Loading...
SR-8-B (98)Drd~ ~~3z(1~~n~ ~o ~ ~ 35~ (~~~e) ~D # 9 352 C~EQ~~ PCD SF KG.SDL f 1ppolsharelopspacelmun~poollccstffrpt wpd Counal Mtg ~ecember ~5, 1998 Santa Monica, California TO Mayor and City Council ~ FROM City Staff SUBJECT Ordinance for Introd~act~on and Fi~-st Reading Approving Development Agreement Amendment 97DEV-002, a Resolut~on Certifying the ~inal Er~vironmentaf Impact Report 98-Q02, a R~solution Approving Adoptiar~ of a Statement ot Overr~d~ng Cor~srdera#~ons and Adopt~on of A M~trgat~or~ Monitormg Plan Applicant City of Santa Monica Community and Cultural Services Department INTRODUCTIDN The Santa Monica Community Callege Distr~ct and the City of Santa Monica have agreed to enter into a Development Agreement Amendment to permit the reconstructjon and expansion of the MunEC~pal Pool Fac~lity In order ta appro~e the Development Agreement Amendment, the follawing actiflns are r~quired 1 Appr4ve fhe Resplution Csrtifying the Final Environmental Impact Repart eWaluating the environmental impacts of the pro~ect proposed in the Developmen# Agreement Amendment between fhe C~ty and Santa Manica College Authorizing th~ De~elopment of the Muniapal Pool Replacement P ro~ ect 2 Appro~e the Resolution making the CEQA findings necessary to appro~e the Amendment to the ~evelapment Agreement concerning the Munic~pal Pool site, anci adopting a Statement of Overndmg Cansiderations and Mitigation Monitoring Plan 3 Introduce tor ~~rst read~ng an ord~r~ar~ee adopt~ng the proposed Frrst Amendment to the De~elopment Agreement Amendment between the City and 5anta Monica College Authoriz~ng the De~elopment af the Munic~pal Pool Replacement Pro~ect g.~ _z_ ~EC ~ 5 ~8 DEC 1 51~48 An En~ironmental lmpact Report has been prepared for t~is pro~ect which identifies one unmitigatable traffic impact However, g~ven the public benefit of a new Municipal Pool facility, the Planning Commission and staff recommend adoptian of a Statement af O~erriding Considerafions BACKGROUND Pro~ect Descriptian Proposed ks an amendment to the existing Development Agreement between the City of Santa Monica ~rtd the Santa Monica Community College District ta allow the replacement and relocat~on of the Municipal Pool facility on tf~e College Campus on the site of the existing Parking Lot $ and w~thin the open space setback ad~acent t~ Parking Structure C and 16~h Street Parking Lot 8 is located on the site of Parking Structure B, wE~ich was demolished as a result of damage from the 199~ Northridge earthquake The Dev~lopment Agreement Amendment fs included in Ariachment A The Development Agreement Amendment vests the de~elopment entitiements for the Municipaf Paol on this specific s~t~, i~corporates fhe En~iror~mental Impact Report mitigation measures, locates pedestrian and ~ehicular access, and requires specific cond~t~ons tor the development based on t~e schemat~c des~gr~ draw~ngs, irrclud~r~g landscaping, Department of En~ironmental and Public Works Management, and Architectural Review Board requirements - 2 - Pra~ect Desiqn Proposed is a 5D-meter competit~on paol, an 80 foot by 75 faot ~nstructional poof, an approximately 7,~00 square foot, 2-story pool building, a 1500 square foot pool equipment building, 2200 square foot pool storage build~ng and 2~,800 square feet of deck and landscape~ area The pro~ect plans are included in Attachment K The main entrance to the pool facility w~ll be through the eastern side of the poal office, allowing for controlled access The facility will have an approximately 18 foot ~igh sound wall afong the entire western edge fac~ng 16`h Street The sound wall, which will be the main element ~~sible from #he stree#, wdl be constructed with a concrete block base of approximately fo~r feet and approximately 13 feet of p[astic sound baffle modules The one story pool starage building at the southern edge of the site mclt~des a sec~ndary pool entrance and pool equipment rooms Use The new Municipal Pool facility will be ~ointly operated by the College and the City's Department of Community and Cultural Services The hours of operation, staffing requirements, permit parking regulatians, maintenance and other operating functions will be established in a Joint Operating Agreement between the College and the City, which will be entered into a#ter the De~elopment Agreement Amendment ~s appro~ed TF~e detarls ot th~s agreement will be t~rta~~zed pr~or to t~e eommencement ot operat~or~ Although the exact hours of programming wilf ~ary according to season and demand, the use of the faality, by either party, w~ll start no earlier than 5 15 a m on weekdays, 7 a m or~ Saturdays, and 8 a m on Sundays, and end no later than 9 30 p m on - 3 - weekdays and 5 p m on the weekends, except for special e~ents and programs such as sw~m meets Develapment Agreement mrtrgatcon measure # 13 req~rrres that Ro instructional activities involWing whistles, bull horns or shouting will be perrnitted prior ta 7 a m on weekdays, and 8 a m or~ weekends Mitigation measures # 4, 5, and 6 afso require that bus route, bus parking, and participant parking information be prov~ded m ad~ance of swim meets to minimize neighborhood impacts due to special events Parkinq, Access, and C~rculatian Vehicular Access and Circulation Vehicular access will occur ~ia Pico Baule~ard at 17~~ Street wEth park~ng availabie m e~ther Parking Structure A or Park~ng Structure C as to be determined in the Joint 4perat~ng Agreement. Vehicles will anter from Pico Boulevard and, once on the campus grounds, will proceed west and enter Parking Structure A, which is ~mmediately to the west of the main Pico Boul~vard entrance, or turn sauth, and proceed toward Parking Structure C If necessary, vehicles may use the pool dra~-aff lane, in front of the pool fac~lity main entrance, and then enter Parking Structure C There will be four additional handicapped spaces at the ground level western corner of Parking Structure C, which will have direct access to the Municipal Pool entry The College shall designate 24 addit~onal spaces during peak use hours to accommodate the expected ~RCrease rn users dr~e to t~tcreased programmmg The primary bus stop serving the poal will be the Pico Boulevard bus stop ~ust east of 16th Str~et Team buses will make ad~ance arrangements to park in one of the college surface parking lots - 4 - Pedestrran Access Pedestrians may access the pool facility fram the ~ 6`h Street sidewalk A pedestrian path at the northern site perimeter wi~l lead to the ma~n entrance of the site's eastern s~de Pedestrians wafking from their cars parked in either Structure A or C w~ll also use this entrance This entrance is at grade I~vel, and does not require a hand~capped access ramp The viewing deck is served by an ele~ator, ta enable handicapped access to the second floor There w~ll also be a secondary controlled pedestrian access for college users at the southern edge of the site, which wEll only be open during the hours that the college is using the pool DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT A Development Agreement is a cor~tract between the City and a developer whECh authorizes the type and amount of development within a specific period of time Typ~cally, in Santa Monica, de~eloprnent agreements have provided develapers with guaranteed development rights in exchange for public benefits A development agreement must comply with the General Plan and Specific Plans but can supersede zoning regulations by establishing its own specific set of development standards The C~ty and the Sarrta Mor~rca College Board of Tr~stees entered into a Development Agreement in November, 19$9 to set forth the design and construction requirements for two parking structures, Parking Structures A and C, both of which were completed as described in the Agreement T1~e preferred site ~or the Mun~cipal Paol fac~lEty has been identified as the open space on the wes~ern edge of the campus, ad~acent to Par[ang - 5 - Structures A and C The 1989 Develvpment Agreemen# gvverns de~elopment in this area In order to b~aild an thrs s~te, the ex~stirrg Development Agreement must be amended The Develapmer~# Agreement amendment outlines the parameters for the specific MunECipa{ Pool faci~ity for which the attached Final Environmental Impact Report was prepared The City recognizes that the College is undergoing an extens~ve master planning process and the Municipal Pool facility is one part of this pro~ect The Master Plan pro~ects were considered as parF of tMe cumulative pro~ects in the Murncipal Pool er~Wironmental ana[ysis The College would like to expand existing Parking Structure C to replace the parking spaces that were lost when Structure B was dem~lished as well as to provide additional parking spaces Since Park~ng Structure C was autharized by the 1989 De~e[opment Agreement, any modification to tF~~s structure would require a separate De~elapment Agreement Amendment Such an amendment can only accur following com~let~on of additional en~ironmental analysis once the College campletes the parking structure expansion schematic design The De~elopment Agreement amendment sets forth all the developmen~ standards, mitigation measures, and re~iew procedures for the completion of the Municipal Poal Facil~ty As ~roposed, t~e follaw~r~g Developrrzent Agreement sect~or~s are amended or added Paragraph 2 Descr~ption of the Property (amEnded to include the Municipal Pool site, includmg bot~ surface Parking Lot 8 and the ad~acent open space) - 6 - Paragraph 3 Description of the pro~ect (amended to mclude proposed Municipaf Pool facEl~ty) Paragraph 4 Approved uses (amended to ~nclude parkmg for pool users) Paragraph 5 T~m~ng of construction (amer~ded ta mclude construction timing for the proposed pro~ect) Paragraph 6 Pro~ect mitigation (added to include mit~gation measures from the Murncipal Poal EIR) Paragraph 7 General Serv~ces, naw Department of Environmental and Public Works Management, requirements (amended to mclude specifc reqwrements for the Mun~cipal Poal pro~ect ) Paragraph 9 Effect of Agreement on land use regulations (amended to include discussion of the replacement of Parking Structure B} Paragraph 18 Not~ces (amended to include appropriate City departments} Exhibit A Legal description of property {amended) Exhibit B ~andscapmg requ~rements (amended~ Exh~bit G Public Works requirements (amended) Exh~bit D Site plans access and circulat~on [added) Exhibit E Mitigation measures (added) Exh~b~t F Standard Conditions for the Mun~cipal Pool Faality (added) Exhtb~t G The ongmal Development Agreement w~thou# exhibits, as all exhib~ts are changed by the First Amendmenf ~added) CEQA ANALYSIS An Environmental Impact Report (EIR}lEnvironmental Assessment ~EA) was prepared for this pro~ect Since the Federal Emergency Management Agency ~FEMA) and HoUSmg and Urban De~elapment (HUD) have discretionary approval of federai funding tar portrons of thrs ~ro~ect, an EA was prepared ~o sat~sty federal er~v~ror~menta~ review requ~rements Although a ~oint document was prepared, the City oniy #akes action on the EIR Therefore, only the EIR is referenced in this staff repart Copies of the draft ElR were distributed to the City Council and notices of availab~lity - ~ - were sent to the Planning Commission at the beginn~ng of the 45 day public review period, which closed an October '!6, 1998 A total of 3 comment letters were received These comment letters, as well as the respanse to comments, are included in the final EIR One camment letter from #he Gran# Gardens Homeowners Assoc~ation was submittEd after the close of the comment period (Attachment I} This comment letter addresses the potential neighborf~oad impacts of specific elements of the pro~ect design The fetter states the Associatian's preference for the proposed pro~ect, which has no exit anto 16'h Street, that the noise barrier should be constructed along the north, west and south boundaries of the M~nicipal Pool fac~lity, and that afl the mitigat~an measures m the DEIR should be implemented The Assaciation also requested that the Santa Monica College parking structures be open on the weekends when the Municipal Pool facility ~s in use, that the secondary entrance be monitored at all times and be strictly for college use, and that the haurs prohibiting whistles, shouting and bullhorns begin later in the day than specified in the EIR All mitigation measures tdentified in #he EIR shall be im~lemented as part of the Develapment Agreement Amen~ment The ma~ority of th~ Association's additional requests are also addressed m the DeWelopment Agreement Amendment Issues relating to bus parking, the hours of the parking facilit~es, monitoring of the secondary gate, and noise restnctions wiCl be addressed in the Joint Operat~ng Agreement which will establish the parameters of the facr~~ty's shared use The requrrements of this operating agreement shal~ cover the Eocatian of pool user parking and the hours of operatEan for the parking structures, and maintenance and staffing of the Paol Faality This Agreement shall be finalized prior to the completion of canstruction of the Munic~pal Pool facil~ty - s - No unmitigatable impacts were ider~tified m the areas of Air Quality, Noise, Artif~cial L~ght ShadelShadow, Aesthetics, Police Protection, Construction Empacts, and Ne~ghborhood Effects With adoption of the recommended mitigation measures, the EIR determined that these jmpacts could be reduced to below a significant {eveE As discussed befow, the anly sign~ficanf impact t~af coufd not ~e mitigated was in fhe area of TrafficlAccesslParking relating to additional trEps on neighborhood streets Traffic The EIR determ~ned that the pro~ect would resuit m a significant ne~ghborhood impact that cauld not be mitigated due to increased traff~c on Pearl, 14~" and 16'h Streets The City has strict standards by which traffic impacts to the ne~ghborhood are anafyzed The significance criteria far neighborhood traffic impacts defines the addition of any new trips to a residen#~al street which has daily volumes greater than 90 percent of capacity as significant As 14th,16th and Pear[ Streets currently function at greater thar~ 90 percent capacity, the addition of any new trips generated by ihe pool pro~ect result in s~gnificant neighborhoad traffic impacts that cannot b~ mitigated The proposed pro~ect, with no ~ 6th Street access, would add 21 aWerage daily ~rips on weekdays, and 17 a~erage da~ly trips on weekends, to 16th Street The additional trips, both curnufafive and those ge~erated by the pro~ect wauld result m 0% increase for Pearl Street, 0 3% mcrease tor 14`h Street ar~d 0 1°~o rr~crease tor ~ fi~h Street Due to the increase in trips, which cannot be mitigated, a Statement af O~erriding Considerations would be required to approve the proposed pro~ect Staff ~~I~e~es that the public benefit of relocating of the Municipal Pool to this site, enabling the 374 - a - spaces from Park~ng Struct~re B to be replaced at the interior of the college campus and thereby reducing impacts on ad~acent neighbars, combined wi#h the public benefit of a new Munici~al Paol fa~ility which m~ets C~ty goals for improved and expanded aquatic faci~ities, outweighs the trafFic impacts of an addition af no more than 0 3% da~ly trips to the immediate neighborhoad Alterna#ives The EIR also cor~sidered alternatives to the proposed pro~ect, as follows 1 The no-pro~ect alternati~e assumes the replacement of the Poo! Facdi#y an the existing site, and the replacement of the Par~Cing Sfructure B on its former site, res~tlting in greater impacts in all categones except for Police Protection and Construct~on Impacts than the proposed pro~ect with no 16th Street access 2 The EIR studied two alternate optEans for the 16`h Street site mbound access only from 16"' Street, or outbound access only