Loading...
SR-10A (22) EPWM CP AA RC RS ro s \sp1608\cc1608ywpd City Council Meeting November 25, 1997 1 t'fA ~ /- ~) tWV- 251991 Santa MOnica, California TO Mayor and City Council FROM City Staff SUBJECT Recommendation to Accept the Certified Results of the Street Resurfacing Assessment Election and Approve the Formation of the Assessment Dlstnct In Conformance with the Right to Vote on Taxes Act (Prop 218) Introduction ThIs report recommends that the City CouncIl accept the certified results of the street resurfacing assessment election as tabulated by the City Clerk and approve the formation of an assessment district for repalnng concrete curbs, dnveways, and sidewalks, for resurfacing streets, for restonng parkways, for constructing concrete gutters, for reconstructing alleys, and for completing the appurtenant work These Improvements are to be performed In fulfillment of the FY 1996-97 Annual Street Resurfacing Program at vanous commercial, Industnal, and residential locations The report also recommends that the City Council adopt the attached Resolution of Intention to assess property owners for construction costs In conformance with the Right to Vote on Taxes Act (Proposition 218) and order the work to begin Background The FY 1996-97 Annual Street Resurfacing Program Includes gutter construction, street resurfacing, alley Improvements, slurry sealing, parkway pavement removal, curb ramp lOA r~ov 2 5 1997 construction, curb and gutter repairs, bus pad construction, and sidewalk and dnveway repair and construction at various locations In the City The crltena used to determine the streets and alleys Included In this year's program and the method of repair Include age, drainage problems, surface and subsurface conditions, complaints received, type of use (I e , commercial or residential), current traffic volume, and projected change of use or traffic volume Bids for the construction of thiS project were received on January 21, 1997 Damon Construction Company was awarded thiS project by City Council on February 25, 1997 The contractor was authorized to proceed with the non-assessment portion of the project until the new Right to Vote on Taxes Act (Proposition 218) assessment dlstnct process was resolved The non-assessment related portion of the work IS complete and the contractor IS currently awaiting authonzatlon to proceed with the remaining work In accordance Proposition 218, an Engineer's Report was prepared which determined the general and speCial benefits of each specific proposed Improvement General benefits enhance the public as a whole, while speCial benefits enhance a particular parcel A copy of thiS report IS available In the office of the City Engineer According to Proposition 218, parcels may only be assessed for speCial benefits ThiS report recommends that parcels be assessed for only 50% of the speCial benefit cost of the proposed Improvements determined by the Engineer's Report The recommended 2 reduction In assessment charges IS In consideration of the burdens on properties caused by the Northndge earthquake and the high policy pnonty which has been assigned to Infrastructure repair and maintenance by the City Council as a significant community benefit It IS recommended that street resurfacing and alley reconstruction assessments for reSidential properties be waived to be consistent with long-standing City policy Consistent with recent City policy, assessments will also be waived for non-profit organizations which can provide eVidence of receiving a welfare exemplion from the Los Angeles County Tax Assessor Proposition 218 DIscussion Ballots and notices of the City's Intent to form an assessment dlstnct and hold a public heanng In conformance with Prop 218 were mailed to affected property owners at least forty five (45) days In advance of the time and place of the public heanng In accordance with State law Ballots were tallied proportional to the financial