Loading...
O1996 DR \ad mm\staffrpts\ 12-05-00\greenbldg2-3 City Council Meetmg 12-19-00 Santa MOnica, California ORDINANCE NUMBER 1996(CCS) (City CouncIl Series) AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA ADDING CHAPTER 7 60 TO THE SANTA MONICA MUNICIPAL CODE REQUIRING A CONSTRUCTION AND MATERIAL WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN FOR CONSTRUCTION AND DEMOLITION PROJECTS WHEREAS, the State of California through Its California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989, Assembly Bill 939 (AB 939), requires that each local JUriSdiction In the state divert 50% of discarded materrals (base year 1990) from landfills by December 31,2000, and WHEREAS, every city and county m California, including the City, could face fines up to $10,000 a day for not meeting the above mandated goal, and WHEREAS, the Source Reduction and Recycling Element (SRRE) for Santa MOnica adopted by the City CounCil In 1990 proposed the promotIon of a Construction and DemolItion (C&D) Matenal education program and, If necessary, a reuse and/or recycling program In order to meet the state mandated waste reduction goal, and WHEREAS, as of last year the City diverted 43% of discarded matenals from landfills, and WHEREAS, approximately 20% of the City's solid waste sent to landfills IS from construction and demolition actiVities and the dIverSion of these materials would have a Significant potential for waste reductIon and recycling; and WHEREAS, reusing and recycling C&D Material IS essential to further the City's efforts to reduce waste and comply with AS 939. and WHEREAS, C&D Material waste reduction and recyclIng have been proven to reduce the amount of such matenal which IS landfilled, mcrease worker safety, and be cost effective, and WHEREAS, except In unusual Circumstances, It IS feaSible to divert an average of at least 60% of all C&D Matenal from construction, demolition and renovatIon proJects, and WHEREAS, to ensure compliance with thiS Chapter and to ensure that those contractors that comply wIth thiS Chapter are not placed at a competitive disadvantage, It IS necessary to Impose a Performance Security requIrement; NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCil OF THE CITY OF SANTA MONICA DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS SECTION 1 Chapter 760 IS hereby added to the Santa MonIca Munrclpal Code to read as follows CHAPTER 7.60 CONSTRUCTION AND DEMOLITION MATERIAL MATERIAL WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN SECTION 7.60.010 DEFINITIONS For the purposes of thIS Chapter, the followmg deflnrtlons shall apply 2 (a)"Apphcant" means any individual, firm, limIted liability company, aSSOciation, partnership, political subdivISion, government agency, municipality, mdustry, public or private corporation, or any other entity whatsoever who applies to the City for the applicable permIts to undertake any construction, demolition, or renovation project wlthm the City. (b)"Class III Landfill" A landfill means a that accepts non-hazardous resources such as household, commercial, and Industrial waste, resulting from construction, remodeling, repair, and demolition operations A Class III landfill must have a solid waste facIlities permit from the California Integrated Waste Management Board (CIWMB) and IS regulated by an Enforcement Agency (EA) (c)"Construction" means the bUIldmg of any faCIlity or structure or any portion thereof Including any tenant Improvements to an eXlstmg faCIlity or structure. (d)"Constructlon and Demolition Material" (C&D Matenal) means building matenals and solid waste resulting from construction, remodeling, repair, cleanup, or demolition operations that are not hazardous as defined In California Code of RegulatIons, Title 22 Section 66261 3 8t seq ThiS term Includes, but IS not limIted to, asphalt, concrete, Portland cement concrete, bnck, lumber, gypsum wallboard, cardboard, 3 and other associated packaging, roofing material, ceramIc tile, carpeting, plastic pIpe and steel The material may be commingled with rock, sOil, tree stumps, and other vegetative matter resultmg from land clearing and landscaping for construction or land development prelects (e)"C&D Recycling Center" means a facIlity that receives only C&D matenal that has been separated for reuse prior to receipt, In which the residual (disposed) amount of waste In the material IS less than 10% of the average weight of material separated for reuse received by the facIlity over a one month period, {f)"Clty-sponsored proJect" means a project constructed by the City or a proJect recelvmg 50% or more of Its fmanclng from the City (g) "Conversion Rate" means the rate set forth In the standardIzed Conversion Rate Table approved by the CIty pursuant to thiS Article for use In estlmatmg the volume or weight of materials IdentIfied In the