to 1~r`' Street in analyz~ng these options th~ Ei R determined that the proposed pro~ect is the en~ironmentally superaor opt~on with the fewest impacts (Attachment J, Final EIR, Table 54, p Vl-4} Bath afternative access options had greater impact far Traffic, Access and Parking, and Neighborhood Effects PLANNING COMMISSIQN ACTION On November 18, 1998, The Planning Commission unanimously voted to recammend to the City Cauncil certificatior~ of the Final En~ironmental Impact Report and adoption of a Statement of O~erriding Consideratians and approval of the De~elopment Agreemen# Amendment The Planning Commission Staff Report is included as At#achment B A Copy of the Statement of Qfficial Action is mcluded as Attachment C The Planning Commission commented on spec~fic operating procedures, not~ng that the weeke~d haurs for paol use ended at 5 00 p m, and that there could be a demand for - 1D - weekend pool use that would extend later into the e~ening hours Although addit~onal ertvironmental analysrs wouPd be requrred ta deterrnine any possrble impacts of extended hours, the Commiss~on recommended that the Counc~! consider authorizmg the additional study to allow the flexibility to extend weekend hours later in the evening StafF supports this recommendation, but beiieves that the additianal analysis should include neighborhood inpuf and be conducted when the new pool faci]ity's final operating budget is being prepared ~n addition, the Planning Commiss~on ~ncluded in its recommendatian operat~onal mechanisms that wauld build i~ incentives #o encourage ~sers to take the bus or use alternati~e modes of transportaiion, and to rnake a policy to gi~e hiring preference to Pico Neighborhooc~ youth PREVIOUS ACTIONS The City's recent long-range plann~ng process for open space and parks identified the need for impro~ed and expanded aquatics facilities as a top community prior~ty In response, the City Council approved the appropriation of $3 9 million in th~ City's FY 1997-98 Capital Improvement Program Budget to replace the City's existing pooE facElity locatecf on the Santa Monica Callege campus Originally, it was assumed that the pro~eet inrould be constructed w~t~rn tf~e extstmg footprrnt of the eurrent Mr~n~cipal Poo~ site, located within the northwestern section of the campus In the wake of the Nor~hridge Earthquake, wh~ch damaged a number of key bu~ld~ngs on the campus, the College mitiated a master pEanning process to guide the physical - ~~ - reconfiguration of the maEn campus to best meet its educational mission This effo~t has ~nvol~ed numerous eammun~ty meetmgs and focus groups ta assess issues and priorit~es and evaluate a range of land use options The pracess culm~nated in review and action by the Santa Monica College Board of Trustees earher this year Supporting the inclusion of the new Municipal Pool on the College campus, the master planning effart ident~fied several potential sites for the pool that would meet the CoElege's goal to create a unified and effiaent campus layout and also meet the City's desire for an expanded aquatics facility that is physically accessible to the public As part of their mast~r plan pracess, the College publicly presented two final site opfions for the pool 1 Rebuilding the pool on the ~xistmg site ~n the mt~rior af the campus, resulting in the rebuilding of the demalished Parking Struct~re B at its previous 16th Street location, which is currently #emporary surFace Parking Lot 8 Parking Structure B was a four story structure with 374 parking spaces that was severely damag~d in the 1994 Northndge Earthquake and subsequently demolished Acc~ss was prov~ded from 16t" Stree# 2 Rebuilding the pool on the site of surFace Parki~g Lot 8 and on the ad~acent green space at the edge of the College campus along 16'h Street, combined with the expansion of Parking Structure C on a part~on of the old pool site Relocation of t~e Municipal Paol facility to th~s s~te would preclude the reconstruction of Parking Structure B on fhe site where it was originaEly located Therefore, construction of a replaceme~t structure with a minimum of 374 spaces efsewhere or~ the Coflege campus woufd be necessary In September, 1997, the City Council approved the award af a cons~ltanf contract for ~he des~gn of the new pool facility to Killefer, Flammang, Purtill Archifects with Rowley Interr~at~ona] as poof sub-consultants S+nce then, the to~lowrng act~vrties have taken place 1 Two community meetings to introduce the community to the project and the in~tial program and to further assess neighborhoad and community issues to supplement the outreach efforts conducted by Santa Manica College - 12 - 2 A preliminary evaluation of the two site options ~ncluding a determination of w~at fac+[+ties could be acc~mmodated on each s~te, prel~mmary analys~s of noise and circulat~on impacts and possible mitigations, and pre~iminary cost estimates 3 ReWiew and desEgnation o~ the 16th Street site as the preferred site and the existing pool s~te as the pro~ect alternative site by the City Council on November 25, '1997 4 Development of a concept design for the new facdity along 16th Street, based on mput from user groups (including seniors, persons with disab~l~t~es, and competiti~e, recreational, and instructional swim part~cipants), 16th Street ne~ghbors, and staff af the Santa Monica College anci City aquatics pragrams 5 Completion of a Draft Environmental Impact Repo~t assessing the impacts associated with replacement of the pool on the preferred site along 16th Stre~t as well as on the existing poof site, and concluding that the ~6`h Street Site is preferable ~n terms of en~~ranmental impacts 6 Completion of a draft Development Agreement Amendment between the City and Santa Mon~ca College ta permit the pool facility to be built along 16th Street, and appraval of the agreement by the Santa Manica Callege Board of Trustees at their No~ember 2, 1998 meeting 7 As outlined above, at the November 18, 1998 pub[ic hearing, tf~e Plannir~g Commiss~on unanimously recommended to Gity Council to certify the En~ironmental Impact Report, Adopt a Statemer~t of Overriding Considerations, and approve the Developmant Agreement Amendment 8 At their November 19, 1998 meeting the Parks and Recreation Commission unanimously recommend~d to City Council approval of the pro~ect Should the Counci~ apprave the Development Agreement and certify the EIR, the fiollowing steps must occur before construction begins ~ Approval of destgn by tt~e Are~t~tectural Re~iew Board 2 Develapment of protect design and construction documents 3 Award of construction contract Completian af construction is estimated by the first quarter af 200Q. This presumes an - 13 - accelerated des~gn process g~ven the f~nding deadlmes requ~red by the U S Department af Housing and Urban Development (HUD) for use of Community Development B~ock Grant Supplemental Earthquake Funds which have been apprapriated to support this pro~ect PUBLIC NOTIFICATION Pursuant to Mun~cipal Code Section 9 48 110, notice of the publ~c hearing was mailed to al€ owners ar~d residential and commercial tenants of praperty located within a~OD foat radius of the pro~ec# site and publ~shed in the Argonaut at least ten consecutive calendar days pr~or to tha hearing A copy of the notice is contained in Attachment G In addition action of the City Council, Planning, and Parks and Recreation Commissions, the City i~as hefd a total of 3 neighborhood meetings on the proposed pro~ect an introductEOn of the pro~ect to the community an November 6, 1997, a design workshap on December 4, 1997, and a focus group meeting on October 7, 1998 to re~iew the plans, model and Draft Envtronmental Impac~ Report BUDGETIFINANCIAL IMPACT The pro~ect is funded by the City's General Fund, Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA}, and Community De~elopment Block Grant Supplemental Earthquake Funds ~n the €o!low~r~g aecounts 01-740-51 'f -20p98-8900-99664 01-740-481-20Q9$-89D0-99421 19-74Q-511-20098-8900-99fi~4 ~ 3-500-402-$6524-5501-13005 01-740-511-20099-8900-99664 70TAL ~1,761,691 157,'k 91 1,527,~61 174,643 450,000 $4,071,086 ° 24 - A preliminary cost estimate completed in November 1998 on the concept design has rdentrfred a construct~on budget of $4,987,65~ The estimate mcludes mcreased costs from earlier estimates ~m No~ember, 1997} due to ~efocation of the pro~ect on the 1 Eth Street site, current poal configuration and constructian costs which have increased significantly sinc~ the previous estimate, and ava~labifity of more detailed information The shortfall of funding will be submitted for cansideration in de~elopment of the FY 1999~00 Capital Improvement Program, ar~d any addit~onal funding should be made a~ailable with the award of construct~on contract (anticipated in mid-1999) Hence, na additianal budgetary actions are needed at this time Staff contmues to rEfine the pro~ect, and is currently re~iewing a~roposal from FEMA for additional funding RECQMMENDATION It is recommended that #he Council take the following actions ~ Approve the Resolution Certifying the Final Enviranmental Impact Report ~~aluating the enWironmental impacts of the pro~ect proposed in the De~eEopment Agreement Amendment betweer~ the City and Santa Monica Gol[ege Authorizing the Development of the Municipal Pool Replacement Pro~ect, and 2 Ap~ro~e #he Resolufian makmg the CEQA findmgs necessary fo appro~e the Amendment to the Develppment Agreement concerning the Municipal Pool site, and adopting a Staternent of Overriding Considerations and Mitigation Monitonng Plan, and 3 Introduce for first reading an ordinance adopting the proposed First Amendment to the Development Agreement Amendment between the City and Santa Monica College Author~zrng the Developmer~t of #he Municrpal Pool Replacement Pro~ect according ta the following f~ndings DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT FINDINGS The proposed Development Agreement is consistent with the ob~ect~ves, pol~cies, general land uses and programs specified in the general plan and any - 15 - applicable specific plan, in that the pro~ect ~s cans~stent with Land Use Element Policy 1 11 ~, which states "Encaurage development of parks and recreation facilities to rneet the needs of both resident and day time population with particular attention to middle size parks and play I~ts geared to families with chddren " As praposed, the Munic~pal Pool facility will provide a ~aluable recreatian fac~lity that serves ~oth the residential community of loca! families and citizens as well as the a~erlapping day tEme and residential community of Santa Monica College students The proposed desEgn, which includes bath the shallaw instruct~on/ recreation pool designed for safe use by children, and the farge, full size campetition poal, which pro~i~es for the needs af the college students as well as adult swimmers, complies with this Land Use Element policy by pro~iding a recreational facility for both fam~lies and individuals A new Mur~icipal Pool facility will also address the cammuni#y priority far the expansion of recreationa~ aquat~c facilities identified m the Parks and Recreation Master Plan process, and the Master Plan strategy of developing a new competitive and instructianal pool complex at Santa Monica College Draft Open Space Element Policy 2 2 encourages the expans~on af open space through shared use af certain fac~lities, and Policy 2 3 encourages the improvement of school sites as public open spaces The Municipal Pool facility rneets both af fhese policies by improving fhe public poal facifi~ies and creafing a new aquatic center at the Sant Monica Co[lege campus The Muniapal Pool Facility is also consistent with Land Use Ob~ective 1 1, to improve the qual~ty of life for all res~dents by pro~iding a balance of land uses, and encourages making Santa Monfca a more ch~ld-friendly environment by providing recreational facdities 2 The proposed ~eveloprnent Agreement Amendment is compatibfe with the uses authorized m the district in which the real property is located, ~n that the sub~ect property is located in the R2 distnct, which perrnits both public parks and schoa! uses, and is also located in the Public Lands Overlay District, which permits recreational facilities 3 The proposed De~elopment Agreement Amendment is in conformity with the public necessity, public con~enience, general welfare, and good land use pract~ces, in that it allows for the relocation af the Municipal Poal to a site where the development of the pool use will have fewer impacts an the ad~acent neighborhood than the rebuilding of a four level parking structure at the site The De~elopment Agreement Amendme~t permits Santa Mon~ca College to implement this portion of the College Master Plan, elirnir~ating the surFace parking lot at the proposed pro~ect site while reducing the amount of college traffic which exits and enters onto ~ 6`" Street - 16 - 4 The proposed Development Agreement Amendment will not be cletrimental to the health, safety and general weEfare, in that it allows a use that is cansistent w~th the ~and Use and CErculat~or~ Element as well as th~ araft Open Space Eiement and Parks and Recreation Master Plan, which identify aquatic uses as a cammunity priority 5 The proposed Development Agreement Amendment wiil not adversely affect fhe orderly de~elapment of the property, in that the De~elopment Agreement Amendment facilitates the relocation of the pool facility to a site that has been ~dent~fied by the Fina! Env~ro~mental lmpact Report as hav~ng fewer traffic and neighborhoad effects impacts than the alterr~ati~es studied, incluc~ing the ~`no pro~ect" alternative In addition, the relocatior~ of the pooi faci[ity, as established by #he Development Agreement Amendment, allows for the future development of the current pool site, if the ca[fege so chooses The mitigation measures and cand~tions required by the Development Agreement Amendment ensure the construction and operation of the pool use in a manner tha# has a min~maf impact to the surrounding community 8 The proposed De~elopment Agreement will ha~e a positi~e fiscal impac# on the City in that the proposed new Mun~cipal Pool facility wifl include state-af-the art heating and fiitration systems w1~~ch will maximize energy eff~aency Although the operating costs of #he facility will increase due to the expanded size, the cost per person served will be reduced due to grea#er energy eff~cier~cy and water conservation features Prepared by Suzanne Frick, Director Karen Ginsberg, Planning Manager Amanda Schachter, Senior Planner Sarah Le~eune, Associat~ Planner City Pfanning Div~sion Planning and Community De~elopment Department Barbara Stinchfield, Director Brett Horner, Senior Analyst Community and Cul#ural Ser~ices ~epartment Attachments A Amended De~elopment Agreement B Planning Cammission Staff Report, November ~ 8, 1998 C Statement af 4ff~cial Action, Planning Commiss~on Meeting, No~ember 18, 1998 D Resolution Certifying Environmental Impact Report ~ - '~ ~5€~ - 17 - E Reso[ution of 5tatement of O~erriding Cons~derafions F Ord~nance App~-oving Arnendment Number One Agreement G Natice af Public Hearing H Radius and Location Map I Carrespandence J Final EIR K Site Plan, Floor Plans and Elevations SDL F 1PPD~,SHAREIOPSPACEiMUNIPOOL1CCstffrpt wpd December 9, 1998 ~ ~~ rj ~ + ~ To the Development -1s- ATTACHMENT A ~~ ~' V ~ J RECORDING REQUESTED BY AND V4'I~N RECORDED MAIL TO CITY OF SANTA ~ZONICA 1585 Main Street, Room 212 Santa ~Ton~ca, CA 94401 Attention Plann~ng Director Space Above Line For Recorders Use 1Vo Recordmg Fee Rec~uired Government Cade Section 27383 AMENDMENT' NUA~BER ONE TO DEV~LOPI~~NT AGREEMENT -Chis Amendment ~Vumber One to Development Agreement {"First Amendment"), dated for reference purposes December _, 1998 ~s entered into by and between the CITY OF SANTA MO~IICA, a murnc~pal carporation (here~nafter "City") and the SANTA M0~1ICA C0~~~1L'1`ITY COLLEGE DISTRICT and T~~ BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF SANTA h1QNICA CO~~~1LrVITY COLLEGE DISTRICT (here~nafter referred to as the "D~strict" and the ~~Board of Trustees'' respectively), and is made with reference to the fallowing RECITALS A C~ty and District and Board of Tn.istees entered into a Development Agreetnent dated No~ember 1~, ] 989 ("Ongmal Development Agreemenf~} 1 ~ ~':~ ` 1~[~ll B The Orig~nat Develapment Agreement affects that certarn reai property described in Exhibit "A," Nos 1 and 2, attached hereto C Pursuant ta the terms and cor~d~tions of the Ongmal Development Agreement, the Crty approved a plan for the development of two {2) parking structures now commonly known as "Park~n~ Structure A~' and "Parking Structure C" D Prior to the execution of the Original Develapment Agreement by the City, the City Counc~l of the Gity of Santa h~onica ("City Counc~l") (1) duly adopted Ordinance No 1502 (CCS) on l~Tovember 14, 1989, approvin~ the Orlgmal De~elopment A~reement, (2) authonzed the City Manager to execute the Onginal Development Agreement an behaif of the City, and (3) certified the or~~inal final Environmental Impact Report on the Pro~ect E Pursuant to the terms and condit~ons of the Onginal Development Agreement, Parkmg Structure A and Parking Structure C were developed F The parties desire to amend the Origmal Develapmen# Agreement to authorize the replacement and relacation of the n~unic~pa! Poo! currently lacated on the campus of Santa h•~anica College ("S'~iC") in Santa Monica {"I~~un~clpal Pool Facil~ty") '~Zore specifically, the parties desire to amend Paragraph 2 relat~r~g to the descript~on of the Property, Paragraph 3 relat~ng to the descnption of the pra~ect, Paragraph 4 relatin~ to appraved uses, Paragraph 5 r~latmg to the tlmin~ af ca~str~zct~on of the pro~ect, Paragraph b relatmg to pro~ect mitigation 2 ~! ~ ~- ~.