obligation of the affected property For example. If one property has work totaling $300 that property has 300 votes as compared to a property that may have $5,000 worth of work receiving 5,000 votes The City Clerk received all ballots and kept them secured until the voting was closed on November 11, 1997 There was a total of 472 ballots mailed to affected property owners with 212 completed ballots returned There were 124 ballots In favor and 88 ballots opposed The final vote count was 76,426 votes In the affirmative and 65,976 votes In the negative The results of the ballot tally resulted In a maJonty of property owners- 3 proportional to their financial obligatlon- voting In the affirmative to form the assessment district Payment Options Property owners paYing for street resurfacing, alley reconstruction, gutter, curb, parkway and sidewalk reconstruction will have the option of making a cash payment within 30 days or Installment payments plus Interest The terms of the Installment payment plan will be determined at the time staff returns to council to confirm costs Method of Spreading the Assessment Cost Recommended costs are summarized In the following table Non-ReSidential ReSidential Property Owners' Property Owner's Share of Cost Share of Cost Total (50% of the Special (50% of the Speaal Work Performed Unit Cost Benefit Cost) Benefit Cm;;t) Gutter Construction $1800 ILF $6191 LF N/A Street ResurfaCing $21 501 LF $7 28 1 LF N/A Alley Reconstruction $70 00 1 LF $23 87 1 LF N/A Sidewalk Repair $7 50 1 SF $2 65 1 SF $2 75 1 SF Driveway Repair $9 00 1 SF $3 10 1 SF $3 56 1 SF Curb Repair $20 00 1 LF $6 88 1 LF $7 90 1 LF Parkway Restoration $4 00 1 SF $141/SF $1 471 SF 4 The Unit costs are set by the Supenntendent of Streets, and are penodlcally updated to reflect actual costs They Include staff time In conducting englneenng surveys, posting and mailing of notices, construction management, inspection and construction The street resurfacing assessment IS calculated so that non-residential property owners pay the same respective unit cost regardless of the width of the street affecting their property Corner lots are assessed either 50% or 100% of the proposed assessment share depending on legal address Owners of corner lots where the legal address IS the street being repaired pay 100% of applicable repair work If the legal address IS the adjacent street, the property owner pays 50% Corner lots have the potential of being assessed for both sides of their lot If both streets are Improved ThiS policy eases the Impact on corner lots by assessing 100% on one street and 50% on the cross street The assessment amounts were spread to all properties In the dlstnct based upon the proportion of the special benefit realized Any amount waived will be financed through City funds not the remaining properties In the assessment dlstnct City funding for thiS project totals $2,570.731 23 and the assessments total $329,11977 The commercial, Industnal and reSidential properties areas to be Included In the assessment dlstnct are as follows 5 STREETS TO BE RESURFACED, ALLEYS TO BE RECONSTRUCTED, AND GUTTERS TO BE CONSTRUCTED (Non-Residential Properties Assessed Only) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Street 6th Court 16th Street 18th Street 19th Street 20th Street 21 st Street Colorado Avenue Franklin Street Michigan Avenue Strand Street Yale Street Limits Wilshire Boulevard to Colorado Avenue Wilshire Boulevard to Montana Avenue Olympic Blvd to Santa Monica Freeway Olympic Boulevard to 495' north Wilshire Boulevard to Arizona Avenue Olympic Boulevard to Michigan Avenue Stewart Street to 26th Street Arizona Avenue to Colorado Avenue Cloverfleld Boulevard to 21st Court Main Street to Ocean Avenue Broadway to Santa MOnica Boulevard SIDEWALKS, DRIVEWAYS, CURBS TO BE REPAIRED, AND PARKWAY PAVEMENT TO BE REMOVED (Non-Residential and Residential Properties Assessed) at vanous locations on 2nd