Waste Management Plan (h)"Covered Project" shall have the meaning set forth In Section 7 60 020 (I)'Ueconstructlon" means the careful dIsmantling of bUlldmgs and structures In order to salvage as much material as possible 4 (J)"Demohtlon" means the deCimating, razing, rUining, tearrng down or wrecking of any facility, structure, pavement or building, whether In whole or In part, whether Interior or exterior (k)"Dlsposal" means the final deposition of construction and demolition or Inert materral, Including but not limited to (1 )Stockplllng onto land of constructIon and demolition materral that has not been sorted for further processing or resale, If such stockpiling IS for a penod of time greater than 30 days, or (2)stockplllng onto land of construction and demolition material that has been sorted for further processing or resale, If such stockpiling IS for a period of time greater than one year, or(3)stockplllng onto land of Inert material that IS for a period of time greater than one year, or (4) dIsposal of construction and demolition or Inert materral to a landfill (I)"Dlvert" means to use material for any purpose other than disposal In a landfill or transformation facility (m)"Dlverslon ReqUirement" means the diverSion of at least sixty (60) percent of the total Construction and DemolItion Matenal generated by a Project via reuse or recycling, unless the Applicant has been granted an 5 Exemption pursuant to Section 7 60 070, In which case the DiverSion ReqUirement shall be the maximum feasible diverSion rate established by the Waste Management Plan Compliance OffiCial In relation to the project (n)"Enforcement Agency (EA)" means an enforcement agency as defined In Public Resources Code 40130 (o)"lnert Backfill Site" means any location other than an Inert landfill or other disposal faCility to which Inert materials are taken for the purpose of filling an excavation, shOring, or other Salls engineering operation (p)"1 nert Disposal Facllltyll nert Waste Landfill" means a dIsposal faCIlity that accepts only Inert waste such as 5011 and rock, fully cured asphalt paving, uncontaminated concrete (Including fiberglass or steel reinforCing rods embedded In the concrete), brick, glass, and ceramiCS, for land disposal, (q)"lnert Solids/Inert Waste" means non-liqUid solid resources Including, but not limited to, SOil and concrete, that do not contain hazardous waste or soluble pollutants at concentrations In excess of water quality objectives established by a regional Water Board pursuant to DIVISion 7 (Section 13000 et seq ) of the California Water Code and does not contain Significant quantities of decomposable solid resources 6 (r)"Mlxed Matenal" means loads that Include commmgled recyclables and non-recyclable materials generated at the project site (s)"Mlxed Matenal Recycling Facility" means a processing facIlity that accepts loads of mixed construction and demolition debris for the purpose of recovenng re-usable and recyclable materials and dlsposmg the non-recyclable residual materials (t)"Performance Security" means any performance bond, surety bond, money order, letter of credit, certificate of deposit, or restncted bank account, provided to the City pursuant to Section 760040 (u)"Post-Consumer Matenal" as defined In Public Contract Code Section 12200(b) means a finished material which would have been disposed of as a solid waste, haVing completed ItS life cycle as a consumer Item, and does not Include manufacturing wastes. Post-Consumer Material IS generally any product that was bought by the consumer, used, and then recycled Into another product (v)"ProJect" means any activity which reqUires an application for a bUilding or demolition permit or any similar permit from the City ~ i (w)"Recycled Product" as defined In Public Contract Code Section 12200(a) means all materrals, goods, and supplies wIth no less than 50 percent of the total weight of which consists of secondary and Post-Consumer Matenal with not less than 10 percent of Its total weight conslstmg of Post- Consumer Material ThiS definition applies to paper products, plastIC products, compost and co-compost, glass products, lubrlcatmg Oils, paints, solvents, retreaded tires, tire-derived products, and steel products A recycled product also Includes products that could have been disposed of as solid waste havmg completed Its life cycle as a consumer Item, but otherwise IS refurbished for reuse without substantIal alteration of ItS form {x)"Recycllng" means the process of collecting, sorting, cleanSing, treatmg, and reconstItuting matenals for the purpose of uSing the altered form In the manufacture of a new product Recycling does not mclude burning, incinerating, or thermally destrOYing solid waste (y)"Renovatlon" means any change, addition or modIficatIon In an eXlstmg structure (z)"Reuse" means the use, in