The URL can be used to link to this page

SR-417-003-01 (30) . . /1.,8 ~ r -- \ GS:SS:RF:db Hospital council Meeting, January 9, 1989 I/lr-003--0/ Santa Monica, California To: Mayor and city Council From: City staff Subject: Recommendation to Establish a Preferential Parking Zone for the Area Bounded by 20th street, Wilshire Boulevard, 26th Street and Broadway, excluding 24th Street and 25th Street between Santa Monica Boulevard and Broadway, and 26th Street Introduction This report requests the city Council to direct the City Attorney to prepare an ordinance establishing a preferential parking zone for the area bounded by 20th street, Wilshire Boulevard, 26th street and Broadway, excluding 24th street and 25th Street between Santa Monica Boulevard and Broadway, and 26th Street. (See Exhibit A) Background staff received petitions from residents of the area surrounding the saint John's Hospital requesting the establishment of a preferential parking zone in their neighborhood. Representatlves of the neighborhood and Saint John's Hospital worked together to develop a proposed preferential parking zone which would satisfactorily resolve the differences between residential and hospital parking needs. The proposed zone is primarily mUlti-family residential development with some single-family development. The proposed - 1 - IAI1'6 a JAN 0 ]JJQ8 . . .. 0/" zone includes maj or commercial development along Wilshire and Santa Monica Boulevards. Staff has conducted a survey of this area that provides the necessary information and analysis required by the enabling ordinance. Staff further finds that the proposed preferential parking zone satisfies all of the criteria in the enabling ordinance (see Exhibit B) for the establishment of such a zone. staff believes that the appropriate parking restrictions for this zone should be fiNo Parking 7 a.m. to Midnight Except by Permit". BUdgetary/Financial Impact It is estimated that approximately 950 permits at $15 per permit will be purchased by area residents in the proposed zone. The zone will generate approximately $14,250 annually in additional revenue. Upon adoption of the ordinance establishing the preferential parking zone, budget revenue account 01-500-401-0000-0029-10000 should be revised to reflect an increase of $14,250. Installation of signs will be done by city crews. The Department's current budget will be sufficient to finance necessary expenditures involved with establishing this zone. Recommendation It is recommended that the City council: 1. Direct the city Attorney to prepare an ordinance to establish a preferential parking zone for the area bounded by 20th street, Wilshire Boulevard, 26th street, - 2 - . . and Broadway, excluding 24th street and 25th street between Santa Monica Boulevard and Broadway, and 26th street; 2. Direct the Planning staff to conduct an environmental evaluation of the proposed zone; and 3. Increase the revenue account 01-500-401-00000-0029-10000 lTI the amount of $14,250 to reflect additional revenue from the sale of preferential parking permits. Prepared by: stan Scholl, Director of General Services Ron Fuchiwaki, City Parking & Traffic Engineer Gwen Phillips, Assistant Traffic Engineer Attachment: Exhibit A Exhibit B - 3 - , , ," I L..-..,'", , , , ,-" - J I " ,,----.J L " "........'---" ~ 1 STRE E. ,.IIiiiiiiii.__ : I ! ,I ~[-lg- " ' . : ! lip! : ' ! ' II I, : j I _ C d' ~j ~- I j III i Ii! : I ' >.' ' !,l~... ~ lii~! , ~O, D : ~ ! ,I _ I I <(~. I I I I :l - - - -'0"'- ! W , STRE~T!oJ ,i __I !"" '" . ~ , i i 111~Z~ : . i ' , ' i i :': '""""t" H"RVAR~~ ~ 0( Z : ~ : I !111 ~ ~ :! [ i ! ' , ! : :, : : , i ' - .', g' 'i' ~>. i'" I 6 illIIIIIllillIIIIIll~illillIIIIJIl~ "1'1 i1'!";, :,:;1 ,,; - I' r- I'I;~' _ IJ ... : I; I !; '. i I. I I. .. I- _ I .. : ~ ! , MflR T , ; i Iii i Ii r i i ! ! ! i 11 UJDIIIJ~ nITJIJJJIQJ ~8ITITIl~ =. ; JJillJ I ! !: j Iii j i 1 i ! i! i B r i i I i i i I ! I i ~ SI! II ! i I i 1E3 .. , rmm "u___ ~ -))( ~T""EE;-T TWlMT' TfTIiTTl ,ilq !'l!iil~lJ~ll!I:1 !ld ! ' II' I' i : I - f Ii; ~ I ~ - ([ j ! I J I]~ ~ [J]JI8]] ,i~i"f~~ ~llillillJ,WjNTr~~ITt"lOOUGL...s ~~ ~ ! ; III H l=lrnnm~ PI>RK ~illIIIIillIl i . fjW~ ~-~ 'II~ -:~~.~:: ~ _F'rSgj mmrm EJHfflfJ~imE1 rm 1f1I[1l ~ciillm~ _~- mI ' l1TTITi1l T~~N(Y~E~~LO ~ ' . lTTTITTTll WlJl1lJlU LW.llWJS : : , S1: JOHN , 1111'1111 f uTlTTTTIfTl rTImTTl~ . H06prrAL -n..u~'T'( - ReST mmrm, 1I,11I!lii!i,!,' l~il!,I!ll~ TR I ,j;~ mmTTTl ~) UJ==j . i ...'! II. rmm . = nMf-h}tTt1~-_ 1111111111111_ - U I ~TI-f ' STREET lTTTffiIi WJillJUlLllillJ1=3 ~IIIII!ljjkrllllllllllllllll~IIII"II"111I1I1111 j , ~ LllilllllllOIIIIIJlIJt:j ffilJll.LWJ:LWillJllllJ 11111111111111111111111111! i :; STRItET , t mmrm Ii l~lT~1 f WilllW~ ~[lllllljjf;II!I!I!11111111IIIIIII[llIli!IIIIIII!II; L ITTnlllTl m Ii 1111 hillll!! Illltj ~ IIIIIIIJ JJ 1111111111111~111111!!! [Ill 1111111Ill] II J ,I Z ST"~'" illmTllll~qmllll ~~~q~ I1I1 r=1 ~1i1q I! Illt H~:q~\ ! 1 \! I '~l Y~t81 \ ! II ~\YHi~ I \ III ITTTTTmlIII ! i IIII j J II~~ I ! II ~~~ II1II11 I ! I~III ! I1II [ 1111) 111111111 I I )~lllI111111111< ~ i 0 ~ ~~~T 0 ~ rmmm J~ I III ill~~~ IIIIIIIIII~ 111:11111111211111 III1II 1~!11111111111 rmmm SCHOOL ~ 1111111 ~ t=111111! I If 1 I1II r I f ~ II j" 1111111] 1111 J 1111" 1111 HI ' mnmT1 . ~ 1I1111! ~ ~ 1111111 ! III! I ! 1 nmm mr 111111111 I; II \I J \ IIII1 _ n 111111j 1 ~ t=11111111 ~ t=j 1I11111111111 i IIIIII rt1 himim 1IIIlIl'IIIIIIIl'\.ntf[ ~ II 1I1111llli ~ _II ] IIII R ~J 1IIIllli I 1IIII11111111 I+n III! II H1 Illllr" -r 111'1 111 tr snw"",, ~ ...-: ( . . ~ 50. J~JO addod ~1 0... , "'" C'Cs ~... "U80 5.. 32J I lidded b... On! . 11<0 ees -,.od .12-80 So. J~J2 t-ddit'Ei b.. 00lI . II'" ees adoopIod .12-80 .ce JZJ~il .......,. on! , ..s. C'CS -..... ..22-10 . SANTA MONICA MUNlCIPALCODE EX.BIT B 103-8 R-62 Chapter 2A-PREFEREN'nAL PARKING ZONES SEC'TlON 3230 SCAle V.hlde Cod. Pro- "IOU The proVUAODll of llul Chapter are ezpreuly eD~d IUIder Ute ConstnUUOll. of Ute sate. An.l.cle XI SectJon 11 together Wlth ptOYUlons of the Velude Code of the SLlw. u amended The provISIOn' tel. forth In the Velude Code .hall pem whenever tJus Ch.pt.er falls to let forth m,.. speafi&: pro- YUllOEl SECTION 3231 DefwuoJJII FOt' the pur- po,e of 01.., Chapter. Ole Certaln word! md phrases are defmed md certaul ptOVUlons ahall bt> consLn1ed as herem see forth unless It LS Ipparent from the contest that I chfferent mearung 15 mtended (a) DwelhDg UnIt "Dwellmg UI11t" shall mean any self.contamed bOWIe. apartment. Sl:OCk cooperative, or eoadOl'l11lUU11l oecUpl~ soleI)' for reSidential purposes lbl Prderent~ Parkulg Zooe 'Preferen- tial Parlung Zone" shall mean a relldentlll area WIth streets IJ1d bound utes deaagnated by the City CouDcll wherem velucles c:hsplay- Il1g a pemut shall be nempt from parlung restnct1Ol15 e!lta.bl1shed punuant to LIulI Cha~ ter Ie) RUldent . Re!lIdent" ahall mean any person who byes m I dwellmg Im1t loelted I.ll a preferential parlung zone ldl Vlilltor VISitor' mall mean a person YUlt.I.llg residenu b\llJlg III a preferential parlung zone SEmON 3232 De..l1Iadoa of PrefereatiaJ Parking Z-e. 1 TIle Crt,. ColUled shall upon the recom- mendatlOn of the Parkmg and Traffic Eng1- neer. conSider for desJgnauon IS I preferenual parkmg zone Lb~e area, tatlSfymg the cntena et:tlhhahed ID tIua Secuon IIlId IDa,... b,.. ordmanee. desJgtl&te I l:ertl11'l __ as a preferenllal Plrlung mne and ma,. authorue the Pukmg &lid Traffic Engmeer to estabbsh appropnaLe pa.r1n"e restnelJOnS fur ,ueh zone. or 2 The Clt,. CoWlci1 mlY. at Its das;:retJon. desJg1late by ordmance I eertam area I' I preferentaal parkmg zone md may llIthoru.e the Parlung and Traffic Engmeer to ...bl1.th panting restndJoJUl for ,uc:h __ SEC'I10N 3232A ~p.cioD Criteria. The 6ndmp referred to 1D tIu8 Secuon .haIl be hued upon lbe followmg Chtena ....bhshed to the sat15fllCbon of the ColUlC1l 1 That non-resIdent vehicles. defined IS LbMe veludes operated hy persons whose de5tUllUOl1lare to nonresldentJa.l areo do or 111I'" subll&Iltaaly &lid regularly IDterfere with t.be Ute of the maJonty of aYa1Jlble pubhe lIU'eet or llIey parkmg splCel by adjacent relldents. 2 That the mterference by the non-rewent velucles relened to III subsec:uon 111 of tAla Seeuon occurs It regular md 'lIULfic:lInt dady or weekly mtervab. 3 That the non-resuient veludes puked 111 the area of the proposed zone callie or are the 8Ou~e of un.re8.!lOtlable DO"". traffic blZlJ'dJ. enYll'onmental poUutaon, or devaluation of real property UI the area of Lbe proposed zone, 4 That no unreuonable dasplacement of non-resIdent vehlclel will result mto surround- Ing reSidential areas. 5 That a ahortage of rellSOnably IVl1lable and convenient rel.dentw related parkLng spaces eZ1All UI the area of the propoled wne. and 6 Thl. alternltlve solutions are DOt feas.. ble Dr prad.1eal SECTION 3232B DUIgllatlon Proee.. Upon receipt and venficaLIOJ:l of a petitIOn Slglled by resIdents bvmg m two-thuds of the dweUmg wuu compn51ng Dot leu thlUl SO percent of the developed froDtage of the area pro~ed for desagnauon or upon adopuon of a motion by the Clly CoW\cd. the Parlung and Trafnc Engmeer sh.alJ undertake ,uetl survey' or studies IL!I deelflecl D8CesSII'V to dewnnme whether an area sbould be desJi1lU8d a preferenual parlung mne U an arel LS deSJg!lated as a prefprentlll1 parlong zone by the reSIdent petition proeeS! the reSidents requesung the designation shall notify aU affened reSidents and present venficll.lOn of such notaflClWon to the Parlung ud Traffic Engmeer SECTION 3232C D1uolucioa "-u. Pro- c:eed1ngs to dlseolve a preferential parltmg c:hstnc:t shall be uutaated upon receipt md venficauon of a peutKln Signed by reudents I1vmg ItI two thirds of the dwe1lm<< WllU eompnSU1g no\ less thlll 50 percent of the developed frontage of the preferenual parlung zone or upon ldopuon of III ordman<< by tbe Crty Council SECTION 3233 Penmta A "'g&ll~ IIDCI Fees The D1nctor of Fmance shall lISi1e pennaa for preC.reaulll parkmg and collect aU fen Appbc:mu shall be reqWl'Jld 10 preaem proof of reSidency In the propoeed penDIt zone rich quahfied appbcf,Dt LS entatled to purchase one Ot' more pem:uu per year The .ddress of velude r8lf1Slrauon and dnnr's been.. must c:omc:llie With the reaJden~ .ddten of appbcam So. J232 B .I.:Jd-rd bll O.d . 1151> cn ~.d "22110 50. J2l1C add.d ~... _ . 1I~ cn ....... .~.I() 50. ]2]3 ad'" ~, 0t<I . liS. C'C5 adeptrd "22 10 c~ - \, he JU5 al1l1.,1 'V 0nI , tl5& " CCS .....pIed 4-22-11I . SM,.A MONICA MUNICIPAL CODE Apphclma requnLulg more Uwl dIree permlU for thew dwelling U!l1t a:l&Y be granted .ddltullw pemuu by the Parmg U1d Traffic Engmeer upon aha1lf1D1 that there are more th... three veludee regu-tered at the dwellmc lUUt. and that IUffioeot off-Itnet partr"'!! .. DOl.v.u.ble &0 Lhe appbcam. IIDd that &0 deny uidJt10ul pemuu would COI'lSUtUCe a bard- Ihlp , Penmt left Ihall COYer th. coR of ...bla.h- mg and mambonn...!! the prerereDuaJ plU'iwlI d1stna These fNS sball be ~ by Cay Council ReM'luwm at th. t.Jme of pariwlg cIJ.anc:t deS1g1W1OD AI of July 1 of uc.b year. Uie fee shall be reduced by ODe ball for each penmt iaaued after that date to be effective for the rem"mder of the yev B DlIJ'atioa Preferent1al parmg perm.lu lSlIued pursuant Ul tIus SectIon shall feJDalJJ III effea for a penod of one calendar y.... or fraction Lhereof. or as long u the permn holder continues &0 res1de III the dweUmg wut for whu:h the permit wu ISlUed or until the preferenual parkmg cilAr!C:t for ...luch the permit wu ISSUed .. ..h""".~d. whu:bevef penod of tuDe IS less C Vianor Penaits Any rellldent may pur- chll3e two Vl.Sltor pennlt5 per dwelhng UDn Each pennlt shall have the address of the permit holder unprmted D Avadability of Parking A preferenual parlung penna sball not guarantee or re!lerve &0 the holder Uu~reof an em-street parlung space Wlthm the destgDated preferenuaJ perk- ing zone E RutrictJou aad Concbtlou Eacb per- II1It issued pursuant &0 Uus Section sball be wbJect to eal:h and every cond!r.,on and Nstnc:tJon !lilt forth UI th.. Chapter and &I ptOVlded for Lhe preferentla! pukIng WDe for wlul:h It wu lSSued lDCh,l'I,n", CODdJUO~ or restnctlOl1l wluc:h ma,. be akel'ed or amended from ume to \1nIe The J!l8I1anc:e of web permit sball n~ be construed w be a pemut for, or 1pP!'O\'al of. any VWIaUOZl of lilY pl'OYWOJI 01 tIua Code or MY other law or regulauOD. SECTION 3235 Eze~ Tbe foUowmg vehicle. aha1l be esempt from perIunc relU1c:- txms pUflUaIIl \0 tlus Chapcer. UI A vehicle owned or operaied by a abhty wbet.ber pnvately or pubbdy DW1led. when ued m the course of bU8m..s (21 A velucle owned or operated. by . JOVemmtlntal agency wben used UI the CDUI'H of offiaal pemment busmesa (31 A ..hiele for wbJ.ch lID aut.honzed emergeDl:Y yehlcle permit bu been lMUed b)' the ec.mm"lIOner of the c.hfomla Hlgbway Patrol when UHd m the course of buame... (41 A ..1ueJe clupla)'Ull' a autbonzed nc:epuon card iaued by the CIty of Suta Momca . 1 ()3.C R73 SECTION 3236 AadaDri&y of C'd)' Saaff UI lbe ParkIng Uld T~&: EnpI"r Ilball have the authonty w promulpte rules UId wi...,.., teer pobcl8II deslll1ec1 &0 IDlpllllDellt thll progJll.Dl. These rules lhaJI be Gbll1lU8d Co IIDd approved by Lhe CIty CouIlc:U 121 Dal'K1.or of FDWlce The Duftsor of Finance idlall have authonty to promulp.te rules and admmJSl.er pohaes dempat.ed Co IIIlplemellt the preferentlal parkmr penmt I}'stem Nt forth herem These rules Ihall be aubl%llued tG ad appro\ ed by the City CounoJ 131 Pohal Cluef The Pollee ChIef Ihall haye the authontv &0 enforce the rules Uld repla- uons esr.a.bh8bed p\ll'lUUl1 to th.LI Cbapwr SEcrlON 3231 PrabulIUClu and r_. lal No velucle .iJall be parked or SlOpped adjacent &0 any CIIrb In a penmt plU'long &one m \'Jol.uon of UlY posted or noticed pro1ub.. bon or restnctJOn. unless such velucle shall have promUlently chsplayed pennlt as chreet- ed. locatIon of pemut &0 be de'termUled by Pohee Each pemut sha.ll bear Uie velucle heense number of the dsuee Any velude UI \IUllaClan of the Code shall be subject &0 a fiDe of twenty-five 1125 001 dollan (bl It .hall be unlawful for &I1Y person to _n. rent. orlease. orcaUH to be sold. rented. or leuecl for any value or CODSlderatlOn &I1Y preferentlal parlung pem:ut Upon Lhe con- VICtIon of a vlOlal.Jon of thIS IUbleCtlOlI. all pemllu J.Ssued to. or for the benefit 01, the dwe!hng umt for wluch the sold rented or lea!llld permIt WII3 .uthonzed shall be vou:! Any penon so conVlC'ted shall be subject to . fine of five hundred 11500 001 dollars lcl [t.hall be unlawful for any peDOlI to buy or othetw1lle acqwre for value or U8l! any prefereDlal parluni pemut, e:lcept as pro- VIded for Ul tlus article. and allY penou ao conVIcted shall be auh)t!Ct tG . fiDe of five hundred ($500 001 dollars SECTION 3238. PnterutJaI Parkin, Zone A. A. nw following named and described IU'Hl: ""thm the City .hall conlCltute PreCel"ellual I'arkinI Zone A. VICente Ternce B No ~hlCle .hall be parked or Itopped adJli('ent to any c:urb in PreferentW Parlanl Zone Adunnll the hounof9 OOa.m to600p.m without . ~rmn ISSUed and dlSpl.y....s In eCl:ordanl:e With thiS Chapter Any vehICle parked or stopped WIthout . pemut _y hr rernoved frorn the streoet by any polK"e omen C TIle annual fee for each pennlt ISSued for Preferenllal ParJana Zone A ahall hr fifteen dollars (115 (0) per pemllt onueh other ree as may hr established frorn time to t.Ime b)' n ~utlOn of the OlyCounc:ll s.. JUt addc-d b", 0nI . lis.. ees ....od 4-UIO h. !2r Icldcll ~'" _ . liS. ees ......... ..2280 ... .... -.... ..,OM -t-.ca ........ ....... ~~t~ ""<. ~. ...;~- . >: -.!... : 1 ~,l ~ 1 ~~ }- : t ilt! ' ~ f , ~ ~' ;! - ~.. l~l' ~~ '" .. ~:-- j ,._ t~ *'. a " -- Ii" ~ ___n . (2 -/2,.--90 /I-C . t(! ~---OO3--o/ If' .... ' - . ~ i I..! t .., - '0 We, the undersigned, live on 15th, 16th, and 17th streets, between Alta and Idaho, in Santa Monica. We protest the use of our residential streets as parking lots for the commercial interests on Montana Avenue. We hereby request that the city of Santa Monica provide us with full permit parking between 8:00 a.m. and 12:00 midnight seven days a week. N~_m,! (sign and print) Address phone 7/f/.?~ 5"-1 ;'ff'-J5d/ ~ ~7i /~.?/~ ell ~ 'ft!J;V ~ 2-- .I '" ,-~ - ~ ;~o -Jlo ~i.& 3rq-6?LfZ- ~r~~~?1-:;~J eA:- qblp~ ~ M I c.A QDlfn tt. 115/- liP f (, :'; 2 _ / , J;f ~_I1t, l' <>; & ~ It" L S- 'f 'Z, {.. - - 7 /1" -~d 5 1"- .~t')r-( .t,~.14 t.. ~~5" if9~~ ~ (it '7J{Au~j~~h 3 9 ~ -:1:rb' 2- d~~-if< ~1UJ~ /', ~6'Y'~ ~ki:or" 57 ~\.~. 'i~L 1. 'J: ;Ql;.AJA . ~ ~ ~ lH~: I. Ii,; ~llll" ~ ~'Y\J2.Il ~ f.. L ME I? L "e/(i<iZ --:-"1 ' r A1 --v - 7 c Ph' 1. ' Q~.............. <: ;.: ~-,~ ,). 7 - /;;. ,";; . ATE f? /\1 (!. i.~ 0 f!/ J(' E R ., ft'! . ,,~~' ~ "72}.... I' /1., rr 3 ~()I/./Yl/JAI A' e.l.i1 ~"-- :; /11 / /. _/.''r'AoJ./ ~ 7..l.:l. /6 ~,Sf,' P! J - fft ?tJ i1/~ )11, J)- Lev I rt~ - J ;1- - -/b s 7;.. 9-/b frk.J It 07 .. ,. . . .... We, the undersigned, live on 15th, 16th, and 17th streets, between Alta and Idaho, in Santa Monica. We protest the use of our residential streets as parking lots for the commercial interests on Montana Avenue. We hereby request that the City of Santa Monica provide us with full permit parking between 8:00 a.m. and 12:00 midnight seven days a week. .., .. ......- t. ."""- BalBe (sign and print) Address Phone .... .. ~ ~/1. ,J'II At2-TH4 G.€.. DEt) N G3b -(? -tU ST, ??'j-Sf() 'f :~_ ~ ,~" ~.36 -(6~ fJ.(., 3?f-s4'J1)' ~Jit. c;.C"''!-li?:'" .,;..t;? ~ 1: ;: ~ (" '59- / L U: ~: ; f-, 3 9 .r:? 'ilK fAN"': Lrl.J.4 ~ Ar10~ A. (. 1'1 _/t-fY<~~<; I,,' 1 9..r'1'>' of fi./:;;-a~Aj r? (L/ZA- h?'1-11.r:!(,T ~9s-, 7~2'1 $ E""-,,-,,~f c @m",'1 A (,39 - Ir?y 3.;l(, s'1)',7..7-..!L 1 ~ Ib.,-PO+. 1:, ""(rC~ ?" 7 /(; JiS{ Srn. "/:,-/-';'(.,2 r.. ~l f\')~'1J0~ f". rn oc..-t(J..Ot..{) 707 I~ f1:; ~rn 'Is /-~70;;2 <;..:. f rJ._--L--~~/,~k 7.1:- /,f J7 M 'rJrd;i. t ~./!_tidL~~:Z ~:7 ~:;:m ::~::;: .. . ~ . -. ~ ~~ W\lLl~r"ll \'\ ~C;:;H.uL~ ......, t~ ~bT<<- 'S.CY\ .2pr~-'i-qt;~ t. i~ - C~~ -?/t1 /6'# W M6-~963 ---. "mf"~-d'~oyJLe~ 7rr? /# 9lr i7~5-P'953 ~ Jj). ~~ 703 16/~ <)'}: 39~7.(tD ~~t.\;( ~Q)/q~()k1 7b) /-6 C;, 39>9/(D ! 11.~L-~ 7/S!{JYl::- 5'1?-b/.;2,6 ~-rrtJd:;RPk5v <) tf 393-~/ ~~ i J1:.~"'~K.. 7 p':- //,.,t!.v-- '5.0/ J bl '1.1 f,'~~~" ~ ~::,.J ~;;~JO r J- 11 // // J; IJ tJ../~. G--"'V' -_/..._~P _ P ~!..-~or, T.c~~;-.y77 :y;,.~ / f~}K/?/ /J / 53... """ .. ~- - -- -- --- - - - - ~_ Ji ~~ ?g,~t,~~; ~C-96Ib .. ~ ......... ., .. ...~ "- ~ .~ ..... " ,- . , ...._1f{~ ~ ~ -:- ,-~ Ii ~ ~~"- ()- ,VJ J~ W\. ~ 2'/~n- ,u6 ~ ~ @ rV\,(Lkoh l1it:fuiT:_ .70<1 I~':J ~CJc(-~'ff ~ :(!Jap~aJMJAJM Jf!~ 7~rz-'11~vJ/- 3'!r-5Lrxt~~ { ilL A~dT~1 r f1Q";+o,,q In s ~ @ q1 ~ _Yl.,^" <nl...d..l~ !'G<( t~ ~ '2fi<;-1~"1-1 :::t.y>1 ~ 9 .J...~m 'Iowno. ~ .J~~- \ IV\-. ,,-f. ~<:::;-:2(., 1..1 '--- ~ /ORU1!;!, g.eA-x/LA~hAlI2~:z;L 73> nili3r 3f's->?'/,lj ~; - . .. ~< 'f!it , .. -., ., .. ~.... t', ~. ,,", - : c: ...... ' ',' ~~- ~ ~ ,; ~-. i . '" .&I, . . ... We, the undersigned, live on 15th, 16th, and 17th streets, between Alta and Idaho, in Santa Monica. We protest the use of our residential streets as parking lots for the commercial interests on Montana Avenue. We hereby request that the City of Santa Monica provide us with full permit parking between 8:00 a.m. and 12:00 midnight seven days a week. Raaae (sign and print) (j) Phone Address ~ L/ 0-1 l~ JI. #JI-3P- 4(6 ,(!j 7 /7t:!1 Sf. /veX AI-hr A,,-P_ List,. 01....30 - ,> ' "-...-;" "'- -- ~ -;..~ Sjo. !: :-:..: ~ :~ - ~ "'f ... A >, " ~, ... e ~m If-C ..:-- 1107-C 21st Street Santa onlca, CA 90403 Jgnuary 23, 1990 tlf] -lC3 -0\ SA 'ITA }~G1HCA CI'l'Y COmWIL Santa l-on~ca, CA !1embers of the Counc~l: I'm writln~ you ln behalf of the residents of 21st Street between Wllsh~re and C~11fornl8 concer~ing the preferent~a1 park~ng zone belng proposed ton~ght. Our petition Vl8.S completed In ~Jovember, 1988; I had spent a year collectlng the s~gnatures. Eecause of the impact that would be caused to Ca11fornla Street, our petitlon was delayed until petitlons from that area could be turned in. Before I could flU1Sh collectln~ the requ~red Slf,natures, the St. John's Hospital neighborhood zone was proposed, and OUT petltion had to walt untll the whole zone could be presented ~s ~ pp,cka~e deal. Thus, we have been wait~ng for preferen- tia.l p~'rking for over tlVO years. The consensus of the slgnees of our yetltlon two years aco was thAt we needed restrlctions of 1 or 2 ~Jur parklng 9 A.h.- 9 P.~. 