Street 3rd Street 4th Street 5th Street 6th Street 7th Street 9th Street 10th Street 11th Street 12th Street 14th Street 15th Street 16th Street 17th Street 18th Street 19th Street 20th Street 21 st Place 21 st Street 22nd Street 23rd Street 24th Street 25th Street 26th Street 29th Street 31 st Street 32nd Street 34th Street Alta Avenue Arizona Avenue Ashland Avenue Bay Street Berkeley Street Broadway California Avenue Cedar Street Centlnela Avenue Chelsea Avenue Cloverfield Blvd Colorado Avenue Copeland Court Delaware Avenue Euclid Street Franklin Street Fraser Avenue G ra nt Street Harvard Street High Place HIli Street Hollister Avenue Idaho Avenue Kansas Avenue Kinney Street La Mesa Drive Lincoln Boulevard Main Street 6 Maple Street Marguerlta Avenue Marine Street Michigan Avenue Montana Avenue Navy Street Oak Street Ocean Avenue Ocean Park Blvd OlympiC Boulevard PaCifiC Street Palisades Avenue Pearl Street Pennsylvania Ave PICO Boulevard Pier Avenue Pine Street Pnnceton Street Raymond Avenue Santa MOnica Blvd San Vicente Blvd Schader Drive Stanford Street Strand Street Wadsworth Avenue Washington Ave Wilshire Boulevard Yale Street Budget/Flnanclallmpact The total cost of this prOject IS $2,899.851 Total revenue of $329.11977 from this assessment is expected to be received In FY 1997-98 Gutter construction. alley reconstruction and street resurfacing assessments for non-residential property owners Will generate $124.531 60 and Will be depOSited In revenue account no 01-500-402-00000- 0124-10000, "Street ResurfaCing Assessment" after construction IS complete and costs have been confirmed Additional revenue In the amount of $204,588 17 for the repair of Sidewalks, driveways and curbs. and parkway restoration Will be depOSited In revenue account no 01-500-421-00000-0179-10000, "Sidewalk Repair Revenue" after construction IS complete and costs have been confirmed A detailed breakdown of assessments Will be available upon confinnatlon of assessments after the work has been completed 7 Recommendation Staff recommends that the City Council Accept the certlfed results of the assessment distriCt, 2 Approve the formation of the above assessment distriCt, and, 2 Order the work to begin Prepared by Craig Perkins, Director of Environmental and Public Works Management Anthony Antlch, P E , City Engineer Renee Cowhlg, Maintenance Manager Attachment Resolution Certified Election Results 8 EPWM CP AA RC RS ro S \SP1608\CC1608y wpd City Council Meeting November 25,1997 Santa MOnica, California RESOLUTION NUMBER 9218 (ees) (CITY COUNCIL SERIES) A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA FINDING THAT THE PUBLIC CONVENIENCE AND NECESSITY REQUIRE THE CONSTRUCTION OF CONCRETE GUTTERS, ALLEY IMPROVEMENTS, STREET RESURFACING, SIDEWALKS AND DRIVEWAYS, CURB REPAIRS, RESTORATION OF PARKWAYS, AND APPURTENANT WORK, IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE FY 1996-97 STREET RESURFACING PROGRAM WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Santa MOnica on September 9,1997, passed and adopted Resolution of Intention Number 9196 (CCS) declaring Its intention to order work described therein to be done, and WHEREAS, Resolution of Intention Number 9196 (CCS) was duly and legally published as required by law, notice was given In a manner required by law and all written objections and protests to the proposed work or the extent of the district were heard and considered by the City CouncIl. and WHEREAS, public hearings have been held pursuant to Resolution of Intention Number 9196 (CCS) and the laws and ConStitution of the State of California on the proposed construction of concrete gutters and alley Improvements, street resurfacing, repair of damaged sidewalks and driveways and curbs, restoration of parkways, and appurtenant work as described In Resolution Number 9196 (CCS), on the following City streets 1 6th Court. from Wilshire Boulevard to Colorado Avenue 2 16th Street, from