~ _~o. 3.~ Q :J;;;<~ ~ c.. ............ t'"W 0 -- (F. \0 ..... ..~-.Ct ~Q~ ;:;-n -:--.f5 ~ (t 3 ,,0. 30" .., p:l n:.., ..~5. ~~ - ~-lV> o;r~ 2.....:j 59..0 scz ii ~ "'" :oJ QQ ,,"0 r. ... ~ =- ~ r+ o (5 :oJ '" '" " '"' ~ o ::l ~ C. ..,n-lV> ~ :;:; <r m c.::; '. (j C ~ -l g::=:E;o ~~-gZ ~~Yi w "< '" ::r E: o 0 ;-':2' o~::~ ;:- ::i Vi 0 !t o;~~ ~T ~3:e- o c il. ~ ~ ~ r. s:;; G- O _ 3 tc '" ~~ 0- g. ~ -- ~ ~ v.; ::r ct 'Oo;~ ~ ell .., 0 ~..,- cE-n ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 n .., 0.- '" - ::r0" '" '" ==!e 0";:;' n'< '" "C "C - -< c - i>>- 5 :... p. .... " 3 '" .') '- g'3 ~D3 D~ ~ ~ ~ Q.~ g -< ~ cr "':::m'go:::oo"'ngc:l :::2' ;::-....;:r ""'3: ~ Olr. "'en@.. a?o '< ;:::r;j'<S-::;l:::>2::: ::l ~[a.~S'=G;:2= ; tc'" 8 =-:::g.., 3:v>O ::: ~-::J"""'" oc.....::s: 25 '<~~~:;=~2*Vl ~ "'-'G{;::;-~ 0 ~ c: C-.f.j t:: f'tc:I-- 2 gg~~~g ~~ r-; ........O~;:J....c 0.., (; ~~ n c.=-_ ::ro Q. ac ":Ec.- "'" .., (t~ cc-S; ~v- G ~~ t"!: -<~ :E ~'< c-~-< ~ co ~ 3t-) GS~ ..gET-' ~a :Jaa ......,~- a--.. (")r.;._, -a- ~-5 ~ ~.B ~ ~ .- =. - '" =- ~ t:'"~- . 0.... tr. c.::T ~E- go~ 5~~ C':I ~ _ __ ;::, (JQ _ ~_J ::c. :E~c. =-6- 9 ~ ~~"8 ~ - ~ ~ ~:i: -o~ n~ (;~ f["2.~ ~g 3 0. '0 co 0.. F. '" 00 =00 00 ~~ ~ -"1'"1') .-.,1""+; ;.~- ~:;~ ~:;:. a.(t f't.(t.(:) OCii O'nen ~gs ~ ~ 0- '" )- ::: 0 . ::J "'" Ir. n-l Oe,:::r .....,-'" 0" 8> v> 2 a ~ f':: _ __ ::T~~ :':::-3: '" n 0 ~ 0: 2 " r" ...., :; A- '" tc ~-~ -~ ~ ~ ~ '" C=o-= g - 3'< g- n-~ g' c"? g- ~ ~ hD? ;;- -< .:- ::: c o.O::J ~ ~.E C-~g g.~~ ~~!': ~:::~ v. 00_ ::J"'" ~ ~ ~ 0... " o .., N c ::J 1;; .., '" e- n 0.. 0' ... .-") , =-'l , ,) ::; ., c 3-len ~ ~ rr"' !: .... n ;:; 0 -l ~e.5 ::J Z ~ t" '"' " '1'1 r;; 5 0. '" - c.:::> o 0.0 ~ ~ " c. is: o ::J n-lV> "::;-m tc <r 0 ~o"""l o e. ;:; .., _ Z c...~ ~ ~ :- ~~::l co :::- o!::.." ""'- :; 0;; ::r .... - 0" "+D <:> ;:l ~ -- o ~ ::J r: E. 3 '" '< 0" " a fi 0.. ~ o ...., s- <:> ~ 0- :i: 5 "" "'" '" '"' ..;;r pO ::: Po o > Z-l >::I: entT1 'T]." Om r-O r-'" Or- :Em enO '1'1 R en co ::J ;;; rn l> 2 -I )> s: o 2 ..., n ::I: l> ("rl tJ:l n l> =i -< -< 0 o ::0 'T] 2: Vl_~ ;> 0 ~ m > 0 is: ." o ... z ~ -n c..I ;> o o o ~ g;~lf ~ rt [ ~~~~CIl g:::.