~ ~ 1 measures, Paragraph 7 relating to General Sernces Requirements, Paragraph 9 relatmg to effect of agreement on land use regulations, Paragraph 1$ relating to notices, Exhibit A relattng to the site le~al descnption, Exhibit B rela~~ng to landscap~ng requirements, and Exhibit C relating to public ~~~orks requ~rements and to add Exhibit D relatmg to project site plans, access and circulation plans and elevat~on plans, Exhibit E relating to pra~ect mit~gat~on measures, Exhibit F relating to ti•Tun~c~pal Poo1 Facility standard condrt~ons, and E~ibit G wh~ch constitutes the Or~g~nal Development Agreement w~thaut exhibits G The illunicipal Pool Facility will be developed in the designated open space set back for Parking Structure C and m Parking Lot S This First Amendment relates only to that development and does not otherwzse change the physical development of Parking Structure A and Parking Structure C already approved by the City and constructed by the District H Park~n¢ Lot S currently provides 9b surface level parkmg spaces This parkting lot is located on the site of former Parkmg Stmcture B Parking Structure B cansisted of four le~els above-Qfade and contained 374 parking spaces This parking structure incurred significant structurai damage due to the I~orthridge Earthquake and v~jas subsequently demollshed The Crty supports the construction of a rep~acement parking structure on the Sh1C campus w~thin the next five ~~ears ~~ hich ~vould conta~n a m~rvmum of 374 spaces The actual replacement parking structure v~-ould be sub~ect to Gty d~scret~onary review and approval after a complete en4~ronmental anal~rsis has been conducted in accordance w~th the Cal~forn~a Envtronmental 3 „ i9 +~° ~- ~~ ~ C. Quahty Act {Caf~forn~a Public Resources Code Section 2100Q et seq ("CEQA"} a~d C~ty standards I A Draft Env~ranmental Impact Report was prepared by Christopher A Jasep~ & Associates for the C~ty with res~ect to the amendments to the Deveiopment Agreement contained in this First Amendment and circulated for public comment, all in compliance with the Caiifornia Env~ronmental Quality Act {the "DEiR") Comments on the DEIR were rece~ved from members of the puh~ic and a final Environmental Impact Report was prepared and duly considered by the Santa ~~son~ca Plann~n~ Commission in connection with its rev~ew of this First Amendment The C~ty Council similarly reviewed and considered the informatjon contained in the final Env~ronmental Impact Report pnor ta approv~ng this First Amenc~ment J The City has complied with all procedures requ~red by Californja Gavernment Code Sect~on 65864 et seq and Santa Monica Municipal Code Sectians 4 4$ 014 et se~c regarding the processing of th~s First Amendment, ~nciuding Santa R4onzca Murucipal Coe3e Sectton 9 48 170 which authorrzes arr~endment, in.~hale ar in part, of ex~st~ng development agreements, by, among other thin~s, completmg the follow~ng 1 The Plannin~ Commiss~on ~-eld a du~y-noticed pubiic hear~ng on the Ftrst Amendment on No~~ember 1 S, 199$ and made its wntten recommendations to the City Cour~cil in accordance u~ith 5anta Manica Munccipal Code Sect~on 9 48 130 4 ~ "' ~ u ~ i 2 The Crty Council held a duly-noticed public heanng or~ the First Amendment Follo~~~ing complet~on af the publEC hear~ng and consideration of the recommendation of the Plann~ng Comm~ssion, the Crty Council adopted an ord~nance approvmg the Fcrst Amendment and authonz~ng the City Manager to execute th~s Agreement K Unless atherwise prov~ded, all terms used here~n shall have the same meaning as in the Or~g~nal De~~elopment Agreement L The provisions of this First Amendment are consistent w~th the City's General Plan for several reasons, including, wlthout hm~tahon, the followmg (1) Land Use Efement Ob~ective i I[improve t~e quaIity of life for a[I residents by providing a balance of ~and uses] encourages making Santa Monica a more child-friendly env~ronment by pro~iding recreat~onal facilrties The Munic~pal Poal Fac~lity prov~des both a competltion pool and a large recreational pool to accom~nodate the community's identified aquatic needs (2) The Draft Open Space Element Pal~cy 2 2 encourages the expansion of open space through the shared use of certam fac~Iit~es and Po~icy 2 3 encourages the improvement of school sftes as publ~c open space The l~~unicipal Pool Facility expands and impraves upon the Crty's ex~st~ng publ~c pool facil~t~es b~~ creating a new aquatic center on the S~1C campus h~ ~~~~~ NOV4', THEREFORE, in cansiderat~on of the covenants and cond~t~ons ~ereinafter set forth, and for other ~oad and valuable consideration, the rece~pt and sufficsency af which are herei~y ackna~vled~ed, the partres hereto da hereby agree tnat the Or~ginal Devetoprnent Agreement shall be amended in the following respects, such amendments to be applicable as ofthe Effective Date 1 Paragraph 2(Descrtpt-on af Property) ~s hereby amended in full to read as follows The Property described ~n Exhibit A cons~st~ng of two {2) lots cammonl_y known as "Parking Structure A" and "Parking Structure C" and the approximate~y 57,350 square foot parcel on ti~e wes# side of Santa Man~ca College upon wh~ch the Mun~c~pa1 Pool Facil~ty ~~~ill be develaped, bounded by Parking Structure A to the north, the access road and Parking Structure C to the east, the Fac~lity Serv~ces Department and athlet~c fieid to the south, and 16~' StrEet to the west 2 Paragraph 3(Description of the Pro~ect), Subparagraph A of the Or~ginal Development Agreement is hereby amended ~n full to read as foIlows ~ Tw~ Parking Structures The Pro~ect mcludes all aspects of the proposed development of the Property u~ith two (2} Park~n~ Stn.~ctures tivh~ch are more 6 ~cl f. ~ l : ~ J particu~arly descnbed herem and ~n Ea~ubit B, including the followmg components 1 Parking Structure A, on the South s~de ofPico Boulevard between 16~' Street and l 7'h Street, contaimng approxirnately 182,000 square feet of Floor Area and providmg approximateIy 402 full size and 292 cflmpact non-tandem park~ng spaces The Park~ng Structure shall not exceed four levels and a Building Height of 40 feet One level shall be at grade and the three athers shall be above grade The structure shaEl utilize the existing exit on 16~' Street as a r~~ht turn only 2 Parking Structure C shall be constructed on the Colle~e Saftball Field It shall conta~n approx~mately 238,000 square feet of F1oor Area and provide appro~mately 485 full size and 359 compact non-tandem parking spaces The Parking Structure shall not exceed fi~~e levels with ane le~el of s~bterranean parkmg, one level of at grade park~ng, and four 1e~~els of above-grade parking The Parkmg Structure s4~a11 not exceed a Bui~ding He~~ht of a8 feet This hei~ht limlt shall not preclude the ~nstallation of solar panels ta atta~n sustainable goals for the mumc~gai pool The Structure shall have one entrance and exrt from 17`h Street at Pico Boule~~ard The st~cture shall have no ex~t onto lb~' Street 3 The Total Flaor .~-ea of the Park~ng Struct~res descnbed in Paragraphs 1 and 2 shall nat exceed 420,a0 square feet 7 '~~° `~~~ 3 The follo«~ing Faragraph 3(Descnption of Pro~ect), Subparagraph D~s hereby added to the 4riginal Development D ~lunictpal Pool Facilrty 1 Frmctpal Components of Murucroal Pool Facility The Municipal PaoI Fac~lrty shall be canstructed ~n the open space area that fronts 16~' Street on the s~te of the former Parking Structure B, currently referred to as Park~ng Lot 8, and on the s~te af the landscape area located ad~acent to Park~ng Structure C and the 16`h Street curbl~ne Canstruct~an ofthe pro~ect ~~~~II consist of a 50 meter (lb4 feet) by 75 feet competrtion poal, an approx~mately 96 feet by 75 feet instructional and recreational pool, an approximately 1,500 square foot poal eq~ipment building, an approximately 2,2~0 sguare faot pool storage and equipment bu~ldin~ and an approxlmately T,500 square foot aquatic build~ng, which inc~udes the fallowmg uses pool locker rooms, tifeguard, paol superv~sors, and registrat~on offices, a first aid room, a view~ng deck and stafflacker room, an ~nstr~ct~onaUtra~ning room, and a coach/campetrtar team office Z Location of 11Tun~cipa~ Poo] Improvements Exhib~t D shows the iocation of the municipal pool and all re~ated pooi improvements In general terms, the competition pool ~~~~II be [ocated to the .~,~est of Parking Structure C on the southern part of the s~te The instruct~onal and recreat~onal pooi will be located to the south of Park~ng Structure A on the northern part of the srte The aquatic buildmg will be located between the competriion and instn.ictional and recreat~onal pools The poal storage and equipment areas w~ll be 8 ~, ~+ ~ ~- t ~ ~ t placed ~n tv~-o separate locations on the project site as follows at the northeast corner of the s~te, ~mmedtately ad~acent to Parking Stnxcture A and to tt~e south of the competition pool near the southwest corner af Parking Struct~re C The poo~ storage and equipment areas v~~ill consjst of enclosed areas bounded by fences, not to exceed 12 feet in he~ght above existin~ grade and measured at a continuum at every po~nt alang the wall 3 A~aximum Height of]~4unicipal Paol Improvements The ma~umum height ofthe aquatic buildmg will be 28 feet abave average natural grade ("Average Natural Grade" shall have the meanin~ set forth in Santa Monica Munic~pal Code Section 9 04 42 030 350 wh~ch ~s ~n effect on the Effect~ve Date of th~s First Amendment) The he~ght of the pool stora~e and equjpmer~t areas w~ll not exceed 12 feet above average natural grade A saund ~~~aZl. not to exceed l S feet m he~ght abo~ e exist~ng grade and measured at a con#lnuum at e~~ery po~nt a9ong the wa11, wjll be constructed around the srte, extend~ng from the r~orthwest corr~er of the site, ad~acent to the propased pedestrian entrance area, along the ~vestern site baundary between the instructional and recreational pool, aquatic building and the street 4 Appro~-al of Schematic Dra~~ings The City hereby appraves Schemattc Dra~;-ings prepared by Killefer Flammang Purtill Architects, dated November 11, 1998, w~h~ch delineate the new Municipal Pool Facility to be constructed, ~nclud~n~, without limitation, those principal components of u~hich are set forth in 9 1ti1 f'K ~ Lr ~ .: Para~raph 3, Subparagraph D The Schematic Drawings shall also include, wrthout limitation, a landscape plan for the Mun~c~pal Pool FacEl~ty The City and the Distr~ct shall maintain a complete copy of the Schematic Drawings stamped "Ap~roved'~ by the Crty The Schematic Drawings shall be a half-size set Further detailed plans for the Municipai Pool Facility, mcluding, withaut l~mrtation, structural plans and working drawings shall be developed by the City subsequent to the Effective Date based upon the Schematic Drawings Minor modificat~ons to the Schematic Drawings may be made by the City upon wntten adm-n~strat~ve appro~•al of the Plamm~g Director without the necessity af amending th~s F~rst Amendment A significant change in the appraved concept shali only be undertaken after amendment of this F~rst Amendment 5 l~Tun~cipal Poal Facil~ty Access, Parking, Circulat~on and Setbacks Access and Circulat~on for the ~'Iun~cipal pool fac~l~ty shall be ~n aecordance with the descrtpt~on ~~h3ch ~s attached as Exhibit D 1 and the pians wh~ch are attached as Exhtb~t D 2 to th~s First Amendment The park~ng for the Muracipal Poal Facil~ty shall be allowed by permit m either Parking Structure A or Parking Structure C, to be accessed vta the campus entrance at Ptco Boule~•ard The prec~se locat~ons far paoi parkmg shatl be established by a Jomt Operating Agreement to be entered ~nto bet~~een the Crty and the D~strict subsequent to the effective date of this F~rst 10 .~ '~'"T `~ ir~:3 Amendment Pool users with pernuts shall be ailowed to park free of charge both dunng tiveekdays and or~ weekends In addition to the Een handicapped spaces currently proyided in Parking Structure C, the D~strict s~all provide another four ground level handicapped spaces These handicapped spaces shall be located in Parking Structure C alang the western face of the structure and shall be available during aIl hours that the Mumcipal Pool Facil~ty zs apen The District shall also des~gnate a minimum of 24 addrt~onal spaces ~~-hich ~~~ill be available to pool users during peak hours (3 30- 5 30 p m on ~r~eekdays and Saturdays) The 24 pool spaces will be located ~n either Parking Structure A or Parking Structure C The precise locations shall be established by the Jo~nt gperating Agreement to be entered ~nto between the City and the Distrtict 4 Paragraph 4(Appro~~ed Uses) 1s hereby amended in full to read as follows Bv the e~ecution of this Agreement, the Crty specifical~y approves the use of Parking Structure A and Parking Structure C for College-related park~ng and far aquat~c-re~ateci parkmg The Joint Operattn~ Agreement ta be entered m#o between the C~ty and the D1str~ct w~ll address the ~o~nt use and operation of the Munic~pal Pool Facilrty by 11 ~` ` _ .141 the City and the District Said agreement shall be consistent with the terms of tlvs First ~lmendment and v-,~~~1 address hours of operation, staffing requ~rements, perm~t parkm~ requirements, matntenance, ar~d other pool operation fitnctions 5 The fallo~~~ing Paragraph S(Tim~ng af Construction}, Suhparagraph E is hereby added to the De~~elopment Agreement E The City shall use its best effarts to commence construct~on of the Mun~c-pal Pool Fac~lity w~thin twelve months of the executlon af this agreement, and #o complete construct~on w~th~n t.~.