Wilshire Boulevard to Montana Avenue 3 18th Street, from Olympic Boulevard to Santa MOnica Freeway 4 19th Street, from Olympic Boulevard to 495' north 5 20th Street, from WilshIre Boulevard to Arizona Avenue 6 21st Street, from Olympic Boulevard to Michigan Avenue 7 Colorado Avenue, from Stewart Street to 26th Street 8 Franklin Street, from Arizona Avenue to Colorado Avenue 9 Michigan Avenue, from Cloverfield Boulevard to 21st Court 10 Strand Street, from Main Street to Ocean Avenue 11 Yale Street, from Broadway to Santa MOnica Boulevard, and WHEREAS, public hearings have been held pursuant to Resolution of Intention Number 9196 (CCS) and the laws and Constitution of the State of California on the proposed repair of Sidewalks, driveways, and curbs, and restoration of parkways at vanous locations on the followmg City streets 2nd Street 3rd Street 4th Street 5th Street 6th Street 7th Street 9th Street 1 Oth Street 11 th Street 12th Street 14th Street 15th Street 16th Street 17th Street 18th Street 19th Street 20th Street 21 st Place 21 st Street 22nd Street 23rd Street 24th Street 25th Street 26th Street 29th Street 31 st Street 32nd Street 34th Street Alta Avenue Arizona Avenue Ashland Avenue Bay Street Berkeley Street Broadway California Avenue Cedar Street Centmela Avenue Chelsea Avenue Cloverfield Blvd Colorado Avenue Copeland Court Delaware Avenue Euclid Street Franklin Street Fraser Avenue Grant Street Harvard Street High Place 2 Hill Street Hollister Avenue Idaho Avenue Kansas Avenue Kinney Street La Mesa Drive Lincoln Boulevard Main Street Maple Street Marguerlta Avenue Marine Street Michigan Avenue Montana Avenue Navy Street Oak Street Ocean Avenue Ocean Park Blvd Olympic Boulevard Pacific Street Palisades Avenue Pearl Street Pennsylvania Ave PICO Boulevard Pier Avenue Pine Street Princeton Street Raymond Avenue Santa MOnica Blvd San Vicente Blvd Schader Drive Stanford Street Strand Street Wadsworth Avenue Washington Ave Wilshire Boulevard Yale Street, and WHEREAS, said Improvements have been considered fully, NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA DOES RESOLVE AS FOLLOWS SECTION 1 The public Interest and convenience reqUIre, and the City Council of the City of Santa Monica hereby orders, the work described In Resolution Number 9196 (CCS) to be done on the following City streets 1 6th Court, from Wilshire Boulevard to Colorado Avenue 2 16th Street, from Wilshire Boulevard to Montana Avenue 3 18th Street, from Olympic Boulevard to Santa MOnica Freeway 4 19th Street, from Olympic Boulevard to 495' north 5 20th Street, from Wilshire Boulevard to Arizona Avenue 6 21st Street, from Olympic Boulevard to Michigan Avenue 7 Colorado Avenue, from Stewart Street to 26th Street 8 Franklin Street, from Arizona Avenue to Colorado Avenue 9 Michigan Avenue, from Cloverfield Boulevard to 21st Court 10 Strand Street, from Main Street to Ocean Avenue 3 11 Yale Street, from Broadway to Santa MOnica Boulevard Any and all of said protests and objections of every kind and nature to the proposed work or to the extent of the dlstnct to be assessed be, and the same are hereby. overruled and denied SECTION 2 The public Interest and convenience requIre, and the City Council of the City of Santa MOnica hereby orders, the work descnbed In Resolution Number 9196 (CCS) as the repair of sidewalks, dnveways, and curbs, and restoration of parkways at vanous locations to be done on the following City streets 2nd Street 3rd Street 4th Street 5th Street 6th Street 7th Street 9th Street 10th Street 11 th Street 12th Street 14th Street 15th Street 16th Street 17th Street 18th Street 19th Street 20th Street 21st Place 21 st Street 22nd Street 23rd Street 24th Street 25th Street 26th Street 29th Street 31 st Street 32nd Street 34th Street Alta Avenue Anzona Avenue Ashland Avenue Bay Street Berkeley Street Broadway California Avenue Cedar Street Centlnela Avenue Chelsea Avenue Cloverfield Blvd Colorado