the same or similar form as It was produced, of a material which might otherwise bea discarded 8 (aa)"Salvage" means the controlled removal of Construction and Demolition Material from a permitted bUIlding or construction site for the purposes of recycling, reuse, or storage for later recycling or reuse (bb)"Sanltary Wastes" means matenals that require speCial handling procedures such as liqUid wastes including domestic sanitary sewage (cc) "Secondary Matenal" as defIned In Public Contract Code section 12200(c) means fragments of finished products or finished products of a manufactUring process, which has converted a resource Into a commodity of real economic value, and Includes Post-Consumer Material, but does not include excess virgin resources of the manufacturing process. ThiS matenal did not reach the consumer pnor to being recycled (dd)"Sedlment" means SOil and other matenal that has been eroded and transported by storm or well production runoff water. (ee )"Separated for Reuse" means matenals, including commmgled recyclables, that have been separated or kept separate from the solid waste stream for the purpose of additional sorting or processing those matenals for reuse or recycling In order to return them to the economiC mainstream 9 In the form of raw material for new, reused, or reconstituted products which meet the quality standards necessary to be used In the marketplace, and Includes Source Separated Materials (ff)"Solld Waste" as per PubliC Resources Code Section 40191 means all putresclble and non-putresclble solid, semIsolid, and liqUid wastes, mcludmg garbage, trash, refuse, paper, rubbiSh, ashes, Industrial wastes, demolitIOn and constructIon wastes, abandoned vehicles and parts thereof, discarded home and mdustrlal appliances, dewatered, treated, or chemically fixed sewage sludge which IS not hazardous waste, manure, vegetable or animal solid and semIsolid wastes, and other discarded solid and semisolid wastes "Solid Waste" does not Include any of the following wastes (1 )Hazardous waste, as defined In PRC Section 40141. (2)Radloactlve waste regulated pursuant to the Radiation Control Law [Chapter 8 (commencmg With Section 114960) of Part 9 of DIVISion 104 of the Health and Safety Code] (3)Medlcal waste regulated pursuant to the Medical Waste Management Act [Part 14 (commencing WIth Section 117600) of DIVISion 104 of the Health and Safety Code J 10 (gg)Source Separated Matenals" means materials that are sorted at the site of generation by indiVidual material type mcludlng commmgled recyclable materials for the purpose of recycling I e loads of concrete that are source- separated for delivery to a recycling faCIlity (hh)"Vlrgln Matenal" means the portion of the product made from non-recycled material, that IS, the material that is neither post-consumer nor secondary material (II)"Waste Hauler" means a company that possess a valId permit from the City of Santa Monica to collect and transport solid wastes from Individuals or businesses for the purpose of recycling or disposal under the City of Santa MOnica's name (JJ)"Waste Management Plan" (WMP) means a completed Waste Management Plan form, approved by the City for the purpose of compliance With thIS Chapter, submitted by the Applicant for any Covered or Non-covered Project (kk)"Waste Management Plan Compliance OffiCial" means the Director of EnVironmental and PubliC Works Management or hiS or her deSignee 11 SECTION 7.60.020 THRESHOLD FOR COVERED PROJECTS (a)Prlvate Projects All construction and demolition projects the total costs of which are, or are proJected to be, $50,000 or greater, or are 1,000 square feet or greater ("Covered ProJects") shall be reqUired to divert at least sixty (60) percent of all proJect- related construction and demolition matenallO compliance WIth thiS Chapter (b )Clty-Sponsored Projects All City-sponsored construction, demolition and renovation ProJects shall be subject to thiS Chapter, and consequently, shall be considered Covered Projects (c)Compllance as a Condition of Approval Compliance With thiS Chapter shall be Included as a condition of approval on any construction or demolition permit Issued for a Covered Project SECTION 7.60.030 SUBMISSION OF A WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN (a)WMP Forms Applicants for construction or demolitIon permits involVing a Covered ProJect shall complete and submit a Waste Management Plan (WMP), on a WMP form approved by the City for thiS purpose, as part of the 12 applIcatIon packet for the construction or demolition permit. The completed WMP shall Indicate all of the following (1 )The estimated volume or weight of the Project C&D matenal, by material type, to be generated, (2)The maximum volume or weight of such materials that can feaSibly be diverted via reuse or recycling No more than twenty (20) percent of