7 days ~ week. The s~tu9tlon on our block 18 somewhat different from that of the others. There ere three restaurants on the corner of Wllshlre/21st and, also, Inslght Tralnln~ Seminars. Patrons and employees of the restaurants use our street for parking from 8rou...'1.d 11 A.:1. t~rough 9:00 or 9:30 P.r.I. 7 days a week. Insig~t Tralnlng Seminars attendees use the street all day and luto the n~ght 7 days a week, partlcularly Saturdays and Sundays, de?ending on the schedu11ng of their seminars ~nd tours. It is alEost i~poss1ble for resldents to find space from ~bout 5:15 P.~.-9:00 or 9:30 P.L;. any day of the l'Teek, and, l1hen the Inslg~'1t Tralnin-: 3er:nnprs events are scheduled, all day Saturday and Sunday, and pertinent weexdays, lTIcluding the even~ng. This 18 not to mentlon regular weekday daytime pqrking, whic~J. 18 alen very heavy. We ofte~ hp.ve to park our cars two blocks away. ThlS 1S dan- serous at nleht for women alone. One car at least has been stolen. Our cars are vanda~lsed and battered by non-resident parkers. Those leavlng at late aours are often loud and dis- turbing. The notlce of tonle;ht's meetlng was dellvered to residents the latter part of last week. ~hose to whom I have spoken have expressed dismay over the lack of relief the proposed hours ~lve to us. We haven't had Iuch time to organize our ..... ... .. . . response. Therefore, I saould llke to re~uest from the Councll the opportunlty to appear at another tlffie to ask for an amend- ment to ton10ht's proposal. It is my understanding ~hat if our block gets restr~cted ~lghtt~me hours, lt w111 be necessary for 22nd Street to be included. We h~ve approached some of the 22nd Street res11 e'lt s for theJ..r oplnions 'O'nd feel we may be able to ~ake a jOlnt proposal for amendment. Si9-c erely , / ; ~~---"~ ,) I!*~l (~iss) n8rbara Reppert . . Montana Avenue Merchants Comnuttee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned merchants of Montana Avenue, are In complete sympathy With the parking problems of our resIdenbal neighbors, we feel the creation of one-hour preferentIal parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the viabIlity of the Montana Avenue commercIal dIstrICt, and do hereby declare our oppOSItIon to such zones untIl a comprehensIve plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed I Signature Business and address ,'I, '..:/ ,,- ,&s-,7'!f~ '.. ;;9f~",,' '" ;;~ He &;,'''' ,- /">Jo rJ {~t_'-- r ----. ~j /}RT-/~-UEr11< /;)/0]5 fY1Ct1~~c., {JUt? :CW4~ ~M'~ 9!A{j:JIfLL ('1), /20, moN7lI1'fA ~V€ . ~~'-:~~~}\~ORf\,,\~ \ ::C~? {ltlc-(,,\lA~'\A.. k0<2- '\. !]c!,:} fit! fI (({,( ! ,~<i~fl-l7Ikk~ ({!!,Y1i ,0 C 1 ~{J IJ i ,r;!:H ~-7/-A..l ,~~ /. ()'-L~1. ' ~, ... J /:2./1,/; ;'1V<"-1Lr ) l.~~ y~<--- f)'6)C) P-p:-;>/-e- /7Lk 1'7 /.+/f ;,-!cn-frF-ti....<7-. k '1lil..i J~",,- \ fC>-~~ ~~'" '..... ~~~-' ~? \--\ ~",",r-:.:A. , Dc ^-'NY NclR-Rf.$ forler7ha-n. OIr.>r-1;"'W- 1;).3/ f)10t,~~. : "Ql~~~j lt~1 Ctrturrn UJ:1!lQ;(r [J-33 ~rren ~ O~- /irtlitAI.lJrfl1- 6n-)(/JLilC:;/CNS 12~ }...JONTA,.:yJ Av~ ---- --v.) 7- c~~'- <~r;\ ~~<v,r_~-:> ( \N , l/t.5~~.- IV\J/Jilr\f\ ~ A f\J L 1~[1R-J ~u~~ <)':b_~rk~)~~~<~ ,~,,1( t4 '~VJ tvtr'vV~ 'R~~f9J~.Mt< ~n1A ~~OtUtU~l>J.,.l-il LJl ~ ~A~ J9-J"LJ ~tr~1A.Lt ,ct~ - PkAUr~A~ , , '- - , " "'- /17/;,) T/}k1 4v~ ---- .~ . . !Jf-J, ;<,:-;, f"l --, , - ~..-:....- ~/ ~ !/ f Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Maruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenue, are In complete sympathy with the parking problems of our reSIdential neighbors, we feel the creation of one-hour preferenbal parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commercial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our oppositiOn to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enbre neighborhood can be developed. I Signature Business and address .~~\ '~\~l' I. E:JI_~ ~~l.:;t:: .~')i FJr7~&1L ,(,~JJ~,1' 1U ~~~- ;:. .~~~~) tru~ ~/- 1vf 7/J1~ }t1~, rV~~ ",... ;t~~:-::.-1 ' 3~ I1vu"'.fL^--P ~?----"-<.J~~n4.\I~ --g,~ t\:z;t., "qis f\A-oN-nA N A- Co~ e kK--TE- r is ,J: ..;{+-.A' ~- i;J.- 3 HcrY\t a--Yl "'- l1/(--J~\ cf~~-rV--~1 Q;" 91t; ~~J/- _)/~/4.J oJJ .~,~,~ If 9/9 /JlO/l~flIfJ SIf7 AI/k{ (j..J : v#P~ ~~/)# 7tJ'2 ih~1a...~ 51J? Ut--NZ-cl+ r~~;/, n1~tf -j-otj lYi~kn,,- 3iLf J #,1Ittzy,v {Os} f)J1l2ncl_ g;~/-r-e -;7CJcP /b4~ C~? ~.y;!;7 /ta;;.ec-T"~ : lp:. A \/ ~ 't- fll}! (/ 1-1 t? HJ~ ~t~ l'J~ fu,( r S J ~~ 0 ~{\t'~J{;l, \ T 'oJ" r ~! V E~ /YLa.....A"c/... /' b ~~ AN C ~L &7.:f 7 yo J ;'Y? &1 f'J ~,A r-r A- ft 1'1--6 fZ. t"e r.1-....-v- \'??-tJ t'lTV /7 ~ 12 {. .n" ri.v T J4-..A.--A- ; ,0~'!c/? ~'Z'>v. /;Z,JJ 77:- ftfjll~",,- 5,"" IAnl1/\ :j };;:;iA ~'~ ;~~/ ~~'~%~ d;;~"':J.i j,,: "o:--v/ ;/~-;r<~f~/t:j' 'lrti/v'!:;fv" .~;'( /lY16/\/Ji-Cu JMf/f'-" ~1J~ ~\:=>\ r'" ce, fi?;r,--(<?-~ ~ ivr~D-- ~~ I /'~ '~ ! i . . 0) Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenuel are In complete sympathy with the parking problems of our residential neighbors, we feel the creatIon of one-hour preferennal parking zones on the streets of 15thl 16thl and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viabihty of the Montana Avenue commercial dlStrictl and do hereby declare our OppoSItiOn to such zones until a comprehensIve plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed / Si~:uJ~ '; diin~s an1J.ddress \ J _ II ! 1#11- ~;, t& ' ;y tj,i!uJIMr} 101 /J.t1(;Jl.{t(~ ~ h. t I. /J \. - . 1 ( I .~ -- ~I/~ (::J:: ~ z.") .1705 m~d ~ I I~;>~ -A- J ~6 --:tv \ f:--I.D~TNJA- ~ ~ ~~ 1(7 ,~~~ .~/\ ~/f-Z~4-1--1.//J~~__ 7/5 ~/~Z4:'~ /4L?<- -~a.A,~- ~~ "~'2-5'-y~~twJL' --r:;~ 71 rJ ~I',- .If::k?O./l.//) ~ ~~EA17E 7:20 MOAlm-..NA- d.Y);!.> -5:/tt1. q,thI~ '"/,. - '/ F..4?/{2 C:~/}N~ {:I- f --,^Ae d ~{(LL-~ r?_ <5' 00 Ho /0 7:-~ X. A. u ~ If fi O'-'I'i,.~:t..."2-Q- e~"",--~~" ~ i h/A~ ~ ~/buAJ4 70& ~ Cu/J2-- ! j - -- . , ;I/rll/ . .< \> . . (2) Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenue, are In complete sympathy with the parkmg problems of our reSIdentIal neighbors, we feel the creatIon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would JeopardIZe the VIabilIty of the Montana Avenue commercial dIStrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensIve plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. SIgnature Business and address ~. >~d'" i, ): J Nl/)C:: 'j (i<, ,,, <yJ:, (i_It, '4. I!',;(/ lI':h (q "~ ii ,d , ..:e..- ~~) / lj&?7~ ~") ~.-~u. ~ r11~h t ()~'4G!t:rv;;1/)fE///"27/t10~~ ;TlIe" ; ~i1\~\,V Ie:--- l~,~,; ( !;\ l \.-- (L I' ~ q~..\,n -7 IW1~.v\'.j \J>A."- \ "J,_\ 117).1 !\I\, iMi'-~~ Ja\..- ~-=~;r-:: c--L: ..'~~ ;(..I( A-vy"1 16-2/; tt ~'7... rp,v# .;),; rC~_ -/." ",'.. 1/'/ I ---r:: / . 7 /'// - ~ ~L- (?t/{/u~ /r;Z ar!/.:r.~ A~/1 / be-I // /?fZ{..1.1~)i-.{(./i '/~~~ ~ ~~dlJe~0' /w7 )1/J~A5~A-cfJolE_ ~ --~ - -;.;1./U~c- 4Ji"~ ~k 1(,17-/ (p %/1,- A1"l1td/1~ .>.?-~ -+ L if: C:;PTloNS U"'U.AL4 Cl. ~ L.u1, It" / ~ n7O/J /U-nc:.. 1J..J..e _ , ( ", .....- -;: l~. ~ .---- / ? 2. 7 /'?Z,,z/;' -' I"{/; )l1 .~ /6 /'i ){,(~('_ ~ I )( ~ r~ ~/CL/ /'7"tb~~ C /?!c"/1h/la.. )"'fipih.c;?-c ~// /l(b~ ~ -i!?t-.4.kpc /,;;,'};,:/5' ~-"'''---- ~ . _ ~_ - - u -- s- 7<::' /1oJ -:' 1. Iv!wv~/t ' If' q~'1(),,-; ~ i ~ I '5 ( ~ M ll11l~ It A-vv- J()frJ,() /11.JI/l//1 %1f;"N --~}t /wllA-IJ/!:/E!L-v-R {j,~~ . lZ:i ---~' -~--'~ .- (;~Nf)I.'~~f;:- ilRc~"/ tYl~rJl%~ Ihv '?/;;;~ I b) -j,J e;;v l-C fLOS I'--' ~p's" ({ C P (11 d #'1' /!-.{'--A . !Lf,ll M{,~ /(,,?! M c/\./?/i ~..c;;"'-c-~j) _~1i~' ~;;1~"'C ~i~~ ~!:;;hf:~~ . . G2 - - .......... Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenue, are m complete sympathy with the parkmg problems of our residential neIghbors, we feel the creation of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the vIability of the Montana A venue commerClal district, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enhre neIghborhood be developed. ,/~, G I SIpatur Busines,and address CJRJ:1'-1:.J ; (~ ~ r - /',006 fl/ C^,rfff~ 4- Atvt fJi.r1rt krlt~/l (;1; f"'/u37 ~' ~ - '" r//' f t;,..J. l/) dJ '--pu. : L-//LU /;,. f~{'_ ~ l~/ h /'2- /fUt1h/LLUJ!lAL L7N !I:IL / ~ 0 V t J- , ffVVl<; b fc~{ y(~kGrd~~) 1~2Lf ~~(JVLtaV,u /rvu &~ d+ 1c'-!iJ 2r : /- J -t / /" r\ < ,?.-?~-rJt~ ~ I ~. -.: / '/'\, \ - ,\ '," \ A.L, ~' ;~ ;';:G~ ~ ~6-~ \~ '"f:~::" ~, ::- ":,1-' -~{;;;;;~;ktf-c~, (~.,'~ !\ ,," ':;'~r;" J,::~~ ::'~7~~;~ ~lz~_/: ~C'~ --'~7 - - /""- ~ . -- ",; .'f;',~ :.. , ' --=t....---L---'~~'..:.{ Cc_~ (0 U...:::. ILL :JLj L-.::v'( ~~Oy.J -:>~/.....~ _ I ~~~:;~;:~'~~:-;~~~~; \vzt~S N~]<~o'f- , . /, (/ ,- I (/ / /" ~ 5 r t::..4 /~ \ <-i . I , ; , (7. --\ ~ /../ ~ !vr\......Jy\..,c.... riJ':.. (, y-h-i7V"r (~-'........., I (i..{ LJ] ,. ~::f~ ,17;:'>1 it:,J+'<:t &;;;J.- - It ~\ Iv!e-':/,If-t'/!)]'L _C]t:"t 1-1,'1(';, C;4 ~S't'3 \Y'" YJ If J ".. . 11-ti.n '\ a-.l SC1.M.t" ttM\ c.~ - L ~ t q ~1f\"tt-lIA-.. \ .it ,A.i'1- S~~ ~llMtCVl , [~,J'yLd.-.. -~J y~ lAj~-.../ /1,,]7 mrr:frnp ["!.&'p ~' ~.> IT! Pt'l?0 , ) 1 . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenue, are in complete sympathy with the parking problems of our residential neighbors, we feel the creation of one-hour preferentIal parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would JeopardIZe the viability of the Montana Avenue commercial district and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire I neighborhood can be developed. : ~~igna~~~, , ' /' Busi~ess ~d address f/ '"' /5dJ,3.))iP d~~ C~'r '1,1 'j 1AJJ~- t l/: &4itJJ-- ~~~U/.,~, ~ , rJ~ .F ..- '----Y'--' iJ' ; .! U~,J;z ~~.,.,.~I .I) c;f /JuJ2 ;/Ji. J7J pOJ! /r Cd 6 /0~-c.1 7 J // I c:JdtAch f (1 ~ 6ic.rc1au: t--0:2UIf.~ilp.vJC '5T'J> J! tk.tt1'''-' il)Jl(JuUtJI (l//JilJ 1o;.tf4U2Ae- 2coo /5tXJ !zCtt4auti:k ~~ ~ \C t"'I. ___~r _ ----r-{.: ~ Ct.') \ S 2.'- .tf1 crv-. + c \"\ 0 . ~')"j;,"nc tA).~'L~0- lJ{~~~-T\;C~~l1JO/)~ J$7f~) ~~A~ ~~r~'~t!;:;~r!/;~ ~: U, /' .' I i "...,",4L.iA~: "- Ji#:>;,{ (/l/t'r't'f ':"7 ;Y1~"-',(\f''''''1 rJ[ , fYn-M.L.. n 1 ~ (~t'"l-.Q '" unt; ~At\il\ ctO{~ SHOD i~?I\ 1-lo/IJTIHJA ~,i{,-/{. I~~i-~L~-i/ - j~~S l\'\0v"-. ,~Z0 ~V'\~-\ct-\A~ At-(., /- - , ' - L v r ' !'-.--! L /f:,-,i..::"'---'-- 0 l:. ~J..A,,3-.... n..... ~>~ ~ \/ _~" / ..c-) --z- 7 / f:': r.... r C\ rv:~ I L1v(\ ~ ,. 'vi \ rr-' t ' . . Montana Avenue Merchants Comnuttee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393--2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenue, are in complete sympathy WIth the parking problems of our resIdenhal neIghbors, we feel the creation of one-hour preferenhal parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to AHa would JeopardIZe the viabIlIty of the Montana Avenue commercIal distrIct, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones unhl a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. SIgna ture ~ \ ~.. \ 'r" ' <; I.... ;. 1:..,.- i\. ,.......~..\_ "'J\ --- "\ ~.J'~''1-.~~J Business and address ~\~-f, 'J~;J' ~v.~A.i \~J"~(C~~~-.J'.j -rz l\~~ \\i),~_(~b,_ i . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned merchants of Montana Avenue, are in complete sympathy WIth the parking problems of our residential neIghbors, we feel the creation of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the VIabilIty of the Montana Avenue commercial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones unhl a comprehensive plan for the enhre neighborhood can be developed. I SIgnature I /r;ltdrbA!;//lftft! ~~u. //3)- ;J-(,rrtlrAJ!-ftJ4:1(h~ ! v - V" Tv , ~..dtl}~ !Y/L/~ //;;~ ~~ ' : -;;z~ VcIt/ t(;/A ~I-i() 1./?~~_/tA_~ ()J(jfa.:Ilv<f {'1JS>l4t'a'-c: f/ - /,' r- - ~ V ,/ I //l y~, L~/:t:i-<L -CF...r2",-.J-A- /IlL'" Jli.{slL.t-h.~{_ ('ft.-Yi ~ \-tz, fv- -:-Ill+- J I D~\ y,,\ 1e--v\~Z\,~\t..- ffi~#~#AYV-~6/#z ~~K //P/ /tJ;#~#- ~ 841-vl i IOJ fYl.JJv\ f ~ . .I -' I - '. . ---;;;{,'.' 7 'II I ~,h- ;~" J-; ....~ ,11~~l~...-t...., ~ _..i......... I';-,/' __ _./_ ______-'L.....-~ ("-- ," "J" ,t_....(... l..-'--t J "-L\__-"--___ /~~ ~ II~q t1~-~; JA'~ ' -i7M/~nl0.4/~ _ 1II1 ~OtUlt1AJr1 At{P ~ ( . L , /'Ii/'/f, t~ /. ~\.C. 'X-A1~' :.:- x.....Lh~; J' / _ .( '::.'\ .AL-(~,-,",--- / ~ - . 4k-ue.fUf;/ ../' 3klNtYV~ I ( J:; H CI-.,-tt1.-VIB. r\ ~')()'L~\~'< ~\,'r:'\.~'JtJ'ic. \\r-:-~I U,~nl\l(,i\ Business and address lCjIJA flf 9ot~ ~-I ' ---; t --z ~-:. - ....-/ -:> r -u ~ .If-; ~ .... tv 1'-- ") S-- /}/ L:4 - OJ 0 '-1-05> ~~(fr . . <;rfr.dr'iJ liJ~ ! Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393--2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parkmg problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. Address r ~,lIl^ ..........':) r~ t . 9[; IJO Z- 90"2-72- (;tJ:J- /4AcV '10702- 0041J 2- I ;. ---- . . ~~ uJ~rr Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 904.03 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tIon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardIze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed Signature / "/< _ Address ~i.It'~~.>:ftt>~ ,//C;t{~t;./.~,..;!(, (~(; ',~ ~;{t:" fCCr/7 t ~v :..:u~ ~ v ...~\ ! I ' f ,_'~ _ !' .......,.. (\, J", ~" - 'y ), '~')"/ J' - \ ~I ~ '~'O ''')A \ ,... - -f- ',\/ ""J' / / ) ~-'/I ..... . __~ ....'J~ I 'i'" ~...~ ..:; '_~ ---- fl~ >-~ <-~ ~/. L ". .~...,,;~ \~ '; - ,~', ~ ...<: i .c::::: /:"_rJi!... ,_/ . .. ~ u~ 1.-' ,'~ .-~ _7-7- (; ~ /G-?~ C:;',t., L. /:' 'i C-,;_...i Y i ~ \'-'\ C\.. \ r \." \- r-{\ \ c'A d Cj.::2)Y d ':~ ~ ~ 11 904 6 ~ ~1Il~~W"1tA~,<-~ dd/~{i;{~~U~i VC~ QOV1r ; \Wt{r~ fnrnv1J ( ~ ;C:;;/4'1J./ S l ~ki :D/.. t4(Ltf ~<; U/l& J. ~";;A~ . \ <; & 4 1/2 ~. to. A.AAt.lLA. - n".-' -!J li'A tjGCZ(" :m{}i>~/L1iv>f;2__) -Z::jqa.I8t~~~~ 90CfO~ : ~~(~ ~.QD\i?f-,-" ~q{;~ ~C~l 'Al-'-L- \j~J\I{--9-- C1vJ-~ \ : M Q~CO !v< ~\i.(.LiA 44- 7 J l +t,- &+ s M) 1 04-0 'J- 5~\A. ~\~ <f0d-~'''-~ 44l II ~ 'sf- S':,fL,\ Ci t: I{ 0-:L ~,,"--\..~~Q. ~~~~\ .x~~ \.~~~ ~~ c\~,d...~~ - - - - -........ ,.... ~ - - -..., "'-- ~ lY)r ~ .-.:}()J 5 lJCUV'~1}-- 1_ J- 1DDY1 , ()MI:!r/€AJ~J2E- /~HEA-...J 'IRJ/f ~Li7JAI A-"t/E- j,.j!J- 960z;:;:.. I, ~+~~ (:j&,jl~ 1lfW-~ ~YrVJ Air # LA) (~i1- q1JD~ (1/" 6' J : (~' a Ul~h,~~ ;','!,tJ I.Wl Sf. Il-- f" ~tUtA 1-lm1 Ut CI\ 16 l(Dr;' : v u : (7 ~L ../~'-"L~~ .?r &, 0 >>J~/-u.--" Do a' A'{/~ - L A C)OO?'h - , ;' KAk rilIlL~LA~ Iw...5r t"'{(-rtn u.d /h.'-L J~A 9co;).~- ; t~1) 20 (:h.:!v~LV--. I[ ~ :J (;'-fl.f- (-+3 ~71 ~tP~ ~t4 {h I (~, (Jk7 ftH() ,1'7/.#dr79~~/ /oY~ /7~ s:/ r~ YcJy<<? I d(~~ 1;'< r\r;e; r - . It U- \ . l'~~-s+ f]tt{ q(),\/~ ! f/-~' ,r \5 ,- .. - ("'J (3'1 UP) D c~E~~1 'fA{rr-I~ wf1fl7T5? I Montana Avenue Merchants Committee I ! 1018 Montana Avenue : Santa Moruca, CA 904.03 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parkmg problems of the distrIct's residential neIghbors, we feel the crea- hon of one-hour preferenba1 parkmg zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the vIabilIty of the Montana Avenue commer- cial district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed SIgnature Address ~ Oh.nJr /110.b~ sf ~JA. ~ " /U 9Of(r FI' ~!~A~~' /~ .J)) '~~7(J"r,;,4 #-j L f(., /'Iq~\~ ru~'Y ., YH [f\, 11 Ch~.~~l-" ~~{q k'JJItL-(AVLA.. (71# ~t.J u:.- Of!rlls,j -1;j.~ 6url1li~ d:0+ qt1 <_~-i- v~(~ 6 ('1. , CfoL/o/ : $irn.1liu'1!f[J{i/.{ I 63'0 - 8.~n(1 Sf S. J( , qC'fOa Ij~~ -~4~ 51/ (;Jrrz"~v( rr~ i>A~-Jb~ 9/~? ( 1/ - / ,/\ I.' / / ~ i ~~1 4?~L//~7J~ r}'l{) If:/1;.-J~ iI$-I Jt2/"u- . t.. II tJA f(~j./-L/ 1/;/.."- - " ./ i 'j<!~ ~~ t?'~ /22-J tt~cr;71'.JA- /l~ r1tY L 4! ~ f~!).2-[ ~c-U Jh~l(_/; A / 1. .:,-,- /0;;n I/.- J) /-' ') /~. YcJ 'T r1 :2 Ii #(l7Y/IJ(/)~ J- / >Ii> !'~R s / 1tf ~/ ') /1 -rtiLfo.- 3 , -/ [P/lG _ -)II<(~~'l-if7~ f1 90Yo.3 , ]v c; ( ,r c~ ij I ' I ; ( fJ\f:UZ--f A-- L tv'''l 0 <;2cJl S8ccv n ('\ rn 1k L LA q aeif 1 r '''/Nrt-1/A +fARI?IS or) I w' ..::; jst--:S-TR'trEl LA 96D,-~7- ---- ^ r: ' r )f?y\ f\ \ ~,~ W.pY?_(X:', l \O\SLv (;()l(nc.l1Yl #"~ L A g{'()L'C1 V If ,- ,. " 'T \ ~"tv j~/iL~2\#vJqf){~ Vr fr?NWcJuJ fh/f'" , ll) . WJD A 7 Mu I rJr)/fli /1/1 Lc.-/{!')<1 L-, ~'}V., (!v_ iOY'cJ",- '~:""-VlA._Q~-f&''''''\{I~v-L-' ).'3~r') G~ ~)+-4_ ~;~ C'~_,1UL{C5 I ~Kn /YVJ>~ -2q'Q <J. Vol ik~ ~ (U()} 9flf) 01-: , - - I ' ) Xv~),~ 3 \lO ~1~: tAL- lfq W~ JOlt! /c/I;f rd;/ I ~ q/) Va I Q <Jt..;J i:!o fJ' ~ 1?tI- ~[):Uo { v v- r~ f--/ . . . 5u~~ Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tIon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- Clal dlStrlct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. Slgna ture Address ~/~ ~ if? ~ ()r~(;.h ,M. <; J..-1- elf 9o~z. .~/~~r;i &fir) ~ ra~ ~i/~~;j :W~-f5(/(k~f(J ~~. pO<lOS : ~$ j Vt1 R ;,0 Lt JL to? 1& ~ & cA-q oo-::;-=t- I ~LJ~~ () laz!-IYYrp:T'#=-1 eij,~ 9o~~ A (LJ..// ftu.fj,~ 7m !ia<~(Qd live P reA 'roJ9- 2. , I ~\C\~[l~'0~,LvJ.A U, h~J.. &\~!~"Y}-r,J~H~L.~ ~ t:102l4.-, ; ~5;1~ lir-~"J. t.a~.;..:- :J '/0 Y \4-.1i...-4...., A'f t{JtJ~- 7 cere .Y , (~.d~~bJff J'/Ir2 JtLffhAa~_ ;J If, fa ft;;(;U liu.lit\{~*c j ~{ Ic~ )M. I cb. ,~3 !~.::? ' 1,- - . \ - or... ..- { I. ..- i::: a--'L"- ;: . \f ~ ___... ~ - ~.... L 'r-..J 'L _,..... ' ..j . !.- ~ i. I I ~ "'.;. .- i - f L -} _ -1, I tl /2Jau;n..s; Ie; f!~/~ c1.' ~1- ,.( J S: (}7 r iI,J~it-.tL- IV ft-A .......' -l /" , .' {Ii &l.--~ f (J~ (0) Of /.) r-"-t0 6% I A .... "". T /1. ~ J( ~ /1/ I1f r'_ J 0 I, d 2. tJ r 11 f t If i 7 f ,It i 0 <{ (] 3 ~ :andto I2U~7 Z<<;Orf Po-f r(tJ!>bLt. CI/ 40U;- Ii/> tI/;'II!..~rrlrAAAr ~/C; eU.hl#~S ~a'-'lf 1?r.J -Srr,m /11'lltt..J} YO]"i;L G- \ f\0. \(j/~ t\P)~1 <?l--zC- :Jlct -Sl. ~1rfbl ()1~IJCiJffA QIJ/IJ'1 ~L1~, RM'~' ~qddl f{eA+i~r'RdjrP RJ r^rlAfihv/A. 90d.G~ (rAlY\I}(~':V\(~c, 1'L't'L1. ~~ p., LA q()Oyl, -/l(o ~ ti\,\t --( U CLu.n I II h ,-])/ ~_tU-,h c~ fr. /- IT q~4 r ',\;, ~' '\ rlj , ~~'f~'"'\ <w)l C?-v\ '~/0~Q J-nd S1 ~llOI SVl ft;qo3 "-' - J I IS" -:..~ ~_ {" ..Jf:- 9D4~3 . . C;;{urC~ {u~~ Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Monica, CA 90403 (213) 393--2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue busmesses, understand the parking problems of the district's resIdential neIghbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parkmg zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to AHa would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensIve plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. S!~ture J' Address ! --!d--rZ~u1r#t/J( ~ ;<1' oS r14~Sf;# 3C/- ( r /lJ{ M q646 f VwiJ ~' ) J 9. ~'-q hI(~ vk,l5 f X -I/- 0If (ltJtJ (j 1 ~~-N,;,vl\. ,-\j,~ r-::-) 7\~ s\ 's Ii . '1l:l+-\ 1\ ~ '1 r' 'I., I' " I" L ~~ (}.;.. lv(l'Ml'v/<1.-'\ Lj S 1\ lRo,j1\')" ~~ 0; (,-"Ii 'i (.7 . :\/ 'cCi c2 ge c-'-- : /) '" ~'; > ML, :v /16 ~ /7>~rkt'tllt 0-~ 't;t 0/ :}'-y 9 i Y ~~ vt 1.. __ <:: C-------. f b u ~ (,,? j<: l, 0 ~v-( .J ,A.t J (.I { () 2- ~z[~~dh1-(/ /)(/t it1/-4- '1,'t-~ ~J&ek!.A[7f >Mhl'-tt. C;o?/t~ : r ,,/t:./0 ~n:'pe~'-c~ nLlt!I-{{/ 'lh2-dD / _ i /" ~ 1 LA tJ.& ~/( ~tJ4D ~ :11. 2 Vv ~' ,"M if . C ~ / ' € u . i ' jA-,q 2;:/1 .Jl..4 3fv1 11;!/-ljY i :fPim~~~~~Lfor I . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Maruca. CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parlang zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposihon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. SIgllf}1re ~. Address ~ 1, .y ! /A~Ad~--~1'KW Li~~l'c Jcj~,~/tfxl ~~u~ ll(lrttfJ~ I V}!f~~7 ~'~-J.&(1Lfi );:;.; L>- 0' dz .k J;~ :' ~ yx-! 7Z2:r {1 ~ F~-p ~ /33<./ 5~S/t. ~ , '._9~y;,-jylfZJt ~'f4~r;b,-fdA,J, 4~1h&:~ I' /i / I ./l1t I ~/--:- '.r ----.,. .rrA/"" >rv 11 ~~ ~ \IJ~ ~ l 14- , <: It fjj &'1..- I~^-(\ tV 1 r A- ! ;'#~~-J;;E. bM~Ut12-- '"'Iftt&/ ANt/LA- \)fl... f.Ac ~1.{t/'~C2.72-'.1 , ',~~/i-A _'d,4i:'-fUH'T 90C;' ~ t.,.jj, SI2~~J J/5 $(1,.";4,, /k/t.({~ ?Cri:'rf .~.JI!:,- _~d cJ ~ ~ II ::! UrJ / ~'~7'-I!(C1U::' 900 -3 ~1M.j>1$1_,L~.{., ~I 'lS- C'(Y.)l; cc"k- )/ iJ.4...lIll-.f c", '1n 6 Go . \i\t. G~ cr>-h~ ~({)J)A1QjJ f d- ~cCo9 ! ~ UuA:t- / .:V / J1~ lid. h~ Jlm-u 6 fL1fo:,. ; e~ '~~.l, -I, ~1ff:', ,'" ',[, ,-~i'tJ 8 j g/-(Jv~, ~:dj)IC.- ('A.~.//JL;-{'1 ,P}- '1-t'- /' f /'" /,,,"} I, ' ,'~ ! ' . {c': .., he( () rji/.'C"i,'....."':...--/! .Lhu: / ...... q'JL t" Oy-dl!// '-t 0t f v / /u... /L-fI t , I ,<I.-- jf T .' u: ~ ,.--" __4 .....-c- 7'{i( 7 ;.. ( . ". - l . i ! . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Mornca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the distnct's residential neIghbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial distrIct, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones Wlhl a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed , SIgnature _ ~-! / /--~' - ' , 'M ' '- , " I , I /' '-'?- - "7 / ' , f<, ////2" //r:ulir;.- {' ff,i.... ,'--../ .---/ l '1 ./ < , " ,,' /. ' ~ ' ,/' --;'/1 'i " - f]' <- b':JY/, (~: -(f,,~~t.- ,:'e€:,:-- - I y~=-= . - --1 A. JJG. "-"--=- ______ (;i 1\Jir~ \...' Address /.. 1'" r:; ~ --, - Q ~ at L A- 'C t - --L": \.... rf j\) I '0-~ ./':"~ .' _ 3 c; ~; 7',/ <;<:;k:r {e:.~ (2/? X / C, ?17 //d~ C;/!/. /2C5 ~l~L~ 9/V\. 1 Y( d L 9 o:J-.~ CJ --" '''- / ;V'/i/J ,~/- {./ - --J ./ I ' ?O/(9~ e . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 I Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the distnct's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana A venue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana A venue commer- cial district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. , SIgnature Address ili{,eV\ 151 wn~ - /;/c.?J /~Lhh./ ~--fi 9~dLl ~~ di~~. :?;;~ (..--/ - ///..5- fffl..-..h //i--' L/1- 7'croy'l , --- -- ,., . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 10lB Montana Avenue Santa MOnica, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from lAontana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the VIability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enhre neighborhood can be developed. I Signature ! ~,\\)bl1~W<<_ ~d-oJ-~ ~A.kafi~JvE-L4 CA f()()~ ;~~~ -- tJ3t> .(1' rnco~Dv, I' ,I J /};r (-Yl~1 /yi. r,.}' ". f l .:.J O,t:;A:, t. A I :..A/ i.' '- '...Y~ ,Jv I--'\, "-..J..J-- j r\... -.:/ -"-______ . ('1:x -'IJ.'- L-~/),Yf1) A _f.7::r-- ~ J: I G 17---- cS;/. ,.J ~ ~ , IJ/ ~ 57: 1M ; -1m.nc,rri~Sh;f1)e '-' aU '?Ad M. ~.1-1 ! I U , :::;: A r,. //J, A Ac.L:i /L /k r ..f? ;y' '/ 'f /j / /I)k / ,.: t '$' ,""1 . :~,,~~ . ~'-\\\ \)''v~~' '--\~ K , _.,~, Ip;;' - f~ \ t-e::"ti..,. .t:- f- CI I ""-_ ~ ^, ." . r ~\ T- -0 ~ __ f ) \ 1. ... I .......l.... I ...- ';+,. \ 111 l' ~ /.i'-" 1'("+_ \. "..... Q-~~, / If). r/ ...{J~h I ~v '~, ir (",'~ . / ..- r I - 1 {;! )t~, , 6f~L .0, ,(I~Jx; L i- i )li()X~)'kJ ~ 1~9 ~~ /?1. ! ~t '.- j! ,r......f~!.J. I (L~ -=- \ ".x., ': r' .,."....... v ...... ,~c r- .; rrfflfO ~U tz, gy-S Td-,fS Address L-A I eft-crcwS- t', . -, of''''': '"\ f'" " 0,', ji ::Jv~1 C L,{ 16 1- t ~ 7,pC(-p7 80 CioS 9-, f'c 5"' ~ ~ ";) "l.- s '=104 ()---~I r otfoe<. .~ ;1f>rL.;-"" ,JJV ' .... , ,--r 9t/J 4/; o D L-) D 3 QO'iu3 . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393--2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parkIng problems of the dIstnct's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the VIability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enbre neighborhood can be developed I I ! Sign~ture. .. Address j {t /__ ( ~ :~;/}fa'lUl tt1?11 (/IW/ft((hl /1 T 1j - // b -f J,~tZ1d;,~, V i I Y j,'/ '--;7;? -;S, /) < ,/; ,.1 ~2 ~/ ~~/ -' /~ / ~/..l;; il ~L/~f""---- ///I:/dd'_yl'///:I-?----.- ~)..:.,( \ . Ad/(~ ,~_..-/-'-c/M~u '. /;//(' , ':(~5-~~ \~~~ t'-~(. ~~ :) ~ <1 5-,--\ c ~~~ r4.\ & q ~ ; ~ -L i I-J!til'c€---- /'4f!Uf'tfd- /f:2.5'dn0'//oC::/?./ ~?<-~ 5 ~~ ?i'0t' : k!t'IA'\\D"--..i J--'o.~ \Ji lA.40-- S 2c I\"l{;\;L"t{\\,!J\ c:ti ~~(\ --; ~ I\;~ ~ ~j(a&L ~,-<;fiJ,7<L \J <;J4~ V~JC\~/-.(J~/}~~ ?:j./L q u10 Z- ! ~~~~,)fu11)-/1~~V'I)\ 'Git CllCLf: ~/r, SLU~ ~~D~\r'(O~ ~04'Os ,i ti!Th{1b Vr~/ ll~l ~Jzt~1LlA-1IL:Jrt0 tzl/~ ~~ ~OI/$ I V -~;:. ~- ;Jl{ I <=t ~ ' '(, ~o3 / f - I '\..;' a i' ~ & d Cr9 ~^- ~~ko ~vHG .CWo ~""~ Q<llrw-e. · :"11\- tk)v~-S Jjt~~____ ln~ tjoCJ 17'7~a- tU-e -<; A, 9cs1z% M Iff{N it z- flee 1t5 s#y Cf 00 r-I d Ilfflhtf A /J V E- 5" . 11. i &; Lt 03, C1~1 ~ 900 ;A~~ .~(>>--<-~ , ~ "1 ~ _..~-i /.. /.: "//7;7. ; '~.uX #/-:MV' --~ .< /" ~ / '~~.t-L (/~ U--/J jl I ~:I f, " ' i ~ ; I '. rl ' ') /( ~J ,J " I t L,,~ - I G --" I .if...... [SOJ.......... . / q c: d /'--1. v-v'--k..-.-....... cZ..<-J-L ....~ ---'1/ / ./? if (/""1/ /J/;i...-p_/l./ <<-- L?-<?, 5-: M ~ , . 0' t.'l-f .)/1 ~o ~a:~ //JI ....,<, -,,1 t"i ,\:'.A /\;.t'. '--:-?t~,,, 0{ -~ i .:... j I. \ - . - - ~vYo3 c:; tJ yo J 9oy!O :7 #0 L/o3 ,,-::;7~ lf~-"~:::" t -...........,f / .....:: . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Maruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue busmesses, understand the parking problems of the district's resIdential neIghbors, we feel the crea- hon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the viabIlity of the Montana Avenue commer- CIal distrIct, and do hereby declare our opposIhon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed ! ~I ,~~,:u, r~l 0! ,), /1'~1' j;, !;Lil (i~~ddreSSI!L!~) ,qi.1t \ ~j "-'- i , V v l " "-L I, l. . l ,-' I '^\../, . __' i . -' (.. ,. I r I ,P; I "I'. - t.t(tL..l C-\.( J,r,' '.'. .'.,/ J ~..i>I" :( ( t U I ~ t C{ ,,' '-- ~ ~. /- i\ >,,~ . r" ~ ti): ~ r ~ -' I ,1..<' '\, f 1 " ' \ J.<~' . C~ 0). HD.JTANf',fts:. ~ n. 0o,/os, i ( 1,/0/ /1/1LJ""\~ / '32t.f q!:f;\1-IJ/ ~ih ()1-z;t>P!() / ( ~~~~ ?SO '//(1/;1;' 0Jn;J6f0'L i ,~. - -: ~ .-'{. I f /1_. H f:;L/ ~/ C: Y t' .l ~:~.,zc~ ,?~'~krr-ci'r /7S-J_ /r~ ~I 9'.?-')/::7_J /in,/ /Ljt:~'\_1...i C-/\/, /"2 U ~/,/ '--/0)-,;/) ~ ;{1 (:' A" ) " ~. ~c~r 'L "~,, I ~. , ~. ,_l/'{'yx..~_~CL - ~Yr"CV"v- - ~1 ~ \... ~ ~ / 1 '\m ez:" 6ft I L I~ C!",-{" 7 . ,!.... (,:.,. J,1rCl.:3A /1/' I . -..- . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 ('!13) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residenbal neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposihon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. ! ~3el~. 1\ !J , c:: \'- fll. r..^O~.A_ ! ~- i /j'Ya~flP.j21/~ i ~Ltlj!./ ~WV\./ ,"" ...r...' ...., ; /. I i I I ~ I Address i (6/ ( L(~ kt/f~([~ 901(;J i 6/6 !J-iS.+ Sri S,I11, 90cj()~: 3 "'9 . 6~ b/ / ? <u.. J7",J2. 'j'".z ? .:>... I fo.f7-crl\sr #-1-/ 5. )11 7L)V03 i - ;i' "-Tn C!/~;o 3 ,_,'I .~ d-M C;o 'foJ- ' ,',. l~ ff7-- '{>>~w K ~Ir-, >fo. Y't\L9 0,-_ ktj 1'1, S r,,-\ ,i 0 V 0 2- , (J'~ / ~Ta;/\j 5:J.? /Od ~. 9~tfOt.. ,mi'WIJ..,jj(L'.AJ----<. /42.Y Nil J/ , . .~, '1C401 d/l~'. ~~b~ ?,I;l ~- ;5-p1,/~i ~~. Y"~ (0.2 ~~.?/'- 7iP? "?#"lu ! ;ifj~~ ~31~~ut!fr.R) 1ct?i I -- - (PD .. .. _IS ._li. ..1:.:1_ .CtI ~. ,ae..ea t!i!b- {f';)2 I b tf:r ~ 2 ~ I1A 9oy;o3 (! ~?'1~~;<x~'Pt- !/7t :8a.i1:/) . -- . . ( r 1J ~ltlmtijJJ~ ~tH-IMU ~ d~1-/ -d; /?~ - ~ /fJfcJ/dc2 / ,g. ~ 6f 9 );,1..- ft 11l7- ,!oYd ~ Q f~ '~I'''' J .~~, f5 C' - J 0w...{, l'~ f'\L_ !;:.'\ -' /:./ ',' , .' f- ~" ~-~ -<-"-- Ie! I1A.I..L jo.- \1'K.Ml 139 - '1-f( Sf 5'l q t, 'I (] ~ CjI1+iJ/lA. Ca,,,,,-f!e eo1'- S'1!::~ -tf;Z '5m C/diD3 qt1J~ ^jtl~ 7~~ ~Lr\./q 9()t!oL-- ( v. ...---, ! -~, L ",___ - 1/ -/, <' < /1 e1 / U /..-? I...::A /:'..1/10/ ;r--/I F1rl~04:"/v" --' -:. /1, I r,.L--T /0.... ~f ./ ,4- i I t/ '( /0-' L-- J/'V ... ~ ~{,~ <1Jie{;l."1 /31,) /5.+ 0_ C;pt/ VuC/ u..;2-- <k~ ~ Jt5h'-/~~-- ~- ~ ~- ~ J~'-f.J-{.~ (pc> '1 //,~ u $', ?1.-1 . . .. Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa MOnIca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- I bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal dlstnct, and do hereby declare our opposibon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enbre neighborhood can be developed '- n Address 72- ./ JI7C!Jr:} /:-~ / -/ r'- OJ~/t":l ~/ /7:' / (A.- t' ~ ~7 / 3' ';:Z;?~ 1 ;1 /r/ N C, ,,<: J; 7 ~ 9-/1:/ (/ S !1?A~ e!' ~j-'C - I (jj Cf{ ~~1 Pi '713 'h1 '" "-' (/1- M j'-- A- u"l<<<(S- r;: '7/ ....- ---> / ~. -j-,r' 1M -? " t; r;.;1 /?,,/ ./ ---::(..0./"........- t:/. ~ ./-. -7 ! <; fT7 /' /" / r./ rJv' ..-:0- (r' L.j ~J '-'/ C ~ 9l7W:J clj-//M<.J IZ31':;'fI{7H /fW.M..iV Lfl (t'~9 . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 39~2867 j I I I I ~ ~ Addr;~~/t/ /~ ~ ;if-~ E;i;/"p( c:'0~~.. ?f/f' /1m/~~ ;4;0. ~:-~ I/u~ C";( & /J~"~ ~;Cr ~-<. ~cJ "".)4.~ tflf /z!,.u I'.-?n.,.d I',t7Y<!- .J/U C ",q '7" y tJ-Y~ I A :(/ ' ,f . /j ---- _" _. c,../c-; .. , oc-- _' . -.., ; ~ /dM.'J1:1 F~YRA... /""- & /}; ./-U 17 tel Jh P. _ 01 J (".4 9 /.) t.; /"-.3 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's resIdential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana A venue to Alta would jeopardIZe the viability of the Montana A venue commer- cial distrIct, and do hereby declare our opposlbon to such zones unnl a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. ---=------- ''/ -., , J J -...;, // ~.....-- -"",' i /'--/'/1" /::.~_' .~p ./ - ,- 7/~' c/--" .r ....z- ..,. ~.....~., /- :.5 \ / 1-___ J / , I ~-.;;r--,.-/,-- "r1Wl , ~fi.:+ ;;;Ec &7 r 9/f- /-11t;-1 ~-J ~c .~ (?,.q.:;; fLd3 . /f / /7;/1 ~,~ ..' ( , 1 / /~' i/:' {' ~ -' c~,./' " / / I 'tJ1 /' u'- / /- ., /''':..-:' (/ /1~/' If 1" /./ I (//-._ .i"J" /, / ""?/,.<l!tFc' S> <~~: ~'hV~~))/J ~:~!~:~:~J, ,,{ 1\_ v' v /' . / i ' . '---_ "A'.L.l' I ' " ~ )F--lICLu, .~~-U(' "A1 /'7 f{.y' ""~c.'E:'_ -::,..:"-; -,?OD c.j (' ( . ) , . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the distrIct's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16thJ and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the vIability of the Montana Avenue commer- aal dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. Signatur€" Co Qv~e-t:) _/'/' i-}' (.;T .--.,,/'.---'---.~"A IJj'Aft~~ ..~ Z J ~I /.1 --. --'"I f if ~ . ~X::;~~:_l "-" 'I v -/I [V'f/y--- 'f?-._~.JJ'J./~ J:.v /../n.': l~~; ltr,-- I-i~ ~ ki1M, 1.ltlJrl{ '~ . "-/~ / -7 -"\ ~l~ ./ - ..---::;/'/ .~~-' - ~~L~J 1ku~~l !~ ~ v ~ ~ -j- i ,I ,"I' (:;,,~ if- ~ _ ;' - -~, . c- ' 'f r + i ::: ,._r"r-, ((----//$(( c;(t{ f/ fifrh I? -1--( (fJ:J1 01 ./Iz ~/J( ~'1/' j('>- ---, ( / -' fir _ ;,.... /\ /", , f-; (! <;fie i ' n W<.......>t,-(j(, "(--Lxi A~i._iL-(../- ~;L I ."5, -J- i '", :~v'J-.~ 'L-&::" c.Y!..A/.Ji ~ 1 ~'-- ! ~. '~' /, r""'t <~'; ",' r "' 1/,' ., <I " : [' , ", ,) /1_' '< / l-'- tL.... ..-!L- L-'_"---,',,"( ) ';\!G<--, 1 '- r':~ ' ~ '-:\ ~ ,. L.- -- J - - , , A id;...:U t> f, <..:.. rA--""1:.1 (i ~ ') L {+r..___ <;'1 tt -::J-...- l'y,/ - J 1 . ~J&it~ ~^-~Lld~'~ #'~- ,J.l /,/\, f ()1'~~11 /1 l L' -v' '?..-; J- -- '/ .' >U, <, f =tF- C" k~;;I ,"'v'w(j Jt.".--L U L--- (. /~ ( ... ,--I f '-oi'r ~ , r )' 1 '7f .' \...-./1--+- /'~~ --~-"---':h:, r: hi ./ ~ ~ At' "C"'" I i J:j l..--1' f.~ .....-11"'.' -./'/ 7-, -'--': c- ..J ~;:;:' 1 : I (..- 'f 1 ."r 1- l , ; J ' l ~"---14.v' :1t-1,;,'y l.v\J--v 1 c: -: ( '~~- 1 /I./f~ I ~ j /'/n Address ;' iJ I 2 J/2IJS T -f' 6/11 ~vu 3 , !,/" .... / ,.- ~ ...7 _~_. '-i v> ~; (;-. " , ~~ c;- ? I" ~-l. I S' f'. /' ( ~.... :). h J c( C "-f c3 7 -.', ,?- /' ",:'}/ ,/)~c:: , S t.. 1 {... i j ,f ,? c' , 'j' 7;:- -'/ ~ '} " - IT(, ----<-- ' I...A_.J, 7 _________ V 1_ L.../ "L!, ? , y.-<" ( ~Jft~~ N-- -- f) ~ f~l~~ /;fl(1;"'; W it ~4-A:; <-/f,.rl CJc~03 7v~ r/1. O'>'\h-Mfi/'"" ~ -,17L ~ 4; (j L/ (] 7 if 3") .(11-- " ~yt rl: ~ 5,~ c, fl'l.-vt- (... I I .... , ' ] ,i---jJ....... YO (~/i~ P" . " / (, {/ (A' 71 y'--?- J .:J/ 1/ /07 C-f ~: tv; ~'! c;t ~ ! DI ,~'\ 4 ~[,J:f ~r-I U-n:+5f-.7f.s---S/1~ '1'(' TO ~ r( C '-j (- \ . ~.- -- ~ r:'& (U ,_7 9-1 rOLf()? .--J \, 1"1 ',--, rJ- - <c' ~ 'I I l..-i v ( C/--.J Sz-vv- G( t '-/-0 ?:> ..::;/Y 0('" Jr, " ( ~. ~r',-- --- <'"'". '-y-? ~// I 3n f(Y'C, s 9{)~ ~--S Pcp- 0-2 ,r, '-1r~l.-r-- . . r-- Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's resIdential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the viabilIty of the Montana Avenue commer- oal distnct, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed SIgnature,., ~'\ {, l . -~}Y\a~ ':J~"-\c~~k-.y ~ 0) \ I Address q).2.- ,- .' C ~_ n ~,....:t:: n(~ '- v*- ,- ~ , '}-r-) YQ CfC 3- . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, I understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- , bon of one-hour preferenhal parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana A venue to Alta would JeopardIze the viabilIty of the Montana A venue commer- CIal dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones unol a comprehensive plan for the entIre neighborhood can be developed I JI ~atureIk-' Address r~ ~ j4 ~ Bi ~ (lfJE) /J~ M,."HJ \ii1 If $O,q ,6!lld;.0. q IJtlfi !i ~U~'fi-"-- J:L---4'3' f croc::''''- J.- \T\'~,7 t~J~ Il l_~ Ji. \ ep --' 900< 9/ ~_ '/1 ~,r h~LU'~v~ FJ- -,~ G ::.y{~L~,,--- 1--')( /;; J/r Cy/.{ 3"?- ~ . I i"( ". ! r" { .. - '.- ~ k-' J ;, \...\ \'vH. L-t (\_;,' n "~); t"" ) -J 1 : :'_ ~ ~; j fl.! r.- L Lf;' ~ '~ I~-::,~ \ (", _. l ~:\\..J u;...... 'l ,~J-- , -~- / ,_, I ~ ~ I r.,.(' y n- J Or --.. \J 0) t (j ~ I ~ " \ \ ,\(J{..\~ -.:.::> u.../--:( 'j/, ;----.., -.h" ~''--Z... c t.. -U vv-_' ~(L~,.4tJ '1../^'..,,\.iE ~ L-w~,'r\-\~\;\ \~I\-f)- 'N~ :2-\~:L~ ~~,~ \\~,)&\~'-'-"" \\t\d 10,*D-+ ~1:ft~~;:~ ~;;~i~ ~~~}t ~~~ ~ 6 ~~~) "--" ,\ -- , " r 1 '{' , ,\, ] ~ / .j,/ . f 1 [5<\jj\ \,.y- \ 7:/1 'oj Lt,~ , ~l(/,-'.~(C"\-;!r,~l......{, -:sz;-( I .Y'- '-,III I,. l-..." lS f' --7'. ~ . ~ - LA ~-:",~ -'7 C'L/. C,' ~! ' .~-e:~----'--r ~ v ~ - - < -' -~ ~ .:-<.:_~-~'----<---<-- c.~~ c.... ' ~\J ILl ~<<o'~~,,\GU , ,_ ;,:~, .', AV~:):Ll~',U( 9< LlC/( U( : ~0~-f2I t--~, D-II;:;... ;;{9c1 (\{ !{C7"VTE./? (..N- 1C'c'Y'{ ~\~,' ~',\ ! 1{ r~t~ ~\l~" 1?~ C;l\r~ Lei! {j z~ Sro,+-p IVLn/ll r~ '-- ~~ ~('(L[c ~ ~)5Y /ill d4- ,S)J~ 7'-L(~/ ;Ji;~k~1(---C '(L- ~ -C:~_L"'--~_ I (' / ,/ ~:.-:z S' ~ /J / _ SJ.. C ,...: .? ( r _ 7 ,;[t - r- ;; III C. 10 'v(~ di v _ :- / "..Y:=9 L~' /?"'~-..s ~ /1 fliI:J;h S: F ~ J ~'l _ C[ L{ Lf (sT~ 1 ~ 4t-C; : ~-1--d;3u4i {;~ _ ,5~ .t//n 7L",,~ , (/ ~. - ~ --,', '"' -\:::--C> ,- L"-../f'..-/ '- 'c ~ 'S '). r3rc"v4~ *~4 wt; ~ 9 oot{ 9 " ' /--~[";; ; ~- .... f'-...! .... :"/--1" .',--- ",---, ? 'i-~L \/4~ S- Is... ~ r~-::..-\ ~ JI ~~.A::.f~-1r1 t:{ c; '1 (; '-. I ',,-' - h... '-1 i[; ~: 4 '-" ) J 3' ~ U (j'!;L..f.tt 1'I.i(. t~ ,-- , ,.J r't,.\.. 0[; 1C~3' <; /--1 Co V() r z~'\(' a r I k' :7/-1 --:,-r~ f c? <'0; f"c'~r -; - } I.~./ f L. \,........._____ f ct:Y03 ~ 1~1 . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa MOnica, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neIghbors of Montana A venue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. Slgpatyre ./? 1 Address ? ~ /// () L? --/- /7 '---/tl/-ttd /j~~M'tf!;>>a:?~_, 0304-&1a1A-t~$Z /~--y_ /\1 -- A {)r;i ',C~,\ :~j\-1 iF,'" >--rvll"J.''..'/rL' J.J-1'J'-{R.-i ',"L/"".7'~' v It ~,'\ l- /'1 - ~::=J\:)?-K~--'> r A(-"JP,/ \ \1 'Y- ,~~\:, ~r "\?r ~ :(; j . /1 . I t ! 'J.-f Il \_CJu- ;.J...{.. /? ((/--/ ,!:/J /1-/1-'-;1 /~j .-:J.rtt:(.! -A/l/{{CJ, {tiLl 7"'. C';L(L.fC1CL,( {/~ -~{.:;!Wl. ~J..~ q 17 &/1, Sf pc iI f'- /-11 ///~ /uJ6 ~~ p- , ! " J I.p--i :5-. C; ( LI! l'-o.:ff..- Ifv;? i#//) c..:- S, () I \ z<< ~/7'i Q:nj,rt-- I l. (...f C'_::' ),/1-_ {, 1/( S f"l ff ~c).1~_ 90(yCf ? c .cj Cd..... '-') , ...;; j' CYdOf'.J" (('>.tA.I/A/YLJL/ . # ' , iV\\cw~) 0 Str.....-L i q 01 \ ~\;\\'f~\n\J~~('\7:- ! ~. 'EY(,lF~, i~, g~~ cC il '(~~d'lr_'h'~V;(f-):'~ Il-:'_~~" :~~i~'(:~it- \'-"\I-\\\.-,/J ~:"'-\~~ '- '\o?"~'L r ) /_/.:2- "/'?; / / c..;: '-" "<-, ~.,:-/'. ):1 ,/~:- t f,- j ,-< ,;y ,,"./ ',(,]/:d/ '.:;.</(V-l.(" /_, I / (jL../ _ Y / ,~ /' Ii' , - ;v 211'/f-.'.... ;';;",i-,'<c-1{C - /(1)~1 [.--ci&:..)t~"'~i S/1-Jl '-;?i'/(7,,'- '\' '~ -, J! / ....! t' ), ~ ~-ri/' "" . (') -":1. I. / Ii 0'" /J- ;~',"'-; !'[',' "'~'il;'....- ;,,,':,'() I VJ",J,,-i~' 11J.:e.. 1:....-1 \ , UO-i.i. i'_/'ril.'!'- -.. ,- j ( C' ~ "~', ( ~)33 (j), rk/VA).e-UfL;; ~ 9 S./l7 ~tk1? \1t\~~\nvCD_",- ~ ~(or{)[\Ytr ~,1;> qQ)7d rLan~yv1 dw~ 5:7+ ~ Prve... J.A 000+1 I : M1fM~ ~)~ ~J:i!;?A!!~~ /~3/{) ///h/lA4~/A ,/jVe- LA-- ;700C/~ i f'J / 'Y'/; "r7 }J),.I / , ? c;, ) . J It lA' ,'I ..J, r / ' /11 C)// ( If) :--:> J ,./:;;/-tUl4..A //( c: /./.>.,,-<A ,/ - .... ,,1l 0.r 1/ I-~, .~,_.\7. ,J!t...,<;/wrr f(' ?,U.-/-_ '.-.,_ --- I( ~-L">'l- 0- I ~'- r rro~ t.. ,I" ~ l ( ,5 VVl (oto~ 902/2- Cj/4-::L3 90CfC+ 9 [JO'i r \ c:: .. ~ 1", ,- ",) ~ \ ~..J r:-- ~j (~~ 'J~ y\ ko, L~ / C ~};J (ti ('::'tf;>;~ /i'/s v ~"l L;r, ~ ~\~l,:t:lr~ /9o/~ ;JA<- GA.fr~ ,i/ r: G,-o~r- r ,T'" \ 0.....-. rJ' L:::, S r""\ ~ b 4t) '; .4/;4-L 70~ 06- ~- ... . . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue businesses, understand the parking problems of the dIstrict's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15thJ 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal dIstrict, and do hereby declare our oppasihon to such zones until a comprehensive plan far the entire neighborhood can be developed Signature Address . f--I~~ f -b.,L{J.:I'c" /C;/9 /W€;Y-1d~... 6ICdO~. L.71 ~~~ ~6~q lr>ICYUnJ At'? L A q~L ~ ~,InW~C)~ ~ij6{~/LuA W' l-A qf)()~+- ~~ saG A~~~ /-.A 9ao.h1 (j;y} i \; DO , /(1r?~7 o.~- 6f:~yC5~r~ 711 6-- - ~- P'r P - . f f ;1l/3 z~ ~~L~~1 , ~ , i~'!"('fMjl~i) fl--1 It tV r;,/V1!.(furf2' --- /-4--1ftiJ! , LMl"- ~l 1W(V\<-fY ~::J,~ ~ A^i~ ii.Q!.1 ~+t {OO<'/Cf : -; - "{r~ . 4i(~ ~ p;,nr, f2, ;".1.-; r0. t11~, 0fi =,; 'tp2 ; l1ALt~ dJA~ -1;yt{ '1\ f../ASu iJAAG X 9rm ff , ! ~~~ ~;/~ WAJO~P~ 6ft? ~~~~~ i '~(Lfv~ /~; ~1:/1~. c2avllXlt-4M49 J;ic -........ ~' ' / tI I '- G- ,", ~]:b~ , ~~, /t:n1 ,7~J ~ ~k_~ v , - -. ' / - - . . ~ ' , .. Al C. ~ tll fV J {1, 1'-i -n-- , \ ...-- Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parlang problems of the dIstrict's residential neIghbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parlang zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from ! Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. SIgnature Address ....--...... ',".1.'.,..", ;:~" ?;" ~ ...,L~ '~-- ,/\-::.. ',~ ,~----/' fj ,,',- /~ ':"1')'-"'1::.... ~. J. "--.A...-Y- r.,.'...--/ ~ \...,./ _' ,I ~ ~ -- ........ ~- j( ~ (- _.' .. t I. /l---t ~ ~ ~ .-- " I ~ -. .?_-':: /i2d~rz~' /1~5,r ~A~t~U~I7&!/" L 4; ft:'oy'7 zJ X~' W~ 9-q.;z' -/2# -# rffGJt5 / d.-//J ~e'#~3 !- ~k~ ;:1l"---6CC(IJA,):'h\ 9cJ7 fkMo~r $+ S7 . It{ ,9t/Vo. I ~L. /~~A'YYl ~ j ,}--oi+(.n /-.UB"Jt0 ST STuD(() C4T-( q (&-(lLk >!t:JJ~jt:l.,r~kt1~ ;2*;~ t:lC:1 '~j:r~,t~ Sid" ~(~,,:0u ,('Cl qOl/CS- ~/ / jjL)lJ2uf~( /;,'YU fjt/{(vJLitc/~7<r// (/t r1J( !c:::-.y' ;L:.. Vj - 4-" - ~ ,j , ~ - . - D -,.' t1' C/ICvLa'vrX---- %Ll"\.J. 'L l~~~ l:."'S.n."v"_~_,'n,"';~ . '~-:. ,FL,-Q.J._....\:r--,-)G:-, IC;U' · :~~4;~r~//~;:j~~"i7f;l~;;r -~~" > ;~;;: ~~1 I-/1.-} '; if/ ,', /[1 ~ /~-;ctAs. j--. 5;z-yZ/iJ /LftJj/tI1 ~;;p~ 9C~~\5 ; ,!dJti'trV/'lt ft!~ij?{/\ / (j:i~t;~!- hU~/f /v!u:.Lf;/7 J?t r? liti fC:J--/?-- t L l~~-~ ~~ -" l~ 0C; ~m,,(~t ".) ~~ 'i,,' ~~ .1. <;\Ylljf I q ~ - y~ CAf-,--//Uv. It:? t /bv'-fr ,IJ,;#'# ;7f(;,IC// (If fQ'Io~ I /~"C(,-HJE.e Iv t:;E:E"nu;=';\' d . fit 7 Pi't/c.~/(ht:L l:.cl lU-L eC<-k- (' It 9' t;Z 7~ ' : ~-if--P L_ ~ST6€K/J /25--// /I~~ 6~A(/--- Ave- .-/aJ C}rc,;; C; 'i _ '/ ~ . ' G7.uLtt" bc"urOu,_~ 83& IS"1-t, ,S+:!J-,~ &o-1A,-~ fY)(fV'\iCA. 9'c:<f(J,~ [' 7';p' ~;J ,<)' 11 i-:r, '~', rJ ,I' /l,... 1,1('\ II,," , { I/.Ll (J1 I ~ ,I/,!;'J:"'.l ()()()V i "~,(\...,J-(..()./'I,,L (/'irJ~ till) ['ffjli.....{,i~0cQ CFllfPO.l '(~{ Hu}. Ur<1<UAIV j tfo ,Brill' -I- /h~ [ 4J, 9 () () f1 ,,{,r??Alf h K-f' fS-ir /r;1!;(\'Z---J/!1JYAAAx,iL./Z,,(: J4L( j1~ I ! ?; (!ftf! I I . . 102-2 rrcuT4uN Montana Avenue Merchants Committee I, 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momc.a, CA 90403 i (213) 393-2867 ; Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residentIal neighbors, we feel the crea- tIOn of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. I Signature ~ v: Address ~ 9rJ~'d _~~~1/0~~? ~::.~& ~ i~!~~~~:-L I b' ,- 3Y/2.Q ~~ ~qD~1f9 I' ( ~ ; /)7cv'~_ C~JJ ( kf/~ ! g9 M. vn /Lpt ~ 0 r.{-o ~ i ~ f./ r:Jl 2- i YL>cJC\? er (9{) If e -l .9C6 'IC;i r ~.... 4- ~\KF"'tPtE~ tOf't MttVY sr: 5111 i .~. erovo~ l ~tfu~ - _ 11<31~~~J}j{N::8~ ~~'i~1 , CJ/a/LLr~/r1/1t~1u/ [)//) _~0V~c>4--.! ~ rev t.L-1 : . . /" /" ' I/A.~ : /'-~ - .j;'1 '", (::0 A .-" ///-c:-- I ---r ,,I' /- . -. " c_" I ~- / ,,' - .-~~' //I'y' /:' /.-1 -jI' , 0'</ (,t' /"-/';7t/ --- ; _~,;~,:,:",,:,~1 /-L---</L."'v:;:~~~~_ ~ - -.' f ~-; < -c.4-, . r " / ' r, ' ,,( /y, , ~ : \ " / I ~ r- t. Q " "~ t ---'.2") I ( J I I ,! aJ, f 1/ 1/ ,/.A! D/2. <.fi....J f~' 7"-<--- '. (,JC:::~ L l \: ii' ..l <>-.....:[- ,I:....;>:?./ c<. (/- Ud-"'....;"?2 :d..... U1. .filu-~ cJ4. ntjS; ~ j! 7 -" r ( I /, .( 1/. ' -I :./ f r) / _y- / //1 '; ,;/ //,'~ r-"/ /..' ct _, L. ' , :~/ ~f,1~ // '~,./ :-<:/ I~ ~~';; -.0 11 ~ ;'11 ~ <' 11/:? ; -~1 t1,A----"\, , -('>C~Y--'f ;' 7~U-:Z v~ ~, /, ..e.-.-~-e., ~.....4 J I --.-J 2 ~ : ~ , I ' ','" - " ~-, /7 /, '~ --- '.(,'''-------' J< , ) / "~-;"_~ ~_ .~ ~ k~ '/ ,;'/9--e....r l.. -?' Cj , ? /:5 ;131~~.~',-(f;~ (3~37 %~~ ~ ~'L /t ~ d03t/ i - , " - - f Ct"r.' ,~ v . . I Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Maruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would JeopardIze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposihon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enhre neighborhood can be developed. SIgnature Address ,;,':--r;: n, ~/I /:2 '7 (/'11/>1"-;:.--<,' ".f' !J --:s c (. I s: ,tl;--Iv 1/ i cr/V IE- $-. J'Fl,. , 18 ') 'J S &;. /I r'~7 '~'lA. t:I ,(; L ;f ;!c;PYL-C i / c-! I 3) '~-r~U-6.-1 \\ ;/ - - j' :kJ...'i,l...-"'l,,- -,=-2) J'J"1C ('1L-,r..,01 Jll....t:/-l-t \.: D \.' , - h t---t', tf 7 I /1_ (tc ,"- ~{ /'1)- / ~z/L-Y-~ I. ~-- ( , //: ; l,. ~ /1,-<"-1... (") 'A J,I, y: / ) " jj l. t:;1A~ f . . / -;(-t. ~ .' ""'- 'j ;) ( , ! (). ~J~ p./ ,1 " !" 'OQJ__Lt./iL l T... 1"--(cL,. ! 1,,- '-"~ \,.. '- ,) .: r~ J) If )ll.!C-/~"<~/ , -")! ~ -\ .:.1 /lji' - ~;'T (1 /j ( ......-tJ ! :~ ... ~~,4'-::';""----A~-<-f J!.l1 J1:.a.... 14' ~I J'j] " r: . .Jr, -u (1!Ulrtl-tvc.- N':...C0i<, " /, p ...' - ( ./ . .; . . - -( ... Yfi.A//?.--"L_ I { '1 j .;j' ~?S /---v A:1 ycycJ-- He~ c-(. ~i':-' 14 :~"'-..L--;; ~..- fe,';'--=: T='- S I'-'! r....,<;. .