~elve months of the commencement of construct~on However, nothin~ ~n this ~irst Amendment shall be construed to require the City to proceed with the construct~on of the Munia~al Poo~ FacEt~ty and the failure to the C~t_y t4 proceed wrth construct~on of the Munici~al Poo~ Faci~lty shall not g~ve nse to an_y liabilrty, clatm for damages or cause of act~on against the C~ty 6 The introductian to Paragraph 6(Pro~ect Mit~gation l~leasures) of the Orig~nal DeGelopment Agreement ~s hereb_y amended m full ta read as follows To comply v~-ith appiicable provisions of the General Plan and to mrtigate specific burdens upon the cammunit_y resultm~ from construction of the Parking Structures and the ~'Iun~cipal Poal Facility, Distnct agrees to undertake the m~tigation measures m Subparagraphs (~) thraugh (G) of th~s Paragraph relat~ve to the 12 '~~ 4 "13i Park~nE Structures and the City and the Distnct agree to undertake the mingat~an measures ~n Subparagraph (F-n relative to the Mun~cipal Poal Facil~ty 7 The followmg Paragraph 6(Project Mitigation Measures), Subparagraph H is hereby added to the Development Agreement H To mrt~gate specific impacts resulting from the development of the Municipal Pool Fac~l~ty, the Crty and the District agree to perform the pro}ect mrtigat~on measures itemized in Exhibrt E attached hereto, in accordance with the timetable set farth m Exhibit E«•hich is mcorporated here~n by reference 8 Para~raph 7(Genera~ Sen%ices Requirements) shall be amended to refer to the Enr-~ronmental and Public Works Department rather than the Department of General Serv~ces 9 Para~ra~h 9(Effect af Agreemet~t on Land L`se Regu~ations}, 5ubparagraph D of the Original Development Agreement ~s hereby amended in futl to r~ad as fallows Crt}~ and Distrtct acknoti~,~iedge that the pro~is~ons of this Agreement are ~ntended to implernent t~e intent ofthe parties that Disfricf has the r~ght to develop the two park~ng structures spec~fied ~n this agreement, Parkmg Structure A and Park~ng Structure C The City~ has the right to cantral development of these stn~ctures pursuant to speafied and kno~vn standards and rules as delineated in th~s l3 ~~ ~ ` !J G Agreeme~t The City shall ha~~e the right to develop the Municipal Pool Facility pursuant ta the terms ofthis Agreement This Agreement shall not be deemed to restnct any right of the City ar the D~strict, as governmental ent~ties, to act in accardance wrth the~r powers. duties, and obligations The Mun~cipal Pool Fac~lity wtll be constructed, in part, on the s~te of Parking Lot 8 ~~~hich currently provides 96 surFace leveI parking spaces This parking Iot ~s located on the site of former Parking Structure B Parking Structure B consisted af four le~~els at~ave-grade and contained 374 park~ng spaces This parking structure ~ncurred s~gn~fcant structural damage due ta the Northr~dge Earthquake and ~~as subsequently demolist~ed The City supparts the canstruction of a repiacement park~ng structure on the College campus within the next five years ti}~hich would contain a min~mum of 374 spaces The actual replacement parking structure ~~ould be sub~ect to C~ty discretionary review and appro~al after a complete environmental anal~s~s has been canducted ~n accordance with the Cat~fornia Environmental Qualrty Act (Cal~farn~a Public Resources Code Sect~an 21000 et seq (`'CEQA") and City standards 10 Paragraph 18 {Not~ces) of the dr~g~nal Development Agreement ~s hereby amended to delete the City addresses to which not~ces, demands, requests. consents, appravals, or communicattons from the D~strict to the City are to be sent and to add the follow~ng C~ty addresses i4 ~~ -- , ^ - : .~ .~ Crty of Santa Momca 1685 Main Street, Roorn 209 Santa Moruca, Califarnia 94401 Attn City Manager With copies to Santa Mor~ica C~ty Attorney's Office 1685 Main Street, Third Floar Santa Monica, California 90401 Attn Crty Attarney And to, Commun~ty & Cultura! Services 16851~4a~n Street, Room Z10 Santa Monica, Ca~ifornia 9440~ Atin Director And to. Planning & Communrty Development 1685 Ma~n Street, Room 212 Santa Monica, Cal~foriua 90401 Attn Directar I 1 Exh~b~t A of the Onginal Development Agreemen# is hereby amended to add the legal description of the property upon which the Munic~pal Pool Facilrty will be lacated The amended Exhibit A is attached hereto and incorporated herem by reference 12 Exhib~t B of t~e Orig~nal Development AgreemeRt is hereby amen[ied to add landscaping, bu~ldin~ design and ARB requirements relating to thE Munictpal Pool Facility The amended Exhibit B is attached hereto and incorporated herem by reference 13 Eshibit C of the Or~emal De~~elopment Agreement is hereby arr3ended to add En~rtronmental and Publ~c VVorks I~~Zanagement requirements related to the Munic~pal Pool Fac~lity~ The amended Exhjbit C is attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference 15 lie! ~ ~- ~ :i 4 14 A ne~v Exhibit D is hereby added to the Onginal Der+elapment Agreement wh~ch constitutes the pro~ect site plans, access and circulation p[ans, and elevation plans for the Mun~cipal Pool ~acility ] 5 A ne~~~ Exh~bit E is hereby added to the Onginal Development Agreement wh~ch establishes the mit~~ation measures required for the Munic~pal Pool Facilrty as establ~shed by #he EIR undertaken for this pra~ect 16 A new Exhibit F~s hereby added to the Onginal Development Agreement wh~ch establ~shes the'bTunic~pal Pool Facility standard condit~ons 17 The Onginal Develapment Agreement, without exhib~ts, is attached to th~s First Amendment as E~chib~t G for reference purpose only 1$ Except as amended by this First Amendment, the 4rig~nal Deveiopment Agreement shall remam in full force and effect in accordance wrth its terms and cond~tions Notw~thstanding the foregoing, m the event of an~~ incons~stency between th~s First Amendmen~ and the Ongtna! Development Agreement, the ap~licable prav~sions of thls F~rst Amendment shall govern l 9 The obl~gations of th~s F~rst Amendment imposed on the parties hereunder shall be effective as of the date upon which the Ordinance approving th~s First Amendment becomes lb J- _ ~ ~ ~ effecttve ("Effect~ve Date") T'he part~es shall execute this First Amendment within ten (10) warking days of the Effectrve Date 20 The parties hereto shall ca~se this First Amendment to be recorded in the dfficial Records af the County of Los Angeles IN ~'~'ITNESS V4'~-~EREOF, the parties hereto have du~y executed this Agreement as of the cEay and year first abo~~e wrrtten CITY OF SANTA MONICA By John Jal~li City Manager 1'~tt~5~ Mar~a Stewart Crty Clerk Appro~~ed as to Form Marsha Jones n'foutrie C~ty Attorney 17 ~ MP ~' LF .~ ~.: s,~vTA MorncA co~UNiTY C4LLEGE DISTRICT BOARD O~ TRUSTEES OF SANTA MOIVICA CONIMUIVITY C4LLEGE DISTRICT By Thomas J Donner Vice President of Bus~ness and Administrat~on F 1~TTYI.~TCT~"I1C01`TRACTIBARII~~UI`TIPOOL VVPD 18 '~"' "~~J ( AMENDED EXH~BIT A PROPERTY DESCRIPTfON 1 Parking Structure "A" shall be located an property cammonly known as Santa Monica College parking lot #4, more particularly described as follows All that real property in the C~ty of Santa Monica in the County of Los Angeles, State of California, as shown in tract no 12543, lots 1, 2, 15 and 1S of Bbc~ 44 of East Santa Monrca, m said crty, cour~ty and state, as per map recorded in Book 17, page 95 2 Parking Structure "C° shall be located on property commonly known as Santa Monica College softball field, more particularly described as follows All that real property in the C~ty of Santa Monica, in the County of Los Angeles, State af Caiifornia, as shown ~n trac# no ~2543, lots 3, ~, 13 and 14 of BIocK 44 af East Santa Manica, in said city, caunty and state, as per map recorded in Book 17, pages 95 through 98 3 The Mun~cipal Pool Facility shall be located on property commonly known as Santa Monica College Parking Lot 8 and on the site of the landscape area located ad~acen# to parking Structure C and 124 feet from the 16t" Street curbline, more particularly described as follows All that real property in the City of Santa Mon~ca in the County of Las Angeles, State of California, as shown in tract np 12543, lots 3, 4 and 5 of BIocK 44 of East Santa Monica, in said city, county and state, as per map recorded i~ Book ~ 7, page 9~ f lppolsharelopspacelmunipoollExhibitA wpd 1 ~ r~ ~ '' " ~~~ AMENDED EXHIBlT B PROJECT DESCRIPTION, LANDSCAPING, AND ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD REQUIREMENTS Pro~ect Description The Santa Monica Community College D~strECt has praposed the development of the following fwo parkmg structures Parking Str~cture A wi!! be located as shown on the attached s~te pl~n exhibit This site conta~ned a surFace parking lot thaf was removed to allow canstruct~on of a four story parkEng structure that will a Utilize the existfng exrt on 16`~ Street as a ng~# turn only exit, and the College will pUrsue w~th the Gity s~grzal+zirrg the ~r~tersect~or~ of 48`h Street and Prco Boulevard The College will also purs~e with the City, #he establishment of a westboun~ left hand #urn signal at the Enfersection of 1~i~' Street and Pico Boulevard b Include the establishment af a new right turn only exit on Pico Boulevard Incfude the establishment of a new entrance on Pico Boule~ard c Accommodate a~prax~mately 694 cars d Be cQnneeted to the existrng parkmg s#ructure Parkir~g Sfructure C wifl be ioeated as shown on the attached site plan exhibit ThFS site conta~ned the college softbal! field and is loca#ed behmd the Busmess Bu~lcf~ng The structure will a Have a singfe entrancel~xit from 17~~ Street at Paco Boule~ar~ and w~li contain no ~ntrance/ex~t on 16th 5tree# b Aecomrr~odate approximateEy $44 cars and wiil ~r~ePUde or~e level ot t~elow grade parkmg (Ail of the above have beer~ completed as part of the original Developmer~t Ag~eernent) The Mun~cipal Poal Faeil~ty will be constructed in the open space area t~at fronts 16~n Street on the s~te of the former Parficing Structure B, currently referred to as Surface Parkmg ~at 8, and or~ ihe site o~ the landscape area located ad~acent to Parlc~r~g Structure C and the 16th Street curbtine '~`" -'~~.3~ Landscap~nq Requirements The Santa Monica Community College D~strict and City of Santa Mon~ca shal! comply with thefa~lowfng IandscapiRg requiremer~#s foralldeve~opmentauthor~zed byth~s Developmer~t Agreement Pr~ar to cammencement of construction biddmg far either or both parking structures or the Muniapal Paol, ten (10) ful! srze sets of landscap~ng drawmgs to the City's Arcn~tectura! Re~~~w Board #or revi~w and approval 2 Landscaping materials, treatments, and irri~ation shall comply with Municrpal Code Part 9 04 10 04 and the City's adopted Water Conser~at~on Ordmance 3 The College shall provide d~ligent effart where poss~ble to preserve and/or relacate any mature trees that wilf ne~d #o be removed #o permit parking structure construction Architectural Review Baard Requirements Tt~e Santa Monica Cornmunity Callege DEStr~ct and the City a# Santa Monica shall comply with the Arch~tectural Review requirements pursuan# to Santa Mon~ca Munic~pal Coc~e Chapter 9 32, and as referenced in Exh~bit F, Standard Cond~tions Prior to commencement of b~dding for the Municipal Paal, ten (10} #u{I size sets of design draw~ngs shall be submitted to the City Planning Div~sion for Architectural Re~iew Board review and approval The Arch~tectural Re~iew Board shall carefully ~eview all bu~lding textures, colors, matenals, surface and pa~ing treatment, signage, lighting, and trash enclosures f Ippolsharelopspacelm~nipoollExhibatB wpd ~ -..~1~ AMENDED EXHIBlT C En~ironmental and Publ~c Works Management Requirements The folbwing Environmental and Public Works Management requirements applyto Parkmg Structures A and C An easeme~t shaf~ be granted ta tf~e Cfty for aif handicapped access ramps which encroach beyond the limit of the public right of way Thrs mcludes an easement at the nor#hwesterly cor~er of the property and easeme~ts on either side of both northerfy drrveways of Park~ng Structure A 2 A hydrology report shail be prepared that at min~mum s~alf address ex~strng street capacrty and rndreate the paterrtral for ftoodrng of those portrans of the structur~ which are below grade The report shafl also address the change in runofffrom the site, ~ndica#e the points at which #his runoff w~l! be discharged, and ~dentafy any changes to the ex~s~rr~g f~ow cor~ditror~s !f rr~d~cated by the hydrology study. a detent~on basm may be required on s~te 3 Complete set o€ c~v~! p~ans s#~al! be subrr~~tted designat~ng alf off-s~te ~mprovemen#s Based upor~ a pre~ious ir~spection cor~ducted ~y the Env~ranmen#al and Puh~~c Warks Management DeparEment, the sidewalk on Pjco Boulevat~d between 16`h Street a~d th~ eastern edge of Parking Structure A w~ll requ~re remova[ and replacement Other off-sife improvements may be reqwred as a res~lt of damage durmg construct~an ~ All runoff from parking areas shall be colfected and routed t~rough an o~l-water separator or other treatment process to be appro~ed by the C~ty, which will reduce the pollutants washmg #rom the s~te into the storm drain 5 Completed grading plans shall b~ submitted and shall include an erosion con#rol plan Afl of the a~ove have been compfet~d as part ~f the or~ginal De~elopmen# Agreeme~# TF~e following En~ironmental and Public Works Management reqwrernen#s apply to construction of the Munic~pal Pool Fac~lity 6 Before Essuance of a~uild~ng permi#, t~e C~ty shaU approve a storage system for the ar~-site dete~t~on runofforan alterr~ate Best Managemen# Practice ~BMP) as defined m the Urban Runoff Mat~gation Plan To the sxtent possibEe, the detained stormwater w~li be distributed to landscaped areas, w~t~ arty remamder e~entually released into the exESting City storm drain connections AI! detained runoff, released into the City's facalit~es, w~il be released after passage of the system's peak flow ~~~i T~~s starage system or alterr~ate BMP shall be ~mplemented priar to Certificate of ~ccupancy 7 Before issuance of a buifdmg perm~t, plans for a stormwater filtering system shall be submii#ed sub~ect to the approvat of the C~ty's Enviranmental and Pu~lic Works Management Department ~"EPWM") Th~s stormwater f~ltering system shalf be ~nstafled for large paved areas to reduce runoff contam~nated by veh~cle o~1 and debr~s fram entering the storm dram system 8 During construction and occ~pancy drain rnlets at or ad~acent to the site sf~all !~e constructed with oii, debris, and silt traps ta reduce the level of pollutar~ts such as oif, debris, and sift in stormwater runofF Those traps sF~af( be efeaned of debris annually or more frequently 9 The Pro~ect shall com~ly wi#h the requirements of a Na#iona! Polluti~n D~scharge Elimination System ~NPDES) permit for storm water discharge ar~d with gwdance and polEC~~s of the Regional Water Qualit~ ~ ControE Board, EPA, and local agenaes 10 The Pro~ect shail be butlt ~n conformance with the City's Urban Runaff Pollutian Ordinance i~ effect on the Effect~ve Date of the Developme~t Agreement 1~ Addit~anal sidewalks, curbs, gutters, pa~~ng and driveways wh~ch need replacing or removal as a resu!# of darnage caused ~uring canstructior~ of #he Pro~~ct shall be reconstructed to the sat~sfaction of EPWM as soon as practicable, and m any event prior ta certificate of occu~ancy 12 Pr~or to certificate af occupancy water flow calculatio~s shall be prepared to eva~uate the capac~ty of ex~stmg water mams at the locatior~s for ~ook-ups to the pro~ect Exrsting water mains which directly service the pro~ect sha11 be upgraded ~f the water #low calculatjons ~ndicate that the haok-up pomts for the pro~ect w~fl cause such ma~ns to rece~ve greater demands than can be accommadated 13 Prior to certificate of occupa~cy storm water flow calculations shall be prepared to evaluate the capacity af existmg starm wate~ draEn I~nes at the locations for hook- ups from tF~e pro~ect Existing starm water dram IEnes which c~irec~ly serv~ce tF~e pro~ect shali be upgraded if the storm water flaw calcula#ions indicate that the hoak- ~p pants ~or the pr~~ect wrl! ca~se s~c~ drair~ ~ir~es to rece~ve greaterdemands than can be accommodateci 14 Sauthern Cai~fornia Ed~son Compar;~ and t~e Southern Cal~forn~a Gas Company shall be cons~alted regarding any feasiele energy conservation measures that cvuld b~ incorporated into the Pro~ect ~ ~.