the sixty (60) percent dIverSion rate can be achieved through the recycling or reuse of Inert materials unless applicant can demonstrate to the satlsfactlon of the WMP Compliance OffiCial that sufficient structural matenals do not eXist for recycling or that forty (40) percent diverSion of total waste through non-Inert materials IS not feaSible (3)The vendor or facility where the Applicant proposes to use to collect or receive that matenal, and (4)The estimated volume or weight of C&D matenals that Will be landfilled In Class III landfills ("Class III Landfill") and Inert disposal faCilities ("Inert Disposal Facility/Inert Waste Landfill") (b )Calculatmg Volume and Weight of Matenal In estimating the volume or weight of matenals Identified In the WMP, the Applicant shall use the Conversion Rates approved by the City for thiS purpose 13 (c)Deconstructlon In preparing the WMP, applicants for demolition permits Involving the removal of all or part of an eXisting structure shall conSider deconstruction ("Deconstruction"), to the maximum extent feaSible, and shall make the materials generated thereby available for salvage prior to landfilllng Deconstruction can be used to meet the sixty (60) percent diverSion requirement provided It IS accounted for In the WMP SECTION 7.60.040 PERFORMANCE SECURITY The proJect applicant shall submit a performance security With the WMP The amount of the performance security shall be calculated as the lesser of three (3) percent of total Project cost or $30,000 The WMP Compliance OffiCial may waive the Performance Security If the total security required pursuant to thiS Sectlon would be fifty (50) dollars or less SECTION 7.60.050 REVIEW OF WMP (a)Approval Notwithstanding any other provIsions of thiS Code, no bUilding or demolition permit shall be Issued for any Covered ProJect unless and until the WMP Compliance OffiCial has reviewed the WMP Approval shall not be reqUired, 14 however, where an emergency demolition IS reqUired to protect public health or safety The WMP Compliance OffiCial shall only approve a WMP If he or she fIrst determines that all of the following conditions have been met (1 )The WMP provides all of the information set forth In Section 7 60 030. (2)The WMP Indicates that at least sIxty (60) percent of all C&D material generated by the Project Will be diverted or an exemption has been approved pursuant to Section 7 60.070 (3 )The Applicant has submitted an appropriate Performance Secunty In compliance With Section 7 60.40 If the WMP Compliance OffiCIal determines that these conditions have been met, he or she shall mark the WMP "Approved," return a copy of the WMP to the Applicant, and notIfy the BUIlding Department and the Solid Waste Management DIVISion that the WMP has been approved (b )Nonapproval If the WMP Compliance OffiCial determmes that the WMP falls to meet the conditions speCified In subsection (a) of thiS Section, he or she shall either (1 )Return the WMP to the Applicant marked "Denied," mcludmg a statement of reasons, and so notify the BUlldmg 15 Department, to ensure that the construction or demolition permit does not Issue (2)Return the WMP to the applicant marked "Further Explanation Required" If the Applicant determmes dunng the course of the project that the estimated tonnage of material to be generated and or recovered from the project IS substantially different from the WMP, applicant shall submit an addendum to the original WMP SECTION 7.60.060 COMPLIANCE WITH WMP (a)Documentatlon Within 30 days after the completion of any Covered ProJect, the Applicant shall submit to the WMP Compliance OffiCial documentation that It has met the DiverSion ReqUirement for the Project Applicant shall proVide a summary of efforts used to meet the DiverSion ReqUIrement and also provide the following documentation (1 )Recelpts from the vendor or faCIlity which collected or receIved each material showmg the actual weight or volume of that material (2)Welght slips/count of material salvaged or reused In current ProJect 16 (3)A copy of the prevIously approved WMP for the Project addmg the actual volume or weight of each material diverted and landfllled (4)Any additional Information the Applicant believes IS relevant to determming Its efforts to comply m good faith with this Chapter (b)Welqhlng of Wastes Applicants shall make reasonable efforts to ensure that all C&D matenal diverted or landfilled are measured and recorded usmg the most accurate method of measurement avaIlable. To the extent practical, all C&D materral shall be weighted by measurement on scales Such scales shall be In compliance With all State and County regulatory reqUirements for accuracy and mamtenance For C&D material for which weighing IS not practical due to small Size or other conSIderations, a volumetriC measurement shall be used For conversion of volumetnc