Avenue Copeland Court Delaware Avenue Euclid Street Franklin Street Fraser Avenue Grant Street Harvard Street High Place HIli Street Hollister Avenue Idaho Avenue Kansas Avenue Kinney Street La Mesa Dnve Lincoln Boulevard Main Street 4 Maple Street Marguerlta Avenue Manne Street Michigan Avenue Montana Avenue Navy Street Oak Street Ocean Avenue Ocean Park Blvd Olympic Boulevard Pacific Street Palisades Avenue Pearl Street Pennsylvania Ave PICO Boulevard Pier Avenue Pine Street Princeton Street Raymond Avenue Santa MOnica Blvd San Vicente Blvd Schader Drive Stanford Street Strand Street Wadsworth Avenue Washington Ave Wilshire Boulevard Yale Street Any and all of said protests and objections of every kind and nature to the proposed work or to the extent of the district to be assessed be, and the same are hereby, overruled and denied SECTION 3 The City Council hereby finds and determines further that the "Special Assessment Investigation, Llmltallon, and Majority Protest Act of 1931" shall not apply to the making of the Improvements SECTION 4 In accordance with the Right to Vote on Taxes Act (Proposition 218), a tally of returned ballots has determined property owner support of the district eXists SECTION 5 Improvements shall be conducted under the Improvement Act of 1913, set forth In the Streets and Highways Code of the State of California, and the Street Superintendent and the City Attorney presented to the City Council the Resolution of Intention required by the Improvement Act to Initiate the proceedings for the Improvements 5 SECTION 6 Reference hereby IS made to Resolution Number 9196 (CCS) for a descnptlon of the work, the assessment diStrict, and for further particulars SECTION 7 The City Council shall certify to the adoption of this Resolution, and thenceforth and thereafter the same shall be In full force and effect APPROVED AS TO FORM ^ "l " .. Ii i' '" I. <(, 1\, . c/~ J ' l..(~l....nJl-"'L.'~' l'~'VL{ (,...--( Marsha Jones Moutne City Attorney 6 STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ss L Mana M Stewart, City Clerk of the City of Santa MOllIca, State of CalIfornIa do hereby certIfy that the attached IS a true and correct canvass of the ballots receIved through the end of the publIc heanng held for the 1996/97 Street Improvement Assessment DIstnct on November 11,1997 Ballots ReceIved In favor Agamst Non-voted ballot Late ballot Total ballots receIved 124 88 01 01 214 $ 76,426 10 65,975 85 000 000 142.40195 $ VOTES IN FAVOR OF ASSESSME11iT DISTRICT: Ballot No Address Amount 001 814 2nd St $14850 003 10122nd 41440 011 2823 2nd 19800 015 2721 3rd 31600 017 2828 3 rd 343 75 039 8146th 2940 043 844 6th 9900 047 918 6th 9900 051 937 6th 297 00 054 953 6th 4950 060 430 7th 481 25 063 1140 7th 14460 064 271 0 7th 343 75 066 2607 7th 15220 069 2625 7th 515 15 076 1034 9th 206 25 079 18149th 220 00 083 333 11th 646 60 088 91811th 213 60 097 105112th 457 90 103 503 14th 987 65 104 1227 14th 9625 107 1412 14th 15900 113 948 15th 206 25 123 81716th 206 25 137 1147 16th 20160 138 115216th 14240 139 422 17th 989 60 140 428 17th 9625 144 144717th 265 00 2 145 958 18th 395 00 146 124718th 275 00 164 851 20th 343 75 165 954 20th 550 00 169 85221st 275 00 170 85821st 16500 173 222821st 52955 176 320221st 6875 196 253 25th 706 80 198 2443 25th 249 85 200 270 26th 265 00 201 168126th 577 65 202 2426 26th 9480 203 2321 29th 672 40 217 431 Ashland 302 50 227 1038 Bay 659 25 230 1221 Broadway 38145 'p') 2727 Broadway 576 05 ~.).... ~~~ 2904 Broadway 32640 ~.).) 