~ ~ u~~ 15 EfficGent irrigation systems shall be installed to mmimize runoff and evaporation and to maxim~ze the proportion of water available for plants in landscaped areas 16 Drougf~t-talerant, fow-water-consum~ng plant var~efies sF~alf be used to reduce irrigation water consumption 17 Photo-vol#a~c systems to generate electric~ty shall be designed and constructed if deemed feas~bte and cast-effective by the Crty f Ippolsharelamended exhibitc wpd h J ~R _ i.~~ EXHIBIT D Santa Monica Municipal Pool D.'I Access and Circulation Description D.2 Access Diagram D.3 Site Plan D.4 Building Elevations ~.~ [;~~ EXHIBIT D 1 MUNiClPAL POOL ACCESS AND CIRCULATION 1. Vehicfe Access and Parking The only vehicle access from outside the cailege campus ta the new Santa Monica Munic~paf Pool an the Sar~ta Monica Colfege sit~ w~ll be ~ia the Santa Mon~ca College entrance on Prca Baulevard and 17`" 5#reet This is one of several entrances to the college, but directfy sen~es Parking Structure A, Parking Structure C a~d the Pool errtranee Vehicles will enter from PECO Boulevard and, once on the campus grounds, wifl proceed west, and enfEr either Parkmg Structure A. which is immediately fo the west of #he main entrance, or turn south past the Pool dro~-off zone, in front of the public pooi entrance, to Parkmg Structure C ParkEng Struct~are C will ha~e four handicapped spaces located at the structure's ground level west corner ad~acent to the entrance to the garage Pool parking shall be permitted as specified m amended Paragraph 3 D 5 of the First Amendment Vehicles ex~t Parking Structure A via the existing 16`h Street egress and right turn arrly exrt, flr vra t#~e Prco Baulevard ex~t Veh~cfes exit Parkjng Structure C vEa the two-way exit at the north side of the park~ng structure, whict~ leads to the internal circulation drive, exitmg on P~co Boulevard at the paint af entry There will be no additional access to or from 16`" Street other than the existing right turn only egress from Parking Structure A 2. Ped~strian Acce~s and Circulation PedestrEans may access the Municipal Paol from a number of pedes#nan access points on the Santa Monica Colfege campus However, it is envisioned fhat pedestrians fram the immediate residential neighbo~hoods will walk along 16th Street and enfer the site from the pedestriar~ walkway a# 16'h Street which proceeds pas# Parking Structure A, around the perEmeter of #he pook site, and enter the pool fac~lity from the controlled public entry point at the centEr of the site's eastern boundary TY~3s pedestr~an e~trance w~ll be th~ mam entrance point to the pool and w~ll be controlled at all times the pool is open P~~estrians waiking fro~ ~, the~r cars parked in either Park~ng Sfructure A or C w~li use t~is entry This entrance will be served by an elevator to #ake handicappe~ users from the ground level to #he WEewmg deck ~ ~~ ~ ~~~J The entrance ~s at grade, and does not require a handicapped access ramp Handicapped users will park a# the four handicapped spaces a# the north edge ofi Parkir~g Str~acture C, from which they w~fl be able to exit d~rectfy out of the bu~iding to a pool pathway, proceeding to the main entrance The~e wrN be a secQndary entrance at tl~e south srde of tYte pool, ~ust west ot Parking Structure C, closer to the existmg locker rooms, for college users only This access w~fl also be controlled by callege staff when ~t is open, but will only be open during the hours which the College uses the pool 3. Bus Stops The pr~mary bus stop that serves the pool w~ll be the Pico Boulevard bus stop just east of 16~" Street Team buses for swEm meets and events will make ad~ance arrangements to park at one of the Santa Mortica College surface parkmg lots, and will discF~arge passengers at the Santa Mon~ca College Pico Boule~ard frontage As part of the Santa Mornca Callege Mas#~rpian, the Calfege proposes to construct an addition to the eastern section of the existing Parking Structure C, over the area of the existing Mun~cipal Poo~ site, that waufd ~nclude additional spaces as well as a new primary entrance and exit at the eastern end of the structur~ if this expans~an should accur, the r~umb~r of vehicles ~s~ng the entrance and exit at the western end of the stru~ture w~ll be reduced, although it wilf rematn a two way access as a secondary entrance, and will provide access 6etween Parking Structures A and C ~~" ` ~.~~t~ C. ~~ ~ ti2 ~ ~ .~ . . •~ • . . ~- ' . . , :~, • „ , a~`y' .-~,~~_ •_.~. ~ ~~ ~ ...o... _ . . ~ ~ ,. .. ~: ~ ,~...,.. ~ ~~ ~~~ e Q °'~~ _`~-~-._.~.. f ~ ~1 f~y 5 ~~ ~„ ~ 0~. t,~ u li ~~ ~"-~ .. ~- -~..-,-r~,s ~. "' ~~„ ° ,.~~ ro~~oqo~ncees,, ~ ~~ a ~ " ~ ~ _Q a ~. _~ o .~ ~n ; ~ o ; ~- ~- ~ s~ I ~ ~~ ~ q I ~ ~ '~^~`"r;~I`.u~00¶6,.. ~~. II.... 4 -. ~,,, ~ ,,,~E` ~ ~ ~ ~ .,I' .~ Y ~ ~~. p ~! 1 il Il .._~.._ .. ~ ~ ~_u ~=~...° °~Gi s i~ ~ ,. ~~ ~.... ~''i~ililllii~ iEl \~ .~ rn ~ ~ ~ ~ _ . ... . { 1 6T1i S7R~ ET lflfFNf!}#!4lflifllFlff}Jl:F7!!I!!!lkl.'1115f1#HiH3lHi1H{IIlf Iklhllll' 111IlIII{IIHIHNHIiIiIHiiIIINNIIII{HlI~IIIHIIINiIIIHII~IIIIIII~IIHIIINIIIIl11lIIIHI~~ifll~qlll~lll! l~Nllll!\ EXHIBIT D.4 ELEVATIQNS F ~PPDiSHkRE'OPSPACE'du1l1NIPCGL~~ax~ibt~v..rnFO~~I wFd a .~, ` ~' ~ `' LJ~ ~ '~.1' i ~ ~ ..., •...~. ..~..~~~,~~ y~ "'"' S f1EXF.R4 MI11FA W!'1iLEYh~YJN . ...__ i~i ,. . .. , _ „_... ,. „__ .~ ~__.. .,,_ NhIV Wl ILLYWJIlS .-. .-. '_' ~~ ~~ x'M1MFlfunix?'+ "'_' -:~'..7^~ ."-' . ] . ,. -~~. -..o ....r.~w 1 .w.~.~ " { -' ,.._., ,.-' _ _ •' . .._. ~ .. •° .,.,~- ~^,. . .~-~.,,,~ .,._ :.7"L' ~~ ~~«n ~ - . _._... ._. ,_~. ~...J ~ ~... . .,.ti - .~?, r ..-..W..,.., I ~....,.~,.~._ EtlllSLF1EYnI~F~F#145~5611~~++~e _. ,_... W••'•rV•• ' "~ ~~~~ :.ANTA MO/~IICA _ MYMICIPN ^F'OCA -- FI FVAIKINS {~ } ~ ~ A 200 C~ 7 .J 1 Y tlF.Nkwl Mn1fn .,•- ~ 1 tiit~~uY Ill~y,y~ry~~lV~l/n .,,..~_._....____"' ,,.._ ' IM11f}li[vnlUx .r . .,__ ..._ . , ,. ._.. „ /~~ , ` ~~ ......__ ,._, . . . , . ..,.,.""__„ ._ 1 ._~... ~~ . ...1 :. ~~. . M M~ ~, ~T~, ~w~ .. ' , ~,~~. . .. . _ .. . - T' _.,, ._~ " ' Mli7F'N Ff.ICL_ . , ._,_,... _. ' "...,_ , "'-_ .. , .. ... . ..... _ ~ _i> ~~i> - ~l _ _.. :. :~.._ ~-._ -.. _: ..:__._. ..-:_.: .. ;..~ ~ .. . ... ~_._ _.:- .__....__...._ _. _ SIR~EFNIHSIRfF14lfYA1KXi ~~ ~~~ 1 . _. _,_. .~ ,... . . , ,.-„ ,._, ...,Y '• - _ _ i ' .._ ~.. .._~ - ~ ~-- _. .. ._. L ._.z__.,. ,_,.,- - ,.., ~..~.~....,,..~.~.z_~. ` _ ~~ 9~CILEI911-011[QFlfl'hNX , . , ,. . , . y 1MTERU rFVNJf[8 .. . _ ~. _..... „ ..,,.. .,... . . _ ............._,_.,,,""__~P~ ~ I dV~~ ~iY~iY '_ ~- ,. .... , . _ . ,.., ~ ... . ...--'~ ~~~.' ~'~~'.~ ~-..-.' _ ~ ~ _' '"'_'~'_ ~"'. .,.._... ._ ~„~"_~~~ '`il~i- -~11>~ Z~~ i~~~. _ ++ww 4 ~ 9.EYATIONS ~ A 2Q1 EXHIBIT E PR~JECT MITIGATION MEASURES TRAFFIC, ACCESS AND PARKING In order to accommodate the net parking increase due to increased usage, the coElege shall designate a m»~mum of 24 spaces vuh~ch will be available to pool users during peak hours (3 30-5 30 p m on weekdays and Saturdays} The 24 spaces shall be Eacated in either Parking Structure A or C The precise location shall be determmed in the Joint Operating Agreement entered mto #~etween the City and the District 2 To discourage weekend paol users from parking on nearby res~denttal streets, the C~ty shall encourage weekend users to park in SMC off-street parking facilities through mformat~onal programs (bullet~n board not~ces, mai[er ~nserts, etc } 3 The ninety-six parking spaces currently located on Parking Lot 8 which w~ll be lost due to the canstruction af the Muniapal Poa~ facil~ty sf~all be replaced Until October 31, 'I999, these replacement spaces will be located at either the City's beach or airport lats The specific requir~ments ga~erning the use of the beach ar airport lots, ~ncluding parking location and schedule, shall be estak~hshed in the Jomt Operat~ng Agreement After October 31, 1999, the replacement spaces shall be provided on the College campus 4 Information concerning appropnate bus routes shall be provided to swim team bus dri~ers m advar~ce of any sw~m meets Bus routes shal! avord resider~t~al streets to access the site To mir~ir~ize drop-off/ptck-up acti~ity along ~ 6`'' Street, team buses shall be required to drop-off/p~ck-up swim meet participants along the P~co Bouf~~ard frontage of the College 5 T4 m~nimize the potential for weekend swim meet participants to park on neigh~oring residential streets, access and parking information shall be included in all swim meet materials to direct participants to the proper parking locat~on 6 Arrangements shall be made with SMC to permit parking of weekend swim meet team buses in SMC surface parking lots 7 If swim mests are proposed wh~ch will take place on a weekday while SMC is in session, a parking management plan shall be prepared pr~ar to the e~ent to ensure t1~at sufFicient off-street parking is a~ailabfe far meEt participants ~t "' ~ ~_ ;3 ~ AIR QUA~ITYICONSTRUCTION 8 Contractars shall use water or other effecti~e dust control measures ta reduce fugitive dust emissi~ns 9 Fraquent site clean-up near the access driveway shall be perform~d to prevent track-out of dirt that could be pulverized by passing cars 10 During construction the maximum practical distance buffers between semi- stationary o~-s~te equ~pment s~ch as generators, eompressors, etc ar~d the r~earest pollution-sensiti~e uses at homes across 16~~ Street and instruct~anal class rooms shaCl be maintained '~ 1 Construction related soil disturbance activities shali betermmated during SantaAna wind conditions, or use contmuous watering far dust abatement NOISE 12 A noise barrier of no more than 18 feet m heigh, measured fram existing grade shall be constructed to ~~eak a!I lines-of-sight between the prq~ect site and residences to the west In addition to extending along the western boundary of the site, the barrier shall ~e located alang the southern boundary The pedestrian entrance shall be designed with e~ther a baffle (overlappad) panel or canstructed to wrap around the northern edge of fhe side untd no line-of-sight relatEOnship remains to any residence west of 16t' Street 13 No swim instructional activities involving the use of attention-gettir~g de~ECes such as whistles, bu[I-hams, shouting, etc shall occur before 7 a m on weekdays or 8 a m on Saturday ar Sunday 14 Gates shall remain closed on swim meet days until 8 a m to deter early arrival ar practice 15 No ampl~fied saund or music shall be used before 9 a m or after 7 p m unless use of such equipment can be demonstrated ta be inaudible at the closest residences f IppolsharelopspacelmunipoollExhibEtE wpd 2 .~~ ~~~~2 EXH~BlT F MUNICfPA~. PQQL STANDARD CaNDITIONS Plans This appro~al is for those plans dated November 11, 1998 a copy of which shail be maintained in the files ofthe City Plan~ing Di~ision Pro~ect development shall be cc~ns~stent with such plans, except as atherwrse specrfred rn these conditcons af appro~al ArchitecturaE Re~iew Board 2 Priorto consideration of the pro~ecf bythe Architectural Review Board, the applicant shall rev~ew d~sabled access requ~rements w~th the Buildmg and Safety D~v~s~on and make any necessary changes in the pro~ect design ta achie~e compliance with such requirements The ArchitectUral Review Board, in its review, shall pay parttcular attention to the aes#hetic, landscaping, and setback impacts of any ramps or other features necessitated by accessibility requirements 3 Prior to submittal of landscape plans for Architectural Revtew Board appro~al, the applicant shal! contact the Departm~nt of En~ironmental and Public Warks Management regarding urban runoff plans and calculatior~s 4 Construction period s~gnage shall be sub~ecf to the appro~al of the Architectural Review Board 5 Plans forfinal design, lartdscaping, screenmg, trash enclosures, and signage shall be subject to review and appr~val by the Architectural Review Board 6 The Architectural Revkew Board, m ~ts review, scale and articulation o~ design elements, exterior colors, textures and materials, window treatm~nt, giaz~ng, and fandscaping T Landscap~ng plans shall comply with Subchapter 5B ~Landscaping Standards) of the zoning ordinance incEuding use of water-conserving landscaping materials, landscape mair~tenance and other sfandards containeci m the Subchapter 8 Refuse areas, storage areas and mechanical equipment shall accardance with SMMC Sectiar~ 9 04 10 02 130-9 04 10 02 150 shall be of a size adequate to meet an-site need, including Architectural Rev~ew Board in its review shall pay particula~ screening o~ such areas and equ~pment be screened ~n Refuse areas recycling The attention to the ~~ . t_ . ~; ~ 9 Before submitting #he Pro~ect to the Architectural Re~iew Board {"ARB"), the Eandscaping plan shalf be prepared, inciucf~ng a street tree plan, by a licensed California landscape architect Plants called for in the approved landscape plan that subsequently die shall be replaced on a one-for-one basis Co~struction 14 Unless otherwise approved by the Department of Environmental and Public Works Management, all siciewalks shall be k~pt clear and passable during the grading and constructian phase of the pro~ect 11 S~dewalks, curbs, gutters, paving and driveways which need replacing or removal as a result of the pro~ec# as determined by the Department of En~ironm~ntal and Publtc Works Management shall be reconstructed to the sat~sfaction of the De- partment of Environrnental and Public Works Management Approval forthis work shall be obtamed from the Department of Environmental and Publ~c 1Norks Management prior to issuance of the building permits 12 Vehicles hauling dirt or other canstruction debris from tf~e site shall co~er any open load with a tarpaulm or other secure co~ering to mmim~ze dust em~ss~ons 13 Street trees shall be maintained, relocated or provided as required in a manner consistent with the City's Tree Code (Ord 1242 CCS}, per the specificatians of the Community and Cultural Services Division and the Department of Environmental and Public Works Management No street tree shall be remo~ed wi#hout the appra~al of t~e Commun~ty and Cultural Services Di~ision 14 All tree transplantation during th~ course of the Pro~~ct shal~ be perFormed by a qualified arbarist, landscape architect, ar tree expert, #o the City's satisfaction Trees that are to be reused on-site shall be boxed in appropriately-sized containers and temporarily relocated to protect them from physical in~ury 15 A constructian period mitigation plan shall be prepared by the applicant for approval by the Department of Environmenfal and Pubfic Works Management prior to is- suance of a bu~lding permrt. The approved mitigation plan shalE be posted on the canstruction site for the dura#ion of the pro~ect construction and shall be produced upon request As applicable, tf~is plan shall 1} Specify the names, addresses, telephone numbers and business license numbers of ali cantractors and subcontractors as well as the de~eloper and architect, ~) Describe how demolition of any existing structures is to be accomplished, 3) Indicate where any cranes are to be located for erection/construction, 4) Descr~be how much of the public street, alleyway, or sEdewalk is proposed to be used in con~unction with construct~on, 5) Set forth the extent and nature of any pile-driving operations, 6) Describe the length and numberof anytiebacks which must extend underthe propertyofother persons, ~ wi~ 4 ~ - ~ ~J ~y 7) Specify the nature and extent of any dewater~ng and its effect on any ad~acent buildings, 8) Describe