-- , rl:illrWl"r . ., ~ ~ ( - ,~J ; ; 1,' .... )- -" I ~....~. ., , , , ' , ' i < .. I..... .....-r IL I .-- '" ~ (....~ ~ ./" J ~--7-' L /U ,~L - JU/~_.fL- ---. 1 / /Y-/ C /.,.. / -((("/r- /,i ,/, (((-(i':";~' (j;- ./ '-.!. L~ i," J -r'; , , : J. ' ' " , ( , , "---'" c..'-;-- 1\ ....-{ ~ L I t.I-. _ -'\.---- ~ ~ \ L.......1 - t.. :~ ('-<""II ... I I i.... I :JV~.A~;i-h,cct / ) 757 r .02< I -::::r /Z~ ;()4J,'~~1Jl/3,jO~VJ /4Lf jr,AJ(q t..-uar -;;;< ~ / / fd-- C:;\,X / ? I ", c -.c .......... ,-,\ '/;:: 1:- AAY" / I /, I j V\..../C ~- J '/&" r I c-! - I '/ ' ; ,- I .. ' ~ If ~ ,ft-- I ", ,I / j 't /-,.1 i C;i, ~ ...../ ~ I(V~V./'~ ------.. ~ ,. _./ '.....i."-.... -------"~ -. L'/I' " ... : ) ~.-; l~ ~ ". Li \,: .: I J <" l_ '-~ C! -"/' --JI ,[&.ot;,/7~ 7c Y'C~ ! 9CllJ2 <) C; 7 eJoY 7 q.aA.v/~ I /... / -") I ~/c.uc- 7'- c; C ( c...' r--- ! .. // {-/ / ... (.~ -([-,< '7:7 V r; "7 f.-~ ;::c. C;[ t.; c-- 3 /. J'~ 'i~7_Z ,( (, "r-; (1,- '/ r- ~ J'L < f.-- ,(../ (je/ ....:2-.. (L , L ~.. c/c ;6~-- 1 :;cy- Y-ora ~ \-;-;; - 3"S~ ;.. ~'I - r- ,'- --; - -; 'I j; [.....-./ ~": ~,'1/ ,. ;' .- ,r' " , /'.~/ " I \ , ,,/ ..:- Li 6!---' , J ~ ~ J . J - / ~ I ~ .. j L / - , ~, ~/ t........ '\" i 1" t..... ;",C . ...- J c- ~; '\ (' f\ f) \' ,: ') J j L ... ./ \. I ~ \-\- ~ '-- ) L --',}v <.. -'...... t---', ^..... (., ) 7F~ ,'7U/(i)/ L'Ic/)<;. cJ7S :-J;Sf <9 :; III c/u<,/(j2, . -:~ / /Y 1 I - .. - , ... ~ l(tl1--(lA- I( r:, t~, /:"~j'--""""" r'? () 11' ( J5 y, )"j:1 C //If ~-' t Z 77- . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa MOllica, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residentIal neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferentIal parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones untIl a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed 7 /~!- ': I / _::- ,///' // .- ) 1 ~ '" ....... < I -0"i ',' . ~,I 7 ' ',u-/ <---'_ , : IfLl1 ~~ I~~ ~lj-JJ,) 9=+1 f),jISTfflll:JM 'q(;LjtJ3 i ~ 6fJ:Jf. 5 H OfoY"',Q B ~ L ~ ~ '~j 1/ /. 'J f. C r l ' oP'o ,'7 it 2 ~ 1-11 1-:1- J-J.1. OL- < ~ oL/ uS ~ ~ - -- ,/ ~!O w.[!~,~~~ Lvt LA 7v'T-J-jb t Lf IY /2JJ fl0pv'JJ .I?5VZ f q 0 tf o~ u qOLfOQ Sj.A~ 9o/~ ~ (k! 1 . I/.;-y-- ;f(l-M /ltla~~th.., .& ,Yj<l~d ~J?~~/ ~ ~Y7!) ~h~ ' / (Itr~' m44/r7.;Y.)-JS' {2m~", ~ s. mG.?" l'lnL . . I ! ! Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue busmesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parkmg zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopard1ze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dlstnct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the enbre neighborhood can be devt"loped Signat}lre ' . Address ~1~, A' )fr,'-:",.,-f'\! t~7/1! /(1) j'~" f,,~ ~-(~ If (/,//' t./\i' ,( ,/Ifr..J"-'L, ,''1\..., ",' ~;,-" ~ ,-'" I v L,( ". .l;~ ...-;....... 'j."-"_... .-/ '-- .", ,r,~....' 'd v; 0C{lj::fi2.~h~JdFl."__ ~ ~ 7~~~-1- /v I If" ::IC'-,#~) r~{ ,-j, t'/+ k bc).::.2.. '~~ ~~ /()&1'7 Lln;/brtrl::.- tv 1-14 10021- /I,. ~~/". -;:",;;-_ /:'s/hr;,; n, ('/ ~~~'" .,,"'k r;k.',t? {)crr"/J: -(.~!.,'~ - .' C') ,-J-, L/V rr--;f.r1r.1 ,l/-' , i I 0~. ( 'J il'''u (~i _ I ~,.--+'" to _ / ;4',' .A" _____ II , 7 " J - " ;/1') I ,J -----Jf ... L /... " " ,(} c~' ~~ ,'""1 Y\ 'i'h',JJC2 /~~ I )',--;'-,-7, '~"<<." '1L,.;d "; 7 ~ d . P i L " (, . _./ ....; ./ / 4-- 10-- \. . ~ f............ vi. L.o'" .. ...., ~--~ ' 1""'"1 ,,, -+--. fl," --I d- ~ -.y--"~ .c, V -yA"i, ~ :: ~ -/1/'- I '''' J (, ,{ -', "'r "/ ',' ~r . 0'\,/ / t:.- ~ <--0 , ,'\' '......... r,' - /' 'r- -r- " \ ~ . t'" ~. \ ' I . . - ('-. i I ~ 1" I I j",.o'" - ,r _r i' ( ~ :';"/rj,,"'- ....... 1,-0 _,,--~ " L l..... :;,:.-1 '::;..-:oJ '':: ..:;: J ~ ,:'v ,"1 tl rr.....1 \...\/'-'0...-'-'-_ 1 j': j/J ,I r ," ,>. ,r ~ ~ j. . f' I. I ,,',i r; I .' ~. I L- ) _I ---r--1 ., . - 7~11 ~ .f : 10' ''-'''''-i l_:...j~", ,>:,,' 'OJ '. r:-, 'r:,} _ -," r tr'.. "" /~~~, ~cf(7(--- (O~ 1r/~1 s~~ 9tJ{o ~ (' ,,; J '-.i ,...._-~_,.n '7' -,f, ;j j __ , r,: P./ -/9-1" ..,L -~~_V"""o/r) I-~ ,.x--r......"......-<.--L--1 i./ J'-' - _' +, rr}--'~r--- JrlH'. '\:;--~ ( ,~~{ /"v j . ( l-rt;yl-lOfitHs-!-tA ~ 040 (;, ovil!d~ /Xvf. ,/--;4', 70030 c.h,.c> '-J---r 'J' ijl_c J " / [0 f/-d /~,', /1,/":.( _?;) r~ r<. ;. / / 5~;?' <- ' -~~ 1 /~~w~)~wJ) ~I Jl~_~(R1f!u:~~,.fJV~~ 1<<:L'1J ~}',,- i r,,:-t... '-};-,r. {J.t_ / OJ,' 4- (j ()f".( --:;{f' "[7<1:\ :.-"" jJ__ ((I7) 3- Y v I yr ,1 '"'' ,- , ,""' " 1,\.. -7 j <Y'" () r- _ . -.::..... ( /~ CJ'c....,,~\ " .J.. "i:" - ' /i U ) f' 'Y' r- ,-, n j' >/;- .~~ l J ..... l' ' (;' t l) ./ '~~ \, ""-" \.....\ , .J' j 1./, I '.i ,VvLl .., r) "" I , ,;f;iil~/~ Zlt?-,I' ,YPrJ _atfirflw"~ ),!Ia,~ ;7/607 i . /" /)... ' ....(, ~ _ T " j~ r, ) // '~~~ ~/,-,~,- I.,;, -., -'y;.. _ ",'/,<Q ~~<_/.; V ~,~ Yb' <:: ,?r' 'Y'./ .. Iff,r/t I _-/< 1/ -#-,. ..-'I. ~ ' fl.'_" J../ \ ' -~ - ( -- o.J ~ - f. ~r I I f'\.-{ t ( t r r { _..__. I 4..-" - ~.... ,.. ~/ .--' ' - "':"'_lr~_'1- '}.~ f S-0 Lue< "1--:,~ ~ .' S I-<'} 1<J li-;j t- ~' J'6L- J t6 {. (ri"J / b! I~/ -:;> 9 ') ,<l t.. L- f I ~-t. /"'.1 V'r' r 11- /1:1-4. /~J<' /l.,-L?U~ X':'\::2 - (cr71J.sJ ---# /01 :-) H cfJ 90"'70\ , ~:,~~.: ,;q-;..~ r," _' " ~l" 1~~I""~___!~, d'1~ / //'l .., j -~, 1"-, . ;: {' ----; , I _-~.. -:. ~"/<;......~,..L,V/I ~ -i rl--<..,-.Ce::->..--!--, ,-:'-c-,t::: ~ 4L---c.-i, -/~I '-. f... \ , yvt;UAA ~j L +J It 1)..13 91-/J7/1i4iM /)t. :td t}O()fv<! ~ ;~~ A<' ft;.d;. ' --7;":?~- ):f-:-7~ h{r G"~_/ It~~. ~ C-t--~ :,-/ /if t L Jf?0. V I I ,- , I r I '--1 f v.....{ ! ---; ; ,...." I . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to AHa would Jeopardize the viabihty of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. , , ,- i <'I ' ~ y I ~./~L"~ "Jf/L- L-~ l .//~.'~/~__ " "~I'''' /1,//, r' I c~ /' : I .. \, '\ . I," iLL '":'; ~ I Pi. -1 t /) 4; OJ'-"/'/ / (7. ( roO;. ~ '"1:.-1: ~ '......... (:~~A ( , ;'l \, 1. ~ I ~l-; - .. \ / t. ~ 0'. c v"'\ 1 .rh... '\./) ( /") r -Y'u:_,::1-J. . v'-- l~ ~fu_",1': /\;Y) 'r- ,- 1 ;" ~l ":'I. (. --. ~-"', - i ,- f .. .~! ....L ----L !\...f P__.a:. --\ _.~ ~ '" '_ / \- i\.....~__ r--- ~: If -.. V "'- ~ ,.,; / 'I J-x:r \...../'v '" .J~ -- '_ J "i, ?-I-- _ .. J:.f _ ,v '- i ( . '1'/-::/I...':',\1'1\"''''f,;; '~Cl/\'V,~'~" I . ]',Vl,\,.'..... J{ A If';/I 11' i YlJ'l' fl "~ -':iJ .,/ I i..,~Lrt-~~ , v' ,'$L ,1-r U_ V; "> " ' )iJJ.) . f!;, D,' ~ ::: " , , ........---1. ^.. " j , )--.., ~ L" ,"I i ~ ...-....t,...r :..! ~ \..... . v, ---- - - --- - '" ! I SIgnature f\ LA1\.f\. 0J\ 0-- '/' ..,- /1 I t.l.' ' "~;I~ Address ~ $\ \'f\ ~~~ V'--"L ~ ~ "~~\i) ~ ~ --. - .I'! Y1J.) G'I f.....~ 0', ") ,/ "l. ,,-", ~ /' r. /;', - /' /~ -x j ~ _ l//-;.,"'" .') ('" L.--(... . ".,-, ,j-:l ~J,..-'J..- 1~ / --~. ~ ,(: , . . .<1".J..""" V...........;---......... L;:L /},-,y cj." 0 .! /t..~j .' f C(DJ-:~ ir~- '. /. "[;".; 4../....v;- , '1C)! :....:_.~,~~. ~ J- ,_ c.... L :___ ..r~ '\. ~ ~-;-c;/ 4 I l~ /~ { ~~ -1 ~..., ../} I .... .' ..:;' ;'. J L--{ / ,,-- ~ -..; ~.~!J....,.. --0.-; -- I \.-~""...........'....':'" ~Lt;-\' "<........ ';;;/t~ .... J IV'-<< ( JDi ILit, (V . I ' 1'" ---.,. 1-1' f _..... . t. , , I',' ' L /~ " . L 1, '1' . I I', ""--{/' '/; J IlL t ,L , j ,,' v'. , i " ;/ 1..- I . I -ofr- '-J ((/(-'1 I z j j U/,-,...l, /_~ . . II ( ,~" i.. e.;'JD(1 J C/I- , , h '\ ~i- \ '1... '), '\: I Vl ,->P II ,. ( Ir r.. -... ~T1 n C-I 2,("-,, fl.. rf f &'{d iJ I - l, \" . SeD (7 h i 0--/ 5 · v~ x.d~ 9 () Y D .)..~ H: ,+ -+--, -:- ;' --R qf'(' -')d ; ",..:.... ~ I,' " 'J',.- i ,:.0-::, _ ) /1 c./>! ) } -- - (""- I ~ 'i--r- , - I ! L -_ , ) , (... ...... / ::- ,- \ ;..:/- V'"l.A- ~ ~ ~ I( - 1,,- I F :. I, ~L"'./ \,,"""-- Cr.. '- ___ ,,' I I":,:', 1.1.. .L':.....v.......... \~..t.~ ,y' ( '/!,;.-r {fly '/ r :. I I '-J ---, j',-, ' ,LcL-lL /, L 7;/ \ , ' ......f .' , ./ /,,\ Itlfl~.:../~ v-- 1.- . " I" " " lo..c. '(,.... i t~. j.h f'. , TFir.- , li. ': " .i~ CiL , G.,.t ~ "..\ -"'I I,'" ..- i;1 i ~{s.- ' /1, r J /A .' / / u/,., V.t / ( I' ~ , / 0>/1. I /,(.. ~U . . r- Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residentIal neighbors, we feel the crea- tIon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to AHa would jeopardize the VIability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones untIl a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed ~ture ,./ (i, ~j' Address /' . ;/ ~ /7 (t/; , J' -oJ /1 / - / \ / / Lu/ I~ 1JJ)(t- / tv 6 j1J Ol..f-r'J.J( a f1 ve..- 1';;( r7Ud.i2.d J t,~~('~~<~~r ~3-;- ~~ ,~- roo2--Z( /if({'fi I< r1t' -c-,"/( ~ rf/rJd 7 Ve{/Y(J, f fIt/. ---17/€ -> t..r 11 rut( 02- <=1 ()~ 9 .~~~(J.~ /36 ~ st.-Jt-II. ~Mfht (~~ [1~~ q'f35~)0r~ 1r'~I7((? (J;:;1o;tJ,1 \----:h-. "J.-_ ~ vJ1 q'-l Y b 121...5A-_ S - /-?.. , C 14 q ()'+Q.J J) tI 'd - IF' (; r\rJ---U~{~ ~-er .. 292 3 -5 /-~ da~/'- fr?~6..-r 7'<.-' k:,/ - , ~'-- \.\ ~l~ ~ in'l \ '\).::) I 't"-/\ S -I~-o,~J cD) G'yy\j;YU'iL\ '{O(/oy o \) 11-,1Y---}~j,-I~~(rL-- CCl'::ti (no.l'!\V\ 1 "C', OJ12-- L f-l ~C)() 21 u\ ' (f;)Or/lV'-;' ?Joh: fOlf s--:"l. s7 Ii (f ~/-7o_ Ilrr}/'{cc> '4'0(1'05 ~~~~h: ACS.~~ Lil ? c Ec-x ~ (; 7- ~-rotG, h, d'l (11 rT' ( '-r S rill 61,'0 Y \ - ~I/// 1:4 //,-'l0JI-! \/ t.--- -, - ~I.- fV\ ,,~kvr',/LS if /'~ I:J...I ;.11 /!/Lfj,~,_i r--t/)x v - .. , .? /I~,r ',v:;J.t.J_ ~ c-L / '/2-<--"",1 If; ~ I !Z 7z~6 F1LrTL--I.l--Cu... /f-u EL 9~?/t (.. ~o K7')07T L tit 90;V"7- j It ~ l,; C j(! O--v.K\ ,~~ l-,L( t:j c c if) ( 3,() 00 fl {>;5L( f1--<'1 r l,."-CCcr ~j/1 I qDC 0' e . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the dIstrict's residential neIghbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from ! Montana A venue to Alta would jeopardIze the VIability of the Montana A venue comrner- aal dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entIre neIghborhood can be developed rJi;x/J/!7imJ/ Ad~;<) 1~~tOI:iJf-tI be I LA y"txlC/ ,/i'. - ;:;~'J-' _ I l/ L {A~__ ..1.-fA'Ck--;' c: tJ-A-:" .J/ ~C;"(/L( l.:t.....d,ij'~f)y1J~-~~I.L~.j5alP.v, . ~, II Il/,,'" 1vl-J~ 7 ,-:Lf-:// /> /1/1;,/1; / Y--1_ -;:;::;-7 tv /J [t( r ,L_ (- J I"~ r) /{.LJ L,c,Lcic,r. Jr. . '-I I _"{i'1 1.<.1/__/ ,.1 J "1 17 ( -.,..- \ T)~ { r.rr. -\ II ~ld/'t / i ^!~(t~~ I,~' (\V ~~r~J:t pdlV '2 ",fIT )~~~~ 1\;;: ( u\ 7~~' 'I ~, . ~t\vv--- \--\\\\,'\\,'JJ c"'- J.J./)) /\-t ,'), ,,~(_J YA)lT(" ht>~L~~,ehU.f'{' ;,j . ,,-~;. - - ~ ,- 1- (-1 S Jh 9' () C/ G..3 - ' . J ~1(4 --"5.-LfLvld--tL4-- t ~L01-; I, I ? t--qt, 0f', .'- l~/.3)-39<f-Lto.Lg f I ~~~'7tL~ ~L~{l ~~:~~;t+~,~:~:U ( /-(1, . : _'"::lo > 'd /' i . ~.Ai A' J A C ~ c; . \./ ~f i,1. I \+t-"ItlJi / . _ (:; tf C( E L/fI-Cl--'/L~ rltl<... - r-~/ft7cPJ:-1'! > t'r I (Oif~ , - d'~ - ~ ~r ' . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residenbal neIghbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of t~e Montana Avenue commer- aal dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neIghborhood can be developed. SIgnature Address diltJ / ~... Qo1 /4 -In -6f .._:'5!;nlrl jkJ1lIA. & qJ)4/1~ , - . . JiUUl (f/if../t;. 20.12 D.eltUtA)'./t? P f" ~il Z'zt liU/Mil YOC(u,/ ? lku:n: L Cf-eHtry'C\. ?7t 0 t:L 1~V1}~ rtrc( L'A I tJ o(J;<;/ ~ ~~'-rl- 6,,;J- zI ~ 1~,z 4- Ae/ 11l(ICc" ("v U~ CoIO ~J -.. r ~u ~l,.Q I~-;)O (.,UJt.c av.r SfY) "- . ~~S~ l(,1v1.~ i0_^ '\ /: J/1<) 1 (~ov ~1J'1'1J~U( ~ I. PA-~lJ1.JOOc{ Cj(:{)'i1 jk/J t1AA~~ jK41 d-at^~U~ .c:Ii4a1tJ8/~iDdzf 'C!JtZJ1l'l;(A ~~ /b/l.s-~ ~ -#,L ~.4 (}9t/a3f!" ! -~~4- ~?/~c4;J;' 1~'7 //#4 -/~ ~~'- - i I ;~~, _ t _/L-;(,/ ,(!, {'-Ie IU:' / ~ / L'r) / ) )1.>:'-11; 7.tfA; ^----' S" /} ; Y {7 fd 5 / 1'/; It, {(i;{!P,1! A2Ai!J b --f:&-VL- ,-$ ,(( III Cl/:@;:, r r - - . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Mornca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parkIng problems of the district's residenhal neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferenhal parkmg zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal dlstnct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones unhl a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. / 0/7 ' rY _;~ l:A/J~~ /U~ i~~~ 1\.:tO ~_,~ ~'~n 1,3d- ~~~J(~ :. ">"":rtt:n~u S !~~ ~d ~~~ 1 ~~~o~o3 i ~ j)~~/ /7~/p- ~dUL. ~_ ?'p~lJ!, 'lJ~1I~'11fdhf/122U- ~JL fir. 1'~" ! v(;; r~ /~ /71,~ ~~sZ;-~~fle?' /:f~ ',- ~-'-~' -. \,' \,/}t, /":! L-'- !c-. (/1! ~ I' 'K"'""~/ ~-":....:l'r_ ,- , ,~ ............\' J _ _ ___~__ \.'r::~ o/\~ ~ . , ' ~~i/-5:}/~::I /?-f{,r;~~~A-. Cl 9tJ>> r ' '/11~st-~~d7~-~~ ~ ^ ,-\- _' : - ,- > c, I ~ ~, " i, (,If --.., / i , i ,(, I' , ' !/ './- . - " J- ~ "'~' / I '-' i ~ / ~ \. i I '1, ~l r F i ......1 ..- ~ " ~. ... r' i , --....J I -... r , ! / - , ' L~ Address /1 (/~ Jo' ~~ ~( (5~ 50 /6;0 ~ "if7 S#( ?atrO (, ~ t . " {\-\ S~ 1:0qo 3 . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardIze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposItion to such zones rmtil a comprehensIve plan for the enure neIghborhood can be developed Slgna.tY-re- Addres~ #?" .I ,,' ~ _ : ~ r;, -7 - ( ':0 -'\" fJ , ~' / /) (, lc -;: 7 7=':_--:>0 - t )'U ^J!./ i ,) l. --~--~ ~{~: /\ ~V~:f'tl-( ~i _t - "-1 ' II L- 'T'\~. ~M,,~~L0. i? 1"C)~ ~ If,,,,-,,-~~ \bJ.j.~ <:1'\ 'i'J' 7a~ Ilfrf~l/Y3;~/!;tiJ;llG,> ;cF,n/ f!h~/:ri ~/I /A r!+:?~~ .~ ; . ~ ; i - ~~1}lS~~,. ~{I,.,/-J . I!; () L/rtl\~7JI /\ \,..-Ir( / -~i\,i'~ l'1J,J,,;I~C" "'r4-' , (t~L{()<i~ I ,/) If' (/,' _ " /; _ ') '1 t i ~ , , ' f ,~-,: L:~_--' -~) ~~1.{,t..d:/1J1"!.j ~-~ ,', ;XV,l/gi/lI{ / //~ O_1'{ i\C.r" , .c- <.::,' J{ 1--":'- ',qr~ ",CJ 1 k r~ ' N_ _ ~ [~I ".\I/-....:.^!\\. ! J l ) ,~~ ~..;,d" ~: ~,- I~Vv -",---A / c..) 0:r ~ io1()2- I~ V. (//:;:~~_AA~ v -'~/) ItftfZI .u~iIt:1lDA fk:#__c .'~2.AN it qn~ 'i (r;~1i;;u----2~-;!:-J;---r: ", ~_,__ ~l'l-/vt4f.- ~}r"~~ I ~t:;. dJL7,';(:/", /--._- L//_~t c;/ . \- ..... .1/ /'{, ._,~ -- I '-...... ~ -.. i I ,/2,vj:. ,i I c"'- //" ; _ i' A\ ' A / ; ~~: ,r---v-,. 0,/ \..- ,[ .....J-.~. I,.. ,-. "---_ fCl83 /HUW.!! (If<<5i7L-J),pniF -54N PEiJ;2L c~ 910732- r ,t/, / ~ L-'< (\ I ,', .L-'L- "L.. <-\... J9BMLI4f-s)f,4~T1-.jJt(JJe SA# PF-J);C/ M~C732 f.,/ v....l. . . ;' i . . I ! Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersIgned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue busmesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viabilIty of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our Opposibon to such zones until a comprehensIve plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. SIgnature ~4'~J1- It- LlAJ LLL- .... . Address q r3J IY'~ 51- 1f: I cr I (n, (' l- C?:5 ~ Q\... L. 'v v..L vt... L L-- 0J.41 cA LA-- (1-- . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residenbal neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would JeopardIze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dIstrIct, and do hereby declare our opposibon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. ~l ture ,/?,: , -' ,r- {J..r::"-! , ',OJ I' ;"L.c , !~J';"\ '~:.J";T l kubrMM flir~ I 1 \ rl/c. JJ ... I: ',', " I", It fH 'f '\ ',JOJ r [',1'1' \ U -- Address / ~ f'" {" /' r ( . .; / I i r 11-\, -I ~~,' "f1/~ J r ~1'''..t '.' -, "_- J ;.,oj. v{...~ I}, J/~7 ~4'iU~~ 4t. /1 .:'(' () c (0/1,;' Yj :1 r; (':{'J7't"'; H"".,' J :fJ ,J , (V '- r--- I: Ii' IJ! ' ' J /1 -Jd Jf!;; ?-- It ,..-. ;r. L/ " 'r-' " , C,-4~6 I f r1,?If1 r:? C{ OJ Lf {7 . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's reSIdential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana A venue to Alta would JeopardIze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- oal district, and do hereby declare our oppositIon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. ~i ~.. /'~l I ' / , . -.(/~:--;r: _ _ / //.~ '-....~ >" ___,//~ /h j?/ ~ ! - i , Gh-~\I' ~ )" ; - ~., t C'\ h f t. (' 0- ,~L-'" );...1 1J_.h.~_ ..r c.. Inll.,.. .... l I,L '\ ",..:.rI,I.. . l ';~4U't' , ~, . / j l~, rl~ ""-'\;~ ; '-../ ,\--{ Iii _'I''L, i'..i I'(~_ J v'--. ....JO/'. 'J 'rj-fl (t'" '.l tv ( ,-./ -~uk~k !M~7jJeC~ ~JM" ~37 I ~--<' - ~--.--" ~ ,$/0 /.A-t-;:r ~~ I JJz/~ I ~, fh. j C4-- 9~fCGt i1l.:ltO S=n 'II c~')-i-e.. 6ivd LA- J cA '10049 LtVJ (ft 1Cj LfJ 3;: " // IfLi~ ~ cJ;CfI.) !lit. "-\. . . / I Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 l ! ! Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parkmg zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana A venue to Alta would JeOpan:hze the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- aal district, and do hereby declare our opposlhon to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. Signature Address ~ 12. _J~~ :2. ?j-J> fi7~ ~ IV / II ?o 0 '1'1 ',- ji ~'-J ! h_ I d2.i-lL r-I{7~i~ JP-({'{{ ~ (Iu' ;/JI..J;'...hfif, ~r-'/rLI_-IU()fr.:. 7LJ-17 1-'/~/1.L' (~/-t~~: 1'~ Itcx 1CJ1./tiLL:JI: ,{j P /hi ::1:) 1-r f(;n{jJt'^--;;;7~1j/1-- 1/?J-:J7 (4{/:JtL-h 4-1- -<r4 ~OOi? 7JIU (( YiI bl,I~(L ~ -'1 {./.!Jj- '.' V ?l~I;-! ri ~{ I)J L~l 'll)) 3v !::11 M&L..tL IOL~ 9Th ~~ '5..",nhfuNrC4 (AI. '104D~ . - , . . Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's resIdential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parking wnes on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the viabulty of the Montana Avenue commer- cial district, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. Slgna ture Address n ~1'{~A_-\,- //1 ~11A---LO (/// 7 [H)~ (..?r;r \" \.r...~~ c.~ ~~~~~ J -::: {c:-~~ \\ ':Q~ \'-~~f~:~~~~~ ! y;, / tJ i:i~~ ~ -J / i :; ~ t-uz (~ Ih~ _ :;;-/~ c;- /J C/?t _1 V---/ /~ I - --...... I . . ~ , Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (2]3) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana A venue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- bon of one-hour preferential parkmg zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would Jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- aal district, and do hereby declare our opposihon to such zones unbl a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed Address ,/J ,17?? / (fYJJjtlAd- rac. pd ~. if OJ. ~ q; q - 9+iJS,-f =Ji- 4 4~,-);Ir-?4-~-..,-r? IIc;?) ,Y/1J.A (; -<.... fJL -'-_If"'. i.:2::J k <-.) L( ~+ -?L( ~:rl ~\-h\ l-Zf c-:-r./( u\ 1'0 i(O Lt! ,,,~ - /1 - _-. I I ,- , --1/1( c/ t{;;e I/f-'J-/f ,) /r.1/ .;///( ?--(1IV' u,./ ~ 7' ,f~'lr 7(1' ~-'7 (/~!;:'t-J(:%zfJj?A %>1 IC: r1fl v'~,~~Il;;'Ii(~~ :?cy~'~ Clal~ ~ /a?3 //cttvatziS '- ::bdA1- ~ (h 7~ o ,- - - Slgnature ) 1vU;C &:;! j)~ - . r- i i ! \ Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Moruca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th from Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopardize the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- aal dIstrict, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. SIgnature , tf"J /L!L7f3{..[<< ,c,Q l.ld~'I/r,LZ~ if ~-r-r -~~~.-- (1---- c~~_ Address 3? c S. ;4N(TA iFv. ~ 1/ If. ~~J -rL./ ~ , MJ/YI~.7.'f:Yr: . ,- - '--j - - J ~ 2~J t07"Zz;,.-,~ L.A f20 i.J,4 Q/a;691 . . ' L-./9- 7c~~y . . r- Montana Avenue Merchants Committee 1018 Montana Avenue Santa Momca, CA 90403 (213) 393-2867 Although we, the undersigned patrons and neighbors of Montana Avenue businesses, understand the parking problems of the district's residential neighbors, we feel the crea- tion of one-hour preferential parking zones on the streets of 15th, 16th, and 17th hom Montana Avenue to Alta would jeopartii7.e the viability of the Montana Avenue commer- cial dlstnct, and do hereby declare our opposition to such zones until a comprehensive plan for the entire neighborhood can be developed. I Signature r .. ~ Address 'JI~~,~,~~'1 f 1Je~iR/l Lj;JS ~/) -ft1.s~ \:~~>~ ~ , U (10) rr,ti.5} r '1');, 4:~ t~ fCL" 1,/ ,1 , , J PI __ , ) c/J . / '1 .I . - '.;v~~f :!?r /'/tn-c,~ o<ne Q ;, dt-t c::L~ Ll1 i~_ Z (( tL-... ~)v' I >:h.;~) ~fiJ{-l/ .21~:+1~. II + ~ 'ST p4J(/i,.' l..l.-k~v\ 1 -,::J C.cPC(l/\ \h.r k -tL:~~;1;,))G~ (; F/(L i) D; ~ { l,/ ,e U L bF K :c G~ E- fllv\ :s-t- ... 9 ...~ US SUPRE:\IE COUR....-PORTS . l/-C , 54 L Ed 2d - ~ t-1/1-co3 -01 [434 US 5] COV~"TY 30ARD OF ARLL-"';GTO~ COl~::-'"":'Y, VIRGDiL-\, et al. PetltIoners. v RUDOLPH A RICHARDS et al. -~ 434 VS 5, 54 L Ed 2d .,l, 98 S Ct 24, reh den 434 1:S 976, 54 L Ed 2d 468. 98 S Ct 535 p..;o 76-1418] --. . . > DecIded October 11, 1977. SL":'.OlARY To ste~ the =ow of commute:" traffic from commerCIal and mdus:;:"lal dlStnc+..s mto ad~olnIng reSIdentIal ne!ghborhoocis. and to r~duce au' poUu. tion a:lC other e","""onmpy,t.91 F'lrects of automc{nle commutlRl{, Arml~ C,?Unt;r Vlr!:?;lIl,la. adopted a zomr.g orcimance w=...!.ch provides for the LSSU- ance or parkl11g' :-:P~:n..lts to resIdents of deslgnat~ resIdentIal areas and to certam other pe:-sons, and wluch p'rohlblrs the ?arkmg of an auromoblle \\-"1thout a Der:n:: in the desl!P1ated areas betw~:l ~ a.:n an~;; m. c;i weeKcays Lomr.