236 1510 CalIfornia 98150 241 1721 Cedar 343 75 246 1047 Chelsea 50175 249 1450 Cloverfield 36638 256 2835 Colorado 14980 257 2930 Colorado 61670 260 3028 Colorado 6875 271 2614 Euclid 13750 277 1055 Franklm 206 25 290 1454 Franklm 6875 291 1457 Franklin 449 25 296 1514 Franklin 66195 304 130 Fraser 13 75 305 136 Fraser 19250 306 839 Grant 48125 314 658 HIli 275 00 316 1348 Hill 38915 322 2302 Hill 39495 323 2317 HIli Street 432 75 325 701 HIli 540 05 329 200 I Idaho 1.835 95 330 2021 Idaho 35225 331 1606 Idaho 4740 336 174 Kmney 14881 337 2009 La Mesa 893 75 4 340 1866 Lmcoln 59625 343 2626 Lmcoln 397 50 344 2640 Lmcoln 596 25 350 2104 Mam 266 84 351 1119 Maple 343 75 352 13 26 l\1aple 743 15 364 1328 Manne 275 00 365 1332 Manne 41250 380 13001 Montana 825 00 381 2632 Montana 9625 390 2024 Navy 343 75 391 2101 Navy 48125 403 515 Ocean 297 00 406 1017 Ocean 231 IS 410 1511 Pacific 14240 412 128 Pacific 288 75 417 2420 Pearl 13750 422 657 Pier 28714 423 827 Pier 13750 426 1334 Pme 41250 430 1044 Pnnceton 945 75 432 653 Raymond 377 40 438 1502 Santa Moruca 145120 453 140 Strand 55840 458 13 3 I WIlshIre 1621 80 472 960 Yale 125800 473 1044 Yale 16500 478 1443 Yale 6875 501 1530 Montana 67400 502 1601 WIlshIre 674 00 508 2906 Santa MOnIca 98331 509 2822 Santa MOnIca 984 04 512 2303 NeIlson 869 46 528 1802 Cloverfield 564 68 534 172821st 673 50 535 1730 21st 673 50 558 1646 19th 364 00 559 1640 19th 16016 560 1640 19th 483 83 561 630 Wtlshlre 238700 575 609 Colorado 2387 00 582 610 Santa Jl.fonIca 238700 583 14156th 1193 50 587 1443 6th 119350 6 588 609 Broadway 143220 589 1343 6th 8354 50 590 1328 7th 477400 591 623 Santa MOllica 2243 78 592 627 Santa MOllica 14322 593 14447th 237800 TOTAL $ 76,426.10 7 VOTES AGAINST ASSESSMENT DISTRICT: 002 831 2nd 388 80 007 2708 2nd 51060 008 2711 2nd 12375 010 27182nd 226 48 025 2731 4th 674 20 029 3120 4th 87975 033 26336th 30440 040 824 6th 917 80 048 923 6th 4950 049 927 6th 1053 36 052 943 6th 10782 058 1127 6th 287 04 061 810 7th 1133 05 074 27167th 11735 078 17479th 709 55 085 427 11th 727 50 096 958 12th 82170 110 2601 14th 967 25 115 1232 15th 284 50 122 2901 16th 807 75 126 847 16th 365 90 8 127 848 16th 249 10 1~~ 1017 16th 17425 ~~ 147 1538 18th 442 20 151 2004 19th 206 25 160 807 20th 48125 172 221821st 667 05 188 902 23rd 153939 197 921 25th 542 00 208 2658 32nd 13750 214 3101 Anzona 116875 224 1663 Ashland 1090 00 229 1017 Berkeley 41250 235 3121 Broadway 270 80 247 1053 Chelsea 1789 80 265 2944 Delaware 343 75 295 1511 Franklm 18960 298 1518 Franklm 203 65 307 1021 Grant 343 75 312 802 Harvard 37125 313 1907 HIgh 275 00 324 2324 Htll 206 25 3~'" 2351 Kansas 343 75 ~~ 9 339 1812 Llllcoln 530 00 341 2102 Llllcoln 397 50 355 211 Marguenta 628 80 366 2019 Marllle 343 75 369 1004 Michigan 21475 398 90 I Ocean 2046 40 405 90 I Ocean 1344 90 413 5506 Palisades 6875 414 634 Palisades 54175 416 1316 Pearl 873 10 418 2102 Pennsylvama 19875 428 938 Pnnceton 52175 411 657 Raymond 227 64 ~~ 434 70 I Raymond 333 55 437 90 I Santa Momca 129912 450 227 Strand 886 00 451 132 Strand 30440 460 1723 WIlshue 109619 468 843 Yale 875 54 469 924 Yale 65415 470 932 Yale 55000 477 1437 Yl1le 1650 10 510 2230 Mam 42125 518 2912 Colorado 1075 98 519 2092 Colorado 678 89 520 2842 Colorado 808 20 521 2834 Colorado 2380 80 524 2211 MichIgan 431040 537 174821st 152171 538 2100 Pennsylvarua 674 00 541 171921st 1347 00 542 172921st 673 50 548 171418th 41919 545 1800 OlympiC 33700 553 166119th 728 00 554 1901 OlympiC 36400 555 1899 Olympic 248 25 564 12476th 119350 571 1513 6th 119350 574 1535 6th 2387 00 576 626 Broadway 238700 580 14487th 1193 50 11 581 584 585 TOTAL 621 Broadway 14236th 1427 6th 238700 1193 50 1193 50 s 65,975.85 IN WITh'ESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my seal thIS 13th day of November, 1997 ~n~~ ~~ :\1ana M Stewart City Clerk 12 Adopted and approved tlus 25th of November. 1997 ~#/~ Robert Holbrook, Mayor Pro Tem I. Mana M Stewart, City Clerk of the City of Santa Momca, do hereby certIfy that the foregoing ResolutIOn 9218 (CCS) was duly adopted at a meeting of the City Council held on the 25th of November. 1997 by the following vote: Ayes CouncIimembers Ebner, FemsteIn. Greenberg, Holbrook, Rosenstein Noes CouncIimembers None Abstain Councllmembers None Absent CouncIimembers Genser. O'Connor ATTEST ~~~.~~ Mana M Stewart, City Clerk