anticipated cantruction-related truck routes, number of truck trips, F~ours of f~auling and parking location, 9) Specify the nature and extent of any hel~copter ha~ling, 10) State whether any construct~on activ~ty beyond normaliy permitted hours is proposed, 11) Descr~be any prflposed constructian noise mitigatiar~ measures, 12} Describe construction-period secur~ty measures incfuding any fencing, lighting, and security personnel, 13)Pro~ide a d~ainage plan, 14) Provide a construction-period parking plan which shall m~nirnize use of public streets for parking, 'f 5) List a designated on-site construction manager 16 A sign shall be post~d on the propsrty in a manner consistent with the public hearing sign requirementswhich shall identifythe address and phone numberafthe owner andlor applicant forthe purposes of respondir~g to questions and complaints during fhe constructian period Sa~d sign shall alsa indicatethe hours of perm~ssible construction work 77 The appl~cant shall ins~re any graf~tt~ an the s~te ~s promptly removed thraugh compfiance with the City's grafitti remaval program 18 A eopy of these co~d~t~ons shall be posted in an eas~ly v~sible and accessible locatian at all times dunng construction at the pro~ect site The pages shall be laminated or otherwESe }~rotected to ensure durability ~f the copy 19 The City Engineer and all affected agencies shall appro~e any construc~ion detaurs, construction work requirmg encroachment into public r~ghts-of-way, or a~y other street use activ~ty (e g, haul rautes} durmg canstruction 2Q The hauling of dirt and demofit~on mater~al and the delivery of construction material shali be prohibited during the afternaan peak traffic periad City streets affected by the Pro~ect construction, shall be cleaned as necessary 21 Construction sha[I be scheduled and expedited to cause the least amount af disruption and interference to the ad~acent vehicular and pedestnan traffic flow 22 If human remains of Nati~e American ongins are encountered during the Pro~ect de~elopment, canstructian shalf be immeciiately suspended, and the County Coroner's off~ce and the Native American Heritage Commission shall be contacted to determine necessary procedures for protect~on and preservation o~ remains, including reburiaf af ff~e Cify's expense 23 In #he event #hat culturallarchaeological resources are encountered on the pro~ect site during the caurse of Pro~ect construction, all earthmoving acti~ity in the area of the resource shal! cease until the #indings are examined, their significance assessed by the Director of Planning, the State Histonc Preservation Offiee is consult~d and recommendations are made for any apprapriate prpceciures #o either further 3 p~ v~ ~ t~ J :~ investigate or mitigate impacts to those cultural resources which ha~e been encountered, including t~e C~ty's payment of excavating costs 24 In the e~ent that fossils are encountered during the Pro~ect exca~ation, all earthmoving activity in the area of impact shall cease until the De~eloper retains the services of a qualified paleontologist, w~o shall examine the findmgs, assess thejr significance, and offer recommendations for any further mvesfigation or mitigation measures 25 General contractors shall maintain equipment engines in proper tune and aperate construct~on equipment so as to minimize exhaust em~ssions at a!i times during the Pro~ect development Such equipment shall not be operated during first or second stage smog aler~s 26 During construction, trucks and ~ehicles in loading or unloading queues should be kept with their engines off, when not in use, to reduce vehicle emissions Construct~on ac#iv~t~es shall be phased and scheduled fo avoid emissians peaks, and discontinued during first- and second-stage smog alerts Excavation shall be discontinued during periods of high winds 27 General contractors shall use reasonable and typical watering techniques during Pro~ect de~elopment to reduce fugitive dust emissions All unpaved demolition and construct~on areas shall be wetted at least twice a day dunng excavation and construction, and temporary dust cavers shall be used to reduce dust emissions and meet SCAQMD Rule 403 28 Canstruction and demolition acti~ities shall take place only during the hours and at the levels speerfed for Noise Zor~e III (Instrtutrana!) rr~ Sa~rta Monrca Munre~pal Code Cha~ter 4 12 ("Noise Ordmance") 29 Except as approved by the Planning Director, the pro~ect contractor shall schedule construction activities ta avoid the s~multaneous operation of equipment such as air compress~rs, backhoes, concrete pumps, ~ibrators, or breakers, truck cranes, dozers, generators, loaders, pa~ers, pneumatic tools, water pumps, power hand saws, sf~ovels, and trucks, sa as to min~mi~e noise le~els resulting from operatir~g se~eral pieces of high noise level-emitting equipment 30 Car~struction equipment shalf be fitted with state-of-the-art noise shielding and muffli~g de~ices ta reduce noise levels to the maximum extent feasible during construction 31 E~ery reasonable effort wdl be made to create the greatest practicable distance between no~se sources and sensitive receptars d~ring construct~or~ operations ~ ~''~ ~~5ti Environmental Mitigat~on 32 Uftra-taw flow pfumbing fixtures are required on a1[ new de~elopment and remodeling where plumbmg is to be added (Maximum 1 6 gallon talets and 1 0 gal~on urinals and low flow shower head } 33 To mitigate solid waste impacts, priarto issuance af a Certificate af Occupancy, the app[icant shall s~[bmit a recycling plan to the Department of En~ironmental and Public Works Management for its approval The recycling plan s~all include 1) I~st af mater~als such as ~vt~cte paper, computer paper, metal car~s, ar~d glass to be recycled, 2) location o# recylmg bins, 3) designated recyclmg coordmator, 4} nature and extent of internal and external pick-up service, 5} pick-up schedule, 6) plan to inform tenants/ occupants of service 34 To mitigate storm water and surface runoff from the pro~ect site, an Urban Runoff Mitigation Plan may be required by the Department of En~ironmental and Public Works Manag~ment ~EPWM} pursuant to M~an~c~pal Cade Chapter 7 9 0 Applicant shall contact EPWM to determine applicable requirements, which include the follow~ng o Non-stormwater runoff, sediment and construction waste from the construction site and parkmg areas is prohibited ~rom leavin~ ~he site, o An sediments or materials wh~c~ are tracked aff-site must be removed the same day they are tracked off-s~te, o ExcaWated sail must be located on the site and soil pdes should be covered and otherwise protected so that sediments do not go into the street or ad~aining properties, a Wasf~ing of construction or other ~ehicles shai[ be allowed ad~acent to a construction site No runoff from washtng ~ehicles on a canstruction site shall be allowed to €ea~e the site, o Drainage controls rnay be requ~red depending on the ext~nt af grading and topography of the sEte o New develapment is required ta reduce pro~ected runoff pol[ution by at least twenty percent through incorporation of design elements or pr~nciples, such as increasing permeable surfaces, di~erting or catch~ng runoff v~a swales, berms, and the Eike, orientation of drain gutters towards permeable areas, modif~catian of grades, use of retention structures and other methods Miscellaneaus Conditions 35 The building address shall be painted on the raof of the building and shall measure faur feet by eight feet (32 square feet} 36 The operation shall at all times be conducted in a manner nat detrimental to `~ ~`' ~° i~ ~ i surroundmg propert~es or residents by reason of lights, r~oise, act~vities, parking ar other act~ons 37 Street andlar alley lighting shall be provided on public rights-of-way ad~acenf to the pro~ect if and as needed per the specifications and with the appraval of the Department of Environmentaf and Public Warks Managemer~t 38 Final approval of any mechanical equi~ment installation will require a noise test in compliance with SMMC Sectian 4 12 a40 Equipment farthe test shalE be prov~ded by the owner or cantractor and the test shall be conducted by the owner or contractor A capy of the noise test results on mechanical equipment shal~ be submitted to the Community Noise Officer for review to ensure that naise levels do not exceed max~mum allowable fe~els for the applicable noise zone 39 Final building plans submitted for appr~~al of a bu~lding permit shall include on the plans a list of all permanent mechanical equipment to be placed outdoors and aEl permanent mechan~cal equ~pment to be placed ~ndoors which may be heard outdoors Monitoring of Canditions 40 Pursuant to the requirements of Publ~c Resources Code Sectior~ 21081 6, the City Planrting Division will coordinate a monitoring and reporting program regarding any required changes to the pro~ect made in can~unction with pra~ect approval and any conditions of appro~al, including those condit~ons intended to mitigate or avaid significant effects on the en~ironment This program shall include, but is not I~m~ted to, ensurrng that the PlanRrng Divrsron ttself and other C~ty drv~srorts and departments such as the Buildmg Di~ision, the Environmental and Public Works Managemer~t Department, the Fire Department, the Police Department, the Resource Management Department and the Finance Department are aware of pro~ect requirementswhich must be satisfied priorto issuance of a Buildir~g Permit, Certificate of Occupancy, or other permit, and that other respansible agencies are alsa ir~formed of condi#ions relating to their responsibilities Pro~ect owner shall demonstrate compliance with conditions of appro~al m a written report submitted to the Planning Director and Building Officer prior to issuance of a Building Permit or Certificate of ~ccupancy, and, as applicable, pro~ide periadic reports regard~ng compliance with such conditions 6 ~a r-~ .. ~ ~ ^ 4. EXHIBIT G 4riginal De~e~opment Agreement (without exhibits) ~~~,~ S t~ a ~ ~ DEVEIAPI~ENT AGREEMENT THIS DEVELA PMENT AGREEMENT ("Agreement") is entered ~nto this ~ Y~~day of .., , 1989, between the SANTA M~NICA COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT and the BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE SANTA MONICA COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT (hereinafter referred to as the "District" and the "Board of Trustees," respectively), and the CITY OF SANTA MONICA, a mun~c~pal cdrporation organized and existing pursuant to the laws of the State of Ca~ifornia and the Charter of the Czty o€ Santa Manica ("Citiy"), with reference to the following facts: A. On May 17, 1988, the City and the District entered znto Cantract Number 5100 (CCS) reqarding: (i) the establishment of a preferential parking zone around Santa Monica Co13.ege ("Callege"); (ii) the l.ease by the City of certain structures at the Santa Manica Airport to the District far use as additional classroorn faci~ities; (iii) the construction of two parking struet~xres by the District on the College campus; and (iv) the provision by the City of temporary parking lots and a shuttle service for use by College employees, students, and College visitors. On June 14, 1988, a preferentia~. parkinq zone was established arannd the College by the City pursuant to Qrdinztnce Number 1444 (CCS). On July 1, 1988, the City leased the additional classraam facilities at the Airport to the District pursuant to Cantract Number 52~1 {CCS) ('+Lease"). On or about July 3, 1988, the City commenced the shuttle servics from the temporary parking lots. This Aqreement is entered into reqardinq ~ the canstruction o€ the two parkinq structures on the College - 1 - ~~ ~r ~ .. ~ Cl "1~' campus t~ ~itigat~ ~er*a~n e^vir~n~e^tal :~pacts created by ~~e establishment of the preferen~~al park~ng zar.e. B. ~ursuant ~o Ca~~_°orr_a ~overn~enc Code Sect~ons b5865 et seq. ar.d Santa Monlca ~unicipai C~~e 5ections 9800 et seq., the Czty is author~zed to enter i~to b~ndinq development agreements w~th persons ha~r~r.q legal or equitable znterests ~~ real property for t~e develapment of such property. C. Dlstrict ~s the legal ~wner of certair. real property ("Property") located in the Ci~y of San~a Monica, Californ~a, as more particularly descri3~ed in Exh~bit A, which is attached hereto and incorporated herein by th~s zeference. D. District as the developer has requested that City enter into ~his Development Agx~eement ("Aqreernent") reqardinq the construction of two parking structures on the ~roperty. District has paid all necessary costs and fees associated with the Clty~S processing of this Aqreement. City has complied with alI procedures required by Santa Monica Municipal Cade Sect~ons 980p et seq. reqardinq the prvicessing of this Agreement. E. The City has caused to be prepared a comgrehensive Enviranmental impact Report wh~ch a«aiyaas in de ail the environmental effects of all aspects of ~he proposed deveZapment of the Proparty. The City considered the Envirorzmental Impact Report in conjunction with the approval of this Aqreement. The Enviz~onmental ~mpact Report was prepared, processed, reviewed~ and approved in cor~formity with California Publ~c Resources CQde Sections ziaoo et seq. and the City oP Santa Monica Guidelines f~r Implementation o€ the California £nvironmentai Quality Act, adopted by Resalution Number 6694 {CCS}. ' ~l~b,t _ ~ _ F. The City Council ~r the City ras found that this Agreement is cansistent ~t~h ~he ~e,^.era1 P~an of the Cz~y af Santa Monica and any applica~le s~ec~fz~ paars of the City af Santa Monica. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration for t~e covenants and conditions hereinafter set forth, the parties hereto do hereby agree as fol~ows: 2. DEFIH~TZONS. For purposes of th~s Agreement, the €oliowing terms and phrases shall be lnterpreted as hereinafter defined, unless *_~E context clear~y andicates a contrary zntent of the parties: Suildinq Heiqht: sha~l be as set forth in Section 3, and shall be defined as the vertica2 distance measured from the average level af highest and Zowest point of that portion of the ivt covered by the building ta the highest point of the raaf excluding parapets, stairways, ven~ilatinq fans ~r similar equipment required to operate and maintain the buildinq. Subterranean parking areas located below the a~erage ground Ievel shall also be excluded from buildi~g hPight. City: the City of Santa Monica, a municipal corporation, orqanizad and conducting business pursuant ~o the laws of the State af C31$farnia and the Charter of the City o£ Sa~ta Monica. City Manaqer: the City Manager a€ the City. District: Santa Monica Community Colleqe District, developer of the Project. Floor Area: shall be consistent with and qvverned by the Zoninq Ordinance. .a ~ ~- ~J b ~ Genera; rlan: ~~~e c~-prerens~ve, l~ng-te r.n ~enerai pia~ for the physical ~evelop~ent o~ the C~Ly of San~a ~onica gursua~t to California Government Cod~ ~ec~~ons 6~300 et, seq. LL'CE: the Land i;se an~3 C~r~-:1~3t.lOF] Fle:~ent af Che Ger.eral P~an of the City. Planninq Commission: 4he Plar.n~ng Co~ission of the City. Pro~ect: ~he proposed develc~pr.:ent of the Property as is mare ~art~cuZar~y descrzbed ~n Sect~on 3 of this Agreement and ~n the Project Site Plan. Project Plans: thase certain Fro~ect Plans dated June 19, 1989 (including renderings) prepate~ by Conrad Assaciates (as the same may be amended fram time to time in accordance with the terms of this Agreement) which are attached hereto as Exhibit B and incorporated herein by this reference and which set forth the basic guidelines and scope for the development af the Project. Parkinq Structures: the twa parking structures to be constru~ted on the Pro~erty, as more particularly described ~n Section 3 of this Agreement and in Exhibit 8. Property; the real property on which the Project will be developed and which is more partict~larlv described in Exhibit A. zoninq Administrator: the Zoning Administratar of the City. 2. DESCRIPTION OF THE PR~PERTY. The Praperty described zn Exhibit A cansisting af two (2) lots commanly knawn as "Parking Lot 4" and "Parkinq Lot 8," respectively. - 4 - .ar ~ ~,b~ 3. DESCRIPTION OF PRa.TECT. A. Two Parkinq StructUres. The Pro,ect includes ail aspects of the propcsed ~~evelopment of the ~roperty w~th twa (2) Parking Structures wh;ch are :r:ore particularly described herein and in Exhibzt B, including the fallowing co~panents: 1. T3~e "Lot 4 Parkinq Structure" shal3. be constructed on Parkzng Lot ~. ~t shall contain approximately 182,OOD square feet of FZoor Area and provide appraximately 402 full size and 292 compact non-tandem parking spaces. The Parkinc~ Structure shall not exceed faur levels and a Suildinq Height of 40 feet. One level shall be at qrade and the three others sha11 be above qrade. The structure shall utilize the existing exit on 16th Street as a right turn only. 2. The "Lot 8 Parkang Structure" sha11 be constructed on the College Softball Field. It shall contain appraximately 238,Oa0 square feet of F~oor Area and provide approximately 485 full size and 359 compact non-tandem parking spaces. The Parkinq Structure shall not exceed five ievels with one level of subterranean parkinq, u«e leveJ, of at qrade parking, and four levels of abave-grade parking. The Parkinq Structure sha11 not ~xcead a Building Height of 38 feet. The Structure shall hav~ ane entrance and exit fram 17th Street at Pico Bou~evard. The Structure shall have no exit onto 16th Street. The Structure shall be set back a minimum of one hundred twenty-four (124y feet from 16th Street curbiine. 