-_-':':ers Who haa regr.uany pan-tee :..., one of the cieslgna~ed resIaent.al areas '::ied SUIt In the Circwt COUrt of _..1....rhngton COUnty, seek.lng to enJou:. enforce=.ent of the ordInance on state a1ld federal constltutonal grounds. The Cir:mt CoUrt encered Judgment for the plamtlJfs, and the Supreme COUrt or VlI'ginia affirmed. holding that :"~e ordmance vIolated the equal prOCectIon clause of the Fourteenth Ame:::ciment (217 Va 645, 231 SE2d 231). - -:;--...~~-~~ ':' -~~~------=--- ..- ----- -- ----=- _i . ~ ..:. - , ~ Grantmg certIO!"arl, the Umted. States Suprerr:.e Court vacated the VIr- ginIa Supreme Ccun's judgment and remanded i:':'-:e case In a per C:..l::am opmion expressu:.g the VIew of Bt.:RGER, Ch. J, a..,d BRENN'A:-r, STE'''''ART. WHITE, BUCK:M:L"X. POWELL, RElDI'Qt:IST, and 5TE:\.~5, JJ , It was held that the ordma.'lce did =.ot, on Its face, Vlolate the eaual n["otectIon guarantee of ~e l' our:eenth ."\..=:J.endmem even 'though the orc..:.nance' Clscnmmateri i:le- tween resIoents a::a nonreSlaentS or the oeSl . ate-:::. reslaentlal areas, SInce the ConStltUtlOn ne:c. er OUt awea the SOC~a1 ana er:, a-cn...entaJ. oOJec~;. ,es or t. e orc.mance "lor ::resumea i: at QlS~ .:> =.. _ no non!"eSi- dents of a local ne~noornooa were InVlClOUS ana :::.rce the equal rotect.on clause requlrea o:::""'Y t e C1lStlnctlOn drawn oy such an ordmance ratlonally promote :he regulatIon's obJectIVes. =--~ -~ ... ~ }1AltSHAU., J , would have granted the petltIOn :cr certioran and set the case for oral arguz::ent. --- Bnefs of CounseL p 831, mfra. 4 - .at-- .,,?-,/ ~ ,- ~~ , ~ - . c "::~ ; , ,,' . - .: , c i '. 4, . ._ .0.; .6 . . - ~ ....,.., };II"~ ~ 31 98 1al Iu- on 11- to lie on ~d .,cr ~ ,,1 "'le "'e ..... .. ~: .~- ,r. m '. "1: of e of ,- '~! ~ \- aa:sstfied t~ Supreme Court Dlge5t. Lawyers' Ed1t1on consutunonal Law ~ ~onmg 9 1 those dlstnct.s-does not. rAts face. )_ equal protection _ parkIng violate the equiI protectlon ~tee of restncnon the Fourteenth Amendment even though A county zomng ordmance whlcb pro- the ordmance discruninates between res- }ublts the parkmg of automobiles Wlth- Idents and nonresidents of the restncted out a peI'tlllt In restncted ~ldenual distr:.~.s: to reduce an' pollunon and areas between 8 a.m. and :) p.rn on other enVlIOnmental effectS oi automo- wee~days--the ordinance proVIdmg for. bue commutIng. a commWUty reason- the ISSuance of pemllts to resIdents ot ably ::nay restrict on-street parkIng ava1l- the restnc:~ areas and to certaUl other abl~ to commuters. thus encoura.gulg re- p~ISOns. ana. the ordmance havmg been bance on car pools and mass tnUlSlt, and actopted to 'litem the flow of commuter. ty also d d that . a co."munl may eel e ra. traffic from commerCIal ana. mQustnal - - dJstncts mto adjouung residential nelgh- ~tnc-=:.ons . on the flow o! outside traffic ::_ borhoods. so as to (l) reduce hazardous mto parncular resIdentIal areas would _ ~ -X- t.r.dnc_ cqI1~lt1onsln trte resldentlai dlS- enhance the quahty of Me there b! re- wcts. t2l Drotect those Ulsr.nCtS froL~ duc:ng noISe, traffic hazards, and litter. .pnI1,,;:;'; ~,:-""xcesslve nOISe. and 1.r3S.n the ~nstituuon neither outlaws such and refuse caused bv the entrY oi co...- SOC'..a.L and enVIronmental ObjectIves nor ~r vemcies r3l ;rotect the. reslQl:;;:ts pre:.-umes that distmctlons between resi- ~ ' ~1' =-=-- d d d f 1 al . of t.lt~e alStrlc+..s from unreasona...~e bur- ects an ncnresl ents 0 a.OC nelgn- dens 1Il galIung access to thelr resl- bor:"ood are IDVIWOUS. the equal prote<:- dences. and (4) )!reserve. the character of tIon clause reqUlnng only that the dis- those distr..cts ai resldenual dlstricf.Sind tmctlon drawn by the ordUlance ratlon- jireser7e-tb'e-" 'ValUe -of the propertY In ally promote the regulatIon's aDJectIVes. ~..... ~ --- i...~-- j, ".. " .~ TOTAL CUE:'-IT.sERVICE LIBRARY!) REFER&~CES 7 Am Jur 2d, Automobues and F.:gnway Traffic ~ 232; 82 Am Jur 2d. Zoning and Plannmg ~9 108. 118 8 Am Jur Proof of Facts 2d 53. t:'nreasonabieness of Zomng RestnCtlon 16 Am Jur Tnals 99, Relief from Zoning Ordmance uSCS, Constitution, 14th Amend:nent US L Ed Digest, Constltutlonal Law ~ 335, Zonmg ~ 1 ALR Digests. Consbtutlonal Law ~ 288; Zonmg ~ 18 L Ed Index to Annas. Equal p~teCtIon of the Laws; )dotor Vehicles and Carners; Zonmg ALR Quick Index, Automoblles and Traffic; Equal ProtectJ.on of Law; Zoning Federal QUlck Inde~ Equal Protection of the Laws; Parking; Zonmg 5 ~ A.&."{NOTATION R:EFER.L"'iCES Supreme Court's Vlews as ~ consutuc.Ci~t1 of re91denc.al zol1Ulg restnCtlons. 52 L Ed 2d 863 Valicbty of :egulatlon proVldmg for re5er"i'ed parlung spaces or parlung pnonty on publiCly owned property for members oi a desJgtlllted group. iO ALR3d 1323. ~ . .. SYLLABt"S BY REPORTER OF DEAJNS Arhn~ounty. Va.. :;:onmg ordi. and rationJll!llll'promotes the onim:mce"" nance proiubltmg automobue commuters stated leglt-:.mate ObJec~I'i'es of reduc~ng from parlcng m desJ.gnateci resIdennal aIr pollunon and othe!' adverse conse- nel~hborhoods _ and proVIdmg fo: free quences of automobile commUtlllg, and par~ng permIts for resIdents or sue;). of ennancmg the quahty of life 10 rest- nelgnborhoods held not to Vlolate the . , E al P C' . th F dentlal areas such as by reaUC~"lg nOise qu rotectlOn ,au..-=e or e our- teenth Amendment_ The dlstmCtlon and traffic h",?~rds drawn between. reSIdents and nonresI- C.er'"..loran granted: 2~';" Va 645. 231 dents of a neighborhood IS not mVIdious SE2d 231. vacated and remanded Bnefs of Counsel. p 83~, infra OPL"UON OF THE COURT large commercial and office complex Commuters who worked In tlus com. plex and had regularly parked In the area sued In the Circ:.1lt Court of Arlington County to enJom the en- forcement of the ordmance on state and federal constltutlOnal grounds The Virglnla Supreme Court. ultI- mately held that the ordmance VIO- lated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.z As stated m lts preamble, the Ar- lmg1:on ordinanc~ 15 mtended ttt2..Leduce hazardous traffic condl. tions resulting trom tne use 01 streets-witr.in areas zoned for reSl- dent1al uses for the parkmg of velucles by persons usmg d1stncts zoned for commercial or md ustnal uses. .; to protect those dis- ~i tncts from pglluted air, excessIve 1. noise. and trasn and reruse causea '{' _f!Y tlle enr;r:" 01 ~u.\,;h vemCles. to f protect the residentS ot those d15. ! tncts tTom '.lnreasonaole ouraens i_in j;!'amm'l' access to thell" rest-- Actlng under the ordmance, the 1 d!n~es; to preserve the character- County Manager designated a re- 1_ ot those disu;cts as ~p<anp.,r'"" .,.,,_ stncted area in Aurora Highlands. a tnctS; to Ol"omatp. efficl~ncv In tnp resldentIal neighborhood near~. gtamtenance ar those streets m a . 1. T1us condmon IS met wb.en "the average SPBCell on such streets on the weekdays of any number of velucle:s [operated by persoll5 month .. whose destl.natlon IS a commef'Clal or md 2. Although the state mal court found the tna1 chstnct] IS lU excess of 25% of the n onhnance lJlval1d under the State and Fed- her of parlung spaces on such streets and eral Constltuuona, the State Supreoe CoUl": total number of spaces ac::'.aily OCCUpied rested Its dectSlon solely on the Equal P-otec- any vehtde:s ncftda i5<"o of the numbe bon Cla~ of the Fourteenth Amendment --jjjj --' --- ~ -- - ~ -- -- - --- -- - ~ Per Curiam. =-~ The motion of D C_ Federation of CiVlC Assoclations et al. for leave to file a bnef as amICI C"..lnae and the petItion for a Writ of CertIoran are granted To stem the flow of traffic from commercIal and mdustnal distrICts into adJ01mng reSidential neIghbor- hoods, ArImgton COUnty, Va__ adopted zoning ordinance ~ 29D The ordmance directs the County :\<Ian- ager to determme those reSIdential areas especially crowded WIth parked cars from outsIde the neIgh- borhood.1 Free parking permIts are then issued to residents of the deSIg- nated areas for thell" own velucles. to persons domg buslOess With reSI- dents there, and to some VLSltors. To [434 US 6J park an automoblle WIthout a per- nut 10 a restncted area between 8 a_m. and 5 p.m. on weekdays is a mISdemeanor. -- =--= ~ --= -=! -- - -====- :!!!!! -~ - - - - 6 - I - ~A(--4{, dinar..~ 'S redUClng ~e COnse- lfig, and in testa n~ no1Se ;45. 231 'iand'!d. :'mplex. li~ corn- : In the ~Urt of ~, me en- ::! state rou.nds. j; ultl- I <:'~ Vlo- "lUse of he Ar- condi- use of -'i" resl- ir'!g of [;;LUcts LLc::tnal ;; dis- =-~'lve :aused 'es; to :;e dis- , .dens resl. racter ",I dis- in the .ina Orany ..~ the ~ Fed. Coul"t Prtlrec. ---!~ [434 US 71 regulatton'sl stated objec- tives." and. therefore, that "the ot'di- nance on lts face offends the equal protectlOn g'..1aI'antee of the 14th Amendme:lc." 217 Va 645, 651. 231 SE2d 231,235. We disagree. /I To reduce aJr pollutl!>n, and other enVlronmp!".::l.1 ptt~P("t<:; oi !l1nnTl"l'!nllp' - commutmg, a commulllty reasonably may restTlct on-street parkmg aVllll- abl~ to commuters. thus encouragmg reliance on car pools and mass tran- sit. The same goal is served by assur- mlr convement parking to reSIdentS who leave tneli'-cars at home dunng the day A commllIUty may also de- cide that restrictions on the flow of outside traffic mto particular resi- 3. :test't1ctlons 1111 nonresIdent parbn!! have Sparked COD.Slderable lit1gaaon. See. e g . South Termmal Corp v EP A. 504 F2d 546. 671~6 (CAl 1974) (rntnCtlons upheld). Fnellds of the Earth v EPA. 499 F"..d 1118. 1125 \CA2 1914) (restnct1ons upheld>; Com- monwealth v Plm'alia. -)!us -. 362 NE2d 513 (1917) (restnctlOnll upheld); State v WlusJJl8.Q. 24 Olno Mise 59, 263 ~ 411 (Ct Com Pleas. 19701 (restnctlona mvalidated), dentlal enhance the aualitv bv reauCl nOISe, tradic and l1tter. By --deduUuli. ~..I",Jn.a~lon agaJ...&c nonresIdents would inhere in such restncbons.' The Constitution does not outlaw these social and envu-onmf!ntal oh- jectlves, nor does it presume distinc- tions between residents and nonresi. dents of a local neighborhood to be in VlW.OUS. The Equal Protection Clause requires only that the distinc- non drawn by an ordinance like Ar- lmgton's ratiQnAlly promote the reg- ulatIon's obJect1ves. See New Orlea ans v Dukes. 427 US 297, 303, 4-9 L Ed 2d 511. 96 S Ct 2513 (1976); Village of Belle Terre v Boraas, 4-16 uS 1. 8, 39 L Ed 2d 797, 94- S Ct 1536 (1974). On its face. the Arlmg- ton ordinance meets this test. {434 US 8] Accordingly. the judgment is va- cated, and the case 15 remanded for further proceedings not inconsistent Wlth this opInion. It is so ordered. ~r Justice Marshall would grant the paneloD for certiorari and set the case for oral argument. t I' ,'. j Georgetown. .,l"!". of Buaml!5llttlen v Ihstnct of Calwnot&. Civ No. 7242-':'6 {DC Super Ct, AWl 9. 1976) (resm.ctl0lUl pnolim1nanly en- Jomed)' The UZ11ted Sl:ates as amICUS cunae D~ that parkmg 1'eStnctlODS to cfiscourage automobLie commutmg have been recom- mended by the EnYU"Oll.l:1ental Procect:Jon Agency to unplement the Clean Au' Amend- mel1t1 of 1910. See 38 Fed. Reg 30629 (1973) 7 ~ - . .--:-- - -: --". - - - _ u__ -- - . /'.~..~ . . J 1- c we, ~he u~d0rslg~ed reslde~ts oE 13th ,~ +- . ~ St.reet, agree thaL^. the:: ilrsL o~ock, two hour _oar~lnc~ LS. ~O~ , ~ _.L _ C~Icrced and does ~O~ 'v,TO r ,0{ _ Prlnt Dd'l'2 add~ess \,} lL-li ,\-..,\ ,3 - GdtP! ~Lf) "l.l, (.J . lr fl., S !:; - t, S,f,t!01 Jl,TJ1CA c4 I ' slg::cature tf/dqu",- 13 ~+~ ,11 r- ----_I. .1 r _I...--t""".. 1-"/" 'L.ir)- ~1 r../}, J I....... -, _ ;.....v I -7. l /" /_~...A ~I-r ~ /~ ,J(t,: rl--'~' - / - . \\ S-t\-I,,(ii'- i'v QN1cA _ (/1 ~v\~p----l , j- .......---'-- f'at...1~ . ~ n ~-- .---::;} _) I-~, ~ I I r-"- or l,i J'" . r' .- ~...... (./ _ -: l.d ~.J..,.J ~ .~' \ " . t .). ., /; f'", - ,- ..iJ{"'"j G \ ,........ F-",,_____ -l~l - i S li~ ~~( ,. I i ~JO C~v~v.\ \ \ . .- i / --. . -(F" 'i'l \.:jf / rf~-..J~i____~'~ ~ ~J r~ \l } ~I ~ I -- If,;oL ;1- __J <"":.,! ! ., (, . .J- ;--. u/<,E -'J f: ; __'1 r 1':):'" ',- ~7"":.1 C c/-.. -, ''" .4 ,-, .}- '" r -......,.-, r~'.i\,'_ < /-, I J"L r~_ ~ i -,.' ~ u: ~r"I.-\..'-..-l; ~ r .~. ~t-:', . / Yt' ,- , L, '-'-t_,,"JJ ... rf" _ .....'l.-~_/t...'I..... ,f./!,'/_ /,! -->] <(--r, ,;1,/.,_'- /.,"" /,'/,1 !c:..Il." \-~. \'-'AA'/.. 11-1. .,,' t-l 71'7A_'JA.'~/h.;/~~/) , ., ~ ~ _ ~ , -1 - ~ " I -....J/~.J--<-'_I"IU'i, t.l- t..-. //:-V-/-?71-r--~ d--/-' )' i-,' // ;-;/ ~ ;; /7 ' ~ --F ' -. -- / 7J"T ~ . ,/t- ~ r/ /J;)', /Uc~ tLe~ tL,eL--c7-r:2lP./L; /ZJ J/ /_97&- s T ~~ / /)!fYYue.L~ ./''/} 'U2~ ,~"'-- d-r1.vJ _~ I-v.i f+r:-,A Jo?:J! ~ 'II\-- ...s -I _S Cvvv fw J..-1 OVvU.o.- //(L" - (~ ~7y..rl , '~;;f~~/) . ' />->"" --'( "n' /f -/J../" . /- '} (; 7() -7 /. ,~-t-A r:i 0::: "'~ / , /~),- C-t:- o'.c-...-//.:..~.rl,,-I /'/ ..--i--" '--" 0,-' '---he....Y ....J ~ ~ //T I A 1// ......... D ~{~, I / / {I eA e",feJL 5N ojF,-t<'-5!<-i- 7/;z. - /S-74. S r ,5 // 'e<1L 7'0%,< . .l~t-.~ set S:-~:...t\.-t;,--, lV\Cl Iv..C..;,~ ~ ~ '1 CJ4<LL ~ .........0.""'\ -.... \000 <...J CL<~2J ~e;.L ~Q 1 \ I ~ : s:....~,'\.J::~ iv( tlJ.-A..C__A G~ S Ccv<.,/ (" ,l 47 0 f,' . I -- 1+ c--_ r l'-.'.<:: \- c...... \C ~'--j r.>;,,-_ ,~'J.,,;) \ i ~-c ~ ~'(<.. l """ C e-~; "'- ~\< <-~ tt ~t ~ k..u"" i I v';:-, -c~, Lw.... 51 rZC T l. C:: f': t~J..Jj ~\~::. b( '-,....-Me:. . . \. J I L~ LXL"'~S~~J ~0~= 'Q '~C_hU:' 11\<.:: \:.L, kJ f(~ \.:~ tZ~t;~C:c..... ~\J'~ b($:+." i~""t.~ €~~,~_''--~~ ~ CJ..... 0.... ~ u..--f.,.\ b w tJ{. C' ( .L. L~ L~:~ ~ '0 (\ 'J<- ...... <=j k~ bf...'-...... b(I,j~lc.~ b, ~,c.\...,\ '::,~ f..~JZ: --Cn'-l~.(1 ~ k.c ~{~ ~~ ~ l..~ c- ~ N- 0:: r~~_A.P~ J'--S~-T\ li.. <.. . ~ ~ J.iY<.'~ n<::. ~~\rUl>^ ~G lli ("{.--'S ~~c~--r y~":\u...'j f<-!M..J , r'" , floJ... \""L." r~ \C{.,Lj c.;, t ,^,.;.;r~-^" k...g -s CJ1 JU: t- .fi\(t;\~ bJ J l--\<'-<1'__~l.i--;{J),1 <:- '-""t.'-'~-te~r 'A-s l1- ~t rf] U'~ f C( 4;.-r fC; b--J . f\,L ~ we' k~'11 ~ u.~ ~J~ \tJ 1t~ \o_llG~j rt-s~C-~1t.~ o-f~~ c.\.L, <--r-.~-o~ r:..f.... ~t:'~r ct~^i ~ ~~ i T ~t 1l,j-,t 1'" .1o~\ ('Il~ ~ r.:- cl4~ tt.. --, "-l-t .;-'" l-- 1- V \ - I .....-., 'fc;<'; k ~ ex~ ') I..-t.... c:;' f'~A_ I.. l;J f'< -I (('4 b ~ ~~ L(,(..(,.( y<..('l\A-\.t" o^,l~ . ~~....~.......':\ <r':;p\.-A ('(...-.rc l-; f \ C7 A ,. ~ \. Q k"$ '() - "'. \ - I\.-~ \. uf.." t~ \ / ~ '--- I . .0{ . . ' I 1-'1;)- / 9/.i I -. I Ie f __/ ~ Lj~ ~ ".I ~)_ ',. /" yet ~_l:( y} '~~ t.--:L _' v / L-tf {f / r" * ,] "'" A ~('j7(...t..</~ ".._, _..L""\"'")- - - - "] - - - / I/('---,{] '~", /,1 f! A , -+.-,~ , __ -T ~_ ..... ... ~ ---...K.....I..L-L-"....A..~-t -";.r ~~~---:' I , ~ :. i; , ~ -" 1;- -......, -~ - i r '-- 'I->L) -( L "i___ _"--'......- :-/'~_"'-_ _ <-~ __jL') .. __~ _~~_ {~~~~~~~ 6_ _ --L -7~ -';" -" o-',-{ ;': r; .-L.' n(r\ f' Jtfzj- u..~(LlJ1-<;rf.. (- k - - J f J -'up . / - :...'>...--'- -: - '-lJ-- t'" I~ .,...... ~~f.~-I Vd r (")-Ll -' - - ~~---I~~:~~~ ~g~ __ , . , I. . ~\ \ ? / ~-..._\t -(_nL - L ;, '---I-:.. ,...." t.' .'\ J... ...Ji:.:..~//".;j-"''''''.l tJ \ l/- /"...~ _L - - -- --,. 1'--ld-_1 Ie fy Sf -, ~]/. /-' ~ - ,/. ~. /, /. ' // ..I ..fiJ/- ,r_~ /'1/. . " 'v=- ff~ T L- /"~a" " r:D u::U-4' 7//,(/ ~"b.C: 57" F -g- ~'t /.J_ / ~-*Ut,u/ /'1~-uC'~{ c~- ~ ~ _~ ~:.1- - \~~/C1C--L:-~~4L--' ' _ /-~ldHL:';.,.4-;7 )id ~;,.- .-Z--'U~ ,_ -' k"f' -f"/ h'- ' -;/ t:;;1~-S--C-':'-.4-~ /' ~ //l:-/d/' ./~ C9-<<?Lj ..__r ~..., L _/'_" / ':.t;:tL4'd~--/~Przr.t;cf-.H~~t1 tt-Z-2j~ I // ~/ // ( ~ // .----/ ,:. _' --4- L./ t.' (_'_ Yi c-,.....~' _.j.~.,~~ /'/ALL cJ--it/&-k.-P-5~.;d'-;#'t:. ,!~~ /17::7 -<-L;' ftffl.c<':,~~ _.t'~~~ ?J~ ... / r;;::r _.~//' -J L L~L.-J--d/ ~/~d~-/~ /7- " 7n.~./4Y:!~4!j ~4 F '" . William B. Gurfield Joan Gurfield 707 15th &:.red &nta Mom:::a, CA 90402 . .January 22,1990 To: Santa 110mca City Council Re: Parking on 15th Street Gentlemen: The current parking regulations for the first part of 15th Street nort.h of Montana Avenue allow two hour parking with the exception of those cars which display resident permits. I have lived in my house on this street for the last thirteen years, and have had a resident parkmg permit since the mception of the program. Over the past few years I have watched the parkIng situatlon on my block and the other blocks Immediately north of ~1ontana deteriorate disastrously. It used to be that I had to contend \'...1th congestIon from shoppers at Fireside ~1:arket. Twice a year, at Thanksgiving and Christmas, there would be a rush of cars parked in front of my house) occasionally blocking my driveway. That was tolerable. However, with the burgeoning of Montana Avenue as a shopping center, these crowded conditions occur almost every weekend. I often have great dIfficulty entenng my driveway becau~e of the cars parked too close to both sides of the entrance. The two hour limIt has been virtually not enforced. There have been many times when friends have inadvertently parked in front of my house without a permit and have received no ticket. In fact, this occurs more times than not, The two hour limit except WIth resident permit has been tried for three years now and is a dismal failure. It is tIme to chan?,e the restriction to no oarkIne- at all exce-ot WIth resident nermit. - - - - Yours sIncerely, f,udl~ t~~ \NIlham B. Gurfield ~ './ (""'-::J -:lA . / ~~ rfv 7 c. J I ...:) . ,! l-1 (,~ -. ~..i~ j ...... fl / nh1./ t!~ ..S Iy II I- ~. ) <- ') t!.~ ilL, .I. .r/ ;.... i (, 1A.- (..-( <t ," .1 . h' . " L-- . '- q ~:' 4. _ ) --.J 1 --- - /\{ -t-.- ' _" '--' ""l -.5~, )~-S 5 i(.-L C/; P c-r i~"l" .f / i :. 0 ....'i-4:1(<J 1 .- ht..-CL 1... ,I , t~. '--- I <.. 'r (~-..c ) (!.-, .... .'{ f!Lt<i (.--r, ..<_, "\.. """...."i,...... !o k '/ I~..,:v'v {'~1f / ....~-_....- ;';/1. ...1 a t,..A------t.....';,. L- (/-<J Ud ("Ii " ~ ""-f ! t-Cu.-o r '" f""/ L-f ----7-01 {~ .. (.. ...- 1i 1"<.---( I J ! - I..' lirt{'" ! !} (.ei- j' 5- i. JL.{.,....~il ! - - .J ".. i -2 / 1~d10-- '- i, j L 1..A 'I -.. ,1..,,,-,- /.1/1.--[(/ l{_v~--v-~l i ~ f0 .. I, vVl.-L-c? 'l-{ i.{")' lv1,~( /; . l....r t<.d I " t &t-<.;h' c7 (U-c n'M... 'JF"1.,.....". /- , ; j , Y-L. t--1..rl.-y ".... -.J"~ // t~f---'" t-1f i I j . tj 'l-;;Yl--:~L _._...... _..."i I t! (t",'-{, I \..J ,,,T j,. ...... D(~ (/:..(:-d ! (,/. (. r- ~- v vl/[.' - \.-. .I' /"-,, , rj ", / \" 1Le:--~~ b,' if ( ", ~-' /;4 if- Ii.... /' t.'IL1..fi _t:./1." v M ,/ ,I ~ j ,J ___- po: "'//f' - f ~--1 ~'-A~) v",--" tv....; h.,-y- (,.{.-'I--"--t} ,/1 . I '''~j ......J" ~ Y-{--V'"' , < A ?h ' ;/ ( /,.-v-{(/y!:.\.....r i 5h~ -' ..,., ') 11:; , , ~_J , "7L i\. ./ riA.. f (f51L"t' OL-,"'L--Cz{:;:1 . j / ) . J ,--- ~ / ,f.r,;""Vt-- C J ," -r {i..-'vHA/l.. i+J1J _J ~ , Y' --}~ ()/ ; - _ I~ '" rt-'f;. l A-< k ty r!/"t/'- l.- - -_..... ~ ....... .Z---c:-~-......t...~~ _i/';l iJ 1-0 . . ~ v/') f /J~! 0/- /J!t:-:? ~44X~F.l-'-dZ~d-- // (/ cf' ;/1 ~ /5~4 Muf~ x~.di }~-#:.u/ ~-LV tt ,9&,--dh-~-~ ,-/~U~J/ J'~//ldA:~~' .J::6~ ~~ c!' -U..:'/Z/ ---.-/~~~ . ....I-- " ./ A -JI-- - . --.L /J .,t.- . t/ C;7 ~~ /-J4~ ----e~A/~ uL ,7-x...-- /,57-...... ~ ~ .J?t .,.,L-V ~;?;Nt!cf!'k..~ _..-.-- ----------- /.~~. ~~~-.k- ~/;C ~ 0~/ ..24~ dtu-/ ~ 1-' _ / t/ . f-' /71~ ~~- 4 fi2h-C-" ;??..i -P---~ ..au /UUY ~~ 4<Y~ ~ ~/ .r ~!4Y.;:d-- fi ~~~/ .L~ d- 6/ I /~ {, i' / r ,{/- / ...QU/'_/ ~____. ~~____ ?0"~ ~~-1'-~?';F ~~/ ~~~ ~ L//: /,1 /.- / ~ . {/ -;:d' - ...../p~.i! -M' .A';b'u-" ~- ./'.fr_-?A/ ~-r/~dL-t.d..(~ ..L40" ~~. 1/' L:/ (/ -",,1.' ~ ~.I_' ....-F ',Y-~f-/ .. 7Jc~/) ~.~.. ' /l... c::7 1/ J' . /!T~.L .dT- ~ ft(,x~, ii. Y~9/(7 z~ - . Chet . Smolargki 7/..2 - ,/.5 ~ ,Lot- J - r:d- r>- ->~ z..- )-r ; // ' L--ftn--;1,..-C-("...IJ/ /3 /' L_ A!.--& ? 0 1-/0 .:<. 0/,-tL [--,,'.lU :i ^UL~,-,_::L:~.e> .L-.J' ~~'-1 _'I -J - ~# / /J I' /' -L ~~L -Ckj (; .__.-:'....~__ .r; _~ _........._~__~j~)...-----t-Q ~ ~ --.' r .;I ':' , .' '-^-" - ';-I.::~,,- I (; I fa -1- Ji// Ii.-/. I {:t2.f}./L---I;,z./--.~~7 ...--<' _ (A--~ /t.. ~ ;-2---,--'-/./);- ,J--t!. JL--' _ /, / l " r! (J f~- ') _L . f ' f, ~ ~ ---:?-e- o-jU~~ //~..c) /<--<--4--) _~..-c lL.,r->~ ..., f I (, L~.,<j(, y)~"-~) 1 11 .- 1 - U ~nJ ;::..f~.:tj~ /..t~ uA ;JL.f-"'Uo...,./ I /)/- ./,j fr- .- ;7---t:~:t;'--,A- Q_' {L,~.'L-- /-.;~ L-- ~ '----....- C'.....--- ..... '-" /- r. t7 /J f1 I ---fJ--' ~ /' t; ,r' / ~.~__,> ,___~ --LA;.[.-&----Y-Y'J JL--' /f!--. ~,_/L '1-.-t'''d (' t.zJ.----- - ~L --r; L/. ') // ~;..-- r'L-Y -W::.J {i n ,I j " -. ~ '--f:.----<~ J / /VI-.......-'<- " .-, -I :, /j~---e.. i -I-- /1..~:"~V"-L ~ ,./L~' , f..... ___i'J ""l- ./'..., 1'0 ff l . /~ --............. v. L-~ ~ ,/ t.. (!~C L ~tk t1j/Y_ ~~ I'~- C--L/ C..Q. _~ -,' --.- . --+- J'i / r.:', ,~ ,--___...--"F ---c::...... .....