~ ~ ~ ::n;;C_ ~ ~~r1;2..0 n~cr-:: Z ~~~g --l n () n Q..r;.t,;~ ~ ~~ ~ gr=:::.;: ,....~ ;;: o r. ~:g _g2oZ g-~&o ~ !;~;i~9 --... 0.::::::,-. g F'i"~"':J ~ ~ ~ ;::! ~ ~ftI0-o =t 0-0 <'> fr~ ~~ r't' _~-c... n- I)\;; V) o~gg ......go.=.. ~(t~g- tn~~~ 0:E<>-'" 0.2"-=':;-= ~ &~ ~ ;::I 3"0 Co: n c..- ~ ::1 ~,<9Q. ;'- I ~ .i +.- '..- - ::; x:' .C--..= ~?"g r ~ ;t> ":l '2.. " .., c ~ ;!:Q .... :> C c. ~- ~ lU ~ [0 !!~e:> &.o~~ ~?"~~ ~ ~;; i5..~~= ~ g ~~ c ;;i:~ :3 c.. -t:, ~. ~ 0 2" ~ S=-::J~g P ~ '" ~ 5' ~ ~ ~ c.. x .-; ::E :~~=- o.~~5 r.r~g.:; ~~5~ ~ ~;:::.. .., '< 8 ~ 0 g :E~ ~ rj'to: ~ C o .., ~ ~::: ~ g ;:; fll" ~ c -, r, '" !jtl:> o t::" a ~ 0> ~ 0 'E ~ .., :; ",r,>o.. o ~ o ~ :; ::>- V' '" P- ::> p. i') (' n: V' g :;; . ...... 3 'B '" "O~ (tl(':l (7-< ~ ~;:c; e;:' ~~o::-? =.., ~c: n=;..:- a=: ~o>CI:I :l ~ ~ ", ~ ~ : t:> ~ ';; ::: : ~ ~ ~ "C ~ ~ n ~~ '- ~ ~ -- ~ ~ ~ t- := o ~ ::5 ~ ~ 8- ~.., ~ ~;> ~ <: o.~ 0 -; ~ ~~ ~ g 5 g g 2. =: Q g ~ ~ Z 0.-3 ~:::<'" ",,<0""'''''"'' tr;;'=.- ::.1"'"< ~ ~~:g 3: ~~ g ~rtv *~~rt.s.~~~ti.G-'=' ~~~ 5~~s~~~~~E:~ -cQrr ~~""'aa.~!i~S-~c[ E. ~ ~ Q ~ ~ ~ 5. Qr ~ ~ 0 ::s o' : ~ s '; g ~ n ;- ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ::f ~ gt:;~ "O_~ ~{f,:~ ;~g~ g Q'Q- o~'< E..cr'~ 0 oj.... "'-< ~oo ::::S.0.-3::r' ~ ~ c.. _"0 ~ 0 - -;r to> ",J o~..s::S""'1:;c~::;-< :;~ ~~E.?~s.g.~ tb"CLfj t? ~ ~ 0..= -~~ no O~~ 0 f;g" ~Er;~~~(b-(t-t~ ~:;: ~5~e.;~~~5~2 ~ ; ~:: ~ ~ ~ [/~ ~; ~ g 00 0.-'" ::l_-....IIQ2.~::l ~"':S ~.~~ o.r.:=-t:ROtO o~ 'fl....::{ ~~::s ""1f:;~ -,('1:1...,.0 V'(b - oo::J .......0.. &..,~ ., ~ C:~ ::r'tr (Il O"a &~ ~ g.C" o ~ ~ ~c. =- ~ -w::s ~ ~~ ;:e-~ cfJer ~e- o~ ::::-::>:::, -g o::S -~ "'!P"C 0::1 ::S!"U II' n ~~ On ~~ c ~ <iQ ~~ f:~ 3 0" '0 " - .; g !i; CflI n ~ ~ ~ -< '"' x [!. s:: 0- " P- ::> o S ... ::; ("; '0 ..., o '" v o \J u ~~ ;;; 3 .., '" ii: -'jVl 9' :::j ::r tr. ;;~t; () 2, ~ g z DQo 00. C ;:; ~ g~,<::;~ g~~~q ~Q~~ 0 tfj ,..::s "0 Z ~::roo ~ n "'" < _ - 0 ;-.; ~ S" 02....,::lVl _ _::: f'o 0"23~;g &g~~-~ ~ 0 ~ &l~ ~~_o,< :: 8.~;;e. o :::.g.~~ ~ ~~ ~F; ;:; "0::> '" ~!f~@..Q o 00.- ::r :3-":r' ~ _ rt g o;~ o ... '0 ~3g n: ~ 0: ..., - .