3. The to~al Floor Area of the Praject shall not exceed 420,000 square feet. w rx ' `(.'b4 B. Landscaplnq. ;.,andscap~ng s~all be as set for~h in Exhib~t B. C. Vehicular and Feuestrian Access and C~rculatzon. Standard s~ze parking spaces shal~ ~e at ieast 8.5 feet wide by 18 feet. Compact park~ng spaces shall be at least 7.5 feet wide by IS feet, The Parkinq Struct~res shall have ~ngress and egress from several locatians on the Property as shown on Exhib~t B. 4. APPROVED USEB. By the execution of this Agreement, the Czty specifically aggroves the use of the Property for College-re~ated parking. 5. TIMINa OF CONSTRQCTION. A. Not less than 30 days prior ta the District's commencement of construction of the Parking Structures, District shall submit all canstruction plans to the City far review to confirm that the co~struction plans camply with this Aqreement. City shall review such construction plans and shall notify District that such plans do ar do not comply with this Agreement within fourteen (~4) days of receipt of such constructian plans. B. District shali simultaneously bid the construction af the two Parkinq Structures, and shall camplete c~nstruction of both of th• Parkinq Structures and of the improvements in accordance with the following deadlines: (i) District to abtain Office of State Architect (OAS) Approval (ii} District to Award Bid (iii) District ta Commence Constructian ~ November 21, I989 January 8. 1990 February 15, 2990 `" `- Il l~.i - 6 - (iv) bistr~c~ to ~o~plete Construction ~~rii 15, 1991 ~istrict must commence constract~on of both Parkinq SCr~sctures on or before February 1~, i990, and, sub~ect to ~xtens~an of deadlines as set farth be~a~, cemp?ete construction af such Parking Structures and all on-site and off-site improvements required in connection trerewith within fourteen (14) ~onths after commencement of such cons~ruction. If pzstrict faiZs to commence and complete constructzon wlthin sueh period, City may terminate this Agreement, ~n addit~on to such other remedies as are set forth in Cantract Na. 5100 (CCS). C. Extension of Dead}.ines. The failure of the District or the Ci~.y to a~eet the performance deadlznes se~ forth above shall nat be ar- event of default if the D~strict or City is prevented fro~n doinq so by reason of events ar eircumstances beyond the control of either the City or the District. In this regard, the parties acknowledge tha~ obtaining OSA approval as set forth in item {i) of paraqraph A above is an event beyond the control of either party. In the event that either the City or the Distri.ct is delayed in complying with any of the deadlines set forth above, the deadlinea so delayed shall be extended for a period ~f not more than s~xty (50) days. If the city or the District is prevented fram complying with any of the deadlines set forth abave fo~ a periad of more than sixty (60y days, the parties shall attempt, within an add~tio~.al thirty (30) days, to aqree to new deadlines. If, at the end of such additional thirty (3U) day period~ the parties cannot agree or~ new deadlines, such failure to aqree shall terminate the City's abligations under this ts r ~ ~ . '~ l, d :i Agreement aru shali ~e an evenc ~f defau~t under the i,ease; provlded, however, that =~e C~llege's fa~~ure to obtain ~SA approval shai~ not ter:,tirate t::is ngree:.~er.t or be considered an event of defaait ander ~he ~ease Lntil the expiration of an addltional thirty (30} day period. Both ~arties sha~l be reasonable ~n ~heir attempt to neg~tiate any new deadlines. D. Dlstr~ct shall be requlred to comply w~th all requirements of the ~ffice of ~he State Architect ("OSA") and to abtain ~SA appro~al of the Pro~ect prior to commencement of construction. In the event af a conflict between requirements of the City and of OSA, OSA req~arements shall prevail. 6. PROJECT KITIGAT~ON MEASIIREB. To comply with applicable provisions af the General Plan and to mitigate specific burdens upon the community resulting from constructian of the Parking Structures, District aqrees to provid~ the following praject mitigatzon measures: a. Physical Mftiqations. (1) Pav~ment treatments shall ba applied to each Parking Structure to mitigate noise effects as €oilows: Pavement ta be hand trowel finished with maqnesium trowel. Finish shall be in rotary pattern to obtain sweated swirl finish. Finish shall be subject to architect's approval. Medium broom finish at right angles to flow of traffic shall be acceptable alternate. (2) Exterior light',~ of each Parkinq Structure shall be shielded and directed away fram surroundinq residentia7. uses. (3} Oper~ings on each ~evel of the Parking Structures shall be designed to eliminate direct exterior penetration of [1 H r9 Y~ .. ~ ~ ~ - St ~ head~ights of vehicles with~n t~e Structures. No open~ng shall be allowed on the west ~ali of either Parking Structure on the second and third leveis. (4} Materials used for the roofs and exterior facades af each Parking Structure shall be af a non-reflective nature. (5) District shall pay Gaty one-fourth (1/4) of the cost of acquisition and installatlon of traffic signal improvements at the intersection of Pica Boulevard and 16th Street and for the ~eft turn s~gnal at the extensian of I7th Street at Pico Boulevard as may be required by the City if in City's sole discretian it determines such signal impravements are needed. (6) Signage at the Sixteenth Street exit of Lot 4 shall indicate right-turns Qnly. (7) The District shall reimburse the City for the cast of installinq a raised center median divider alonq Sixteenth Street adjacent to the Lot Four Parking Structure exit that will physically prevent left turn exiting onto Sixteenth Street. B. air Quality Durinq Conatruction. Equipment engines shall be kept in proper tune to reduce e~chaust emissions . Such equipment shall not be operated durinq first or second stage smaq alerts. Durinq excavatian, the site shall be watered at least twice dafly to prevent excess5.ve dust, and waterinq shall be increased during periods that wind speeds exceed 15 miles per hour. Mud and dirt shall be removed from the surroundinq streets and publicly uaed sidewalks on a daily basis. G. Yahf.a~• 711ars Plan. Prior to issuance of a CertiFicate of Occupancy for either Structure, District shall submit a - i~17~ - 9 - ~~ehicle aiar:a plan for review and approra~ of the City Manager whlch shali address measures the ~istrict sha~i take ta mitigate no~se fram vehicle alarr,~s with~n ~oth ~ark~nq Structures. D. water Conservation. {Z} Automatic sprinklers shall be set ta water landscaping durinq eveni~q and early morning hours only sa as ta reduce excessive ~~ater require~ents due to water Ioss by evaporat~an. (2) To the extent feasible, landscapinq sha~i cansist of drought-resistant pZants and the ldndscaping plans shall be subject to the approva~ of the Department of General Services as to the water conservation feat~res of such landscaping. 8. Impact~ on Traffic and Neiqhborhoad Durinq Construction. (1) Vehicles hauling dirt vr oth~r construction debris from the site shall cover any apen load with a tarpau~in ar other secure coverinq to m~nimize dust emissions. bistrict shaZl maintain a staging area on the Property for use b}{ canstruction firms and vehicles and s*~11 dssiqn ~raFfi~ patterns for construct~on vehicies, both an-site and off-si~e, in order ~o minimize th~ impact of construction activities on adjacent streets. Pr$or to the commencemen~ of construction bidding, District shal~ prepare a eonstruction period mitiqation plan which shail implement the items specified in this Paraqraph and which shall address canstruction hours, naise mitiqation, and the ~ lacation oF construction staginq areas and District shall sixbmit such canstruction period mitiqation plan to the Department of ~4 ~ .- ~~ ti .~ _ ~n .. General Services for review and approval. In addition, D~strict shall cooperate with the C~ty's Depart~e~t o€ General Services ~n arder to de~elop other mutually ac4eptabl~ ;:~eans for minimizing Pro~ect impacts. (~) District shail prepare a construction vehicle clrcu2ation and daily use p~an that specifies the praposed construction routes, hours, and da~es, and zndicates the manner by wh~ch the co~leqe will reasonably seek to ~iniMize noise, vehicle, and related impacts caused by construction activities. ~ Sazd p~an shall ident~€y one or mare designated individuals who will ~e responsible for coordinating and monitaring the construction vehicle circulation use plan and who will also be available during normal office hours ~o respond ta neiqhborhood resident c~mplaints reqarding canstruction vehicles. ~istrict shall mail a copy of said plan to all current property owners and tenants residing within a l0a foot radzus of the colleqe campus boundaries. A copy of the construction vehic~e plan shall a~so ~e published at Ieast once in a local daily newspaper. F. Energy Con9ervation. Each Parking Structure in the Project s~all c~mply with all pr~visi~ns of Title 2a of the Ca~ifornia Administrative Code relating to energy conservation. 3. ~aa~ssibflity. The Project's handicap accessibility requirements shall be as detenained by the office of the State Architect's Access Compliance Department. 7. aBNER~L SERVICSB REQOIRSI~ENTB. District shall comply with all requirements af the Ci~y's Department of General ' Services as enumerated in Exhibit C. Nothinq in this Aqreement ~r ~; .~ ~ ~~ ~, is zntended to exempt tre Pro~ect frc~ _o~pliance with current ~r future requ~raments af ~he Ce~ar~:^er,t of General Serv~ces to which the District would :the r~~se ue sub~ect, and which are applieab~e to other ~:~proveraent~ within the C~ty an the date any such future requirement ~s p,aced into effect in the City. 8. CHANGES TO THE PROJECT NOT REgUIRING AMENDMENT OF DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT. If Distrzct desires to make any of the following changes to the Prvject, D~strict shall do so in accordance with ~he provisions of ~his Section. If District desires to make any other changes to the Project, an amendment of this Aqreement shall be required. A. Upon approval of the Zoninq Adbninistra~er, District may, without amending this Agreement, (i) increase the Flaar Area of e~ther Parking Structure above the respective F1oor Areas set forth in Section 3 above, t~y an amount nat greater than 15,OOQ square feet for either Structure, pravided that the tatal FZoor Area af the Praject shall not exceed 440,000 square feet; (ii) relacate the driveway accasses to the Pro}ect by not more than 5 feet if approved by the City's Department af General Services; (iii) re~ocate tha exterior wal~.s of any bui~dinq by a distance of nat mora than 4 feet; however, in no case may the 16th Street setback be redu~ed as a result of such relacation. S. District shall file an application to the Zoning Administratar on a form approved by the Zoning Administrator which shall require District to speciPy the specific chanqes being requested and ta attach plans describinq such chanqes. - 12 - r~~. ..~,~~ C. The fee f~r ~ny s4c~ aY~~LCation shall be equal tn the fee then established 5y rescl~~~~n ~~i ;evelop„~ent review perma.t applications. D. The Zon3nq Ad:~in~s~ra~~r :~ay arprove or conditionaZly approve the applicaticn if he or she finds that the changes applied for w~ll not adversely affec~ the cor~patibility of the Prolect with the s~srround~ng r.ezg~borhocd and are harcnonious with the overall scheme of de~elop;~ent of the Pro~ect. E. A statement of afficial act~on shali be issued by Che Zoning Administratar pramptly folZowing his or her decisian stating the decision and findirigs in support thereof. 9. EFFECT OF AGREEMENT ~N LAND IISE REGOL~ITION$. A. The City's zoning codes, orc~inances, rules, regulations, and official policies governinq permitted uses, density, design, improvement, and standards and specifications for the Praperty shal~ be those cades, ordinances, rules, regu~ations, and officia~ policies of the City governing permitted uses, dens~ty, design, improvement, and standards and specifications generally applicable to the develapment of real property, as defined in the Zoning Orc~inance, in force at the time of ths execution of this Agreement, except as modified or as otherwisa pravided herein (as so modified, the "Existing RegulationsM); pro~ided, however, that: (1) District shall be subject to all increases in City-imposed application and processing fees and chargea with respect to su?~sequent applications for development and , canstruction within the Property, so lonq as such fees and - 2 3 - . - t~ ~ G charges are of general applicat~cn an3 r.ot ~~posed soiely w~th respect to the Property. {2} Norhing herein shai~ prevent Czty, in subsequent actions applicable to the Praperty, (a) from applyinq new rules, requlations, and po~ic~es which do nat conf~ict wzth Existinq R~gulatians, or (b) from denyi^g or conditionally appzo~inq any subsequent development pro~ect application relating ta the Property on the basis of such new rules, regulations, and palicies. (3y In the event af fire or other casualty, requiring reconstruction af more than fafty pexcent (50~} of any building previousiy constructed hereunder, nothing herein shall prevent City from agplyzng to such recanstructian all requirements of City's Building Code and other construction- related standards and specifications then in effect. B. As applied to this Agreement and the Project, any provisions of the Santa Monica Municipal Cade or appendices thereto inconsistent with the provisions of this Agreement, to the extent of such inconsistencies and not further, are hereby modified to that extent necessary ta effect the provisians of this Aqre~snt . C. The desiqn €eatures, signage, and landscapinq plan for the Pro~ect will be reviewed and approved, or conditionally approved, by City's Architectura3 Review Board {"ARB") in accordance w:tth design review procedure~ in effect under Existinq Regulations. Except for desiqn features, siqnaqe, and landscaping~ such review shall not include any other aspect of w '^ rt f~i ~ ~ ! ~~ _ 1 A the Pro~ect wh~ch has been spec~fical~y approved by this Agreement such as siting, buildinq ~ass, or density. D. City and District ackr,owledge that the provisions ~f this Agreement are intended to zmplement the zntent of the part~es that ~istrict have the r~ght to develap the Praject, and that City has the riqht to control development of the Property, pursuant ta specif~ed and known standards and rules which will remain the same during the term di this Agreement. This Aqreement shall nat be deemed to interdict any riqht of the City or the District, as governmenta~ entities, to act in accardance with their powers, duti~s, and abligations. E. City shal~ not be entitled to impose any mitigation measures or fees in lieu thereof for impacts caused by development af the Fraject oth~r than as set forth in this Agreement and such fees as are normal~y charqed or impased in connection with the cons~ructian of projects af similar si2e, suah as water and sewer connection fees, plan cheCk and building permit fees, and other similar fees. lo. CSRTIFIC~TEB OF OCCIIP]~t~iCY. Upon completian of either Parkinq Structure oonatructed under this Aqreement and Contract Na. 51D0 (CCS), Existinq Regulations, and other applicable aqreement~ betwean City and District, the District shall be responsible for obtaininq fram OSA a Certificate of Occupancy therefar. 