--. /v~ ~r...! ("" - - ~ . - A~. ~ 3-./) ( SEP 1 1 1990 /VI' OfJ/J;/O 01';( . September 6, 1990 Santa Momca City Councll Members RE: Santa Momca's PreferentIal Parkmg Zone S on 16th and 17th streets Dear CouncIl Members: We, as residents of 16th and 17th streets, are mterested m restonng a sense of commumty to our neIghborhoods. Montana avenue IS becommg a fast paced gallena shoppmg area, As a result, our neIghborhoods have become parkIng lots for these merchant's employees and customers. ThIS IS not what Montana Ave. was designed to be. As you know, It is supposed to be a neighborhood commercial dIstnct and that fits well mto a resIdentIal enVIronment. Today the reSIdentIal and the commerCIal dlstnct are not very compatIble. As reSIdents, our mam concern is for the safety of our chIldren All these stores and the attendant traffic congestion create an enormous hazard for the youngsters of thIS neIghborhood. Several automobIle aCCIdents mvolvmg chIldren have occurred. One of them involved a chIld who ran out from behmd a parked car. The street was so packed With cars that the dnver, a woman on 15th street, could not see thIS chIld t S approach Despite several months of rehabIl1tatlon at Chlldren 's HospItal, thIS young boy suffers Irreparable bram damage and wlll be handIcapped for hfe. ThIS tragedy IS lOdIcatlve of the senousness of the traffic condltlons on 16th and 17th streets. Our streets, 16th and 17th, are the only streets north of Montana that have retaIl stores that intrude mto the reSIdentIal area. These are also streets where the buildmgs are older and proVIde madequate customer parking. Furthermore, these streets are Impacted by havmg three restaurants, 17th Street Cafe, Cafe Montana, and OggI'S, wIthm this area. The staff of the Santa MOllIca Parkmg DIVISIOn has recommended one hour permIt parkmg. Ron FuchIWala has stated that one hour IS the fIDr compromIse. We are wIllmg to compromise, but the problem WIth one hour and the reason we campaIgn for full permIt parkIng IS that, m checkmg WIth Santa MOllIca parkmg Enforcement on several occaSIOns, they mformed us that m a two hour parkIng zone you can expect an Enforcement Officer to tIcket once a day. WIth one hour parkIng, Enforcement tnes to ticket two times a day Hence, two hour permIt parkIng becomes four hour parkIng, and one hour permIt parkIng becomes three hour parkIng. 1'j-1J4 +~ a-I) SEP 1 1 1990 . . The employees, also aware of the one-time-a-day parkmg enforcement, take advantage of thIS. They park for the entue day movmg theIr cars once to aVOId tlcketmg rendenng the enforcement policy IneffectIve. We have also enclosed sIgnatures from 15th street reSIdents saYIng that two hour parkmg IS not enforced and does not work We want to be fan. We want to share these streets with the customers of these stores, yet our children r s safety takes pnonty One hour IS the only fau compromIse Thank you very much for your tIme. tP ("; &~ ~~ r;:/ 4- ~) v / Sincerely, Q~t~~~ ~~. ChnstIne Brown Susan & Norman Levme Orson Moses MackenZIe Waggaman Laura & DaVId Young Lou Plachowsla. For the reSIdents of 16th and 17th streets ~.~~ ~ ) . . . . i.-ie +--~e "no' r . -~ " , -_.. .... e Slgr,ec: ~~'=-~:'UcrL~ cf ~ ,;--c, ;: l r <:: t- b i 0'--' I, t - - .:... ~ - ~...... .", , '!rO, c.--. r-;... '\ U r p a :: ':;: 1 ~-.. --3 :... S :5 c -=.:- ~~~c:r"o( . :::r,,-et, agr,,'E' '--- .- ~ '- \ r c ~"'- (1 0.:-' (~ I'V ~L._+ t}-, _~. ;:.. .. ^ ..e -~C2 5 '1 at ?r l -:. ~ r>J.:~e adcires.3 ,,_ /: r.. Sl .f J' . 5.1;:"1)1 J!ii"'i~/l (.d: I . Slc.;nat:'1.ce III /; t1'-:./ L. ri" (,-t/...u...L-fc1<- p /j-"''/------- \,) 1 L-l ; r'ty,,\ " - Gd~ Pi .~-z...~j ~ - , .f,'-- _J' I ; _ I , . I..y.; 'L ... ~ _ "'~ i / i.........". ./ .. -v ' :;' ........i ~-..... i .' , / .. , f\.< (t;r .~-~ .. / -- I,i\ ,\ NoN\cii, ,c.p 'h-lv\.9->-I r _ . i .."""'- ,'..... _ :'t~i)~~"" . LtJ ~ thAi..) 0--lH.Jt-'.- '~ "'r \.. 0 ~{\'--- h \ .....J~ /'....~ "- --,.. \ ~---- ',,-, , Jo.lt - ;'~ ~-.. ~ ~ S,\-"1........r:'f\ r " .IO.:-.I,......,I'.} , - : ~. -~ i ; -: , l~'I'! i -j 'I; (- -, 1 l '.... ~ "..... J .:. 1 ~ :,- . ~............ ,. ~ 0. ,; /', { ",). -' -' .:.. ,..i l(",zi. ~J ~;? r 1-:' ( ), ---," , ( J.-'" Ie"'" !...r ~ ....~~i }. <:::"-. -<-. r" r"" .r G -.' It.,1\...'O I'.;......... ,. A... ':;,: ~ ,/ -_:/ X'f :'/;,; ~ '7,,' 'S n 57', S'cvLl~J}o" C^ ~ 1J~':Y)n~ /' /2d_ct'~ u. c2-c9-cZ:" E?c~; 7z; J/ /0 z1: _ ~ T ~~~ %1.r4ue..e- .I:~. r::ee Jh.v~vJ -~(-vu ~1 Jch I,ll. -.s+ -.Sevvvkv }.--1.01-vUtA-- d1 {- ~,~ I I "1 V~:I f _ - / f (,..- ....> 7.w/~~ -: c 70-7 /...j--+-n ~0f ~~/77-7?"7~~~tr/-c;t' ;: / ..::roa~---.. G-..' ,-(1c1J/ , / Ji., (i'4e5teR- 5'No)..lTl2sf{l.- 712-/":; Sr c5 ij e~L. 7'A ... . William B Curfield JOM Curfield (en 1Slh &red &nta Mar 1C3, CA 90402 . .J anuary 22, 1990 To' Santa ~loruca CIty CounCIl Re. Parlung on 15th Street Gentlemen: The current parking regulations for the first part of 15th Street north of Montana Avenue allow two hour parking WIth the exceptIOn of those cars which display resident permits. I have lived in my house on this street for the last tlurteen years, and have had a resident parking permit since the InceptIOn of the program Over the {last few years I have watched the parking sItuation on my block and the other blocks Immediately north of Montana deteriorate disastrously. It used to be that I had to contend with congestion from shoppers at Fir~slde Market. Twice a year, at Thanksgiving and Christmas, there would be a rush of cars parked 111 front of my house, occasionally blockmg my driveway. That was tolerable. However, WIth the burgeonmg of Montana Avenue as a shopping center, these crowded condItions occur almost every weekend. I often have great dIfficul ty entering my dnveway because of the cars parked too close to both SIdes of the entrance. The two hour lImit has been virtually not enforced. There have been many tlmes when friends have inadvertently parked in front of my house WIthout a permIt and have receIved no ticket. In fact, thi.5 occurs more times than not. The two hour limit excevt with resldent nermIt has been tried for three - - years now and IS a dismal faIlure. It is hme to chane-e the restri<,;tiQn to no narkine- at all exceot ~~"th resident nermit. - - - ... Yours sincerely, wa~ t~~ \Vllliam B. Gurfield . -t).l-ett:.. ~r, c-~:"l\".t:_ Iv..o fv..c).'.) CA 9CJ~ ...--'\"" """'''} IO~ r, <.J~:J oLd-1v~ I ' I ,,---, --:-- Sc- l--- ~ I --- 'r ( J 0 ~ ~...,- \ 0... pJ\. 'C '" '-- (.... (.....~.... t -J. ,_ C ...A_/ I" ~ -. J o ! I I <" I t ('"-~ r r (u, 'C '--"\..~ .-....... I:) '-<. .), ,~_( - Q.<<: C. . ,-r-" I --, - - I ;-L- t - k. --- . , · ~ - ~ r-- _ .. ~ --'\......................1"'......... ...d..bl, \~...."--::..I\..'-..J~ ~,(~_~ \:r~~ _. ('"or-..... lr'.!'"t.~ \ /1- ~- -.-~ Ii '- ..J.. \ \ "'-,~' \.l....\ <,. :-,', t-t..c \. "- ~<::. \' ~ 'I:.;" _^j 11~--:::. r:J' r 1..-M~.... . . , L....'-~ - w\....\ l,... i'v>, --~', f.-[.... I ; -- -\ r l -- ~ j . \..~ ~.J ~ I '-. ~ , '-, '\',<'.....:.-."'\ l,~,.......... '^--.~- , . (" v \ l I L., re- ~~ \'-."'S ",<".\ '-c..... ..\.....;.. t)C(: io-.. .T....... '"t. \1 t= l\..\,.' r...,-,-f. ~ c-...... CL "L--f.,..\.~{J d;: C(__CL~~~j\.1 ~ ~~(1..~___ IN~ "-OJ. b,->:+ ~;>lCJ<._t<...~ b, ~,u;.,.,;":,~Co-~c:;t ~rll.J"',,\ ~~ It.,(~ ~:: ~ l..~ Ck \V. ~,.:~ \_~~ ,l...~-t\.I.i...<' .:L '::..11 y<.(~~ u:.~ 2:..c(r-w." ~~ et<: -:---s -=-~<-^-t" fC...:' k~~ f(,' f\.4..X ,te1.A \l~ rG.... l,cu"j ~ r '^-<'~(~...... L~~ <--> r:~u tv:. ( Uv..\\ti.:~ bJ J }-\c.~-,,"~.-r~ bl ~ (L,u.e.....,l..l A.s "- ",,~tt Jij tr" \.<..<....x \.<":k~/U-\ "--,,,11k~, ~ u::~ ~~ \tJ!tee f~~1u-1 It-S~c-t:.~~ n..l~ cA.L\ (.-,\.~~ TA.. sr~r cJc~ ~C'..j5", I ~ ir..:t 'X 's c.6o~\ r~,-, t::' <_k"4" tt.. \,oi1c4 ~ \sCl SC~{- t:: f<~ \~ 6J ~~~'-~ f<.-fi\A-..t- O-A..Gj . \: ';cA<~~ I ~~~? ~~ (ht\'-l~? k"~'() , ~ " f ' .. L -~~V::J ~'1 rt -..; r '-" 7r' i "~i lz ( h~ 11 J I f l: 1. I..... ! ." _' "- J ') [~-.- (,,- 'l...- ., I ... I 1.-1"..-1.......(../..... , -, _ /-t cr 0" ). '\ ............,.. J f-...... Dc-"':-,. ( ,~ -'l,t ~ '\ /' .. ~ .' ,i. (.. (. I.. p :.'-r VV;.. l- I . : l) ,,-iA':'o<;....) {lUL-( , ( {-~"- /....-y ({ .~: I v , ~ I_.-Z -r lk:) Ct""-(C:~ fo 1 ../ f"" !.:... i v [UiAf ~J yU--C--!"'" (~ U6 tl.c..-(Iuv.-af:' . " Ii .! J ..j ./ - r ~ ') /r l1 f- f l<...-y /L ( Lr~{f I f jtf( .' . .L ~- \..01<-~ ~.....r L:~('" ) -J . f ' j vt.-v f. c7 iU-G-(....-p....... i .. P ('--'-Y ,d- "t"--r; / .............~ I ! {_ /" .} .; 1.1.A1", (r ,t-"_' , ' "' i J ........ _ .I ~rJ ( (t ,- S J.0-'k (UH1 ----J fo .fV,"'-{,.,t. ; .f I) ~ 1.-'1"<-, , J '---/ ,( v'v . .~. .} --Jl.--A _ . ....... T ( , -- .c. 1-.-/ f-~1.- (yvt-7L / V~J r~V( !,u:J f01 I.....~~) (; ~4Y tv-,.~~"-fi o ,,) i C- {..Vl,V1..t,..- , ,"- / { J,-C-'.A b.:'~ 11....- r ,A..-v (~1- ,----,- I --'- L- 1..::1 /,) v(. c:c..o) ''-i) , ) / -.... .. --- rl--S uf~ 10-- L-:J Ct:!r<A <<'.j l..t.v r'C I "It~ c~t: {<ft-.. ffiv(0T~ S~ ~ -J-f- 1-6-"\ , ------ (~i j " - -' /cr ty [. {Of:.fo . . '-:- . lm" //" / 1.1 I / ;> ~- / /[Lr.1 u...--4~.-ff ,/--- ...?<"-L ;{P.?~ (/ i/ //- //I~/f~1. ~ - j / - ~~. /;d,-.K-C~ J/~.-P.// I~~--L-L/ :J/ M~~ '-;0 ~~ / ~ .r. ~ / "~ ...,.... , J_ .....?<-.V ~?/,---4~<-~ /?,i~ ~-fl" -<-.- c:;<: --L,z~/t/ ~,/.'1':.,~-~ i/ r/ ~I /JUf ~--y~~L C--.:&- /7~L- ~ -..t!/~.v ~//c.-~__ ~ ~ &tv---?/ k ~ ~~--/{/ ...hdzu--- ~ ~~ i' _ _ .../- ..1. r _ /'. / {/ -7 _ /' - ",#_/. . / ,,?UJ..? ~~ d /-(.~z:" /?-<.- p-p__X-#-.-/ --CA'.-L-:/ ~(---{/~ --C{~ - ~ - / ~ ~ _1A-L/ ~ -4![!-/Y~ -4 ~..A/~(/ .../~ ~ ir:--c:7 J' / f - .r . - / ,quA/ ~ J~~-- a~d ~~z!~. ~ ~ _ / / ./ - '" ,4--, . // ~L p ....../~J!.L/ --<---fru-- ~ --(.#~../- --Ct7X.~btdzc,r~ ~ ~~ ;/ ;-- (/ /~~L- ' 7/(4.-/) ~~ 1/? _./s-~~ ~ ~ ;?!~, fJ j7~</b L. '1. . - r - / .,- ~ /" v. ~.., / /(..1'<-'" L-~I.~ ~(,-.,'/ f. qf'k, 7?J f/ ~~/ 5,;r:" - A ~~ //- L" _ /',-'l /;.../ /'H:~"J.UE~{ cL-C---, ~ I' .. - ... -",,- ,. ......... /' -' . , . /c --~ ~_____ ~ ,/ .." .'..1 " ' ~/ ~ ~ _L-- c--?L- .vK---~ ~ . ~ . / / ) d ~ ~. -" /- / _ --2 ~ ~_";:t:~ ./--; ,~-,<----/ ~~ ~.J!;(<:'~ /~ / --- - ~ ~ " /-- - .' ~ t::-ft~ /JfI A -' ,,-' -".' ~ ' ___ zP.--.t----::!--.::.-~ ~~ / ~-:) /L_ t:f/, .-It:--<- /-y~-- ...-r.. .., --; _ ~:!~..~O;;-; _~,//w-.f-A-+~~~;i f~' t C ~ , '----r / r ~. - - ,~//.!--::i" -<-...,- ___j.r ~;U./-:Z~--~ /[iLL, L/[C ~_ -&-7t" ~_}-~-d r,t4'Z r~--r~?-~---- /~/ .-C-Z/ fl'/t~;~ -i,nt'f, cJ~-cL4 ' / /../, _ ----7 .J /. '- <--~~:=:-~. ~ i__-" < /t---d-A.c -/7-"" /;/.~ J 7J/.~./4/j;;,zJ ~~-~. . ~ 21-1 fA 1{' r 000/0 , .. \ \- Santa }IConreajv{{J -Cify Jfqjhbors }'2 - 12 - q D December 10, 1990 To: Santa Monica city council From: Mid-City Neighbors Re: Residential Preference Parking District - st. John's Hospital Dear Council Members, The Board of Directors of Mid-city Neighbors unanimously recommends the establishment of a residential preference parking district in the neighborhood of st. John's Hospital. Because of the ever increasing demand for vehicular parking in this area, residents and their guests cannot find parking within reasonable distances of their homes. Demand for parking space here exceeds that often found around supermarkets and around Santa Monica College. We must, reluctantly t also recommend that no parking be permitted in the area at any time, other than to residents and their guests, rather than the alternatives of one hour or two hour, non-permit parking. The continuous use of even such 11mited parking by hospltal staff and visitors would continue to overwhelm the available space. In this era of limited resources, st. John's Hospital must provide for vehicular parking for its own staff and visitors and reduce its operational impact on its neighbors. We appreciate your consideration and adoption of this proposal at this time. RespnctfullY, "'-" M~G~::-:!an~=~t Mid-city Neighbors leI!} f4ihSf/S~~niCa CA !J04b5(2f.J)4J24t51 SA CITY PLANNING DIVISION Community and Economic Development Department MEMORANDUM DATE: October 17, 1990 TO: The Honorable Planning commission FROM: Planning Staff SUBJECT: Conditional Use Permit 90-026 Develop~ent Review 90-006 vesting Tentative Tract Map 46656 Address: Applicant: 951 Ocean A~enue Sakakura America, Inc. Su"MMARY Action: Application for a Conditional Use Permit, Development Review and vesting Tentative Tract Map to allow the construc- tion of a sixteen unit condominium project. Recommendation: Approval with conditions Permit streamlininq Expiration Date: October 20, 1990 SUbdivision Action Deadline: June 9, 1990 SITE LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION The subject property is a 37,500 sq.ft. parcel located on the northeast corner ot Ocean Avenue and Washinqton street having a frontage of 250 t.et on Ocean Avenue and a depth of 150 teet on washington Avenue. surrounding uses consist of mUlti-familY residential on the adjacent lot to the north (R4), multi-tamily residential acro.. W.ahinqton Avenue to the south (R4), multi- family residential across First Court Alley to the east (R4) and palisades Park across Ocean Avenue to the west. zoning District: R4 Land Use Oistricts: Hiqh Oensity Housing Parcel Area: 150' X 2501 - 37,500 square feet PROJECT DESCRIPTION proposed is the construction of a sixteen unit, four story con- dominium buildinq with a 39 space suDterranean parking garage accessed trom the First Court alley. The project would include - 1 - ~~6J, G .."\ 'f- . ,. .~ . .. ~ -..: s=: ......-. ~~ ......-;......-~,_ ..,Jo-'_ - ... -- -~....:;~"'- ~ ~:! 1!1f:.;~ two two-bedroom units, and fourteen three-bedroom units. A Con- ditional Use Permit and Tentative Tract Map are required for all condominium projects. A Development Review is required for proj- ects over 25,000 square feet in area in the R4 District. The proposed project is 51,210 square feet in area. MUNICIPAL CODE AND GENERAL PLAN CONFORMANCE The proposed project is consistent with the Municipal Code and in conformity with the General Plan as shown in Attachment A. CEQA STATUS The prcject is categorically exempt from the prov~s2ons of CEQA, pursuant to Class 3 (14) of the City of Santa Monica Guidelines for- Implementation of CEQA. RENT CONTROL STATUS .. The subj ect property is exempt from Rent control as a vacant parcel. FEES The proposed 16 unit condominium is subject to a Parks and Recre- ation Facility Tax of $200.00 per unit and a Condominium Tax of $100o.aO per saleable residential unit. ANALYSIS Background The proposed project was reviewed by the Planning Commission at the July 18, 1990 meeting. The Commission expressed general sup- port for the project but concluded that some design modifications were necessary and that the redesigned project should return for their review. Specifically, the Commission felt that the front elevation of the building should be redesigned to break up the large, blank facade, and that more quest parking should be added. The Commission also encouraged the applicant to discuss the proj- ect with the surrounding residents. Since the July meeting, the applicant has made some modifications to the building, including a redesign of the front facade which features larger terraces and recessed courtyards. The number of guest parking spaces has been increased from three to eight. The applicant has also met with some of the neighborhood residents in order to ensure that any concerns they may have are addressed. North of Wilshire Moratorium Section Jef) of the North of Wilshire Moratorium (Ordinance Num- ber 1507 CCS), states that a property shall be exempt from the moratorium if the following requirements are met: - 2 - ., (1) The applicant owned the property or had entered into escrow for purchase of the property on or before May 9, 1989. (2) No structures were on the property on May 9, 1989. (3) If located in the R4 District, the application shall comply with the development standards contained in the moratorium (See Attachment E). Information submitted with the application confirms that the ap- plicant did own the property on May 9, 1990, the property was vacant and the application conforms with the development stan- dards for the R4 District contained in the moratorium ordinance. Project Design The proposed project would include 16 single story flats on four floors, with two two-bedroom unrts, and fourteen three-bedroom units. The R4 District density standards of one unit per 900 square feet of lot area would permit 42 units on the subject property. The proj ect -meets or exceeds the development stan- dards in the R4 District including setbacks, lot coverage and he~ght. The building would feature large balconies on the Ocean Avenue frontage and co1tlJllon courtyards adjacent to each unit. Staff has expressed concern to the applicant regarding the design of the building in terms of the exterior facade. Conditions ~o the Architectural Review Board have been included to ensure that ARB pay particular attention to the design of the building in terms of the compatibility with the surrounding properties. Parking The required parking is based on the number of bedrooms of each unit. Parking is required as follows: 2 two-bedroom units @ 2 spaces each - 14 three-bedroom units @ 2.5 spaces each - Guest parking @ 1 space per 5 units - Total Parking = 4.0 spaces 35.0 spaces 3.0 spaces 42.0 spaces The proj ect provides 39 parking spaces in a one level subter- ranean garaqe and eight guest parking spaces on the ground level adjacent to the rear alley for a total of 47 spaces. CONCLUSION The proposed condominium complies with all applicable prov1s1ons of the Zoning ordinance, the North ot wilshire Moratorium and the General Plan and therefore merits approval. RECOMMENDATION - 3 - o. It is recommended that the Planning commission approve Condition- al Use Permit 90-026 , Development Review 90-006 and Vesting Ten- tative Tract Map 46656 subj ect to the following findings and conditions: TENTATIVE TRACT MAP FINDINGS 1. The proposed subdivision, together with its provision for its design and improvements, is consistent with applicable general and specific plans as adopted by the City of Santa Mon1ca in that the plan conforms to the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance and the General Plan. 2. The site is physically suitable for the proposed type of development in that it is a standard lot with no unusual characteristics. 3. The site is physically suitable for the proposed density of development in that a 3~,500 square foot lot in the R4 District can accommodate 42 units. 4. The design of the subdivision or the proposed improvements will not cause substantial environmental damage or sub- stantially and avoidably injure fish or wildlife or their habitat in that the proposed development is an in-fill of urban land which does not support fish or significant wildlife. 5. The design of the subdivision or the type of improvement will not cause serious public health problems in that the proposed development complies with the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance and General Plan. 6. The design of the subdivision or the type of improvements will not conflict with easements, acquired by the public at larg> , for access through, or use of, property within the pro~osed subdivision in that the subject site is ade- quately served by existing streets and alleys. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FINDINGS 1. The proposed use is one conditionally permitted within the subject district and complies with all of the applicable provisions of the "City of Santa Monica Comprehensive Land Use and Zoninq Ordinance", in ~hat the proposed condomini- um conforms to the Zoning ordinance and the General Plan. 2. The proposed use would not impair the character of the district in which it is to or located, in that it would be located in residential district. integrity and be established a mUlti-family 3. The subject parcel is physically suitable for the type of land use being proposed, in that the proposed project meets the density standards for the R4 District. - 4 - 4. ... :;I, 6. 7. 8. 9. 10, 11. 