- '0 ~ '0 ~ ~ == bO~ ~ -, ~ o ;.g- ..,"'.... > :3 tt> ::> 0- 3 n: ::l - '" '" ":l '" a 5';; '" n: ~) "'(lC C n_ <= ~ '< ;J> tr. .., 0 ::> trl ,., ..., '< {) g '" "d -'j ::l 3 ~ 5 0';;; ~ z '" ~::l :-0 23:1: og::;g' 5~O 0' lI' :'" "'= .., ::> 2. ~ :>~3 o ~ ~ ~ r;-~~ o~~ ::>0- o!?"O ~~o -0< ::r~~ E;Vjo g~~ ~=2, ... ==- ~ge: '" - .. . 20 :Ie. ~ 5' '< "' ::> 0"0 ::! '" ~v; vD~ to=-::> 0 'JO ""::s C "'0""0_ n;o._ g~~~ " CJ" ""'L ?loG- '" ... :E ,.:; =' -a::>'""c ~K~~ ~ ~ .... c ;.;!..~~ ~- -~;::.-- ~~"'g 'C:"i?~ C ::r::s ::l .:l~~c 25 ~<:rrs::; no"':j, ~o.::!~ -~g~ ::;- ..... r) ~~O~ o 0--<-< jl"'l1o. 5g~; ~ 0 ~ ~ :s....""0' ge-~Q. . ::l. ::; (lC !j '" --'"' o~g g (j '" 3~5. 3 l' ::l g~!a c:r "" ,., "<ri 0 $~ C ~m~~~~0 S'g-. v =- :.-...;f ::- n:tt~;:;~ ~!5go~ ~-_:"2.~~ tl' ~ ,... .1-1. ~ .-.:="'_.... ~ ~ ~ ~ :;, -,. ~ foil} Q~:3 ~ -- n V'l 5 a e: V' {';:;.. -' 2 g =~ r.. ::I 0'0 ""I. 2~ :T= '-t .., !; ::'> I't =- n ft" 5.~e. x V'J = ~ ; ::--: ~ 0. gn 5 _ t: ~ C1:"" ~ <-a o .20 is ::! ~:; :;r. c.. ~ '" 8~~~r.; = t:tt n ::3 f;; :; t;'nl11 '" D~ !" 0::;1_ ~':<Q. -t.... ., -~ ~ nO :;_.....~ ~ ~;;;~gg~ OS~~~; ...,.....o~~::I ~~::ra......() ~ 2!:: (").... tt> '" ~og~~g- 3==~;g~ ~~~=-- ~(")Jl",g,5 t;; 0 - ~"O -- ::::I r.; ~ "'1 :::: ::>"-0:0.-::1 ~~~5~~'g g.-< 00<> 0::; ,<.,...""1q; _ ~ ::.~ :3 ~ ~ ~~~~f'tO 5. g"'~2: ~~ t:I:' g.a; c..:J::l--r+~ ~,?-"'t;;~o ::l to ::E::r' ::I"" o.n~~g-o ~ f'8oG-~n ~ a.g'~6 5 ~ ~ ;'~....", ~~ o. =~ ~ 0 1""'1- n = g.~~5 [g ...,0. ... i:a~QCJ &3[~r 0: ::> P- "1;; n: ::> e ,;z '" ~ 5- ;; ::> Q. ~~ -'< UJ ~ C tT' '" 0 {)::>::r ::l (') n o '" 0 z 2,~ !'O :r ~ 0_ "0. z~.. o ;:, '" ~~ '" 0 "0'" '" '" """ s~ ,.,. '" ~3 o 5 g ..... en-+ 11~;' ~ 6~ .... ::> c:r ~ V'I 0- ~ I n o ::I' .. 2" '" 0- ~ o 3" 'C ~ 3 '" a o ....~ ~ S Eio: 1:;"= c ~ _lI<> lil : 1;;; - '" ag", _ 2 ~ 0 c- C <: g.d <r ::r' '" '" -+< .... - <: ::l nr. ~~ !" ... o o ..., s:: ~ .... ... a ~ C <l> 5.~ tt> '" p.~ .... (1l .Q == '"' <l> r '" t: '0 "0 o ... ;:;- P- O" '< , .'& ;~'" :> .1 z g <> en )> 2 -I )> ;: o 2 )> . CJ ;1J )> C) c: DJ ~ )> rn -<z. 0-1 :O;l> o C'l :2 ;l> )> 2 ZCIl n-l m !l ;r- ~ o ." ... IQ '" W i ~ :to ~ ~ ...... '" ::l t: "" ~ V\ \C ....., \"J --- '" --- i~ .., m .....