11. ENpORCEME1~iT = P$RIODIC REVIEIf, 0~ COMPLI~MMCa ~'PS 11aRaEl~E~'T. This Aqresment is enforceab~e by ar~y party to it notwithstanding a change in any applicable qeneral or speci#ic ~~ ~~~ ' _ i~ _ plan, =oning, subdivisicn, or bui'_d~r.g =egulat~or,s adcpted by t~e City whtch alter or amend ~he Ex~sting ~egulations. The City shall review this Agreement at least once during every twe~ve (F~) month period iroo the date this Aqreement aas executed. Durinq each periodic _eview by the City, Distz~ct shall bs req~ired to de~onstrate goad faith compiiance wzth the terms of this Agreement. ZZ. DEF~OLT. D~strzct or Clty shall be ~n default under this Aqreement upon the happening of one or ~ore of the followzng events or canditzons ("Event of Default"): A. District defaults {~~District Defau~ts"): (1) District shall fail to pay City any amount due under this Agreement as and when due. {2) District shall fail to perfarm or camply in good faith with any vf the other aqreements, terms, covenants, or conditions of this Aqreement on pistrict's part to be per~ormed or complied with, and such nonperformance or I1Ci1COIDp11~IiCB shail continue for a period of thirty (3~) days after written notice from City, ar, if such perfonaance car,not reasonably be completed within such thirty (30) dr~y period, District shall not in qood faith hav co~~ncod such perlormance within such thfrty (30) day period or shali not diliqently and continuously procaad th~rewith to comp~etion; providad, however, that in no event shall such cure pariOd ba extended beyond one hundred twenty (120) days lra~ the date nf such notice. (3) A material warranty, raprassntation, or written statemant mada or furnish*d by District to thi Cfty is fals~ or ~ - 16 - r17 I-a ~ ~j ~ u proves to have been faZse in any materzal respect when it was ~ade. (4) A findinq an~ deter~inatian by the Ci~y Council of the City made u~an the basis of substantial evidence following a Qeriodic revzeW under Section 11 or otherw~se of District`s good faith compliance ~ith the t~ r.r,s of this Agreement that Dzstrict has not complied in good fazth with the terms or conditians of this Agreement. (5) An express repudiatian, re€usal, ar renunciation of this Agreement by District, if the same is in writing and szqned by the District. B. City default ("City Default"): {1) City shail fail ~a comply in qood faith with the requirements hereof regardinq the pez-~itted development standards and uses specified hereiri and such failuze shall continue for a period of thirty {30) days after written notice fram District, or, if such failure cannot reasonably be remedisd by City within such thirty (30) day period, City shall no~ in qood faith have ca~m~tlced to cure such failure within such thirty (30) day period or shall nat diifgentZ~ and continuaus3y proceed therewith to completion; providad, however, that in no evant shall such cure period b~ sxtandad beyand ane hundred twenty (~20) days from the date vf such notice. (2) City shall expressly repudiate, refuse, or renounce this Aqreement in writing. ~ ,.r ..i: ~v 13. PROCEDURE UPON DEFA~LT. A. Upon the occurrence of a D~strict Default, City may term~nate this Agreement upon writ~en not~ce to District or, in the ~ase of a Dlstrict Default ~~nder subsectian 12A(4) hereof, City may modkfy or te~;nate this Agreement pursuant to pro~edures set forth in the Existing R~gulations. B. Up~n the occu~rence of a City Default, District ~ay terminate this Agreement upon °Nritten r.otice to City. C. AlI remedies at law vr in equity, including specific performance, which are not otherwise prov~ded for in this Agreement ar in the City's req-lations governing development agreements, are available to the parties to pursue if an Event of Default occurs hereunder. D. If this Agreement is terminated on account of an Event of ~efault, the rights, duties, and obligatians of the parties hereunder shall cease as of the date af such termination. If City is the terminat~nq party, then any and all benefits, includinq money received by the C~ty, sha11 be retained by City. Notwithstanding any ather provision of ~his Agreement to the contr~ry, Distr~ct's and City's ~bligations to pay or perform ab~igatiens incurred or accrued prior to the date of any termination of this Agreement shall survive any such termination and shall hs enforceable after such termination. 1~. ~OTICS OF TER~IINATION. ~pan termination of this Agreement, the parties hereto shall execute an appropriate notice of termination suitahle for recordinq in the Official Records of Los Anqeles County. - 18 - ~ r' _ ;; ! ~ 15. DQRATION OF AGREE~ENT. :~~s Agreement shall expire twenty-five (25} years fro~ executi~n r~ereof. After expiration or fu~l satisfaction the parties shall execute an appropriate certlficate of ~er-^~inat~on nh~c~ sZall be recorded in the Officiai Recards of Los ~ngeles County. 16. SIIPERSED~RE HY 3UBSEQIIENT LAWB. ~f any aqency other than City passes any law or regulat~.cn ("Law") after the date of this Agreement which prevents or precludes compliance with one or more provisions of this Agreement, then the parties shaZl meet and confer in ,ocd fa~th ta 3eterm~ne the feasib~].ity af modifying or suspending one or more provisians af this Agreement to comply with such new Law based an the effect such modification or suspensian would have on the purposes and zntent of this Agreement. In addition, Distriet shall have the right to challenqe the new Law preventing complsance with the terms of this Agreement, and, in the ever~t such challenge is successful, this Agreement shall remain unmadifzed and in full force and effect. 17, T-EME'~IEB CUMULATIVE. lny right or remedy ~f either party in this AqrBement and any other riqht or remedy that that party may have at law or equity upon the other's breach of any covenant, aqreement, term, provision, or condition in this Agreement shall be distinct, separate, and cumulative riqhts or remedies and no ene of them, whether exercised by that party or not, shall be deemed to be in exclusian of any ather. Each party may, in its discretion, exercise any and all thereof, at ance or ~: -~;~~ _ , ., _ in succession, at such tim~ ar ti-es as the party cons~ders appropr~ate. 18. NQTICEB. Any not~ce, de~and, request, consent, approval, or cammun~cat~on ~:~,ch either party zs required to or may give to the other hereunder sha11 be in writing and shall be delivered or addressed to the other at the address below set forth or to such other address as elther party may from tame to ti~ne direct by written not~ce given in the manner herain prescribed, and such notice or com.~nunicatian shall b~ dee~ed to have been given or made when communicated by personal delivery or by independent courier service or by facsimile, or if by mail, on the second business day after the c3eposit thereof in the United States mail, pastage prepaid~ registered or certified, addressed as hereinafter provided. All notices, demands, requests, censents, approvals, or communications from District to City shall be addressed to City at: City of Santa Monica 1685 Main Street Santa Monica, California 90401 Attentian: City Manager With Copies to: City Attarney 1685 Main Street, Third Floor Santa Manica, California 90401 Attention: City Attorney And to, D~rector of Camm~nity and Economic Development City of Santa Manica 1685 Main Street Santa Monica, California 90401 Attention: Directar And to, Director of Planninq City of Santa Manica 1685 Main Street . Santa Monica, California 9U401 Attention: Director _ ~n _ ° -k~?: Al1 notices~ de~ands, re ~ues*s, corsents, approvals, or communlcations fro~ Czty ~o ~~stri~t shall be addressed to District at: Santa Monlca Com.~unit•~ C~llege District Office of the Superintendent and President 1900 Pico Boulevard Santa Monica, California 90~05 Attention: Superintendent and President, UR~ENT Wlth coples to: Buszness S~rvices Santa Monica Coliege 1900 Pico Boulevard Santa Monica, Califarnia 90405 Attentian: De~uty Superintendent 1,9. INDEKNIFICATION. A. City shall have r~o liabi~ity of any kind whatsoever for, in cannection with, or as a result of the Froject, ar any portion of the Praperty, or the condition thereof or the ownership or aperation thereof, or any act or occurrence that occurs ~hereat or in connection therewith, at any time during the term of this Agreement, whQther for any damage or in~ury to any persons whatsoever or to any property of District or af any other person for any reason whatsoever, z~~~.luding, without limitation, those occasioned by or arising from: 1. The demolition of existinq buildinqs, if any, or the construction, operatian, or maintenance af the Prvject or any improvements upon any portian of the Praperty, or the condition of any portion of the Property. 2. Any conduct, act, or omission of City, its agents or employees except for any claim against City for any injury or damaqe to District or any ather persor- which was caused by the ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~i ` 1 ~~~u _ neqi~ger~ce :~r reck~ess :r «~'~i~•al ~~s~ondsc~ of City ;,~ a;,•f ~y its agents or e^ployees, to t~e exter,t not covered by insurance. B. D~strict agrees to ~ndemnify, defend, and hol~ harmless, City, ~ts C~t~r C~unc~i boar~s and commissians, off~cers, agents, ar~d employees frc~ and against: (1} Any and a~i act~ons, causes af actian, o~ligatlons, losses~ i~abillties, dar~ages, in~ur~es, c~aims, and de:~ands of ar.y kind whatsoever that may resuit fxam any claira, assertion, or impasit~on against C~ty by any person of any liabzlity or cla~m therefor for any matter or of any klnd as ta which City ~s to hava na liability as provided ~n subsection (a} o€ this Section, as well as all costs and expenses includinq, without limitation, attorneys' fees, relating theret~ reqardless of the merit or outcome thereo€; (2) Any and all penalties, fines and prosecutions, suits for abatement of any public or private nuisance and the imposition against City of any Iiens, as well as any costs or expanses (including, w~thout limitation, attorneys' fees} related to any such claims, penalties, fines, prosecutions, suits and impositions, regardless of the merit or out~ome thereof; which occttr dur~nq or relate to the term o€ this Agreement, and which arise out of District's operation, business, or any other acts or omissions of District with respect to any portion of the Property, or out of any use or accupancy of any portion o€ the Property by D~strict or any other person during the term of this Agreement, or out of any condition af any portion of the Property - 22 - .~F - l~n~. ~~r~rg 4~e ~er~ ~f ~~is Hyree-e~T, ~r o4~ of ar~y defa~lt by ~~s~r~ct in ~he perfo:mance or o~se ~:~^ce of any obligatian on Distr~ct's part ta be per~c~:ed ~~r.der ~~~s Aqreement or out cf a~y fa~lure by Distric~ to ~~~p~y ~i~~ any legal requirements or applicable agree~ents cr covena^ts N~th respect tc any use, occugancy or conditzc~n cn, ~z, or a~out any por~ian of the Property; provided, however, that C~ty, ~~s C~ty Counczl, boards ana cammissions, offieers, agents, ard employees shall not be entitled to indemnification for damage caused to such indemnified party hy reaso~ of such inde~nified party's own negligence or willful act or wiliful omisszon. 20. NO ORAL M~DIFICATION. Ko statiement, action, or agreement hereafter made shal~ be effectzve tv change, a~end, waive, modify, discharge, terrtiinate ar effECt an abandanment of this Agreement in whale or in part unless such statement, action, or agreement is in writing and signed by the party against whom such change, amendment, waiver, modification, discharge, ter~ination, or abandonment is saught to be enforced. Y1. $BVER~iBILITYi IIN~LIVITY OF P1riRTIC[TLAR PROPI8ION8. If any term or provision of this Aqreement or the applicat~on thereof to any person or c~rcumstances shall, to any extent, be invalid or unenforceable, the remainder of this Agreement, or the app~ication of such t~rm vr provision to persans or circ~mstances other than those to which it is held invalid or unenforceable, shall nat be affected thereby, and each other term and provisian of this Aqreement shal], be valid and enforced to the fu].lest extent permitted by law. ~i r ~ J ~ ir _ "1 "1 - 22. ATTO RNEY-8 FEEB. I~ ~3se suit sr~all be brought because of breach or alle~eµ ~reac~ cf any covenant or condit~an here~n canta~ned on the ~~ar~ of Cist:~.ct or City Co be k~pt or performed, the prevailing par~y shal~ be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees zn additzon to co;~rt costs and any and all other costs recoverable in said ac~~cn. Such attarney's fees shall be deemed to have accrued en t;~e comnencer~ent of such action and shall be paid whether or no~ such actlvn ls prasecuted to ~udgmen~. In any case where this Ag~eer~ent provides that Either party zs entitled to recov~r its attorney's fees from the other, the recoverinq party shali be entitled to recover an amount equal to the fair market value of services provided by attorneys who are emplayed by the recoverang party as we1Z as ar-y atto~neys' fees actualiy paid by the recovering party to third parties. Z3. E%HIBITB. A12 exh~bits attached hereto and/or referred to in this Agreement are incorporated herein as thouqh set forth in full. 24, CON8TRQCTION. The parties agree that each party and its counsel have reviewad and revised this Agreement and that any rule of construction ta the effect that ambiguities are to b~ resalved against the drafting party shall not apply in the interpretation af this Agreement or any amendments or eychibits thereto. 2 5. COII1~iT$RPI~RTS . Th i s Agreement may be executed i n several counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an oriqinal, - 24 - 1~~ ~~ - ~~~.~ and s~ch caunt~rparts sha~l ~~nst~~~~4e b~~~ cne ard the same instrument. 26. RECORDING OF AGR£EMENT. The partles hereto shali cause th~s Agreement to be recorded in the Official Records of the County af Los Angeles. The cast, if any, of recording this Agreement sha~l be borne by C~strict. ~N WxTNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have duly executed this Aqreement as af the day and year first above written. CITY OF SANTA MONICA, a munic~pal corporation APPROVED AS TO FORM: (~}~'(.?~..~ w~.. R06ERT M. MYERS ~~ City Attorney ~y . t1 ~ • J~HN JALILI City Manager SANTA MONICA COMMUNITY COLLEGE nISTRICT By~ LMCDA172/hpw k •i •' ti E ` ~ 1 E~ ~} ATTAGHMF~1rI' B { 4 - _ : `l' il