12. The proposed use is compatible with any of the land uses presently on the sUbJect parcel if the present land uses are to remain, in that the existing structure would be demolished. The proposed use would be compatible with existing and permissible land uses within the d~strict and the general area in which the proposed use is to be located, in that the area ~s a mix of single-family and multi-family resident2al units. There are adequate provisions for water, sanitation, and public utilities and services to ensure that the proposed use would not be detrimental to public health and safety, in that the proposed development is an in-fill of urban land adequately served by existing infrastructure. Public access to the proposed use will be adequate, in that the site is adequately served by existing streets and alleys. The physical location or placement of the use on the site is compatible with and relates harmoniously to the sur- rounding neighborhood, in that all setbacks, lot coverage and height requirements for the R4 District and the North of wilshire Moratorium have been met. The proposed use is consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the General Plan, in that the area is de- fined as a Low Density Housing area by the Land Use Ele- ment of the General Plan. The proposed use would not be detrimental to the public interest, health, safety, convenience, or general welfare, in that the proposed project complies with the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance, the North of wilshire Moratorium and the General Plan. The proposed use conforms precisely to the applicable per- formance standards contained in Subchapter 6, Section 9050 and special conditions outlined in Subchapter 7, Section 9055 of the City of Santa Monica Comprehensive Land Use and Zoning Ordinance, in that no performance standard per- mit would be required. The proposed use will not result in an overconcentration of such uses in the immediate vicinity, in that the area is defined as a mUlti-family residential district. DEVELOPMENT REVIEW FINDINGS 1. The physical location, size, massing, and placement of proposed structures on the site and the location of pro- posed uses within the project are compatible with and re- late harmoniously to surrounding sites and neighborhoods, in that the project complies with the property development - 5 - standards adopted as part of the North of Wilshire Moratorium. 2, The rights-of-way can accommodate autos and pedestrians, including parking and access, in that the site is ade- quately served by exist1ng streets and alleys. 3. The health and safety services (police, fire, etc.) and public infrastructure (e.g. utilities) are sufficient to accommodate the new development, in that the proposed development is an in-fill of urban land adequately served by existing infrastructure. ~. Anyon-site provision of housing or parks and public open space, which are part of the required project mitigation measures required in Subchapter SG of the City of Santa Monica Comprehensive Land Use and Zoning Ordinance, satis- factorily meet the goals of the mitigation program, in that the project is not su6ject to the provisions of Sub- chapter SG. 5. The proj ect is generally consistent with the Municipal Code and General Plan, in that it complies with the development standards for the R4 District. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT AND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW CONDITIONS Plans 1. This approval is for those plans dated Oc~ob.r 2, 1990, a copy of which shall be maintained in the tiles of the City Planning Division. Project development shall be consistent with such plans, except as otherwise specified in these conditions of approval. 2. The Plans shall comply with all other provisions of Chap- ter 1, Article IX of the Municipal Code, (Zoning Or- dinance) and all other pertinent ordinances and General Plan policies of the City of Santa Monica. 3. Final parking lot layout and specifications shall be sub- ject to the review and approval of the Parking and Traffic Engineer. 4. Minor amendments to the plans shall be subject to approval by the Director of Planning. A significant change in the approved concept shall be subject to Planning Commission Review. Construction shall be in conformance with the plans submitted or as modified by the planning Commission, Architectural Review Board or Director of Planning. Architectural Re lew Board 5. The ARB .all pay particular attention the the exterior facade to ensure that the design of the building is com- patible with surrounding properties. - 6 - 6. prior to consideration of the project by the Architectural Review Board, the applicant shall review disabled access requirements with the Building and Safety Division and make any necessary changes in the project design to achieve compliance with such requirements. The Architec- tural Review Board, ~n ~ts review, shall pay particular attention to the aesthetic, landscaping, and setback im- pacts of any ramps or other features necessitated by ac- cessibility requ~rements. 7. Plans for final design, landscaping, screening, trash en- closures, and signage shall be subject to review and ap- proval by the Architectural Review Board. 8. The existing mature trees located in the northwest corner of the parcel shall be either preserved in their present location or relocated to a specific location on the prop- erty to the satisfaction of the Planning Division and the Architectural Review Board1 9. The Architectural Review Board, in its review, shall pay particular attention to the project's pedestrian orienta- tion and amenities; scale and articulation of design ele- ments; exterior colors, textures and materials 1 window treatment; glazing; and landscaping. 10. Landscaping plans shall comply with Subchapter SB (Landscaping Standards) of the zoning ordinance including use of water-conserving landscaping materials, landscape maintenance and other standards contained in the Subchapter. 11. Refuse areas, storage areas and mechanical equipment shall screened in accordance with SMMC Section 9040.13-9040.15. Refuse areas shall be of a size adequate to meet on-site need, including recycling. The Architectural Review Board in its review shall pay particular attention to the screening of such areas and equipment. 12. No gas or electric meters shall be located within the re- quired front yard setback area. The Architectural Review Board in its review shall pay particular attention to the location and screening of such meters. 13. The Architectural Review Board shall pay particular atten- tion to the location of the proposed roof decks in rela- tion to the privacy of adjacent residents. Fees 14. The city is contemplating the adoption of a Transportation Management Plan which is intended to mitigate traffic and air quality impacts reSUlting from both new and existing development. The Plan will likely include an ordinance establishing mitigation requirements, includinq one-time payment of fees on certain types of new development, and - 7 - annual fees to be paid by certain types of employers in the City. This ordinance may require that the owner of the proposed proj ect pay such new development fees, and that employers within the project pay such new annual em- ployer fees related to the city's Transportation Manage- ment Plan. 15. A Park and Recreation Facilities Tax of $200.00 per resident~al unit shall be due and payable at the time of issuance of a building permit for the construction or re- placement of the residential unitCs) on the subject lot, per and subject to the provisions of Section 6670 et seg. of the Santa Monica Municipal Code. construction 16. During construction, a security fence, the height of which shall be the maximum permitted by the Zoning Ordinance, shall be maintained around4the perimeter of the lot. The lot shall be kept clear of all trash, weeds, etc. 17. Unless otherwise approved by the Department of General Services, all sidewalks shall be kept clear and passable during the grading and construction phase of the project. 18. Sidewalks, curbs, gutters, paving and driveways which need replacing or removal as a result of the project as deter- mined by the Department of General Services shall be re- constructed to the satisfaction of the Department of General services. Approval for this work shall be ob- tained from the Department of General Services prior to issuance of the building permits. 19. Vehicles hauling dirt or other construction debris from the site shall cover any open load with a tarpaulin or other secure coverinq to minimize dust emissions. 20. Street trees shall be maintained, relocated or provided as required in a manner consistent with the City'S Tree Code Cord. 1242 CCS), per the specifications of the Department of Recreation and Parks and the Department of General Ser- vices. No street tree shall be removed without the ap- proval of the Department of Recreation and Parks. 21. A construction period mitigation plan shall be prepared by the applicant for approval by the Department of General Services prior to issuance of a building permit. As ap- plicable, this plan shall 1) Specify the names, addresses, telephone numbers and business license numbers of all con- tractors and subcontractors as well as the developer and architect: 2) Describe how demolition of any existing structures is to be accomplished: 3) Indicate where any cranes are to be located for erection/construction; 4) Describe how much of the public street, alleyway, or side- walk is proposed to be used in conjunction with construc- tion; 5} Set forth the extent and nature of any pile- - 8 - driving operations; 6) Describe the length ana n~~ber of any tiebacks which must extend under the property of other persons; 7) Specify the nature and extent of any dewater- ing and its effect on any adjacent buildings; 8) Describe anticipated eontruction-related tr'-1ck routes, number of truck trips, hours of haulinq and parking location; 9) specify the nature and extent of any helicopter hauling; 10) State whether any construction activity beyond normal- ly perm~tted hours is proposed; 11) Describe any proposed construct~on noise mitigation measures; 12) Describe con- struction-period security measures inCluding any fencing, lighting, and security personnel; 13) Provide a drainage plan; 14) Provide a construction-period parking plan which shall minimize use of pUblic streets for parking; 15) List a designated on-site construction manager. 22, A sign shall be posted on the property in a manner consis- tent with the pub11C hearing sign requirements which shall ident~fy the address and p~one number of the owner and/or applicant for the purposes of responding to questions and complaints during the construction period. Said sign shall also indicate the hours of permissible construction work. 23. A copy of these conditions shall be posted in an easily visible and accessible location at all times during con- struction at the project site. The pages shall be lami- nated or otherwise protected to ensure durability of the copy, Environmental Mitigation 24. Ultra-low flow plumbing fixtures are required on all new development and remodeling where pltlm~ing is to be added. (Maximum 1.6 gallon toilets and 1.0 gallon urinals and low flow shower head.) 25. Prior to issuance of a Certificate of occupancy, project owner shall present documentation to the General Services Department certifying that existing Santa Monica occupan- cies with toilets installed prior to 1978 have been retro- fitted with ultra low-flow toilets (1.6 gallons per flush or less) such that development of the new project will not result in a net increase in wastewater flows. Flow from existing occupancies which will be removed as part of the new development may be deducted from flow at- tributable to the new development if such occupancies have been occupied within one year prior to issuance of a Building permit for the proposed project. Alternatively, proj ect owner may provide a payment to the General Ser- vices Department in an amount specified by General Ser- vices in lieu ot the installation requirement, which tunds shall be used by the City for the exclusive purpose of achieving compliance with this condition by retrOfitting - 9 - existing occupancies. Flow calculations for new d velop- ment and existing occupancies shall be consister with quidelines developed by the General services Depar ent. Miscellaneous CUP Conditions 26. The building address shall be painted on the roof of the building and shall measure four feet by eight feet (32 square feet). 27. If any archaeological remains are uncovered during excavation or construction, work in the affected area shall be suspended and a recoqnized specialist shall be contacted to conduct a survey of the affected area at project's owner's expense. A determination shall then be made by the Director of Planning to determine the sig- nificance of the survey findings and appropriate actions and requirements, if any, to address such findings. ., 28. street and/or alley lighting shall be provided on public rights of way adjacent to the project if and as needed per the specifications and with the approval of the Department of General Services. 29. Any lofts or mezzanines shall not exceed 99 square feet unless appropriate required parking is supplied. Such areas shall also not exceed 33.3% of the room below unless compliance with the district's limits on nQmber of stories can be maintained. Validity of Permits 30. The Conditional Use Permit and Development Review shall be of no further torce or effect it the Tentative Map ex- pires prior to approval of a Final Map for said tract. 31. In the event permittee violates or fails to comply with any conditions of approval of this permit, no further per- mits, licenses, approvals or certificates of occupancy shall be issued until such violation has been fully remedied. 32. Within ten days ot Planning Division transmittal of the Statement of Official Action, project applicant shall sign and return a copy of the statement of Official Action prepared by the Planning Division, agreeing to the Condi- tions of approval and acknowledging that failure to comply with such conditions shall constitute grounds for poten- tial revocation of the permit approval. By signing same, applicant shall not thereby waive any legal rights appli- cant may possess regarding said conditions. The signed Statement shall be returned to the Planning Division. Failure to comply with this condition shall constitute grounds for potential permit revocation. - 10 - 33. This determination shall not become effective for a period of fourteen days from the date of determination, or, if appealed, until a final determination is made on the ap- peal. Any appeal must be made in the form required by the Zoning Administrator. INCLGSIONARY UNIT CONDITIONS 34. The developer shall covenant and agree with the City of Santa Mon1ca to the specific terms, conditions and restrictions upon the possession, use and enjoyment of the subject property, which terms, conditions and restrictions shall be recorded with the Los Angeles County Recorder's Office as a part of the deed of the property to ensure that three affordable units are provided and maintained over time and through subsequent sales of the property. An affordable unit shall be defined as being affordable to households with incomes not exceeding 100\ of the (BUD) Los Angeles County median ~ncome, expending not over 30\ of monthly income on housing costs, as specified by the Housing Division of the Department of Community and Economic Development. This agreement shall be executed and recorded prior to approval of the Final Map. Such agreement shall specify 1) responsibilities of the developer for making the unites) available to eligible tenants and 2) responsibil~- ties of the City of Santa Monica to prepare application forms for potential tenants, estaplish criteria for qualifications, and monitor compliance with the provisions of the agreement. Owner shall provide the City Planning Division with a conformed copy of the recorded agreement prior to approval of the Final Map. This provision is intended to satisfy the inclusionary housing requirements of program 12 of the Housing Element of the General Plan of the City of Santa Monica (tlprogram. 12") . Developer may satisfy the Obligations created by this Agreement by demonstrating to the Director of Plan- ning compliance with ordinance 1448 (CCS), which provides implementation standards for Program 12. TENTATIVE TRACT MAP CONDITIONS 1. All off site improvements required by the City Engineer shall be installed. Plans and specifications for off site improvements shall be prepared by a registered civil en- gineer and approved by the city Engineer. 2. Before the City Engineer may approve the final map, a sub- division improvement agreement for all off site improve- ments required by the City Engineer shall be prepared and a performance bond posted through the city Attorney's office. - 11 - 3. The tentative map shall expire 24 months atter approval, except as provided in the provisions of California Govern- ment Code Section 66452.6 and Sections 9380-9382 of the Santa Monica Municipal Code. During this time period the final map shall be presented to the City of Santa Monica for approval. 4, The developer shall provide the Engineering Department of the City of Santa Monica with one Dizal Cloth print reproduction and microfilm of each sheet of the final map after recordation. 5. Prior to approval of the final map, condominium Associa- tion By-Laws (if applicable) and a Declaration of CC & R's shall be reviewed and approved by the City Attorney. The ee & R' s shall contain a non-discrimination clause as presented in section 9392 (SMMC) and in the case of con- dominiums, contain such provisions as are required by Sec- tion 9122E (SMMC). 4 6. The developer shall provide for payment of a Condominium Tax of $1,000 per saleable residential unit per the provi- sions of Section 6651 et seq. of the Santa Monica Municipal Code. 7. The form, contents, accompanying data, and filing of the final subdivision map shall conform to the provisions of Sections 9330 through 9338 (SMMC) and the Subdivision Map Act. The required Final Map filing fee shall be paid prior to scheduling of the Final Map for City Council approva-l. 8. The form, contents, accompanying data, and filing of the final parcel map shall conform to the provisions of Sec- tions 9350 through 9357 (SMMe) and the Subdivision Map Act. 9. The final map shall be recorded with the Los Angeles Coun- ty Recorder prior to issuance of any building permit for a condominium project pursuant to Government Code Section 66499.30. 10. Pursuant to Section 9366 (SMMC), if the subdivider or any interested person disagrees with any action by the Planning Commission with respect to the tentative map, an appeal or complaint may be filed in writing with the City Clerk. No appeal or complaint may be filed after a ten day period from the Commission's decision on the tentative map. Prepared by: David Martin, Associate Planner Attachments: A. B. C. D. Municipal Code and General Plan Conformance Radius and Location Map statistical Information Sheet Summary of CC & Rls - 12 - DM PC/CCP9026a 10/10/90 E. North of Wilshire Moratorium F. Vesting Tentative Tract Map 46656 G. Plot Plan, Floor Plans and Elevations .. - 13 - ATTACHMENT A MUNICIPAL CODE AND GENERAL PLAN CONFORMANCE Cate90ry Permitted Use Municioal Code " Land Use Element Project 16 Units 1 TJnit/900 sq.ft.= 42 du Same He~ght 4 Stories/45, Same for a pitched roof, 4 StorieS/40' for a flat roof 4 Stories/ 40' Setbacks Front yard 20' ,. 20.5' Sideyard 251 28.4' Rearyard 15' 38' Lot Coverage 50% 47.5% Parking 39 Spaces 47 Spaces plus 3 Guest Spaces priv. Open 100 sq. ft. per unit 260 sq. ft. per Space unit Landscaping 50% of front yard 96% of front yard - 14 - ~ :.~ --:; .~~" - rr jl -l " .. , ,.. - . I .. .- ~ .. ~ ~ . 'i a5 c ..I :( i ~ '" u. c ~ c. c.! .rro'il', ". 1- ::;.! ~~~ , I /-_! ' I... .. "..,,'" If ." If · / 1 " .. I E ~ ~. · '. .: < 11i~ > .. ..~: ~ ~ j~ u. ~ - , . ~S ~ · v ~ .c: I" .. ," I. .. .... ::c :-.1'" I . ." .. . .. . . "'~-1 ~ ~ o~H"" ,: '\. .. .. . -... ., ST=1E::- . ~ j I ,j, .. - c .. ~l I DC C C TI:\~" ~ ~~\ . ... - .. .':0" I ;) :l "f J '~y y 1.. ~., P I -. iii J .: ,I .,... ~ I! J ~,~ ~;.' l . ~ -.i i "1 . Wl' . ,3-01 ~ III . II 'IIll . I II III :JiC i .. . . I . 1301 j 3! ~...!~. 1~,1~1' !~w I 1.1 N ',; oJ . fib, n Q io 1 ~ 1I tI ~ V'.\~ ~ ~tl.. Nt .WI to!- wi' 'IIii III _ w- I STREEi . ~ .. .. "j . !II !' !l l I;..i t. .... I - . . ~ . . i. 1.. I ~ . ! _ ~.._~..- .. "'II"" !.,I,,"~ !\!_ '~ I C 1:[ - .-' J~ ~ , '~4 I. ~ % ~ o ~ ::; .c Iff':; Os LEGAL DESCRIPTIONLV"3 ~.pJ;DiP.~ ~t.D~ ~~ CASE NO '1'bWAJ CY: ';Afl/f'A ~flJld\ lCNE J:?-1 STo,!:p A.['IO~,"c:.,; _ OA TE APPLICANT SAKAKU2A CO. t''...:EL''-' HEAIWiG DArE RADIUS MAP FOR PLANNING DEPARTMENT Cily of Santa Monica CALIFORNIA i'ltfe' ,,"'c1.' A'Ias f.' lQ SheelNo 4 AeoQ\J"~ R3CI'LlS 500' --- .....IJ~, ..~.~...~ ~ SAKAKCRA A~ERICA INC. C.U.P. ~ 90-026 STRATISTICAL INFORMATION SHEET A. 01. TOTAL NCMBER OF UNIT f16 02, UNIT TYPE "A" 21869,00 SQ. FT, "X" #02 UNITS = 5,738.00 SQ, FT. 4 03. UNIT TYPE "B" 3,248,00 SQ. FT, "X" #14 UNITS = 45,472.00 SQ. FT, TOTAL AREA FOR UNIT "A" & "B" = 51,210.00 SQ. FT. B. LOT AREA 249.08' "X" 150.26' = 37.534.95 SQ. FT~ C, PERCENTAGE OF LOT COVERED BY BUILDING 47,50 % D, PERCENTAGE OF LOT COVERED BY LANDSCAPING 36,50 % E. SELLING PRICE OF EACH UNIT. 01. UNIT TYPE "A" S2.500,000.OO "X" #02 = $ 5,000,000,00 02. UNIT TYPE "B" S3.000.000.00 "X" #14 ~ $ 4,200,000.00 TOTAL SELLING PRICE OF UNIT "A" & "B" ~ $47.000.000,00 951 OCEAN AVENUE, SANTA MONICA. CA 90402 ~~M"&J\ C- C'rY 01 Santa Monica C.;ml"1Ul"OlV ard Eoonon';c Je....loomert Oecart:"ent I'larllllnQ 11\4 z~ DI~\SlQR ;2' 3"; 458 6J4' T~ACT NO ADDRESS ... ~ - : .. ~ RESUME (thrs should be a bnef summai)' not an Index to :he COIT'OIe18 set) CONDOMINIUM ARllctES OF INCORPORAllON BYLAWS AND CC&Rs Type of Organ1zato" ,o--=r~=_~ MC~Jal Be-e=~: C~~~o~a~~o' 2 MelT'bersn1p .........;..