measurements by weight, the Applicant shall use the standardized ConversIon Rates approved by the City for thiS purpose (c)Determmatlon of Compliance and Release of Performance Security The WMP Compliance OffICial shall review the Information submitted under subsection (a) of thiS Section to determme whether the Applicant has complied With the DiverSion ReqUirement as follows 17 (1 )Full Compliance If the WMP Compliance Official determines that the Applicant has fully complied with the Diversion Requirement applicable to the Project, he or she shall cause the full Performance Security to be released to the Applicant (2)Fallure to Comply If the WMP Compliance Official determines that the Diversion Requirement has not been met, he or she shall return only that portion of the performance security eqUivalent to the portion of C&D material actually diverted compared to the portion that should have been diverted according to the WMP Any portion of the Performance Security not released to the Applicant shall be forfeited to the City, and shall be used to recover costs associated With sorting mixed C&D loads at the City recycling center If the WMP Compliance Official determines that the Applicant has fully failed to comply WIth the Diversion ReqUirement or If the Applicant falls to submit the documentation reqUIred by subsection (a) of this Section Within the reqUired time period, then the entire Performance Security shall be fonelted to the City All forfeited Performance Secuntles shall be used to recover costs associated With sorting mixed C&D loads at the City recycling center 18 SECTION 7.60.070 EXEMPTION (a)Appllcatlon If an Applicant believes It IS InfeaSible to comply with the diversion reqUirements of this Chapter due to the circumstances delineated In this Section, the Applicant may apply for an exemption at the time that he or she submits the reqUired WMP Exemptions may be granted based the follOWing considerations (1 )Lack of storage space onsite (2)Contammatlon by hazardous substances (3)Low recyclablllty of specific materials The Applicant shall Indicate on the WMP the maximum rate of diverSion he or she believes IS feaSible for each material and the speCific circumstances that he or she believes make It mfeaslble to comply With the DIverSion ReqUirement (b )Meetmg WIth WMP Compliance OffiCIal The WMP ComplIance OffiCial shall review the Information supplied by the Applicant and may meet With the Applicant to diSCUSS pOSSible ways of meetmg the DIVISIon ReqUirement Upon request of the jUrisdiction, the WMP Compliance OffiCial may request that staff from the Solid Waste Management DIVision attend thiS meeting or may require the Applicant to request a separate meetmg With Solid Waste Management DIVISIon staff 19 Based on the mformatlon supplied by the Applicant and. If applicable, Solid Waste Management Staff, the Compliance Official shall determine whether It IS pOSSible for the Applicant to meet the DIvIsion Requirement (c)Grantlng of Exemption If the WMP Compliance Official determines that It IS mfeaslble for the Applicant to meet the Diversion ReqUirement due to unique Circumstances, he or she shall determine the maximum feaSIble diversion rate for each matenal and shall IndIcate this rate on the WMP submitted by the Applicant The WMP Compliance Official shall return a copy of the WMP to the Applicant marked "Approved Exemptfon" and shall notIfy the BUilding Department that the WMP has been approved (d)Denlal of Exemption If the WMP Compliance Official determines that It IS pOSSible for the Applicant to meet the Diversion ReqUirement, he or she shall Inform the Applicant In wntmg The Applicant shall have 30 days to resubmit a WMP form In full compliance With Section 7 60.030 If the Applicant falls to resubmit the WMP, or If the resubmitted WMP does not comply with Section 760030, the WMP ComplIance Official shall deny the WMP 20 SECTION 7.60.080 APPEAL (a) The applicant or any Interested person may appeal to a Hearing Examiner from any ruling of the WMP Compliance Official made pursuant to thIS Chapter In accordance With Section 6 16 030 Notice of any appeal from the ruling of the WMP Compliance OffiCial must be filed Within ten (10) days of the date that such ruling IS made The deCISion of the Hearing Examiner upon such appeal, relative to any matter Within the JUriSdiction of the WMP Compliance OffiCial, shall be final and shall not be appealable to the City Councilor to any other City body or offiCial SECTION 7.60.090 ENFORCEMENT (a)The DIrector of the Department of EnVironmental and Public Works Management, or hiS or her deSignee, IS authOrized to enforce Sections 7 60 030-7 60 060 as follows' (1 )For the first faIlure to comply With the provISions of SectIons 760030-760060, the Department of EnVironmental and Public Works Management shall Issue to the