-1 r"'J !"l"IO...... ~,,;>:lgC/) ::; ~ <.., ~ 3~>g-"' ~<Z~~ -gco~ o.rr:"""lr., v Z ;:j V'J' Ul-l 8"m <? rn 2.z :5 ::: < 0 g <: rn Z . (') " ;""") --- ~ i: ;;'. "-""r--n 3:m==:r :.o,~ r"'J z--- ::Or-> ~ .., " ;>:l-r"'J - ~go5z ce;(1~tn ~ ~ r-::: !"l"I '" C<O QZ;>:l::tl 5rnr:.li ft, (I). G '" 0.0 ';;;-c/) ---> <: t'l'" C/) > Z -l > 3:: o z r:i > I:l:l > -< g,;r~~ :l2~~-l ::r;:r ::r o ~ e: r;; '"'0 :: (1: 0 ap..~a. ~ [~ 5 ~ ~~ ~ 05.2:g ., '::I) ('tI ~ 5~~= S~Q.5 R :; ~ ~ Vlo..v:.(t. ::o;iEfo ~-'iJ"G ;.~~ '" 0. '" ~3~fr c:~5-~ Oci~-gn <t-=--~p ~~g~ ". r. ~E.O< .g ct; :::I ('ll C. ;~~ ::J r; ::J (D :, p :; ~ s: ~ ~ - ..., ==~E- ~ ~... ~ r.r- ~ 1)1: S:S" 2 ~ n ... "" .'" Z'" ~E. n o - S 3 Cf''O o "0 < ~ g n ~ '" Cf'::;' o ~ ~ " ;:r'r-t- E:8~ o _ '0 .... g a ~ f: ;5 ~ g 5 II> ::l - II> ~ @ ~ c ~ _ ., - ... 0 ti g ~ Q ." Q. - rtE:~ (.I]~ n "" C " "" "" - - ... "" 0. '" tI n CIl 0"::: ~ ~ 2 r r ~ 0-< ::l <> X o '" ""'3 :0'0 <'t '" :E 0. ",,",) '. ...-.;. t ! t-.j O'~ ~ :::'.?6 ;;.gt;>~ c 0 ~ r.. ~ ~~~~g ~~:[~ 80 2 ~ C': ~;~ag~ Q:~~~~~~ -;r~~~~~ f1IC.-'~r"4G _v-::I::rv- ~ '"C .=: G <:- .... .... 0 ~ ~ ~ 8.~aD~gg O"'t:"-'<-<~ r; "<: - co'" .... :::.~ ~~o. ~ a~;'~~~~ ('")~n=-.-+~ ~"'ror;ct~~ ~[Z:~~5 :;'~2=~e l'S'~(":;-2:h ~ s;.;.:::- 0 (tl ~-o~ u;~~. '-' < ::::r -,; c:r .. ... \C c;. ~ -< o..~ -.J o~~~aw (t 0 3 ~ _ ~ ~<"O(t~ 1l1<>-<~::::;' 3g:...~~v &W5Q@ s- (; ~~ ~.g o _ ~ g '" o ...... CI) )> ~ :c Z C) -I C ;l> 3: :s:: m o Z Z -l ~Z W ~ -< o :c 52 Z )> Z n m 'T1 ~ < o :c o TI )> o o ~ ::L o Z TI C ... -i ~ J: w m , . i " ~>'- ~ Ii . ~ TO. Don Arnett, Dlrector of Recreat~on and Parks i t l ~ [.;.::: II:-'L I'c ~~ fl_'jII DATE: October 16, 1981 FROM: SUBJECT: Clty Clerk Ann Shore Reef Pro) ect '" ~ Attached are two certified copies of sect10ns of C1ty Council i--:: ""~ ... minutes of October 6, 1981, relatlng to Councll approval 1n ~7h.~ l-~ ;.,-",- I:[ 1ft" .- K ;or ~ ~ ~ !;;< - &- ,. R f.'" ~..... t, I:i~ 'L ~ t- ~ r r~ t~ ~~. [' ~ ,", ~{ concept of the Bay Reef proJect. This is sent for your trans- mittal to John Lyle, 1816 Manning Avenue, West Los Angeles, California 90025, at his request. earlier this week. Attachment ~ - ~ ~ " ,,- ~'".. t> t ~- ~ L:r. t: r f; ~""- f~' ~ . !"">-'" ..- f", '" ~-.- i' ,