- cando~ir~~ 'o~eawre~s 3 MemoerstllD TemlirJatlon F31.::..ire -I-~ pay d....:es. sa:'e 0: :;-.:.t 4 \lO'-ng R;ghts O,e vc~e ?e= =~~dD-~'~un ~n~t 5 Management 5 perSQ, Boa~d of Oi=ec~c~s Ch~ef F~,anc~al C:f~cer ?~es_den~, lce-?~eslde~t, Sec=eta~:, 6 P'o;ect LIe ?~oJected 11~e ~n~:~~~ed 7 Eflect'Ylty Tern of and Amenament:; to CC&Rs Anendne~ts or by ra~or~~: vc~e 8 l,!aln:enance ProvISions a Url~S 3y ea.::~ 1. "'d,i '....l.~-,.;,a 1 LI.l t c~~""e r b Common Areas By Hot'\eowners AssoClat:..OI' 9 Oatllag,.R&palroratlandOnmenIPrOVlSlons Bv I"1SUral'ce :Jr:::ceeds -:Jr s";)ec~al assess-e- of the owners, t~e Assoc~ation lS rea~~=ed to =eca~r da~ace~ cOr'l.-..cn areas 10 Oescrrpllon and ownership of conaom Inlum LJn.lS Ie l S un~ts rarglng In Size ~rc~ 2,363 -ed~an s~ze bei~~ ),249 5C :t 11 DescnptlOn. ownership and use of common areas OWnersh:..p of "~e co~~on a~eas shal: =e ~ 2/] ~"'C:l~C~~ -~~:cs~~. each of the ~r~t Cw~e~s a,d co~or ~~~as _saae 5hd~: ~c 3' 3:~~~~~ ~o all ~l'lt ~wrers 31d ~~elr ~~ests ~~~~osed ~o co'struc~ &5 ~~~jo~:r~ su ~~ :0 6,~16 SG :t _ Wlt- ~~: JWl'ers-:~ shall be ~c~ a~~ 12 Parking Space AssIgnment 42 oark:..n~ spaces. c:nlt o....ne=s 13 ReslnClKlns ~~l=~ s~al: be ~~-be~ed 3nd 3SS~~r€j _~ ':~:? a Owner's FinanoallLegal Status '-:c r e o Use "eSlcel1tlal c Any RestnclIons on Age of OcCJpants "0 d PelS ",,0 \-.. Preparec by Till, -:"O-'IY :;: .,"":5 e..l~-u. 1-; ;~ (-'_1 {'\.tt:::)r....L~v 1~ Oat. :J. -, r- 1'0 -- ~l'\~ D CA: R.1I!M: 1. ...S66jhpc: Cley Cou~clL Meetlng 12-12-99 Santa Monlca, Callfornla ORDINANCE NUMBER :. 5: ~ (Clty Councll Series) ~~ ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA EXTENDING THE MORATORIt~ ON RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE AREA BOUNDED BY OCEAN AVENUE, MONTANA AVENUE, THE EAST SIDE OF 14TH STREET AND WILSHIRE BOULEVARD FOR TEN MONTHS IN ORDER TO ALLOW FOR PREPARATION OF AN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT THAT EVALUATES RE-ZONING OF THE AREA AND FOR ADOPTION OF CONTROLS ON TIMING OF CONSTRCCTION OF DEVELOPMENT ~OJECTS APPROVED IN THE AREA AND DECLARING THE PRtsENCE OF AN EMERGENCY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION 1. Findinqs and Purpose. The City Council finds and declares: (a) A slqnifieant level of development activity has occurred between January 1987 and March 1989 1n the area bounded by Ocean Avenue on the west, by Montana Avenue on the north (lncluding the R-3 and R-4 zoned property on the north side of Montana Avenue), by 14th Str..t on the east (including the R-3 zoned property on the e.st sid. ot 14th Stre.tl, ana by WilShire Boulevard on the south (hereinafter referred to as the "moratoriua are."). (b) More than twenty-one (21) re.idential development projects that will result in the construction of 269 new residential units in the moratorium ar.a have b.en approved between January 1987 and March 1989. This number of projects and " - 1 - A.~M€1Jr E- un1ts 15 slqnlflcant when compared wlth the development actlvlty 1n the two prey lOUS two-year perlods 1n the mcratorlum area. Durlnq the perlod from 3anuary 1985 throuqh December 1986, only four (4) residentlal development proJects, which resulted 1n the constr~ct1on of slxteen (16) new residentlal un1ts, were approved :.n t.he !:lOra1:0rlUm area. Ourinq the pariod from 3anuary 1983 through December 1984, only five (5) residential development proJ eets, WhlCh resulted in the construction of seventy-seven (7i) unlts, were approved in the moratorium area. (C) While the City's LaJd Use and Circulation Element, adopted on October 23, 1983, ldentities a standard of 48 dwelllng unlts per net resldentlal acre for hiqh density residential areas 1n the Clty, the development activity that has occurred between January 1987 and March 1989 has resulted in 49.4 dwellinq units per acre 1n the R-4 portlon of the moratorium area. (d) While the City's Land U.e and Circulation Element ldentlfies a standard of 35 dwellinq units per net residentlal acre for medium density resldential areas, development activlty that has occurred between 3anuary 1987 and March 1989 has resulted in 40.9 dwellinq units per acra in the R-3 portion of the moratorium are.. (e) A number ot existinq properties in the moratorium area are underdeveloped in relation to the City'. existinq allowable helqht and density limits. This is siqniticant in that the redevelopment ot the.e currently underdeveloped properties at greater height and densities could r..ult in tn. 10.. ot views and. light and could po.e a threat to the exist.inq character of the naiqhbcrhood. - 2 - ( f) Slgn~f~cant parklnq aerlclencles eXlst 1n the moratorlum area and lncreased development is llkely to exacerbate an already unacceptable level of parking problems. (q) There 15 cont~nulnq and lncreasinq concern reqardlng the capaclty of the exist1nq infrastructure In the morator;.:..:.::\ area to support lncreases In densltles. (h) There lS contlnulnq and increaslng communlty concern that an lncreasinq number ot appllcations are and wlll contlnue to be flled for development projects wlthin the moratorium area. (1) The amount of construction activity taking place in $ the moratorlum area causes siqnificant disruption and nOlse problems for the resldent5 of the area. (J) The lncrease 1n development activity in the mcrator1um area poses a threat to the public health, satety and ~elfare ot the residents. (k) In 1 iqht of the above-mentioned concerns, the C 1 ty Counc1l adopted Ordinance Number 1478 (CCS) on May 9, 1989, which ordlnance established a 45 day moratorium and adopted ordinance Number 1484 (CCS) on June 13, 1989, extendlng the moratorium for SlX months. (1) During the past six months, the City'S Planning Divlsion convened a ta.k force compo.ed of residents and property owners in ~. moratorium area to participa~e in discussions about solution. to the above-men~ioned concerns. (m) On November 21, 1989, the Planning Division presented a statf report to the City Council containing statt recommendations and recommendations of the task torce. Following the staff report, the City Council directed that the moratorium - 3 - t be extended 1n order to allow the staff to prepare an envlronmental lmpact report to evaluate proposed re-zonlnq ot the area and tor preparatlon of an ordinance ;oVernlnq the rate and tlmlng of constructlon proJects in the area. (n) Pendlnq pOSSlble re-zoning ot the area, adoptlon of modLfLed development standards, and conerols on tlmLng of constructlon of approved development projects in the area, 1t 15 necessary to extend the Lnterlm control measure established by Ordlnance NUmber 1484 (CCS) in order to preserve the ex:ut Lng character of the moratorium area and prevent any further i aggravatlon of the parklng and other intra structure limitations. SECTION 2. Moratorium. (a) Subject to the exemptions set forth in Section 3 of thlS OrdLnance, a moratorLum is hereby placed on the acceptance for processlnq of any applications tor approval of tentatlve tract maps, tentative parcel maps, administrative approvals, development review permits, conditional use permits, or any other City permits for the erectlon, construction, demolition, moving, conversion of, and excavation and qradinq for, any residentlal bUlld~nq or structure, including any hotel or motel, on properties zoned R-] or R-4 in the moratorium area. Cb) Subject to the exemptions set forth in Section 3 of this Ordinanc., the Planninq Commission and City statt are hereby directed to disapprove all applications filed atter April 28, 1989, for approval ot tentative tract maps, tentative parcel maps, admin~strativ. approvals, development review permits, conditional use permits, or any other City permit. for the - 4 - erect1.0n, COl",structlon, demollt1.0n, movlnq, conversJ.cn of, and excavatJ.on and grad1.nq for, any re.identl.al bU1.1d1.nq or structure, l.ncludlnq any hotel or motel, on propartl.a. zoned R-) or R-4 in the morator1.um area. SEC7ION), Exemptlons. The followlnq appllcatlons are exempt from the provlsions of Sectlon 2 ot this Ordinance: (a) Applications for approval of permits involvl.ng the erectlon, construct1.on, enlargement, demolition of a sl.nqle famlly dwelling, or movinq of, and excavation and grading for any sl.nqle faml.ly dwelling. I (b) Applications for approval of permits involvinq the erection, constructl.on, enlargement, demo 1 i tion, or moving of, and excavatlon and grading for any multiple dwelling development lntended for rental housing tor persons ot low and moderate income or for senior cltizens, and which development is financed by any federal, state or City housing as.istance program or owned by any non-profit orqanization, provided the Director ot Plannlng determlnes that such development is in conformance with the General Plan and the Zoning Ordinance and provided a deed restrictlon is recorded r..~ricting the development to such purpose. (c) Applications for approval ot permits involving the rehabilitation or enlarge.ent ot existin; dwellinq units. (d) Applications for projects d....d compleee on or betor. April 28, 1989. An application shall be d.e.ed complete tor purpose. ot this ordinance within titteen (15) days for subdlvision maps and parcel maps, and thirty (30) day. tor all - 5 - other per~lIl ts. atter the Planning DiViSlon receives a substantlally complete appllcation together with all informatlon. reports, drawlnqs, plans. flllng f..s, and any other materlals and documents requlred by the approprlate application forms supplled by the City. If, wlthln the specified tlme perlod, the Plannlng D1V1Slon fails to advise the applicant in wr1tinq that hlS or her appllcation 1S incomplete ana to spec1fy all addltlonal information required to complete that appllcat1on, the appllcatlon shall automat1cally be d.emed complete. An appl1cation 1S "sut:lstantiallyt complete" if the miss.lng lnformatlon 1S supplled within two (2) workinq days ot the City'S request. ee> Applications for approval of permits involvinq the erection, construction, enlarqem~t, demolition, or moving ot, and excavation and gradinq for, projects which have been qranted development permits by the Planninq Commission or Planning DivlSlon prlor to April 28, 1989. (f) Applications for approval of permits l.nvolvinq the construction and excavation and qradinq tor, projects where the following requirements are met. (1) The applicant owned the property or had .ntered into .scrow tor purchas. ot the property on or before May 9, 1989. (2) ,. No structure. were on the property on May 9, 1989. (3) It located in the R-3 District, the application me.ts the tollowinq develop.ent standard.: - 6 - . . ( l) MaXlmurrt BUlldlnq He 19ht. Three storles, not to exceed 35 teet for a flat root, or 40 feet tor a Pltched root. A pitched roof 15 deflned as a root wlth at least t....o sldes ha"lnq no less than one foot of vertical rlse for every three feet of hor1zontal run. The walls of the bUlldinq may not exceed the maXlmum helght requ1red for a flat root. (11) MaXlmum Gnlt Density. One dwelllng un1t for each 1250 square feet of parcel area. No more than one dwelling unlt shall be permltted on a parcel of less than 4,000 square feet 1f a slngle famlly dwelling existed on the parcel on ~ the effective date of th1S Chapter. (li1) Maximum Parcel Coveraqe. 50 percent. (iv) Mlnlmum Lot Size. 5,000 square feet. Each parcel shall contain a minimum depth of 100 feet and a -:nlnlmum wldth of 50 feet, except that parcels existing on the effective date of this Chapter are not subject to thlS requirement. (v) Front Yard Setback. 20 teet, or as shown on the Official Districtinq Map, whichever is greater. However, 25\ of the front elevation up to 14 feet in height shall be set back an additional averaqe of 5 teet and 30' of the front elevation above 14 teet in height shall be set back an additlonal average of 10 r.et tro. the required rront yard setback. (vi) Rear Yard Setback. 15 t.et. (vii) Side Yard Setback. The side yard setback shall be determined in accordance with the followinq formula, except tor lots of less than 50 teet in width tor which - 7 - . the Slde yard shall be 10\ ot the parcel wldth but not less than " feet: 5' . {storles x lot v~~th) . - 50' For any portlon of the structure between l4 feet and 28 feet. 4n helght, an addl':.lonal 4 foot average setback is req\ared. For any portlon of the structure bet...,.en 29 feet. and 38 feet, an addl~lonal 8 foot average setback from the mlnimum slde yard setback is requlred. (Vlli) Landscaplnq. A mlnimum of 50\ of the requlred front yard setback shatl be landscaped. A minimum of SOl ot both required slde yard setbacks shall be landscaped. At least two 24'. box trees shall be planted in the front yard. {ix} Private Open Space. For projects of 4 or 5 unlts, 150 square teet of private open space per unit shall be requlred, For projects of 6 units or more, 100 square teet ot prlvate open space per unit shall be required. (x) Development Review. A Development Review Permlt is required for any development of more than 22,500 square feet of floor area. (4) It located in the R-4 District, the applicat~on meets the tollowing development standards: (1) Maximum Buildinq Heiqht. Four stori.., not to exceed 40 t..~ tor a flat root, or 45 feet tor a pitched root. A pitched roof i. detined aa a root with at leaat two sides havinq no le.. than one foot of vertical ri.. for every three t.et of horizontal run. The walls of the building may not exceed the maximum heiqht required for a flat roof. - 8 - (11) Max~~um Unlt Oenslty. One dwelllnq Unl~ for each 900 square feet ot parcel area. No more t~ ~n one dwell~nq unit shall be perm~tted on a parcel of less than 4,000 square feet ~f a single farnlly dwell1nq eXlsted on the parcel on ~~e effective date of thls Chapter, (ll~) MaXlmum Parcel Coveraqe. SO percent. (iv) M:nlrnurn Lot 51ze, 5,000 square fee~. Each parcel shall conta1n a I'rlln~rnUm depth ot 100 feet and a ::'llnlrnum wldth of 50 feet, except that parcels eX1.stlnq on the effect1ve date of th~s Chapter are not subJect to thls -- -- requlrement. (v) Front Yard Setback. 20 feet, or as shown on the Off1cial Dlstrlct~nq Map, whichever is greater. However, 25% of the front elevation up to 14 feet in height shall be set back an add~tional average of 5 feet and 30t ot the front elevation above 14 feet 1n height shall be set back an additional average of 10 feet from the required front yard setback. (vi) Rear Yard Setback. 15 fe.t. (vii) Side Yard Setback. The slde yard setback shall be determined in accordance with the following formula, except tor lots of less than 50 feet in wldth tor which the side yard shall b. lot ot the parcel width but not less than 4 feet: 5' + (stories x lot width) 50' For any portion of the structure between 14 te.t and 28 te.t in he1qht, an additional 4 foot average setback is required. For any portion of the structure between 29 te.t and 38 t.et, an - 9 - , addltlonal 8 foot averaq. setback from the mlnlmum 51.de yar~ setback 15 requ1red. (Vlll) Landscaginq. A mlnlmum of 50\ ot the requlred front ya.rd setbacK shall be landsca.ped. A minlmum of sot of both requ1.red slde yard setbacks shall be landscaped. At least two 24" box trees shall be planted 1n the front yard. (lX) PrIvate Open Space. For proJects of 4 or 5 unlts, 150 square feet of prIvate open space per unIt shall be requlred. For proJects of 6 unIts or more, 100 square feet of prlvate open space per un~t shall be required. ~ (x) Development Review. A Development RevIew PermIt 15 requ1red for any development ot more than 25,000 square feet of floer area. SECTION 4. ThIS OrdInance shall be of no further torce and effect ten months from its adoption, unless prior to that date, after a publIC hearing, noticed pursuant to section 9131.5 of the Santa Monica Municlpal Code, the City Council, by majority yote, extends the interim ordinance as provided by Section 9120.6 of the Santa Monica Municipal Code. SECTION 5. This ordinance i. declared to be an urqency measure adopted pursuant to the provisions ot Seetion 9120.6 ot the Santa Ironica Munioipal Code and Section 615 ot the Santa Honica City Charter. It i. nece..ary tor pre..rvinq the public peace, health and safety, and the urqency tor its adoption i. set forth 1n the findinqs above. - 10 - SECTION 6. Any provislon of the Santa Mon~ca MUn~c1.pal Code or appendices thereto lnconlllstent with the proVlslons of thiS ordinance, to the extent of such inconslstencles and no f~r~~er, are hereby repealed or modlfled to that exten~ necessary ~o affec~ the provlSlons of thlS Ordlnance. SECTION i. If any sectlon, suosection, sentence, clause, or phrase of thlS Ordlnance is for any reason held to be invalld or unconstltutlonal by a deC1Slon of any court of any competent ]urlsdlctlon, such deC1Slon shall not affect the validlty of the remalnlng portlons of thls Ordlnanc8. The Clty Councll hereby declares that lt would have passed thls Ordinance, and each and every section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase not declared J.nvalld or unconstltutional without regard to whether any portlon of the Ordlnance would be subsequently declared lnvalld or unconstltutlonal. SECTION 8. The Mayor shall sign and the Clty Clerk shall attest to the passaqe of this ordinance. The City Clerk shall cause the same to be published once in the official newspaper wlthln 15 days atter its adoption. This Ordinance shall become effectlve upon adoption. APPROVED AS TO FORM: ~M.. ROBERT M. MYERS City Attorney ,........... .........,.. --- ...... -......-- -- u - 11 - Adopted and approved th~s 12th day ot December, 1989. r'\ '""1 'fA).s;......., ( (~ " .) Mayor r hereby certify that the toreqoinq Ordinance No. lS07(CCS) was duly and regularly introduced at a meeting ot the C~ty ~ Counc~l on the 12th day ot December 1989~ that the said Ordinance was thereattar duly adopted at a meeting ot the City council on the 12th day ot December 1989 by the tollowinq Council vote: Ayes: Counc~llllemD.rs: Al:ldo 1 Finkel, Genser, .renninqs, Mayor Zane Noes: Councillllem.bers: Katz, Reed Abstain: Councillllem1:>ers: None Absent: Councillllem1:>er.: None -'I ATTEST: J ..., / _ / -,...., ,: /~ J ,-,:ctlc~ ~",ntLJ ~h~1 <;tty Clerk . . . De-c q l '1'10 Md fri Y--A 4'if.t- 7Jwni-e.fr.J c., ~u~ 1f'e fl-z.c,rcJr:'cr;. P~-;\R--LO. ,-...~, t:..-C P-4.<>-.h'-(j V ~ " 'i~~ -, . DEe 1 2 1990 :t Z---if)~ 1\ frC:~l <~ C---0("-n0. l m"t' ~.J'f. \.--...a:. --J Lt- {::;~ ctu \.lUte G rrcJ S'11QGrJ& S U'Pf>cJ r-z-l ~ L.' -thL pl.L pL~5ec(, l'/i.t:y-~~ 1 ~ P C:v-J c'Uj 'J oCtl e.. f\ 4: f.-.. LA L..l CO {J"...L," rr.c0...(L-L.. d'S ~~ ytl.- ~~ h Ch.'L f\.: 0 Il.-U-<-.-- _^^,r.......-- f1"C~~ l;-ChA~./'>t- ---<.j:' -A--J -Iv t (~ PC-v~&--.O ..4h. ~ str-'t'c-k- J,{ c-<L.L.:~ ~./\L.. G______ ;L ---4--:.+GL-L_---.c......+o - fA C) 'J --- -\' I I fUr---'t D~\. ~lV.L t.-..cv .....&-Y~ '-.:j 'Y'-J ~ T L1.) l ':l fLl',,",,'_ c.--..d2- I'r-c<"'b c ~ '--CA\.. iL--hL": l c--::>\--UA, S!",,,,,e~'\:-S .)~cvrt lY1e(-<..-v-:) l....:vt ~.vth d~, G..",-& ~E)~ ~ CLr~ \.Jblc h \,-...x c:. tel ~'l) rc/J..-, t _. t \[ ~ l:G.tL4- C"LUCLC\ J ..\v\..JU -h 0v\.r~ ~ 0vs- ~ ~W'\~ cJ.--,.\.J..--.....y~ Wlh" _. lYlL - D"I S---\-orLL'.t ~CL--n'L:"'O cl~~ A>t I../J j.,.---;;pe'c.( t'0LC(:J ct----t=Dc...s.t \'0 bL rJ t\.,,, C>r' (' ''''''''PVH-Lt"C ):J'-1I).-l Gl~ s.f" 4<---Z rk lcrv..l'n!.n:.,t.L cv__o-d-cprne .--,,-t G.::J--,n\rv',-,-" ~ +0 f~ r1c...L -L tU..:;: I't;-~ Lt.- I l s 0... ,.-\,< , ~/.t- L.-C li.L l.:,e... i f\.L-...., 4. S'Y\-. '"'O~ Iv) ,j l -~. -- r "f- cLc--t'Li--J..I -<."'0 pUL-L ':V(~ l\1\t:- /It.-':.l,de-r.-G u"'- -\-JLA J O---v; c... ~ -k->-Jr.....-r"l ---h\.. ~ ..Lo) c........ c... JX- \,^- c.L~:e.-G.. n IV, ~ V'v~ ) ~ t;-u--'- ,-,-t L/J -\ ~\.(:- '\..t)r^-'"F{L.)l e -t~~ ~o tv d..:::: ..h:, 1 ~ ~ If--c (--e-<),J ent3 r-e""-c..lj,,Cv~ k: ~-'L'; ~ 0 ...\-{..,e--L.'- ...) . ~ ,9 ~'7eC -k ~--..y- C1-U [f\ :Q 'S -I:~ S-tl.- E t (\L< '";) r _&-(.{. t~' q l'L--n, h k ..v.., ~ ---.) (I .-21 ~.j I ?tk' v_=-.- f~'.u --1/ ~ '- k -\'1,-",-,- ':l j)/k- p,; r -Q...... oj L.J Z f'''L-( &. yJ'u. v~"t) ',-Y- PCL-YLIc.;Vl,'-1. :..J \....-/ P '\..-<-' P v---Vt1 -4?-v ' t"'.o<< --, .. j} I'- ~~ /rY'- .-- ~ I (V "'---'I \,) ~..h&y-.. ...j \~:L"\ U 'L".Ji(f i c.c, 17J~~ Ifti9 r ~ 1...:::5-4, t..... I'-i. -"\'\.--..J ~- 1 1)0 , - '~-t..... l(~3G - ,::> - b+ ~ {A-,\ b\. t1\.-c 1\-.( u.. J CA q 0 l.t C 'i ~fl lIdic ~990 ' nj~