affected person a written notice that mcludes the follOWing information (I)A statement speclfymg the Violation committed, 21 (II)A speCified time period within which the affected person must correct the failure of file a wntten notice disputing the notice to comply, (III)A statement of the penalty for continued noncompliance (2)For each subsequent failure to comply with any provIsions of Sections 7 60 030-7 60 060 follOWing written notice pursuant to this Section, the Director of the Department of EnVironmental and Public Works Management may levy a penalty not to exceed five hundred dollars Any statement informing a Violator of a citation shall Include a notice setting forth the hearing rights provided m subsection (a) (3) below (3)Any person assessed a penalty pursuant to subsection (a) (2) may dispute the penalty by requestmg a hearing on a form provided by the City wlthm the time and manner set forth In Section 6 16 030 provided that no hearing request shall be deemed timely filed and no hearing shall be held unless, Within the time penod to request a hearing, the person depOSits With the City Treasurer money In the amount of any unpaid penalty due under thiS Section If as a result of the heanng It IS determined that the penalty was wrongly assessed, the City shall refund any money deposited to the person The deCISion of the Hearing Examiner shall be final 22 except for Judicial revIew and shall not be appealable to the City Council (4)Jt shall not be a defense to the assessment of any penalty or to any other CIVil enforcement action proVIded for under thiS Section for a person to assert that any VIolation of Sections 7 60.030-7 60 060 was caused by the actions of a person other than the person assessed except If the Violation was caused by the criminal or negligent action of a person who was not an agent, servant, employee or family member of the person (5)Any penalty collected hereunder shall be deposited In the Refuse Fund to be used as reimbursement for the Department of EnVironmental and Public Works Management's costs and expenses of administratIon and enforcement of thiS Chapter (b)Any Violation of thiS Chapter shall constitute an Infraction punishable by a fine of five hundred dollars Each day that a Violation occurs shall constitute a separate offense (c)A Violation of any proVIsion of thiS Chapter IS declared to be a public nUisance and may be abated pursuant to Santa MOnica MunICIpal Code Chapter 8 96 or by means of a CIVil action 23 (d)The City may enforce the provIsions of thiS Chapter by means of a cIvil action The burden of proof In such cases shall be preponderance of the eVidence (e)Any person who commits an act, proposes to commit an act, or engages m any pattern and practice which violates thiS Chapter may be enjoined by any court of competent jUrisdIction (f)The penaltIes and remedies established by thiS Chapter are not exclusive, and nothing In thiS Chapter shall preclude any person from seeking any other remedies, penalties, or procedures proVided by law. SECTION 2 Any prOVIsIon of the Santa Momca MUniCipal Code or appendices thereto inconsistent With the prOVISions of thiS Ordinance, to the extent of such InconSistencies and no further, are hereby repealed or modified to that extent necessary to affect the proVISions of thiS Ordinance SECTION 3 If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase of thiS Ordmance IS for any reason held to be invalid or unconstitutional by a deCISion of any court of competent JUriSdiction, such deCISion shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of thiS Ordinance The City CounCil hereby declares that It would have passed thiS Ordinance, and each and every section, subsection, sentence, clause, or phrase not declared Invalid or unconstitutional Without 24 regard to whether any portion of the Ordmance would be subsequently declared Invalid or unconstitutional SECTION 4 The Mayor shall sign and the City Clerk shall attest to the passage of thiS Ordinance The City Clerk shall cause the same to be published once In the offiCial newspaper within 15 days after Its adoption ThIS ordinance shall become effective after 30 days from Its adoption APPROVED AS TO FORM MARSHA JONE City Attorney 25 Adopted and approved this 19th day of December, 2000. State of California ) County of Los Angeles) ss City of Santa MOnica ) I, Marla M. Stewart, City Clerk of the City of Santa MOnica, do hereby certify that the foregOing Ordinance No 1996 (CCS) had It's introduction on December 5, 2000, and was adopted at the Santa MOnica City Council meeting held on December 19, 2000, by the followmg vote Ayes Council members. Holbrook, O'Connor, McKeown, Genser, Katz, Mayor Pro Tem Bloom, Mayor Feinstein Noes. Council members None Abstain Council members None Absent Council members None ATTEST \ ~ ~'~,~ Mana M. Stewart, City Clerk